Top Brit general: We must leave Iraq
This is huge, not only in terms of military strategy, but because of the challenge it represents to the British government's authority. The head of the British Army is in open rebellion against the government's Iraq policy. Gen. Sir Richard Dannatt says that the Brits have to leave Iraq because they're making the security situation worse. They are no longer wanted there, he says. And there's this astonishing warning about British society:
Sir Richard warned that the consequences will be felt at home, where failure to support Christian values is allowing a predatory Islamist vision to take hold.
He said: "When I see the Islamist threat in this country I hope it doesn’t make undue progress because there is a moral and spiritual vacuum in this country."
"Our society has always been embedded in Christian values; once you have pulled the anchor up there is a danger that our society moves with the prevailing wind."
"There is an element of the moral compass spinning. I think it is up to society to realise that is the situation we are in."
"We can’t wish the Islamist challenge to our society away and I believe that the army both in Iraq and Afghanistan and probably wherever we go next, is fighting the foreign dimension of the challenge to our accepted way of life."
"We need to face up to the Islamist threat, to those who act in the name of Islam and in a perverted way try to impose Islam by force on societies that do not wish it."
"It is said that we live in a post Christian society. I think that is a great shame. The broader Judaic-Christian tradition has underpinned British society. It underpins the British army."
The General seems nostalgic for a time when Britain had a moral force capable of combating Islamic intimidation. By saying that the Judeo-Christian tradition underpins the Btitish Army, perhaps he is saying that it provides the restraint necessary to prevent things from breaking down into savage anarchy. Certainly he is witnessing savage anarchy everyday in Iraq among the warring factions. Perhaps our J-C orientation causes us to under estimate the savage potential in military involvements in faraway places. This underestimation causes us to get in over our heads.>
Indeed: the capital is Paris.
I stand corrected.>
The guy has to be fired, period, a la MacArthur. Generals don't get to advocate policy, if you want democracy to survive. Ex-generals, yes. On-duty generals, no.>
Hasn't he already caved in?>
I was right: by the time I posted that, he was saying there was no difference in his and Blair's positions.>
Post a Comment
By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.