|
Previous Posts
"The veil is on my face, not my mind" #Egypt
Sometimes, Twitter's forced succinctness produces the most insightful commentary:
Almost fell over when a niqabi in Luxor told us she voted for Hamdeen Sabahi. "The veil is
posted 10:45:47am May. 24, 2012 |
read full post
»
Muhammad Asad and Islam as a rational faith
There's a lengthy essay by Talal Asad of his father, Muhammad Asad (b. Leopold Weiss 1900 d. 1992), a convert to Islam from Judaism and one of the 20th century's great Islamic thinkers. I found this part p
posted 7:49:11pm May. 22, 2012 |
read full post
»
Mubarak, Facebook! and shukran
Today, Facebook goes public, and begins trading on the New York Stock Exchange at 11:00am Eastern time (the truly addicted stockwatchers may want to bookmark this). Amidst all the
posted 10:32:41am May. 18, 2012 |
read full post
»
Islam and Star Wars Day: Allah is the Force
Jumah Mubarak, and May the 4th be with you! Today is Star Wars day, the day we remember with fondness the three greatest movies of our childhood
posted 8:57:52am May. 04, 2012 |
read full post
»
the post-Osama world, Year One
It's the one-year anniversary of the successful killing of Osama bin Laden. Having gone through the requisite 5 stages of emotion over the act long ago, I find that looking back at it now, it feels as though little has changed. Al Qaeda remains a distributed threat still seeking to harm America, tho
posted 8:49:01am May. 01, 2012 |
read full post
»
|
posted February 11, 2009 at 12:22 pm
So atheism’s a religion, huh? Then so are vegetarianism, republicanism, athleticism, mathematicianism, alcoholism, Mets fan-ism or and other idea that can be classified/made to end with ism. When you can classify a single DISbelief that doesn’t involve gods, rituals, temples or holidays as a religion, EVERYTHING becomes a religion. Good call, genius.
posted February 11, 2009 at 1:21 pm
All those examples you list do not enter the realm of religion, however some do try to take them to that level.
Atheism, OTOH, is a religion in that it asks for faith on behalf of its adherents. It’s the very definition of an article of faith to say, “There is no god.” One really has no way of knowing. So, it’s something that requires faith to believe. Additionally, because of that core doctrinal belief, a certain philosophical/moral code is derived. Again, something religion does. And atheism certainly has its list of commandments (evolution, global warming, embryonic stem cell research)! But there is debate between different atheist denominations as to how serious the transgression of them really are.
As atheists say theists have no way of knowing there’s a god, that we’re all playing pretend, the accusation cuts the other way.
Sorry to tell you the truth, but ‘dems the bricks.
posted February 11, 2009 at 5:33 pm
I’ve probably only known one or two atheists in my lifetime who think they can say “There is no god” as a statement of fact, and they are wrong. As your billboard says, you can’t prove a negative, so that’s not really a defensible position. That is why the majority of atheists don’t make that claim – they prefer a position to the effect of “The evidence for the existence of god provided by believers is highly unconvinicing.” There is no statement of faith involved; rather, just the statement that we don’t share your faith.
If you are claiming that the ability to shape a person’s morality or philosphical code is what makes something a religion, then every example I listed (in addition to everything else in life) qualifies. I imagine it would be more accurate to say that a religion is something that gives you a specific set of morals or philosophies to adhere to, which atheism does not.
As for the evolution, stem cell research, etc. remark, I shouldn’t have to tell you that those subjects are 100% unrelated to atheism. There are atheists on both sides of the board on each one of those issues, just as there are among the religious. Do tell – exactly what is it about the disbelief in gods that is supposed to tell someone what to think about global warming?
posted February 11, 2009 at 6:32 pm
If you can’t prove a negative, neither can you disprove it.
Arnold Harris
Mount Horeb WI
posted February 12, 2009 at 12:26 pm
Ironic that you can advertise atheism on the side of a bus in the UK, but the law would then prevent a faith group from being able to advertise God.
posted February 12, 2009 at 12:30 pm
Doh. I realise now that the comment above makes me look like a butt. Sorry folks. I should read slower
posted February 13, 2009 at 4:26 pm
What a great idea! And as for the L A Christian tourist not liking it? Who really cares? She doesn’t even live there so she needed to “just get over it”, IMO. London is a great place. If I had see that during my trips to London, on one of the buses, I would have thought it was a neat campaign. England isn’t as up tight as the USA.
Washington DC ran some bus atheist ads over Christmas, with Santa in the picture. Not a big deal.