Ayaan Hirsi Ali writes about the time as a refugee in Holland, that she learned about the Holocaust. She told her sister, also a Somali refugee, what had been done to the Jews of Europe by the Nazis and their...
One important step might be that those who are so afraid of the Islamists destroying the Modern Western Civilization must also come to grips with the fact that, more often than not, they themselves equate this same culture as "evil." Look at the threads about the women's lib movement for example. Make up your minds those of the religious right! Is Western civilization "evil and must be destroyed," (and therefore the Islamists are doing your bidding) or is it something you wish to have left intact? That's my problem with many, many arguments from certain factions -- their consistent inconsistency.>
Joey
December 17, 2006 5:24 PM
Does the choice have to be between "materialistic junkheap" and "smoking crater?" Besides a very small fringe, people on the Religious Right are not in favor of violence to achieve means. Bin Laden is right when he calls this country decadent, but that means it should stop being decadent, not that everyone in it should be killed.
God bless.>
Major Wootton
December 17, 2006 9:57 PM
Joey - - I can grasp the difference! Fantastic! Hope others can, too.>
Karen LH
December 17, 2006 10:01 PM
Also, what Bin Laden wants the culture to look like is very different from what we think that healthy Western culture should look like. Just because we agree on a few points doesn't mean that we agree on all.>
Burlap Bagg
December 17, 2006 11:11 PM
Not to let "the religious right" off the hook or anything, but aren't there lots (and lots) of people on the left who also think America is evil and are therefore, shall we say, not *wholly* opposed to Comrade Bin Laden?>
Gretchen
December 17, 2006 11:30 PM
So I guess some of you are saying that denying the holocaust and advocating for a new one is not evil? That telling heinous lies about the Jewish people is not evil? That corrupting children with hatred is not evil? That it's not evil that moderates are either afraid to speak out (because you know what will be coming to them) or are silently complicit with the prevailing view?
Wow. Then just what is evil? Do we need to see lots more incinerated Jews before some of you will believe in evil?>
Karen LH
December 18, 2006 3:27 AM
It's hard to understand how it is possible for whole populations not even to have heard of such a major historical event that is still withing living memory.>
ONC
December 18, 2006 5:27 AM
ONC
Anon,
I believe it was Michael Moore who on 9/12/01, said that America had it coming. I dont believe he is excatly Mr. Religious Right, but he seems to think this country is quite evil.>
car insurance detroit, car insurance minneapolis, affordable car insurance, auto car cheap insurance quote, auto insurance quote, budget car insurance, car cheap insurance, car cheap insurance quote, car cheapest insurance, car company insurance,car cost insurance low, car insurance, car insurance minnesota quote, car insurance online, car insurance online quote,car insurance quote, car insurance rate, car insurance uk, cheap car insurance quote, cheap car insurance uk, classic car insurance, free auto insurance quote, free car insurance quote, free online car insurance quote, online auto insurance quote
atlanta used car, bad credit used car loan, buy used car, buy used car cheap, car max used car, cheap used car for sale, donate used car, find used car, japanese used car, kelley blue book used car, orlando used car, used car, used car blue book value, used car chicago, used car classifieds, used car dallas, used car dealer, used car detroit, used car for sale, used car for sale by owner, used car history, used car houston, used car loan, used car los angeles, used car new york>
Franklin Evans
December 18, 2006 4:58 PM
http://madfedor.blogspot.com/
While wondering if I'm right in assuming that john's post is supposed to convince the reader of America's decadence, I'm struck by a couple of random thoughts.
Let's all stand up to these Holocaust-denying Muslim cultures, and publicly insist that they are all hate-filled war mongerers who want nothing more than to establish Muslim dictatorships in every country. When they complain about our telling lies about them, we can simply point out that our "lies" are no more "lies" than their "truth" about Jews is "truth".
[Personal caveat: that is an ill-formed and incomplete idea. I don't personally believe in the core descriptions.]
To Burlap Bagg: two sets of your "enemies" are not by definition "friends" of each other. I don't know of any liberal this side of the lunatic fringe who even thinks that we got what was coming to us, and Michael Moore may be excused (but not forgiven) for using exaggerated rhetoric in order to promote his livelihood. I am, in many ways, just as liberal as Moore, and in no way do I permit him to speak for me, not even in those areas where I may later agree with him: I simply don't trust him any further than I trust most televangelists, and for the same reasons.>
kim margosein
December 18, 2006 5:47 PM
To ONC:
I don't know about Michael Moore, but I recall two guys named, IIRC Pat Robertson and Jerry Falwell saying the same thing. Do their names ring a bell with you? Are they Christian by any chance?
Kim M>
Tuan
September 18, 2008 1:54 PM
It is the Christian Nazis who gassed the Jews and it was always the Western Europeans who ill-treated them.
The Jews have lived in Arab lands for centuries in peace and harmony. The problem between Arabs and Jews happened after the creation of Israel in Arab Palestine.
Stop blaming everyone else.
Now Ayaan Ali is playing to the Western prejudices.
Post a Comment
By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.
Rod Dreher is an editorial columnist for the Dallas Morning News, and author of "Crunchy Cons" (Crown Forum), a nonfiction book about conservatives, most of them religious, whose faith and political convictions sometimes put them at odds with mainstream conservatives. The views expressed in this blog are his own.
Subscribe
Sign Up: Receive Crunchy Con in your in-box every day
One important step might be that those who are so afraid of the Islamists destroying the Modern Western Civilization must also come to grips with the fact that, more often than not, they themselves equate this same culture as "evil." Look at the threads about the women's lib movement for example.
Make up your minds those of the religious right! Is Western civilization "evil and must be destroyed," (and therefore the Islamists are doing your bidding) or is it something you wish to have left intact? That's my problem with many, many arguments from certain factions -- their consistent inconsistency.>
Does the choice have to be between "materialistic junkheap" and "smoking crater?" Besides a very small fringe, people on the Religious Right are not in favor of violence to achieve means. Bin Laden is right when he calls this country decadent, but that means it should stop being decadent, not that everyone in it should be killed.
God bless.>
Joey - - I can grasp the difference! Fantastic! Hope others can, too.>
Also, what Bin Laden wants the culture to look like is very different from what we think that healthy Western culture should look like. Just because we agree on a few points doesn't mean that we agree on all.>
Not to let "the religious right" off the hook or anything, but aren't there lots (and lots) of people on the left who also think America is evil and are therefore, shall we say, not *wholly* opposed to Comrade Bin Laden?>
So I guess some of you are saying that denying the holocaust and advocating for a new one is not evil? That telling heinous lies about the Jewish people is not evil? That corrupting children with hatred is not evil? That it's not evil that moderates are either afraid to speak out (because you know what will be coming to them) or are silently complicit with the prevailing view?
Wow. Then just what is evil? Do we need to see lots more incinerated Jews before some of you will believe in evil?>
It's hard to understand how it is possible for whole populations not even to have heard of such a major historical event that is still withing living memory.>
Anon,
I believe it was Michael Moore who on 9/12/01, said that America had it coming. I dont believe he is excatly Mr. Religious Right, but he seems to think this country is quite evil.>
http://www.4carloancalculator.com
mortgage calculator, online calculator, auto loan calculator, car loan calculator, car payment calculator, automobile loan, mortgage rate calculator, loan payment calculator, free mortgage calculator, auto payment calculator, interest only loan calculator, interest only calculator, percentage calculator, loan amortization calculator, mortgage amortization calculator, auto finance calculator, car loan payment calculator, calculation loan, auto loan payment calculator, car loan finance calculator, yahoo auto loan calculator, vehicle loan, loan calc, calculate loan payment, calculate car loan
http://www.4freeautoinsurancequote.com
car insurance detroit, car insurance minneapolis, affordable car insurance, auto car cheap insurance quote, auto insurance quote, budget car insurance, car cheap insurance, car cheap insurance quote, car cheapest insurance, car company insurance,car cost insurance low, car insurance, car insurance minnesota quote, car insurance online, car insurance online quote,car insurance quote, car insurance rate, car insurance uk, cheap car insurance quote, cheap car insurance uk, classic car insurance, free auto insurance quote, free car insurance quote, free online car insurance quote, online auto insurance quote
http://www.4usedcarsearch.com
atlanta used car, bad credit used car loan, buy used car, buy used car cheap, car max used car, cheap used car for sale, donate used car, find used car, japanese used car, kelley blue book used car, orlando used car, used car, used car blue book value, used car chicago, used car classifieds, used car dallas, used car dealer, used car detroit, used car for sale, used car for sale by owner, used car history, used car houston, used car loan, used car los angeles, used car new york>
While wondering if I'm right in assuming that john's post is supposed to convince the reader of America's decadence, I'm struck by a couple of random thoughts.
Let's all stand up to these Holocaust-denying Muslim cultures, and publicly insist that they are all hate-filled war mongerers who want nothing more than to establish Muslim dictatorships in every country. When they complain about our telling lies about them, we can simply point out that our "lies" are no more "lies" than their "truth" about Jews is "truth".
[Personal caveat: that is an ill-formed and incomplete idea. I don't personally believe in the core descriptions.]
To Burlap Bagg: two sets of your "enemies" are not by definition "friends" of each other. I don't know of any liberal this side of the lunatic fringe who even thinks that we got what was coming to us, and Michael Moore may be excused (but not forgiven) for using exaggerated rhetoric in order to promote his livelihood. I am, in many ways, just as liberal as Moore, and in no way do I permit him to speak for me, not even in those areas where I may later agree with him: I simply don't trust him any further than I trust most televangelists, and for the same reasons.>
To ONC:
I don't know about Michael Moore, but I recall two guys named, IIRC Pat Robertson and Jerry Falwell saying the same thing. Do their names ring a bell with you? Are they Christian by any chance?
Kim M>
It is the Christian Nazis who gassed the Jews and it was always the Western Europeans who ill-treated them.
The Jews have lived in Arab lands for centuries in peace and harmony. The problem between Arabs and Jews happened after the creation of Israel in Arab Palestine.
Stop blaming everyone else.
Now Ayaan Ali is playing to the Western prejudices.
Post a Comment
By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.