I am continually torn with how to address the issue of politics and spirit. I am not only a Pagan, I am also an American citizen and a political scientist. That is my field of expertise. Anyone who looked at my blog before I was asked to join Beliefnet will notice that it was much more political than it is now. And I posted less often. And it is hardly the only blog on this site that deals with politics to a significant degree.
That is a bit of context. Now to the issue at hand. Is this blog too political?
Pagans as I use the term focus on the Sacred as it manifests in the world. That means we should be concerned with its well-being. That also means we should oppose those who would destroy or desecrate the world through ignorance, malice, or greed.
I am afraid that refers to MOST Republicans and MOST conservatives these days. It was not always so, Barry Goldwater was remarkably liberal by modern standards. There is nothing about what conservatism used to be that would preclude conservatives being Pagans. And I suppose some of the current kind could be today, if they worshipped Ares .
I am among the first to admit these failings are hardly limited to the Republican and conservative side of the political divides in this country. But it is also true that as a group they have done more harm and are doing more to prevent ameliorative action than any other organized force in America today, with the possible exception of the corporate oligarchy.
When conservatives begin to police their own ranks a bit better, when they loudly criticize the moral monsters in their ranks, when they start electing conservatives who demonstrate some adherence to principle, or start pushing back against the criminals who have hijacked their position and their name, I will be far gentler. I am a political theorist who prefers reasoned debate.
So far, with few exceptions, they haven't. Torture defender John Boehner is the Minority Leader in the House, not some crazed back bencher like Barbara Bachmann. Glenn Beck is super popular with the conservative crowd. When some Republican Congresscritter dares criticize Rush Limbaugh, a few days later they come crawling to the feet of the Immense One, to apologize.
Do old style conservatives still exist? Yes. But if you didn't know where to look, you would not easily find them. They stand out as much as spottted owls, and are about as common in public discussions. two come to mind that my more political readers might have heard of: Meghan McCain, who has more cojones than all the 'conservatives' in Congress and the media, and Andrew Sullivan who still cares about things like law and decency as amounting to more than slogans.
Some people may want to stay utterly uninvolved in the affairs of this world. Fine. But remember, these people have imposed themselves on us. they have sought, gained, and miused political power. They say they are wagng a 'culture war' against us.
I wish I could ignore them. At one level the world can definitely take care of itself, but at another level I don't want to look back in a few years and say I wish I had done more.
I make my headlines pretty clear as to whether it will be a political or non-political post. Don't read the political ones - it's easy to know what to avoid. But don't presume to tell me that when I am addressing politics, I am not being Pagan or it is not a 'Pagan Blog.' I do not say this is THE Pagan Blog, it is A Pagan Blog, as it most assuredly is.
If you do not want to be involved in political issues, don't post comments on political posts. It's easy. The post immediately before the Boehner one was far far longer and utterly non-political. But Mike ignored it to make whatever point he wanted to make on the other.
The media has done a mostly horrible job reporting to the American people as to the crimes committed in their name, and even now most media figures are making light of these issues. I feel a responsibility to make information available to people who do not follow political events closely. That includes many readers of this blog. I do not simply bad-mouth people - I provide links to back it up, and they are respectable links.
Some people deserve bad mouthing as terrible examples of human beings and terrible examples of American citizens. In my view there is not enough moral condemnation of the extreme right in this country - not nearly enough. I know that to some degree I am 'preaching to the choir' - but given what we have been through the past 8 years, we all need to know we do nor speak and act alone. We have been through a period when those who saw fairly clearly the horrors 'conservative Republicans' were going to unleash on our land were attacked as un-American, sympathizers of terrorists, the 'hard left,' traitors, and worse.
Now the criminals who held power speak of a bi-partisanship they did not practice then and are not practicing now. They urge us to look forward and let bygones be bygones, though the crimes they committed stink to the heavens. Too little discussed is just how many of the current gang of criminals got their start in the Nixon White House, or later got awar with cimes under Reagan, when George H. W. Bush pardoned them all upon becoming President.
Democratic members of the ruling elite are often happy to let bygones be bygones because so many lost any moral standing by caving to conservative threats during the Bush II years. If justice is to be done, it will be because Americans insist on it. If justice is not done, it will happen again because it means that if you have enough power, the rule of law and basic decency no longer apply.
That is a bit of context. Now to the issue at hand. Is this blog too political?
Pagans as I use the term focus on the Sacred as it manifests in the world. That means we should be concerned with its well-being. That also means we should oppose those who would destroy or desecrate the world through ignorance, malice, or greed.
I am afraid that refers to MOST Republicans and MOST conservatives these days. It was not always so, Barry Goldwater was remarkably liberal by modern standards. There is nothing about what conservatism used to be that would preclude conservatives being Pagans. And I suppose some of the current kind could be today, if they worshipped Ares .
I am among the first to admit these failings are hardly limited to the Republican and conservative side of the political divides in this country. But it is also true that as a group they have done more harm and are doing more to prevent ameliorative action than any other organized force in America today, with the possible exception of the corporate oligarchy.
When conservatives begin to police their own ranks a bit better, when they loudly criticize the moral monsters in their ranks, when they start electing conservatives who demonstrate some adherence to principle, or start pushing back against the criminals who have hijacked their position and their name, I will be far gentler. I am a political theorist who prefers reasoned debate.
So far, with few exceptions, they haven't. Torture defender John Boehner is the Minority Leader in the House, not some crazed back bencher like Barbara Bachmann. Glenn Beck is super popular with the conservative crowd. When some Republican Congresscritter dares criticize Rush Limbaugh, a few days later they come crawling to the feet of the Immense One, to apologize.
Do old style conservatives still exist? Yes. But if you didn't know where to look, you would not easily find them. They stand out as much as spottted owls, and are about as common in public discussions. two come to mind that my more political readers might have heard of: Meghan McCain, who has more cojones than all the 'conservatives' in Congress and the media, and Andrew Sullivan who still cares about things like law and decency as amounting to more than slogans.
Some people may want to stay utterly uninvolved in the affairs of this world. Fine. But remember, these people have imposed themselves on us. they have sought, gained, and miused political power. They say they are wagng a 'culture war' against us.
I wish I could ignore them. At one level the world can definitely take care of itself, but at another level I don't want to look back in a few years and say I wish I had done more.
I make my headlines pretty clear as to whether it will be a political or non-political post. Don't read the political ones - it's easy to know what to avoid. But don't presume to tell me that when I am addressing politics, I am not being Pagan or it is not a 'Pagan Blog.' I do not say this is THE Pagan Blog, it is A Pagan Blog, as it most assuredly is.
If you do not want to be involved in political issues, don't post comments on political posts. It's easy. The post immediately before the Boehner one was far far longer and utterly non-political. But Mike ignored it to make whatever point he wanted to make on the other.
The media has done a mostly horrible job reporting to the American people as to the crimes committed in their name, and even now most media figures are making light of these issues. I feel a responsibility to make information available to people who do not follow political events closely. That includes many readers of this blog. I do not simply bad-mouth people - I provide links to back it up, and they are respectable links.
Some people deserve bad mouthing as terrible examples of human beings and terrible examples of American citizens. In my view there is not enough moral condemnation of the extreme right in this country - not nearly enough. I know that to some degree I am 'preaching to the choir' - but given what we have been through the past 8 years, we all need to know we do nor speak and act alone. We have been through a period when those who saw fairly clearly the horrors 'conservative Republicans' were going to unleash on our land were attacked as un-American, sympathizers of terrorists, the 'hard left,' traitors, and worse.
Now the criminals who held power speak of a bi-partisanship they did not practice then and are not practicing now. They urge us to look forward and let bygones be bygones, though the crimes they committed stink to the heavens. Too little discussed is just how many of the current gang of criminals got their start in the Nixon White House, or later got awar with cimes under Reagan, when George H. W. Bush pardoned them all upon becoming President.
Democratic members of the ruling elite are often happy to let bygones be bygones because so many lost any moral standing by caving to conservative threats during the Bush II years. If justice is to be done, it will be because Americans insist on it. If justice is not done, it will happen again because it means that if you have enough power, the rule of law and basic decency no longer apply.

Add to Newsvine
Add to StumbleUpon
Gus, I don't think this blog is too political. I come here for religion, spirituality and theology too, but I also know that politics affects EVERY part of my life.
My Pagan group discusses politics when we get together. So does my family around the dinner table. I don't see why we can't do it here as well. Although I don't always comment on the political posts in your blog I do read them and think about what others have said. I enjoy comments from a Pagan perspective which doesn't always happen in "other blogs". Anyone who doesn't want to read the political posts in your blog can easily skip them. Maybe start the titles with "Political" so that those who don't like them easily know what to skip.
Is this blog too political?
It's interesting that I've chosen to join not one but two religious movements that do, typically, concern themselves a lot with political matters: Paganism and Quakers. It's especially interesting given the fact that, of all the things I need from my religious community, political discussion is not actually high on the list.
Yes, I know that in the Pagan view, the embodied sacredness of this world and this moment makes it inevitable that we should be involved with the politics of the world. I wouldn't have it any other way! And I'm downright proud of how ubiquitous Quakers are at any kind of peace demonstration or action, and glad to see Pagans becoming more articulate and activist on matters of peace and environmentalism, too.
But it's not just liberal ideology that unites my two spiritual homes, but an experiential orientation toward religion. For both Pagans and Quakers, religion is something you do, gods are something you engage with... not something to believe in in a dry and intellectual manner.
There are many places it's possible to find intelligent political commentary. In fact, it's my impression that even specifically Pagan blogs are more often oriented toward politics than toward religious experience... and that's where I have an issue. I am hungry for more reminders to the Pagan world (and to me) that our religion is not notional, but rather rock-my-world, blow-my-socks-off, wake-me-up to smell-the-coffee experiential.
I know from your writing that you have felt those astonishing moments of revelation and direct encounter with the Goddess. I know from my own writing how hard it is to put that kind of encounter into words at all. But I see the Pagan movement as in danger of becoming theoretical and dry if we don't somehow share the word that these gods we're talking about aren't just "nice ideas", but are in fact echoes of the deepest levels of real there is, and, to paraphrase the Quaker expression, they have "come to teach their people themselves." I want us not to settle for anything less!
Not that the politics don't matter. And, given the amount of political writing you have always done, those who decided your voice would be good to invite into Beliefnet must have thought the political aspect of our practice belonged.
But for my taste? A little more ineffability would serve me better. (Mind you, that's perhaps more my job to provide than yours, if that's my leading. But since you asked...)
Cat C-B, Thank you for reminding us of the Friends who have dine so much good for so long.
Ok, first of all, it's your blog so you get to decide what to post. Second, considering the state of affairs these days, how in the ever-lovin' blue-eyed world can anything be too political? I mean, we live in this world! And it is fabulous, and it is sacred, and, if we don't develop a passionate interest in how we're living and how decisions are made, it could be over way too soon. I think any responsible discussion about life on earth now needs to include the sacred and the political.
That said, personally I could do with more poetry...
Gus,
I read this blog for the politics not the Paganism. :)
Your border-crossing views are very interesting to me.
Thanks and keep up the good work.
Post a Comment
By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.