Crunchy Con

Crossing to safety

Tuesday May 29, 2007

Did you know that Iraqi Christians are sneaking across the US-Mexico border, fleeing Islamist persecution? Here's a fascinating story from the San Antonio Express-News detailing the phenomenon. Excerpt:The journey north from Guatemala through Mexico to the Texas border lasted 17...
Advertisement
Comments
Phil
May 30, 2007 1:39 AM
HASH(0x96ec67c)

Does anyone still want to defend the position that peace and love will be breaking out in Iraq any minute now? The refugee crisis is going to be off the scale when we do get around to pulling out. Hope the folks who stood by us over there are making their own plans to get out because it's a good bet that no one in this administration is foresighted enough to see that when we do leave lots of the locals will want to go with us. -Phil-

SteveM
May 30, 2007 1:55 AM
HASH(0x96ed598)

Another example of the thunderous silence of the "moderate" Muslim community. And in this case I mean the Iraqi government in Baghdad. We are sending boys to die so that the Maliki government can turn a blind eye to the persecution of Iraq's non-Muslim citizens? Sheesh...

Joey
May 30, 2007 2:04 AM
HASH(0x96ef1e4)

I think the American government needs to come up with some sort of way to help Iraqi Christians, as well as those who have worked with the U.S. government, either come to America or flee Iraq for another country; with the situation so bad there (though I continue to pray that it does work out, somehow), it would be wrong for us to abandon them, after we, whether with good or bad intentions, caused these problems. God bless.

fbc
May 30, 2007 2:28 AM
HASH(0x9708534)

I don't think the U.S. Government (read: "Bush Administration") is smart enough to even realize that there ARE such a thing as Iraqi Christians. Nor do they realize that there are such a thing as Palestinian Christians, either, but that's a whole 'nother topic. Its either that or they simply don't give a sh&t.
Which is it Mr. Bush, are you ignorant or evil? (Personally, I think he's both.)

Mandrake Xerxes Beersmogg
May 30, 2007 2:35 AM
http://www.beliefnet.com/blogs/crunchycon/

Dreher: "Did you know that Iraqi Christians are sneaking across the US-Mexico border, fleeing Islamist persecution?" With a little switching, the above turns into: Did you know that Iraqi Jihadists are sneaking across the US-Mexico border, seeking to execute Islamist retribution? Rod, if "sweet" people can sneak across the border, what is there to stop the "not so sweet" people? Of course the question is purely academic since, as everybody knows, there is no border.

SteveM
May 30, 2007 3:37 AM
HASH(0x9816764)

Two things about comments above. First re: mine. Iraqi Christians are the canaries is the coal mine. When we finally withdraw from Iraq whether "successful" or not, that's the political philosophy of the Iraqi government government we can expect. Either totally Islamic or heavily invested in the philosophy of Sharia Law. Either way, it isn't worth another guy dieing for. Secondly, if we don't pay attention to the process flow of stuff into the United States, we waste a ton of money premised on the politics of fear promulgated by the Bush administration over the past 5 years. We can check every square inch of every container that floats into American ports. But if the Canadians and the Mexicans do not check every square inch of every container that floats into their ports, the terrorists simply ship bad stuff to Canada or Mexico and drive it across the border to America. And can somebody please explain to me how to track every package shipped by air freight? Is too hard to imagine that bad stuff can be shipped in piecewise by air? And terrorists coming to the US from Mexico? Even with an inpregnable fence between the US and Mexico, and Islamist has to only get into Canada and walk across 3,000 miles of unsecured border. There was a sad and stupid story a couple of years ago about the new requirement for passports to travel between the US and Canada. A US and Canadian town pair that traded freely across each other s border were really inconvenienced because they did so much business with each other each day. Well a terrorist without documentation has to only meander down the river few hundred meters and wade or canoe across. The only point of this stupid regulation is to reinforce the politics of fear. Intelligence is not an sufficient condition for wisdom. Those Ivy League guys in the administration are idiots. I can't wait until this fiasco of an adminstration is over. (Rod, if calling somebody an idiot who is objectively an idiot violates blog rules, please delete the above line and let the rest stand.)

Rod Dreher
May 30, 2007 4:08 AM
HASH(0x9816818)

Steve, it's only a deleteable offense if one refers to someone else posting here as an idiot.

SteveM
May 30, 2007 5:55 AM
HASH(0x98166bc)

Rod, Thanks for the guidance. I'm an idiot so I guess you can delete anything I ever post in a mobius strip twisted logic kind of way. I dunno, maybe I can get a job with the Standard, or even fetch donuts for Michael Novak or the "I got mine and the hell with the rest of you troglodytes" eating cake, genius IQ Charles Murray. "And oh Maria, you missed a spot over there in the corner." Steve P.S. Recognition is the first step towards a cure.

IBreakCellPhones
May 30, 2007 10:16 AM
http://ibreakcellphones.blogspot.com

Looking back, is there anything short of iron-fisted rule (You will not assault anyone nor advocate such, or you and your family will be put to death, a la Saddam) and keeping it up for a couple generations that would prevent this lamentable situation?

Scott in PA
May 30, 2007 12:52 PM
HASH(0x981a44c)

Although I'm an immigration restrictionist, I believe that this is one group (Iraqi Christians) that the US has a moral obligation to help re-settle in other countries and if necessary, the US.

~tv
May 30, 2007 3:24 PM
HASH(0x981b058)

Although I'm an immigration restrictionist, I believe that this is one group (Iraqi Christians) that the US has a moral obligation to help re-settle in other countries and if necessary, the US. Why only Iraqi Christians? Are there not others in Iraq to whom we have a moral obligation (cosidering how we destroyed their admittedly screwed up society over a lie)?

~tv
May 30, 2007 3:26 PM
HASH(0x981a110)

I'm sorry, I misread "I believe that this is one group (Iraqi Christians)..." as "This is *the* one group..." Forgive my faux pas and ignore the question (unless anyone who does believe they're the only group to whom we have a moral obligation, then feel free to respond.)

Richard Barrett
May 30, 2007 3:49 PM
http://web.mac.com/richard_barrett

I've heard some Lebanese friends of mine suggest that one long-term consequence of what's happening in the Middle East right now is the exodus of pretty much all Christians. If Iraqi Christians are at the point of sneaking across the US-Mexico border, I have a hard time disagreeing with them. SteveM is quite right in calling this the canary in the coal mine. Richard

fbc
May 30, 2007 3:59 PM
HASH(0x981bab0)

So the Bush Administration set out to make the Middle East safe for democracy, and ended up making it uninhabitable for Christianity. Sounds about right. As the French say, it was worse than a crime - it was a blunder.

kim margosein
May 30, 2007 4:52 PM
HASH(0x981f214)

" I don't think the U.S. Government (read: "Bush Administration") is smart enough to even realize that there ARE such a thing as Iraqi Christians. Nor do they realize that there are such a thing as Palestinian Christians, either, but that's a whole 'nother topic. Its either that or they simply don't give a sh&t. " This is all too precious for words. The "Jesus is a Marine" Christianists are by their own actions bringing about ruin to their co-religionists to support the most anti-Christian regimes in the middle east. Just keep them Saudi and AIPAC checks coming.
6/8/1967 Remember the Liberty

Eric W
May 30, 2007 4:57 PM
HASH(0x98225f4)

I remember reading before our invasion of Iraq that toppling Saddam Hussein would be bad for Iraqi Christians, since Hussein, being an atheist/pragmatist, used force to keep the opposing forces in Iraq from fighting/destroying each other, and he also protected the Christians from what would be their fate under an Islamic religious state. Of course, to many American Evangelical Christians Iraqi believers are not really "Christians," since they are "Orthodox": Who Are the Iraqi Christians? *sigh* Kyrie, eleison

bill h
May 30, 2007 5:23 PM
http://wildernessinthecity.blogspot.com/

1. Asylum law is so poorly attended to here, that Iraqi Christians have no guarantee they will receive asylum. I believe I would tell and Iraqi Christian to flee to Canada, which I am ashamed to say, but believe is true. 2. I Wonder why Iraqi Christians weren't fleeing in droves under Sadaam? Could it be our experience in democracy has made things worse for them. Answer: yes. Democracy has its limitations. One byproduct of the fall of the Soviet Union was an increase in violent anti-Semitism in Russia. 3.There should be huge public outcry on this subject. If and this is a big if, this administration had integrity it would immediately institute temporary protected status for Iraqi refugees. We owe this to them

Rod Dreher
May 30, 2007 6:10 PM
HASH(0x9930c44)

Eric W: Of course, to many American Evangelical Christians Iraqi believers are not really "Christians," since they are "Orthodox" Interesting you mention that. Yesterday I had lunch with a new Evangelical friend who told me that some years back, she was with a group of American Evangelicals visiting Russia, and they attempted to evangelize Russian Orthodox believers. She said she's embarrassed by that now. Similarly, my wife is mortified by the attitude she and other members of her Baptist church youth choir had in 1992, when they visited Barcelona as part of the Olympics festivities, and were invited to sing in several area Catholic churches. Julie says they were all moved to tears by the fact that for the first time in 500 years, Christians would be in those churches.
On the other hand, wouldn't Catholic and Orthodox believers expect to try to convince Evangelicals of the truth claims of their faith? I think what offends is not so much the notion that Evangelicals are trying to convince Orthodox and Catholic people that they (the Evangelicals) have a more authentic version of Christianity, as it is the idea that (some) Evangelicals think they are not even dealing with fellow Christians in these cases.

Eric W
May 30, 2007 6:31 PM
HASH(0x9930c2c)
I think what offends is not so much the notion that Evangelicals are trying to convince Orthodox and Catholic people that they (the Evangelicals) have a more authentic version of Christianity, as it is the idea that (some) Evangelicals think they are not even dealing with fellow Christians in these cases. Rod Dreher | 05.30.07 - 12:15 pm | #
Give this a read sometime: :) Witnessing to People of Eastern Orthodox Background Brought to you from the Website of the friendly people at NAMB: "The North American Mission Board (NAMB) is the domestic missions agency of the Southern Baptist Convention. Our defined mission is to proclaim the gospel of Jesus Christ, start New Testament congregations, minister to persons in the name of Christ, and assist churches in the United States, Canada and U.S. territories in effectively performing these functions."

Eric W
May 30, 2007 6:34 PM
HASH(0x99312b4)

The link didn't seem to work. Here is the URL: http://www.namb.net/atf/cf/{CDA250E8-8866-4236-9A0C-C646DE153446}/BB_E_Orthodox_Manual.pdf and I'll try creating a link again: Witnessing to People of Eastern Orthodox Background

Anglican Peggy
May 30, 2007 7:14 PM
HASH(0x99335c0)

Not to make light of this very real and very serious Christian exodus but there is what might be considered good news in a relative sort of way.
Not all Christians are fleeing Iraq. Instead many of them are congregating in an area close to Kurdish areas. Here they are working together to protect themselves and to preserve their culture and institutions. I have to admire their courage and gumption in this endeavor.
Perhaps it might be a good thing being separated out from the muslim majority as the Kurds were from the rest of Iraq under Saddam. If we raise hell, much like was done for the sake of the Kurds at one time, we can ensure that US protection of this area will continue even after we officially take our boots off the ground. Perhaps then, this area too will become, rather characteristicaly of this ancient community, another beacon of success and peace like Kurdish Iraq and might even surpass it. Christians have long excelled in learning and in business in the region.
I realize that its an optimistic vision, but being a Christian, I find it hard not to be. We are resurrection people after all. Whenever Christians have taken a stand in the past, revival and renewal have always followed. We have been on the ropes many times and come back near destruction. Why should these people be any different? Especially if we also work for their survival.
I'm not sure which practical actions will have to be taken for the sake of Iraq's Christians, but I know for sure, it starts with not giving up on them.
Thanks to Rod (and others) for making sure that their plight is publicized.

Clare Krishan
May 30, 2007 11:05 PM
HASH(0x9933560)

On posted pdf URL: Money Quote: "American: How do you know about God? I thought the Communists made sure nobody believed in God anymore. Russian: They tried, but we all knew he still is there. Russia has been a Christian nation for over a thousand years. It would take more than 70 years of Communism to change who we are. American: Wow, a thousand years that s over four times older than America. I had no idea!
Now consider my Mesopotamian version: "American: How do you know about [Christ]? I thought the Mohammedans made sure nobody believed in a [Trinitarian] God anymore. Chaldean/Syriac: They tried, but we all knew he still is [here on our altars]. [Iraq] has been a [part of mission territory ever since Jesus's disciple Peter founded the See of Antioch] for over [two] thousand years. It would take more than [1400] years of [Islam] to change who we are. American: Wow, [two] thousand years that s [ten] times older than America. I had no idea!
So four years of Operation Iraqi Freedom wreaks more havoc than Mohammed's cohorts could in the intervening millenia and a half?
Whose side is the "enemy" on?
Methinks the Great Deceiver has played us... were we not ripe for the picking? Serious pruning will be needed to heal the Body of Christ of its "american exceptionalist" errors (both north and south of the border) - I caught the AU Law School Commencement Speech broadcast on CSPAN (from the Roman Catholic Basilica no less) by VA Sec Jim Nicholson http://www.c-spanarchives.org/videolibrary/index.php?main_page=product_video_info&products_id=198331-1&tID=5 Can't find a transcript - but I can approximate how he described being asked back in the early nineties (he was Ambassador to Holy See) by Pope JPII how America was going to use its immense temporal powers to serve the people of the world, but ducked an answer, instead recalled frequent diplomatic meetings where they "disagreed" but the meetings always ended with the Pope praying "God Bless America"... duh - I'm sure he'd pray God Bless Mecca if Saudi Arabia ever recognized the Holy See diplomatically and sent an envoy for "dialogue" http://www.catholicnews.com/data/stories/cns/0702490.htm But they don't... and yet we're asked to believe they're a close ally of the USA? Why? Close business partner? Yes I'll grant that, but nought else...
N.B. we start selling 'em "stuff", then their state-owned (read Monarch) assets get super-concentrated, then buy send their corporate raiders to buy us out? Sound far fetched? A year ago OMX pimped out the Dubai Stock exchange. http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0EIN/is_2006_May_22/ai_n16374842 Now that same Muslim monarch' personal bank account [exchange] plans on out bidding the Nasdaq for the rights to control Nordic financial markets. http://business.timesonline.co.uk/tol/business/industry_sectors/banking_and_finance/article1850845.ece Heck Sudan must be rubbing their hand in glee - the USA bans 'em using dollars to trade oil with the Chinese? Up yours! They'll just use riyals in Tallin instead... The prosperity gospel in action, folks!

paagle
May 31, 2007 2:56 AM
HASH(0x9936348)

This sickening little tidbit about Iraqi refugees caught my eye the other day: Iraqi women survive by prostituting themselves I believe much of this is the result of our (Bush's) gross incompetence. Thus, we have a moral obligation to take in hundreds of thousands of Iraqi refugees, including husbandless & fatherless women, as well as religious minorities (meaning non-Muslims) and those who have assisted us.

HASH(0x993633c)
May 31, 2007 4:52 AM
HASH(0x9936324)

Inexcusable that these Assyrian Christians are not allowed asylum in the U.S. No great number of brain cells are required to grasp that their lives are in danger. BTW, Assyrian Christians are NOT Orthodox. They are non-Chalcedonian Christians. As are Copts.
At any rate, onward marches the rule of ignorance in denying these suffering people a safe haven.

Eric W
May 31, 2007 5:29 PM
HASH(0x9937c18)
BTW, Assyrian Christians are NOT Orthodox. They are non-Chalcedonian Christians. As are Copts.

I was using "Orthodox" in the general sense, meaning Eastern and/or Oriental and/or etc. Orthodox. I.e., as opposed to (Roman) Catholic or Protestant Christians.

Nazim Haq
June 7, 2007 12:37 AM
HASH(0x96ea530)

Its outrageous that Rod Dreher would lambast the situation of the Iraqis and categorize only the Christian persecution, as biased as he is. Under Saddam (remember the great evil madman?) Christians, Sunni, Shia's lived in relative peace and intermarried.
Now thanks to Rod Dreher's US gov't that wanted to end WMDs (the worst excuse of 'em all to justify the invasion) Iraqis are suffering more than ever.
Its not JUST THE Christians but wholly the Shia's and the Sunni Muslims whose lives have been uprooted, their country "shocked and awed" and their future rendered hopeless. And what does he point out? Few Iraqi Christians fleeing? How about admitting the very Iraqis whom US helped to displace with their magic "march through democracy throughout the Middle East" FOR ISRAEL'S and OIL's SAKE. Pathehic.

Post a Comment

By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.



Please type the text you see in the box below to verify your post and help us prevent spam. You have a limited time to type - you may wish to compose your comment in a separate document and paste it here upon completion.

Type the characters you see in the picture above.

Advertisement

Search This Blog

About Crunchy Con

Rod Dreher is an editorial columnist for the Dallas Morning News, and author of "Crunchy Cons" (Crown Forum), a nonfiction book about conservatives, most of them religious, whose faith and political convictions sometimes put them at odds with mainstream conservatives. The views expressed in this blog are his own.

feed icon Subscribe

RSS Feed

Receive updates from Crunchy Con

Advertisement

Advertisement


About Beliefnet

Our mission is to help people like you find, and walk, a spiritual path that will bring comfort, hope, clarity, strength, and happiness. More about Beliefnet.

Legal

Copyright © Beliefnet, Inc. and/or its licensors. All rights reserved. Use of this site is subject to Terms of Service and to our Privacy Policy. Constructed by Beliefnet.

Advertisement

Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.