Advertisement
This blog is no longer updated and is closed for comments. We welcome your comments about politics in our Politics forums.
Diana Butler Bass is a religion scholar and author of Christianity for the Rest of Us: How the Neighborhood Church is Transforming the Faith. She blogs at God’s Politics.
Tony Campolo is Professor Emeritus at Eastern University and author of The God of Intimacy and Action: Reconnecting Ancient Spiritual Practices, Evangelism, and Justice, with Mary Darling. He blogs at God’s Politics.
Rod Dreher is a columnist for The Dallas Morning News and author of Crunchy Cons: The New Conservative Counterculture and Its Return to Roots. He blogs at Crunchy Con.
Bruce Feiler is the author of seven books, including Walking the Bible: A Journey by Land Through the Five Books of Moses. He blogs at Feiler Faster.
Dan Gilgoff is Politics Editor at Beliefnet and author of The Jesus Machine: How James Dobson, Focus on the Family, and Evangelical America are Winning the Culture War. He blogs at God-o-Meter.
David Kuo served as a special assistant to President George W. Bush and is the author of Tempting Faith: An Inside Story of Political Seduction. He blogs at J-Walking.
Dr. Richard Land is president of The Southern Baptist Convention's Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission and author of The Divided States of America? What Liberals AND Conservatives are missing in the God-and-country shouting match!
Michele McGinty is a mom and a student at Westminster Theological Seminary in Philadelphia. She blogs at Reformed Chicks Blabbing.
Brian McLaren is a pastor, musician, and author of Everything Must Change: Jesus, Global Crises, and a Revolution of Hope. He blogs at God’s Politics.
Steven Waldman is co-founder, CEO, and Editor-in-Chief of Beliefnet. His book Founding Faith will be published in March, and he can be reached through the Beliefnet community.
Jim Wallis is executive director of Sojourners/Call to Renewal and author of God’s Politics: Why the Right Gets It Wrong and the Left Doesn’t Get It. He blogs at God’s Politics.
In a world teetering on world war with attrocities in Iraq, the Sudan, Palestine, Tibet, and Southeast Asia the Bishops are worried about openly gay Bishops in committed relationships and not those (like Bishop Otis Charles) who hid their orientation so they could continue ministry. Out of sight out of mind.
In a world where women are abused and neglected, sold into slavery, aborted for being daughters and not sons there are some Bishops who are concerned that those lacking Y-chromosones (and penis') are being consecrated.
Bishops, Never in the Gospels does your Jesus say anything like "Blessed are those who discriminate against homosexuals..." or "When women sought to be ordained you kept them out--enter into the joy of my rest!"
Greenman
Just out of curiousity are American dioceses still buying airline tickets so African and Asian Bishops can attend the Lambeth Conference?
Has it ever occurred to you that the atrocities you are so concerned about are the natural consequence of the dilution of Christian morality?
In a world filled with hate, what do we have in the one place where we should be demonstrating the love of Jesus? We have more hate. Hate the gays, hate the women priests, hate those who support the blasphemers who have diluted the fanatical fundamentalist exclusionary morality, hate , hate, hate .... and the ultimate hypocrisy, it is hate being clothed in the name of righteousness, robed in the "name of God".
I am quite certain that whatever form God has, He is so very pleased with the actions of these faithful servants who are faithfully demonstrating so powerfully what divine love truly IS NOT.
"Has it ever occurred to you that the atrocities you are so concerned about are the natural consequence of the dilution of Christian morality?"
That's assuming that those practicing Christianity are in some way morally superior to those who are not of the Abrahamic faiths, which is demoinstarbly untrue. It's also assuming that such atrocities occured less often when Christianioty had a strnglehold on Western civilization, which is disproven by historical records.
Any religion that persecutes persons merely because of their differences is undeserving of any form of the label "compassionate".
As for Anglicans who hate homosexuals, maybe instead of importing backward homphobic priests and bishops from Nigeria (so well known for it's acts of compassion - NOT!) they should move themselves to Nigeria where they can openly practice their mindeless prejudices.
Lauren,
Thank you for the mention of Martyn Minns. He has been marginalized and ignored.
The last time I was naive enough to mention to an older Episcopalian the 39 Articles (which my aunt read by flashlight as a girl), he responded with some mention of the diocesan newsletter. Perhaps his diocese (Memphis is in it) does call their newsletter "the 39 Articles," but I severely doubt that.
"Hate." Old men in self-inflicted Depends Undergarments have been hated if they have not been warned. God has his categories of love and hate. Psalm 5 speaks of God's hatred. No, it is not a blistering Nazi emotion or conviction. Having said that, to ignore Jesus' being crucified on the cross for our sin is to hate Christ Jesus.
No, I don't support civil penalties against practicing homosexuals. Jesus cut that out by ceasing the stoning of the adulterous woman. Imagine however the worst of homosexual haters: what homosexuals do to each other and themselves eclipses civil execution.
I didn't mention practicing christians. I talked about Christian morality. Not living up to a standard of conduct, and defining a standard of conduct downward are not the same thing.
And, yes, Christianity is a superior system of morality.
Buddhism has a far better track record than Christianity.
" what homosexuals do to each other and themselves eclipses civil execution."
Unless someone is gay himself, he/she have only the perverted opinions of homophobes on which to base such a statement.
It is a miracle in & of itself that the majority of gays grow up sane under the overtly unreasoned persecutions practiced by the body of followers of Abrahamic religions.
"And, yes, Christianity is a superior system of morality."
Because you say so?
I am honestly repulsed by some of the comments here.
Alec, can you expand on what exactly "homosexuals do to each other and themselves" that is worse than EXECUTION?
This is why I'm not a Xtian.
"Crack is whack!" - Whitney Houston
I have some questions for all Christian religions and their righteous leadership. While Jesus walked the earth and taught all who would listen, He never personally attacked nor identified abortion and homosexuality as being sinful much less an abomination to God His Father. Do you think He forgot, or was somehow remiss in His duty to save us from damnation? Or do you think that perhaps since He was a Jewish Rabbi, Jesus never considered them abominations or even sinful? If He, in His infinite wisdom as One of Three Persons in the Trinity did not condemn abortion or homosexuality, what gives you the right to? I am talking about Jesus’ direct words and not those stories and rules contained in other books that do not quote Jesus’ words. Thank you for your time and answers. I look forward to reading them and gaining insight into your reasons.
Thank God we have A New Earth coming. All the old judgmental structures will eventually fall away and we will each connect with God or Source directly and eliminate all these middle men. From the beginning of time, all wise ones have said go within, but we just didn't trust our inner selves to listen to Source. That is changing with the new generations as well, as they flee from the bureaucratic structures and controls. Jesus didn't need to have a degree or credentials to share the truth and neither do we. Everything has been structured to death from our churches to our governments to our educational systems, and corporations, and bound up by laws made by a few to simply control all the others. The bottom line today seems to be monetary rather than awakening to the truth of who we really are. In A Course in Miracles Jesus says, "Return to Love" and that is the only law we should seek. When we live and act out of love we do follow a path that eliminates injustice. Today we see more and more people turning away from structured religion, and I believe it will continue until there are less fear filled people needing the narrow teachings of the church.
I used to be a fundamentalist simply because that was my introduction to Christianity. In those circles, if a leader becomes or outs as a homosexual, he would be out (not likely a she). In other words, I learned a certain attitude toward gays that it is very hard to change.
But change I have. It isn't exactly toleration of a sin; it is more a recognition that we're all in the same boat. My job as a Christian is reconciliation not division over endless issues. Does not "blessed are the peacemakers" mean that we are to become bridge-builders instead of wall-builders? Jesus is the savior of all, not just heteros.
If I don't like my present leader, for whatever reason, I have the option to leave his or her church and let it become what it will become. Or I can stay and try to be an influence for peace and encouragement in the gospel.
I think these older denominations are struggling with these issues, and they are tricky. But in the bigger picture ~ in the picture of the whole communion of believers in the world ~ I think God is trying to bring us all to comprehend love, which transcends power-struggles. In that sense, the more fundamentalistic among us will have to shed their prejudices against people who are not like them and get off their pedestal of a "righteous" hatred of gays. It's hypocritical. It is also an example of "straining at gnats and swallowing camels." It politicizes the gospel, and frankly they are shooting themselves in the foot. Anti-gay is not the church mission.
In the end, God is in control of the whole thing. And I think all churches are going to have to face themselves and own up to the their various xenophobias. May God help us to love one another and get on with what really matters in the short lives we have.
As Christians, we should stop quoting Leviticus, unless, of course we are willing to give up our ham for Easter, oyster stuffing for Thanksgiving, and poly-cotton blends in the summer. Women should also be prepared to remove ourselves to the "red tent" during our monthly cycle, not returning to public life until undergoing a ritual cleansing and having our priest sacrifice a dove on the altar upon our return. (Men, while we are out of commission, you can figure out who will cook all the meals, clean the house and handle the car pool duties ferrying your progeny to and from school, ballet and soccer practice.)
Can we all finally agree to just get over Old Testament law? Christ came and the law is fulfilled. We are no longer bound by it. Could the spirit have made it any clearer than with Peter's vision when he is commanded by God to "kill and eat" even the "unclean" animals in his vision and is told that nothing made by God is "unclean."
When it comes to the Anglican Communion, many people do not understand that ++Rowan is not like the Pope and cannot "discipline" the member churches in the union. In fact, his current stab at "discipline" by not extending an invitation to +Gene Robinson, who was the properly elected Bishop of New Hampshire, merely made himself look small, mean-spirited and not very street smart. The Bishops he tried to appease boycotted Lambeth anyway and left him hanging out to dry.
The Anglicans have always been unique in that we are loosely bound together having formed from one "mother church," but agreeing to govern ourselves, tolerate (even celebrate) our differences, and to support each other in the spread of the gospel. We are NOT a "confessing" church, but a creedal church. We have never needed any statement of theology set in stone ("You must believe this, or else. . .")nor do we now. We have the Holy Scripture, the Prayer Book with the creeds (tradition), and last, but certainly not least, the good intelligence God has bestowed upon each of us to discern the calling of the Spirit in our lives (reason).
God is love, and I believe I found God in the love I discovered in my local Episcopal Parish where every political and theological viewpoint can be accounted for from far right to far left and everything in between. We have a genuine loving and caring for each other, however, and every week we meet around the altar and share the body and blood of our Lord. To me that is the beauty and strength of the Episcopal Church. There is room for all around the table. That was also the beauty and strength of the Anglican Communion before the current power grab started.
In response to the posting by Ro Ford. Well said; a beautiful understanding of the teachings of Christ and of the purpose of religion in society. LOVE!! UNDERSTANDING!! HELPING ONE ANOTHER!! Taking care of the plank in our own eye before we condemn or brethren for the splinter in their's. Thank you. Maybe there is hope after all. Good Luck and God Bless!
Jim
Post a Comment
By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.