Beyond Blue

It's a Wonderful Life

Thursday January 1, 2009

I am publishing this from my archives today because I'm taking the day off! I was really moved by Larry's blog entry on the holiday classic, which I try to watch each year, to remind me that, despite my illness,...
Advertisement
Comments
Babs
December 19, 2007 11:31 AM

Great post, Larry. One of my daughters and I justed watched it again on Monday morning. It is one of my top five favorite movies. James Stewart communicates the character's emotional state throughout the movie so well that it is hard to believe that he did not receive an Academy Award, but that does not diminish the enduring value of this movie.

Like so many of the BB readers, I identify with the desperation of George Bailey as the world crumbles around him. I see myself in his sharp tongue with his children, his impatience, his phone call (painfully and with some shame, I see myself),and his resolve to kill himself. In the first half of the movie, we see George as a decent man who does what he feels obliged to do at the price of giving up his dreams. Sometimes the things we think we want for ourselves seem forever beyond our reach. It is hard to not harbor resentment, often well-hidden because it doesn't fit with our ideas of ourselves as "good people." So it goes underground and eats away at our souls.

It is when George asks God to help him, because there is no one else to turn to, that really touches me. The punch in the mouth which drives him to the river, is actually what brings him to the river and his meeting with God through Clarence Goodbody. It seems that George has worked hard his entire life, but God has played no part in it. With God, the most humble life has meaning. Without God, money and good looks, and all the other things we value aren't worth a hill of beans.

An aside about the punch in the mouth: from my own experience, sometimes when I pray and an immediate answer seems to pop up, I think this is what God wants from me. When it doesn't work out, I wonder whether God answered or not. Sometimes the immediate answers are indeed from God, but we have to be careful not to assume it to be so.

I just wrote last night about my struggle with God. How I want him to be more integral to my day, but how I also want to maintain distance. It is so difficult when you are being pulled both ways. I want God so badly, but because of early life experience, am sometimes afraid and want to hold him at arms length. I wish it weren't so, but it is where I am right now.

Larry Parker
December 19, 2007 12:34 PM

I said my piece in the post, obviously, but I noted that Saturday Night Live parody for two reasons:

1. The very desire we have as humans for justice as revenge, given how George has been wronged, is itself desperately wrong. (I just wrote an anti-death penalty post on my blog last night -- no offense to those on BB who disagree, of course, but that's how I see it.)

Back to the movie -- we have to realize, as George finally does, that we have to take responsibility for our own lives, the good and the bad, and (as a psychologist might say) "integrate them into the whole."

2. "It's a Wonderful Life" could never be remade -- not only because it would be sacrilege ("colorizing" it was bad enough) but because Hollywood executives would insist on an ending JUST like that on Saturday Night Live.

I'm imagining Tom Hanks as George punching a wheelchair-bound Kirk Douglas as Potter in the face, with the last line, "BANK ON **THIS**, POTTER!!!!"

Ugh.

CLeo
December 19, 2007 2:44 PM

Capra chose those characters so well that we loved them even though some weren't very lovable. In real life it's not that simple, by the time we begin to see the real person, too much water has gone under the bridge or they have moved away.

Peg
December 19, 2007 2:57 PM

And wasn't the phone scene where the chemistry between Mary and George was heating up, the best? There is definitely something worthwhile to leaving things to our imagination, in my opinion.

Frank
December 19, 2007 4:09 PM

Thank you for posting this. Larry, you really hit the proverbial nail on the head. My wife and I just watched It's A Wonderful Life a few days ago - and I feel so clean and fresh after a visit with all those characters. I remember the restaurant/bar where George gets punched by the school teacher's husband. That place is like our minds somehow. If bad things are ongoing they seem to get trapped and clog up the pipes with dark. Far better to dwell on the positive and be reminded that good is great.
It is a wonderful life...
Frank,

Larry Parker
December 20, 2007 12:58 AM

Cleo:

"Water under the bridge" -- what an eerie, and I'm certain unconscious but nevertheless so prescient, metaphor when we discuss IAWL. Think how important water (including snow) is in so many parts of the story.

Frank:

You've figured out the bar scene better than I have (for your own life). But for my mind it really is the key scene in the movie, at least as far as a turning point.

To everyone:

Bnet's software ate it, but I also was going to blog on two other holiday movies that have become "insta-classics" -- "A Christmas Story" and "Love Actually." I can't recommend both of them more highly (though neither, of course, is IAWL).

Larry Parker
December 24, 2007 1:50 AM

... and thanks to the powers-that-be at Bnet (with a nudge from Therese?) who put this on their front page December 23.

Dona J.
December 24, 2007 10:17 AM

Larry,
Boy oh Boy, talk about one of the most heart wrenching movies of all time. And yes, it does make you wake up and smell the coffee. This movie is one of my all time favorites too. I watch it every year. With all that we go thru in this life, we have to remember that if He (Father God) brings you to it, He will bring you thru it. Sometimes bad situations, can be turned into a good situation when dealing with our Father. Keep the faith and Hold on to His never Changing Hand. God Bless and Merry Christmas to everyone. Don't forget to sing Happy Birthday to Jesus. Jesus is the reason for the season.
Sincerely, Sis Dona J.

TRICIA
December 24, 2007 11:18 AM

YES MY COMMENT IS THAT ITS CHRISTMAS EVE AND IM A TRADIONALIST IN LOVING THE MOVIE BUT EACH PERSON IN THEIR HEART AND SOUL SEES THIS WORK OF ART BY THE GENIOUS FRANK CAPRA AS THAT A MAN NEEDS A GOOD WOMAN TO STAND BEHIND HIM IN TIMES OF TROUBLE WHICH SHE DID. THE BANKING SITUATION ONLY PUT OFF NEVER RUINED THEIR LOVE AND ROMANCE AND I HAVE AN ANGEL ORNAMENT WITH A BELL LIKE IN THE MOVIE . AND YES I HAVE THREE ANGELS IN HEAVEN AND THEY ARE ALL STRONG WOMAN WATCHING OVER ME AND MY SADNESS THIS CHRISTMAS BUT I HAVE A TRUE ROMANTIC HELPING ME MAYBE IM HELPING HIM TOO I RESPECT HIS LOSSES AND FEELINGS HAPPY HOLIDAYS KAL

Anonymous
December 24, 2007 12:18 PM

IF I HAD TO LIVE THE REST OF MY LIFE WITH ONLY ONE MOVIE, IAWL WOULD BE IT. OFF COURSE IT WOULD HAVE TO BE IN BLACK AND WHITE. I WOULD NEVER WANT TO WATCH THE COLORED VERSION. IT JUST WOULDN'T BE THE SAME.

MERRY CHRISTMAS TO ALL AND LISTEN FOR THAT BELL...........

KARL CACCIOLA
December 24, 2007 1:28 PM

MERRY CHRISTMAS TO ALL
TO MANY OF YOU THAT THINK THAT CHRISTMAS
IS ALL ABOUT SHOPPING AND EXCHANGING GIFTS .
I WOULD LOVE TO KNOW WHO STARTED THIS TRADITION
AND WHY . PLEASE , ANYONE LET ME KNOW , BECAUSE
CHRISTMAS HAS GOTTEN COMPLETLY COMMERCIAL AND
OUT OF FOCUS . A DEVOTED CATHOLIC K

Dianne
December 24, 2007 3:51 PM

I most certainly must check out that movie...if not this year by the next for sure...but this year I intend to go one better...to be the embodiment of that angel, and bring an element of peace and joy to one close friend, and more than a friend this Christmas, if only for a few hours. He has found himself in a very difficult situation and is captive in self-made isolation. I cannot reconcile this to my spirit, even as I am a bit stressed about my own outcome of Christmas, but it is better to give than to receive, and hope to restore the blessed hope and joy of this season, if only to one person this year. It will certainly reaffirm my own. I may have seen that movie as a child, but cannot remember only one small detail in it....you have now resparked my interest in it and I hope to be able to enjoy the movie and its message soon. I am looking forward to a new holiday tradition in watching it....thank you, Therese, for reminding us that even in times of stress or discouragement, it truly is a wonderful life!

Pup Wiley
December 24, 2007 4:03 PM

This movie was made the year I was born.
It remains one of my favorites.

CLeo
December 24, 2007 4:08 PM

Larry, yes, water is very symbolic, isn't it? water is life, the river of life. That's what George contemplates while pondering suicide, water keeps on running under the bridge, it's life renewing itself, it's the eternal flow.

sandra weisz
December 24, 2007 6:52 PM

I loved watching that movie on television. i've seen it numerous times in peices, never all the way through. it was made in tarzana ca. i'm a native of l.a. i know. and it was made in the hot summer with artificial snow. looks real huh? well i,m homeless now living in motels and having no christmas whatsover and i thank you for reminding me of this wonderful movie and what it meant.in 1945 my parents were children living in foreign countries, so i love seeing what america was like back then, since i,m the first one born here. for me 2007 in southern ca. is the great depression. but that movie and you Theresa gives me hope . G-d bless..

Kisha
December 24, 2007 10:50 PM

My favorite movie. In fact I am watching it right now. Sometimes we do not realize how our lives impact upon others.

ravenbraveheart
December 24, 2007 10:52 PM

Sometimes I am not able to see the wonderful life or pathway as I like to say, cause of my Depression, anger, hurt & pain. I have a very hard time 2 years ago, the thought of suicide was very near, yet as you can read, I am still here, anyway the holidays are very hard, yet this year or should I say that in the last 3 days. I have been shown how much peolpe really care. I am very Thankful for that, & for my mind & my soul to be able to see then really feel it cause you see I do have a wonderful life pathway.
anyone who is feeling alone, Please take from me, we are not even if we feel we are, look around someone is there.

Barbara
December 24, 2007 11:17 PM

Theresa -

Tonight I am feeling more than just a little like George, having just come back home from a Christmas Eve service at the church I attend, with a fellowship time following the service. During that time, a very dear lady from the congregation came up to me and slid an envelope into my coat pocket, and with a heartfelt hug, said, "Merry Christmas, honey! Don't you worry about a thing, God is taking care of you for awhile now!" (the newspaper which employed me as a freelance news reporter for the past 14 months recently ceased publication as of Dec. 10th, leaving me with NO job at the present time)
When I got home, I took out the envelope and opened it -- inside was a beautiful snowy Christmas scene on the front of a card that said beneath it, very simply, "Happy Holidays." When I opened the card, I realized it was one of those cards in which people can slip money into an inside pocket, which said on it, "Wishing you all the beauty and wonder that this holiday season can bring" In the pocket was a $100 bill.
I am crying as I write this to you, filled with such gratitude to God for speaking to one of His people who found it in her heart (and her wallet)to help me, and wondering what I have done to deserve such special treatment. Teresa, two weeks ago, I was nearly to the point of complete dispair, ready to just give up, lay down and go to sleep, preparing to pray that I would not wake up the next morning. But instead, I knelt next to my bed, and cried out to God, "Oh, Lord, please help me!! I am so lost!" Within several minutes, an enveloping sense of peace and calm came over me, and I slept like a baby that night, for the first time in many months. Since that night, I have felt an overwhelming sense of anticipation, as though something wonderful was about to happen to me -- well, tonite, it happened.
I have struggled with severe depression for the last three years, taken several different antidepressants that seem to help for awhile and then lose their effectiveness, and gone on probably 200 walks when the frustration and pain became more than I could bear. I stumbled onto your Beyond Blue blog about eight months ago, and have avidly devoured every post since. I truly believe that the God of my understanding has brought you into my life with "encouragement, strength and hope" that has kept me going on more than one bad day. In February of 2008, I will mark three years since I attempted suicide with alcohol and, thankfully, failed -- I have been sober since September, 2005, and since completing inpatient dual-diagnosis treatment for depression and chemical dependency, I have become very conscious of how much my emotional state fuels and triggers my desire to get roaring drunk and forget everything that makes my heart ache.
Thank you for everything you write, my GOD, you have no idea how very similar we are!! I pray for you every single night, that God will keep you safe and hold you close in His arms when the world just gets to be too much to bear. It sounds so noble of me, until you realize how dependent I am on reading your blog, how much you help me get through this crummy, rotten life, one day at a time, one step at a time, somedays, one minute at a time!!
But tonight, it truly IS a wonderful life . . . .!

Mary
December 25, 2007 4:54 AM

Hi Barbara,
I could really relate to your e-mail. I also have attempted suicide but many times. I am now going thru a mixed bi-polar state. I have been bi-polar for 35 yrs. and I sometimes think all the older bi-polar people have died. I am 61 and sometimes everything is so difficult - driving, thinking is fuzzy (maybe from zyprexa) and getting out of bed is the hardest. In June I had surgery from a fall when I broke my hip and femur (leg bone). I was on the floor for 7 hrs. yelling for help, before my neighbor heard me. By the time I got to the hospital I suffered from dehydration, high blood pressure, pneumonia, low red blood cell count and 3 blood clots. I was on a catheter for over 3 weeks and it's only been since Nov. that I can make it to the bathroom on time. Physically, I'm doing great but then the depression hit. I'm taking parnate (MAOI) and starting to feel a little better, except when I wake up and think I have to get thru another day. I never used alcohol or drugs (except what's prescribed) but I do use a lot of natural supplements. Has anyone tried elemental lithium, EFT (Emotional Freedom Technique), Sam-E or other alternative therapies?

Kurt Eisbrenner
December 25, 2007 1:05 PM

I have seen the movie several times. Every time I notice something in the background, the plot, or the credits that I hadn't seen before. Like the bit part by Sheldon Leonard (later the executive producer of the Andy Griffith Show). Or the amounts of money involved - the $2000 honeymoon money and the $8000 George's uncle misplaced. You can't help but think what $8000 in 1946 would be in today's money? Or the downtown with all the Mom & Pop stores, locally owned and operated businesses. What happened to all those downtowns, indeed, what has happened to America the last 61 years when the last domestic maker of Santa suits has even gone out of business?
People have loved and adopted this movie because it is history, a reminder of the beloved past, of past Christmases. One of our ministers (Donny is only in his 30's) said that people love to remember and return to the past, it gives them comfort. In downtown Fort Wayne we have a Santa and reindeer display sign and a wreath sign that once were on the outside of what was one of our most beloved department stores. Every night before Thanksgiving thousands of residents and visitors flock to our downtown to see these signs lit up by the local dignitaries and Santa and local celebrities. They are 67 years old. The store, Wolf and Dessauer, went out of business 38 years ago. The store building people loved and revered burned down in a fire in 1962. The signs spent 21 years in storage then were resurrected 28 years ago and returned to downtown for Christmas in 1980.
I say all this because people long for a return to those values that Frank Capra wove into the movie. And they miss an America that most Americans living have never experienced.....
We need to get in the car and drive to South Bend to my family's so I will just say, "remember no man is a failure who has friends, thanks for the wings" (Clarence). And Merry Christmas, to all those who remember, and all those who only know through what has been passed down through the generations!

CLeo
December 25, 2007 5:12 PM

@Mary, I'm bipolar as well, something I didn't discovered until rather recently. I was "lucky" to come to this diagnosis, because it helped me stop condemning and judging myself. It's been very difficult for me to live with no filters, as we bipolars do. Over the years I've been punished, criticized and vilified by those who should know better but don't. For instance, a person very close to me is a trained Psychologist...this person still believes that attemption suicide is akin to becoming a prostitute, yet this person has the license to counsel and to "help" others...I now wonder how effective his help was and is, actually it's more of an ego trip for him to have people come to him seeking his help. I can't but wonder how many there, in the so called "Helping Professions" are like that. I'd another one of those, one a Ph.D who is hot and insitent in being addressed as "DOCTOR", tell me that "Bipolar disorder" is a convenient diagnosis, one that professionals use when they don't have anything else to say or don't know.
So my point here is don't feel too bad, maybe you should take a look at what your meds are preventing you from seeing. I'm not in medication for depression or to keep the moods even, I discovered that I can do that effectively by controlling what I put in my mouth, sugar, fried or spicy foods, empty carbos, alcohol, chocolate, etc, those are verboten for me. I've discovered that by living with no filters I'm not at a disadvantage as many others are, I'm very sensitive to what goes on around me, phonies, malicious people, really kind people, beauty around me, etc., all the things I was made to feel guilty for perceiving once upon a time.
The most important part is knowing what works for you and choosing your professionals with upmost care.

blanche
January 1, 2009 1:50 PM

Thank you, Therese, for the reminder. Thank you, Larry, for your wonderful post.

Larry Parker
January 2, 2009 8:49 AM
http://community.beliefnet.com/doxieman122

And I found my Donna Reed this year. Amazing, just amazing.

Sharon Wilson
January 2, 2009 3:04 PM
http://www.coachingfromspirit.com

I think many of us have felt like George at one time or another. Movie is wonderful and inspirational because it gives alot of heart and hope.

Post a Comment

By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.



Please type the text you see in the box below to verify your post and help us prevent spam. You have a limited time to type - you may wish to compose your comment in a separate document and paste it here upon completion.

Type the characters you see in the picture above.

Advertisement

Search This Blog

feed icon Subscribe

RSS Feed

Receive updates from Beyond Blue

Beyond Blue: The Book!

Can't get enough of Therese’s wise, funny, uplifting journey through depression and anxiety?

Pre-order your copy of her upcoming book today!

Advertisement

Advertisement


About Beliefnet

Our mission is to help people like you find, and walk, a spiritual path that will bring comfort, hope, clarity, strength, and happiness. More about Beliefnet.

Legal

Copyright © Beliefnet, Inc. and/or its licensors. All rights reserved. Use of this site is subject to Terms of Service and to our Privacy Policy. Constructed by Beliefnet.

Advertisement

Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.