For those who want a list from best to worst in one place — here it is:
1. Stevia. Zero calories. Glycemic Index: 0
2. Coconut sugar. 16 calories per teaspoon. Glycemic Index: 35
3. Trehalose. 11 calories per teaspoon. Glycemic index: low/moderate in most people.
4. Honey. 22 calories per teaspoon. Glycemic index: 55.
5. Xylitol. 10 calories per teaspoon. Gycemic index: 8
6. Molasses. 16 calories per teaspoon. Glycemic Index: 55.
7. Whey Low. 4 calories per teaspoon. Glycemic Index: about 25
8. Truvia/PureVia. Zero calories. Glycemic index: 0
9. Agave nectar. 15 to 30 calories per teaspoon. Glycemic index: 30
10. Table sugar.16 calories per teaspoon. Glycemic index: 65
11. Sucralose (Splenda) Zero calories. Glycemic index: 80.
12. Aspartame — Zero calories. Glycemic index: 0
13. High fructose corn syrup — 16 calories per teaspoon Glycemic index: 87
You will notice that the calories and the glycemic index aren’t the only deciding factors in these ranking. This is my judgement based on health benefits or dangers, price, accessibility, taste, and ease of use. Your list may be different — and that’s fine! As I have often said, God didn’t make us with a cookie-cutter. Find what works for YOU!
Eating to live and living for Christ,
Susan Jordan Brown



posted April 20, 2012 at 9:28 am
Yes, everyone knows their own body best. There is no “one size fits all” plan for everybody. Diabetics especially need to keep careful watch on how foods, particularly sweeteners, affect their blood sugar levels. Thanks for reading and commenting!
posted April 20, 2012 at 9:27 am
Good idea!
posted April 19, 2012 at 1:22 pm
Thank you for your research. It is very helpful. You are right that what works for one will be different for someone else. I do well on stevia, trehalose and xylitol and not so well on the coconut sugar. I tried it 2 yrs. ago and wanted to like it!! I do know, on the honey, that it is best to find local, “real” honey….very little on grocery shelves is pure, real honey..and 1/4 tsp. a day of local can help with allergies ( in people over 1 yr. of age only)…