Beyond Blue

5 Ways Churches Can Minister to Those with Mental Illness

Friday May 15, 2009

Awhile back Mark Brown of Brownblog asked me to write two blog posts: one about how you grow your faith as a person with a mental illness, which he published awhile back, and one about what churches can do to...
Advertisement
Comments
Linda
May 15, 2009 11:30 AM

you are totally freakin amazing therese!! jesus is definelty going to give you the helping people with mental illness crown when we get up to heaven.

Deb Sabin
May 15, 2009 12:41 PM

I just wanted to say thanks for the information. I have mental illness and what keeps me going is my faith in God. I have a hard time concentrating so eight now I do not attend church. Prayer and my fait in God is what keeps me going. May God cointue being with you!

dawnspromise
May 15, 2009 12:44 PM

This is a fantastic suggestion. I do hope people bring this suggestion to their pastor/rabbi/spritiual leader. thank you so much for your courage.

Larry Carter Center
May 15, 2009 2:01 PM

There are at least 3 kinds of mental illness and some might suffer from all 3: irrationality, brain chemistry imbalance or brain structural injury/defect.
I wonder how many people in the first category get only rational emotive therapies? Religion is inseparable from magical thinking and how mentally ill people are supposed to get out of that trap with more magic, more imaginary friends, more alleged deities non-extant in human history so far, it just disgusts me that writers of any kind on this subject of how someone can heal from any illness without miracle, without praying to any alleged deity who has yet to have a proven answer, it all just makes me want to scream.
How can an altar boy or young nun wannabee heal from a pedophile priest? How does a young mind loyal to the institution of virgins having babies, alleged baby gods surviving an execution & torturous death, how do kids handle betrayal without mental illness?
How does any believer sitting in any pew, sort out religious metaphor from outright religious insane impossible claims of their preachers? Demons cause illness? Faith & prayer works?
Give me a break. I'm not in the thought police business like too many millions of religionists and violent theocrats are.
American Atheists are not cultists. We think for ourselves & have no interest in thinking for anyone else, mentally ill or mentally well enough to contemplate hell threats or heaven bribes.
I'm glad anyone gets better, but I deeply resent anyone who claims an alleged deity, Jehovah, Allah or Buddah or Krishna "saved" only them but no one else in a train wreck, tornado or housefire.
Mental health must include a decent respect for other's feelings.
Think twice believers when making universal statements, non-inclusive statements, taking ownership for one's ideas & statements should not have the escape clause of faiths versus the proper demand for proof of facts.
Peace, Larry Carter Center 843-926-1750

Colie
May 15, 2009 6:50 PM

Hi Therese:

I have just begun a few weeks ago reading your columns and viewing some of your podcasts. I have to tell you that I feel very grateful that you are around. I have had quite a lot to deal with in the past few weeks or so. I have mental illness and have been struggling with faith myself. I also wanted to thank you for your suggestion about Anne Morrow's book on one of your podcasts. You have had a great impact on my life thus far and I hardly know you.

Thank you,

Colie

Barbara Bowman
May 15, 2009 9:04 PM

Larry C.C.-- Ironic your closing, "peace." Do you have it?

I believe that Therese is advocating a multi-faceted approach to healing: talk, support, medication if needed, and attention to the spiritual. We are creatures of body, mind, and spirit. In almost any illness, all need to be addressed in the search for a return to wholeness. Too often mental illness is something one is ashamed of. There is a stigma attached to it, and that stigma is present in faith and secular communities.

We are all too aware of the shortcomings of the religious community. Many wish to address them, but need the tools. That is what this posting was about.

Vincent Zimmerman
May 16, 2009 6:24 AM

Therese, I sometimes think I must be the only person diagnosed with bipolar disorder and generalized anxiety who doesn't find peace and security in faith. I don't know why, but fostering a belief in a higher power has caused me nothing but misery and pain. I tried prayer, going to church, bible studies, and nothing did me any good. Different religious beliefs and practices have the same effect. Nothing feels right, nothing touches me on a personal level. I was desperate for a religious or spiritual experience that would touch my heart and point me down the right path. I no longer burn with the desire to find a higher power, because after years, even decades, of searching, I haven't found anything but anguish and agony. I am glad that seemingly everyone but myself can find peace and solace in a higher power, that they have a support, in times of trouble, someone or some thing that provides them with strength and comfort. I envy others for this, but I'm not bitter towards them. They have something wonderful, a true blessing. I wish I could say the same for myself.

Vincent Zimmerman
May 16, 2009 6:29 AM

P

Your Name
May 16, 2009 8:26 AM

Therese, there are parishes in the US who do minister to those of us dealing with mental illness. I did a search and tried to start a program with the blessings of the priests but it just didn't work out. The programs are prayer centered and educational. Once a month prayer meetings and then yearly info workshops.It would be great to not have to deal with the fear factor. I was a very well educated social worker and found my midlife breakdown extremely shameful and embarressing. It was as damaaging to me as to others that knew me at that time. I am still in recovery with these feelings.If we could only get to the AA level of acceptence in society. I think we need more witnessing - more lay people doing the homily.My great uncle did a PHD disteration at the Catholic University of America when he was blacklisted as a priest on Scrupulosity. To read it is sad and he advocated for "mental hygiene" classes for all Catholich High School students.It's a tough one to sort out but at least we have a start.

Christine
May 16, 2009 9:18 AM

Hi folks:

Just as there is "mental illness" and "mental illness", there is "spirituality" and there is "spirituality".

2nd point first: every single person's spiritual aspect is completely unique, and I'll be darned if there aren't as many spiritual approaches to life, sickness, and death as there are human beings in the world.

1st point: my friend is "paranoid schizophrenic" (3 years) with very little insight into her condition. She will not so much as admit the problem, let alone take the medication prescribed. She was at one point actually quite "religious" (whatever that is), but it's hard to say now what her spiritual state is. The priests of her parish(es) have no clue what to do, and avoid her. I'm not blaming them, though. If a half-dozen shrinks and a large, religious family, including a 15-year-old daughter can't get through to her, I actually think the priests might be worse than useless, if that's possible.

My background nationality is Ukrainian, and in that language, the word "psychotic" is "bozhevil'nyy", literally, "godwilled".

BTW, also: there is "peace" and there is "peace". You won't find me trying to define that word, either.

Best wishes. Thanks for the food for thought.
(And yes, there is "thinking" and then there is "thinking".)

Barbara Bowman
May 16, 2009 9:38 AM

Vincent,

I can hear the longing for God in your posting. Our life experiences can either help us in the search for faith, or be a hindrance. If there is someone you respect for their faith, perhaps you can ask him or her to be a spiritual guide or mentor. Not every religious practice or study will be of help. But sometimes you have to start with one thing, stick with it, and allow it to grow in you. I found that being in a long-term Bible study layed a foundation that has helped me greatly over the years. It helped me begin to think of God in more personal terms. In doing so, it has helped my prayer life.

For me, praying to a "higher power" doesn't work. I can't converse with an intelligence - I need a person. I can't often remember specific Biblical passages, but Psalms 139 is one that has stuck over the years. David is speaking about how God has known him even before he was born. Psalms 27 is another favorite. My counselor pointed that one out to me. The line that my counselor gave me is verse 10 - even if mother and father forsake me, yet You will not forget me.

I feel so inadequate to address your posting. But I want you to know that there is a person who read your words and wanted to offer you support. If an ordinary person like myself feels great compassion for your longing, I can only say it is because God has placed that compassion within me. And can God grant us something that is not part of God himself? I believe that God has placed within you the desire to know him, and he will not forsake or forget you.

Avinash Machado
May 16, 2009 10:12 AM

Mental illness is a serious issue and needs to be handled by therapists and doctors.

Vincent Zimmerman
May 16, 2009 3:47 PM

Barbara, I have tried bible studies, for over three years, and I was baptized. None of it did any good, and I opened myself to God, or whatever name he goes by. The more I prayed and studied the bible, the worse my depression and suicidal thoughts became. I looked into other religions, I researched other cultures' belief systems. Bhuddism, Hinduism, Native American, Paganism, Wicca, Bahai, Islam, and others. None of them gave me anything positive, no peace of mind, no sense of serenity or security. I feel angry sometimes, frustrated that so many others have this relationship with a higher power, or God, however you want to refer to it, but I don't. I don't have anything, and it eats at me, it's like a gnat flying around my head, I can't get rid of it and it drives me crazy. I feel like I'm the only one who has this problem. Not very realistic, maybe, but that's how I feel. Very much alone. Very much hurting.

Your Name
May 17, 2009 9:30 AM

Vincent you aren't the only one with that problem, I promise you. Even trying to be an atheist or agnostic has brought me little peace. Just trying to find peace with myself, leaving the god to well...god or whoever. Don't be alone though. I'm UU we always have room for questioners without answers in our community. It surely helps to have people around you, even when you don't know what to believe. Henry Nelson Weiman theorized that divinity exists within the communion between individuals...creative interchange. It's the closest thing to "truth" I think I've found.

Barbara Bowman
May 17, 2009 9:10 PM

Hello again, Vincent.

First of all, I think it is important to seek professional treatment for your depression, as it sounds like you have been trying to cope with it for a long time. I have a counselor that I've been seeing regularly for years. I was very fortunate in the person I found, because he treats the whole person. Many counselors ignore the spiritual side of people, and I think that is a mistake. Additionally, I have been on an antidepressant for almost as long. The combination of talk therapy and medication has made a real difference.

As I said in my first comment, life experiences can be a help or a hindrence in our relationship with God. As I've progressed through counseling, I have gradually found a greater ability to pray, something that was almost impossible prior. You have to find the right combination for you. Scripture works for me. Being a member of a small congregation has made me feel less alone. The only person aware of my personal situation is the pastor, who has been genuinely caring.

As I reread your entry the thought came to me about how some people spend their lives searching for love, when love is really the by-product of a relationship. Could it be as you desperately seek peace, you are missing the opportunity for the relationship to develop?

Please know that I am not being at all critical or trying to diagnose. You have probably heard it all before, but sensing your situation, I want to reach out and help if I can.

Your Name
May 18, 2009 5:09 AM

I have been separated for almost a year and have two daughters. An 18 year old and a soon to be 20 year old. They stay w/their self centered father (who by the way made me sign a prenuptial----so I am poor and all alone). Don't know why my daughters would want to stay w/their father in the most disgustingly, filthy house I have EVER seen. I was a stay-at-home mom for 18 years and have now been working for a little over two years only making $10.50 per hour. I will probably soon be living out of my car.
The link above was emailed to me by my 18 year old daughter just today. I want to believe things will get better. I do believe in God as He is the only One I have to turn to, but it's a long, hard road and I hope I can make it. It is very hard to function day to day.

Vincent Zimmerman
May 18, 2009 2:17 PM

Barbara, thank you for your kindness, and Your Name also. Thank you both. I do currently take medication for the bipolar disorder and the anxiety. I used to be in counseling, but that didn't help me, as I think the counselor was treating me as just one more patient, one more file in the filing cabinet. I understand how any counselor or therapist, psychiatrist, or any other professional could become indifferent to the patients they see. Some level of detachment is needed, for maintaining a professional relationship, and probably their own sanity! But it's that indifference to the patient's pain that drove me to stop seeing my counselor. I don't need someone pretending to care about me and my problems. I don't need someone to judge me even while they're sitting there listening to me pour out my soul to them. I'm more than capable of judging myself. And yes, I did try to develop a relationship with God, or however you want to refer to him/ her. I tried prayer, but it's difficult, after awhile, to keep praying to someone or something you don't feel is there. The bible, and the people at church, say that you shouldn't base your beliefs, your faith, on feelings. I'm sorry, but I can't do that, I can't disregard my feelings. If I feel something to be true, then I have to go with those feelings, wherever they guide me. I think there's more reliability and truth in what I feel than there is in some book that was written thousands of years before I was even born, by people I never met. At least I know where my feelings come from, I look at this person every time I look into a mirror. I know myself better than some dead guy who wrote something down three thousand years before I came waltzing along. If God is real, and wants to talk with me, why the subterfuge? Why not give me something that leaves no room for doubt? Then, at least I'd know he was real, and could decide from there where to go.

Cathy
May 18, 2009 3:14 PM
http://www.myspace.com/artrageousminds

I'm so glad to see something on Beliefnet about Mental Illness and the church. I am a single mom and for the past 14 years have raised my bipolar son on my own. For too many years than I wish to remember I had the why him?, why me?, why us? syndrome. Three solid days and nights of prayer brought me God's answer. With his answer my son and I have formed a nonprofit organization that brings awareness to bipolar disorder (along with other mental illnesses and issues) through the arts.
I went to my pastor excited and elated that God answered my prayer. I asked if I could please have a fundraiser on the church property to get things rolling. I was turned down. When our church planted another, and was looking for ministries I went to this one, thinking surely, I would not be turned away again. I offered an after school art program (this is in a very depressed inner city area) for the children of the area, and wanted to hold a support group at the church once or twice a month depending upon need. Once again I was turned down.
Since then, my feelings toward my church have (not surprisingly) changed. I rarely go, although my faith has not been broken. To those who are bipolar, and to the families and caregivers who love them, I pray for you all - each and every day.

They say Satan strikes hardest when you're about to be blessed by God. Shortly after forming our organization (Artrageous Minds) I was involved in an awful car accident that took me out of commission for six months. Just as I was feeling up to the task at hand, my home was invaded and my computer, along with all of my contacts, business plan, information, etc etc - was stolen. And that wasn't enough for this thief. As soon as I had it replaced, he broke in and stole that one too. Being in the hardest hit area of this recession my son and I are among those who had to file bankrupt and will be losing our home.

My plans now? Well, I'm still hoping that through God's grace, we will be able to start a working art studio/gallery where we can have not only support groups, but also classes in creativity. This summer I am attending art fairs and selling my own artwork, in an attempt to raise money to get things going. At the end of the summer, we are planning a private benefit performance by a 90's rock star.

So I guess what I'm saying here is... I really do wish that the churches would educate themselves. My own church told me that me and my son should pray, and he'd be saved (cured) by Jesus. People are afraid of the term "bipolar". They are afraid of the words "mental illness". Rather than being afraid - I wish they would open their hearts to compassion.

Cathy Weaver
May 18, 2009 3:33 PM
http://www.myspace.com/artrageousminds

Vincent, I meant to address you directly in my last post.
You are NOT alone in your thinking. Reading your words, I thought - oh, I've had this conversation before - with my own son. He too doesn't know what to feel, or how to feel about any higher power. He (very lightly) explored Buddhism and also tried going to my church's youth group services a few times, and also attending with me once or twice. He is not comfortable in that setting at all. Sometimes I feel that is my fault, that he has no faith. When he was young, I wouldn't take him anyplace that he'd have to sit quietly for any period of time, as I knew that would end up in a very loud disaster. Both of us now, are a little on the recluse side of the coin. I've alienated myself over that past 14 years simply by staying home with my son and caring for him, rather than going out after work, and having an adult social life. My son, with his anxieties has become the one afraid to spend much time in public, feeling that he is being judged by "everyone out there".
Still I pray though. I pray for him, and I'll add you to my prayers as well Vincent. I hope you'll visit my website and friend me. Take heart in knowing this if nothing else. You are NOT alone, and there are people out here who do care, and who do understand.

Your Name
May 20, 2009 4:15 PM

I MAY NOT HAVE FAMILY AND CLOSE FRIENDS HERE,I MAY LOOK ALONE BECAUSE
I DON'T GO TO SOCIAL FUNCTIONS AND ALL I DO IS TO TAKE SERIOUSLY MY
OBLIGATION AS A MOM OF 4 GIRLS,BUT I DON'T FEEL ALONE.I HAVE MY FAMILY
AND LOVE ONES WHO CALLS ME ON THE PHONE ASKING HOW I AM DOING,I CAN
PRAY TO GOD ANYTIME AND HE LISTENS TO ME.ALL I AM ASKING IS THE BLESSING OF A GOOD HEALTH TO ALL MY LOVE ONES AND I SEE IN THE NATURAL
THAT NOBODY GET SICK,THAT IS ENOUGH TO KEEP MY CONFIDENCE THAT GOD
LISTENS TO MY PRAYERS.WHATEVER OTHER ISSUES OR PROBLEMS LEFT UNANSWERED,I AM PATIENT TO WAIT FOR THE LORD.NO MATTER HOW BAD OUR
SITUATIONS IN LIFE,WHAT MATTERS MOST IS THE WAY YOU TAKE IT,I TAKE IT
AS A HARD LESSON LEARNED AND PRAY THAT GOD WILL MAKE MY PATH STRAIGHT
AND WORK TO MAKE MY LIFE WORTHLIVING AND TO LIVE A PURPOSE DRIVEN LIFE EVERYDAY AS I LET GOD'S WILL INTO MY LIFE.

Jennifer Long
May 29, 2009 9:16 PM

I am asking any of you readers to share with me and others if any of your friends or loved ones have hurt your feelings by being jealous that you live at home with your parent even though I am an adult. My mom and I are both on SSI so we are very low income. I have this friend from church who recently stated this comment about our singles guy leader who lives with his mom. She said we need to get out in the real world and pay 600 or 700 per month for rent. She is very cold hearted, bitter, and I think jealous of those who get a check from the government. It is not our fault we suffer from an mental illness.

Post a Comment

By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.



Please type the text you see in the box below to verify your post and help us prevent spam. You have a limited time to type - you may wish to compose your comment in a separate document and paste it here upon completion.

Type the characters you see in the picture above.

Advertisement

Search This Blog

feed icon Subscribe

RSS Feed

Receive updates from Beyond Blue

Beyond Blue: The Book!

Can't get enough of Therese’s wise, funny, uplifting journey through depression and anxiety?

Pre-order your copy of her upcoming book today!

Advertisement

Advertisement


About Beliefnet

Our mission is to help people like you find, and walk, a spiritual path that will bring comfort, hope, clarity, strength, and happiness. More about Beliefnet.

Legal

Copyright © Beliefnet, Inc. and/or its licensors. All rights reserved. Use of this site is subject to Terms of Service and to our Privacy Policy. Constructed by Beliefnet.

Advertisement

Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.