Losing southeast Louisiana
The Times-Picayune has a stunningly well-done series on how incredibly fast southeast Louisiana is sliding into the sea. Here's a
fantastic interactive graphic explaining how the entire region was built up in time, and how thanks to the works of man, it has mostly eroded away since 1930. Here's
part one of the series.
That's a stunning graphic. I had no idea SE Louisiana was THAT much of an ecological disaster!
What, if anything, can be done about this? The NOLA graphic suggests that levees are biggest culprit. But if you dismantle or stop building levees, don't you have to abandon New Orleans?
All the work the Corps of Engineers has done in the 20th century to control the Mississippi River has played a major role in this disaster. The Corps was channeling the river in part to keep the Port of New Orleans viable. And now we see that it's helped make New Orleans itself close to non-viable. What a tragedy.
I don't mean to be uncompassionate, but at what point do we say, "Look. You guys are living on a flood-plain. You know that. We know that. You want to keep living there? Fine. That's your choice, but don't come crying to us when your house washes away." My heart really does go out to people who lost everything and my church and my family have and are doing their part to help out, but seriously, is anybody shocked when New Orleans (or Florida or Mississippi) is hit by a hurricane? For that very reason the help we've been focusing on up here is helping people permanently relocate somewhere else.
BeProf, I totally agree with you. Please all pardon my sarcasm at the beginning but I am so sick and tired that every time Katrina gets brought up Bush gets the blame for it. To be quite honest I never voted for Bush, I have not been happy with that man at all, but living in liberal oasis of Austin, TX I have seen every sort of problem laid at that mans feet. To put it bluntly, if children could vote I have no doubt that they would be told that Bush is the reason why puppies and kittens die. Again, having never voted for Bush, if he could run for a third term I think I would vote for him just to piss of those who had done everything imaginable to blame him for everything that has ever gone wrong.
Ugh.. That whole Mississippi River situation is not a good thing then. There has to be an economical way to transfer goods from river barges to oceangoing vessels. New Orleans was founded as a port, to be that station of transfer where river boats and sea boats can come together to transfer things. Do we need to move the NO port operations to Pascagoula and set up fifteen parallel rail lines between there and Baton Rouge? In so doing, would we just abandon the Mississippi River delta and let nature take over? What makes other rivers different? Do they have this problem in Alexandria on the Nile? The Amazon doesn't have much trade going on along it. Are there similar circumstances with the Yellow River in China with all the silt it carries?
Post a Comment
By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.