Tomorrow is Pentecost, which William Pike calls "the crazy uncle we just ignore." He notes that it's the very birthday of the Church, yet so many Christian churches today either don't observe it, or just pass over it lightly. I...
then a couple of weeks ago there was Ascension Day, otherwise known as Flying Jesus Day... that must be the crazy aunt we Christians just ignore... "fascinating parallelism there"... sure... the outlandish Myth that God gave instructions to Moses compares well to the outlandish Myth of Pentecost... it sure is fascinating to try to comprehend why that superstitious ancient Hebrew culture kept creating outlandish claims of supernatural events... they certainly invented some very fascinating Myths... faith hope love joy peace to all...
peter
May 27, 2007 4:47 AM
HASH(0xb36ab28)
how so ironic that mr. falwell passed away a few days ago...he represented the covenant of law....the arrival of the Spirit the covenant of grace....
Erin Manning
May 27, 2007 5:54 AM
a
Well, my Catholic parish certainly doesn't ignore Pentecost--nearly all the songs our choir practiced on Wednesday for tomorrow's feast day are about the Holy Spirit, both in English and in Latin. (Of course, we're sneaking "O Sanctissima" in too, but it's also the last Sunday in the Marian month of May). Of course, one of the hymns we'll be singing will be that perennial Penetcost favorite, "Come, Holy Ghost." I wonder how many Catholics sing this ancient hymn without picking up on the reference to the battle over the 'filioque' contained in one of the verses of the Edward Caswall translation?
Rod Dreher
May 27, 2007 6:12 AM
HASH(0xb36d5bc)
Oh, we don't miss it either at my Orthodox parish -- in fact, the service is extra-long tomorrow, oy. But you really don't hear much about Pentecost in our culture. Seriously, do Pentecostals observe the holy day that gives their movement its name? I wonder.
cs
May 27, 2007 7:55 AM
HASH(0xb36d52c)
As a Pentecostal, yes we observe Pentecost (often in an exuberant worship service, and often hearing sermons on Acts 2). Generally speaking, Pentecostals are also aware of the parallelism with Sinai. Interesting parallels between the fire at Sinai and the Upper Room, as well. Though this year, our local church is having a Memorial Day picnic after church. Go figure....
Mark
May 27, 2007 1:07 PM
ocabatonrouge.blogspot.com
The singing of "O Heavenly King," after its 50 Day absence from our liturgical and devotional life, is a great joy. Also, notice the Kneeling Prayers read during the Vespers after Liturgy today: theologically rich! Interestingly, the designation of Pentecost as the "Birthday of the Church" has been the source of some debate, since many of the Fathers explicitly taught that the Church had existed since the Old Testament Prophets, or even from the beginning of creation. For example, according to Saint Gregory the Theologian, "The Prophets established the Church, the Apostles conjoined it, and the Evangelists set it in order" (PG 35, 589 A). Saint Clement, Bishop of Rome, says in his second epistle to the Corinthians, the Church "was created before the sun and moon"; and a little further on, "The Church existeth not now for the first time, but hath been from the beginning" (II Cor. 14). But nonetheless, Happy Feastday!
sigaliris
May 27, 2007 5:49 PM
HASH(0xb36f6f8)
Thank you, Mark! I very much like those quotations. They capture the understanding that our history is eternally alive in the heart of God. Before I read them, I was having trouble bringing together what I was thinking about Pentecost. Now I think it is this: that we sometimes lose sight of the fact that celebrating an event liturgically is never a memorial service for a past event that happened once, but is over. It is a reminder to ourselves, by participation, that Pentecost, like all sacred events, is eternally present, and is happening now in our lives. Between us and God, there is no other time but NOW. At every moment in our lives, the spirit of God is on fire with longing to enter our hearts. Now. And now, too. And now again. Just as the son of God is always waiting for us to allow him to be born in us, always rising from the dead, always meeting us on the road and waiting to be recognized. V-8 commercials always make me think about Pentecost. It s those moments when I let my actions be motivated by anger, despair, irritation, weariness--and then I think, *headsmack* Wow! I coulda had the holy divine all-creative spirit of God instead! How can something so magnificent be so easy to forget? Of course, if we all remembered it, the blogosphere would probably cease to exist because we d all be out in the world, greeting each other with the eyes and hands of love and wondering what we could do next--this day, this instant--to renew the face of the earth.
Clare Krishan
May 27, 2007 10:50 PM
HASH(0xb370070)
TO affirm Sigarilis and the comment on our perspective of "time," recall that medieval theologians likened the "bush that burned but was not consumed" to Mary's perpetual virginity. Early sacred art promoted the perpetually "fascinating parallelisms" of the Incarnation in a distinctive four-quarter-double-overlay format in icons of the type "Mother of the Burning Bush," following quote from http://ocafs.oca.org/FeastSaintsViewer.asp?FSID=102500 (celebrated not on Pentecost but Sept 4) "The Unburnt Bush Icon of the Most Holy Theotokos is based on the miracle witnessed by Moses in the Old Testament. In Chapter 3 of Exodus God calls Moses on Mt. Horeb from the midst of a bush which "was burning, yet it was not consumed" (Ex. 3:2). Moses is informed that he will lead the Hebrews out of their slavery in Egypt, and then God tells him His name, "I am Who am" (Ex. 3:14). The Church has always regarded the Unburnt Bush on Horeb as a type of the Most Holy Theotokos giving birth to the Savior Christ, while remaining a Virgin. This imagery is to be found in the Church's hymnography (for example, the Dogmatikon at Saturday Vespers in Tone 2), and also in iconography. One of the earliest depictions of the Mother of God as the Unburnt Bush shows her holding her divine Son in the midst of a burning bush. Moses is shown to one side, removing his sandals, for that place was holy (Ex. 3:5). Most icons now depict the bush in a symbolic fashion. There are two overlapping diamonds: one red (representing the fire), the other green (representing the bush), forming an eight pointed star. The Theotokos is shown in the center. In the four corners of the green diamond are the symbols of the four Evangelists: a man (St Matthew), a lion (St Mark), an ox (St Luke), and an eagle (St John). These symbols are derived from Ezekiel 1:10 and Revelation 4:7. Archangels are depicted in the four corners of the red diamond. The design of the icon has become more complex over time. Now we can see archangels, Moses and the burning bush (Ex. 3:2), Isaiah and the seraphim with the burning coal (Is. 6:7), Ezekiel and the gate through which only the Lord may enter (Ez. 44:2), and Jacob with the ladder (Gen. 28:12). The Theotokos is shown holding Jacob's ladder which leads from earth to heaven. Sometimes the Root of Jesse (Isaiah 11:1) is shown in the center of the icon's lower border. There is an old story about a fire which was consuming several wooden buildings. In the midst of the fire an old woman stood in front of her house holding an icon of the "Unburnt Bush." A witness happened to see her there, and marveled at her faith. The next day he returned to the spot and was astonished to see the old woman's home completely unscathed by the fire, while all the other houses around it were destroyed. This may explain why the Mother of God, through her Icon of the Unburnt Bush, is regarded as the protector of homes from fire. It is believed that the earliest icons of the Unburnt Bush originated at St Catherine's Monastery on Mt. Sinai." A selection of other artworks (ancient and modern, East, West and Coptic) that repeat the theme (for those of us who have lost this Russian Oklad showing evangelist symbols (associated with visions of Jeremiah/Ezekiel) in relief, with closeups of cleaned and restored corners beneath: http://www.icon.lt/images/080d.jpg Moses on Sinai http://www.icon.lt/images/080e.jpg Isaiah's vision http://www.icon.lt/images/080f.jpg Ezekiel's vision http://www.icon.lt/images/080g.jpg Jacob's ladder Image from a recent Ebay listing http://www.tertiasp.ru/50-03.jpg Mass produced enameled cast-brass for the common man's home http://www.iconastas.co.uk/stock.asp?code=453055694 Holy Transfiguration Monastery http://www.thehtm.org/images/a-9.jpg Mosaic at Saint Gregory of Nyssa Episcopal Church, California http://www.saintgregorys.org/Arts/Objects/BurningBush.html Moses and the Burning Bush Icon from St Tikhon's Bookstore http://www.stspress.com/detail.aspx?ID=233 Icon written by Nasef Lateef at Coptic net http://www.coptic.net/pictures/Icon.MosesAndTheBurningBush.jpg Western treatment in illustrated Manuscript c 1480 http://www.getty.edu/art/gettyguide/artObjectDetails?artobj=1851
sigaliris
May 28, 2007 12:13 AM
HASH(0xb370c98)
Wow, Clare. That is awesome. Thank you for the wonderful images and commentary. I never knew that before!
Clare Krishan
May 28, 2007 5:51 AM
HASH(0xb362b8c)
Glad to oblige! I learnt after some recreational googling this afternoon that the Russian icon title is Mother of God of the Unburnt Thornbush "Matachka Bozhaja Neopalimaya Kupina" Haven't found a counterpart in Greek, it seems this motive was a Slavic innovation: after the fall of Constantinople artists relocated to the Russian Third Rome and with renewed vigor dedicated themselves to developing their sacred craft. Here's a page (translatable in AltaVista's BabelFish) with more details (angelic themes likened to the traditional eight gifts of the Holy Spirit, received at Confirmation/Chrismation, personified as virtues): http://babelfish.altavista.com/babelfish/trurl_pagecontent?lp=ru_en&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.loukin.ru%2Fstat%2Fbmkupina%2Fkupina.htm [http://www.loukin.ru/stat/bmkupina/kupina.htm I could quite easily imagine them as personifications of the eight beatitides of Christ's Sermon on the Mount ie the Gospel values by which we can live the moral law!
James P.
May 29, 2007 11:39 PM
HASH(0xb362b44)
Interesting to note is that on the second night of the Shavuot, a memorial service for the departed is prayed-- one of four during the course of the year. On the second night of Christian Pentecost (Sunday night), in the Eastern Orthodox tradition, a long prayer for the departed is said at the Kneeling Vespers. The parallel between the Jewish Pentecost and the Christian Pentecost was especially well-known in the early Church and is seen in this parallel, among many others.
ScurvyOaks
June 1, 2007 12:35 AM
HASH(0xb3732b0)
Anglicans consider Pentecost a principal feast day and celebrate it under the name Whitsunday. We attended worship at a very high, Anglo-Catholic parish in Freeport (Bahamas) -- my Presbyterian kids' first exposure to bells and smells. There was as much incense as I've ever seen. Whitsunday is such a big deal in the Bahamas that Whitmonday is an official holiday.
Post a Comment
By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.
Rod Dreher is an editorial columnist for the Dallas Morning News, and author of "Crunchy Cons" (Crown Forum), a nonfiction book about conservatives, most of them religious, whose faith and political convictions sometimes put them at odds with mainstream conservatives. The views expressed in this blog are his own.
Subscribe
Sign Up: Receive Crunchy Con in your in-box every day
then a couple of weeks ago there was Ascension Day, otherwise known as Flying Jesus Day... that must be the crazy aunt we Christians just ignore... "fascinating parallelism there"... sure... the outlandish Myth that God gave instructions to Moses compares well to the outlandish Myth of Pentecost... it sure is fascinating to try to comprehend why that superstitious ancient Hebrew culture kept creating outlandish claims of supernatural events... they certainly invented some very fascinating Myths... faith hope love joy peace to all...
how so ironic that mr. falwell passed away a few days ago...he represented the covenant of law....the arrival of the Spirit the covenant of grace....
Well, my Catholic parish certainly doesn't ignore Pentecost--nearly all the songs our choir practiced on Wednesday for tomorrow's feast day are about the Holy Spirit, both in English and in Latin. (Of course, we're sneaking "O Sanctissima" in too, but it's also the last Sunday in the Marian month of May). Of course, one of the hymns we'll be singing will be that perennial Penetcost favorite, "Come, Holy Ghost." I wonder how many Catholics sing this ancient hymn without picking up on the reference to the battle over the 'filioque' contained in one of the verses of the Edward Caswall translation?
Oh, we don't miss it either at my Orthodox parish -- in fact, the service is extra-long tomorrow, oy. But you really don't hear much about Pentecost in our culture. Seriously, do Pentecostals observe the holy day that gives their movement its name? I wonder.
As a Pentecostal, yes we observe Pentecost (often in an exuberant worship service, and often hearing sermons on Acts 2). Generally speaking, Pentecostals are also aware of the parallelism with Sinai. Interesting parallels between the fire at Sinai and the Upper Room, as well. Though this year, our local church is having a Memorial Day picnic after church. Go figure....
The singing of "O Heavenly King," after its 50 Day absence from our liturgical and devotional life, is a great joy. Also, notice the Kneeling Prayers read during the Vespers after Liturgy today: theologically rich! Interestingly, the designation of Pentecost as the "Birthday of the Church" has been the source of some debate, since many of the Fathers explicitly taught that the Church had existed since the Old Testament Prophets, or even from the beginning of creation. For example, according to Saint Gregory the Theologian, "The Prophets established the Church, the Apostles conjoined it, and the Evangelists set it in order" (PG 35, 589 A). Saint Clement, Bishop of Rome, says in his second epistle to the Corinthians, the Church "was created before the sun and moon"; and a little further on, "The Church existeth not now for the first time, but hath been from the beginning" (II Cor. 14). But nonetheless, Happy Feastday!
Thank you, Mark! I very much like those quotations. They capture the understanding that our history is eternally alive in the heart of God. Before I read them, I was having trouble bringing together what I was thinking about Pentecost. Now I think it is this: that we sometimes lose sight of the fact that celebrating an event liturgically is never a memorial service for a past event that happened once, but is over. It is a reminder to ourselves, by participation, that Pentecost, like all sacred events, is eternally present, and is happening now in our lives. Between us and God, there is no other time but NOW. At every moment in our lives, the spirit of God is on fire with longing to enter our hearts. Now. And now, too. And now again. Just as the son of God is always waiting for us to allow him to be born in us, always rising from the dead, always meeting us on the road and waiting to be recognized. V-8 commercials always make me think about Pentecost. It s those moments when I let my actions be motivated by anger, despair, irritation, weariness--and then I think, *headsmack* Wow! I coulda had the holy divine all-creative spirit of God instead! How can something so magnificent be so easy to forget? Of course, if we all remembered it, the blogosphere would probably cease to exist because we d all be out in the world, greeting each other with the eyes and hands of love and wondering what we could do next--this day, this instant--to renew the face of the earth.
TO affirm Sigarilis and the comment on our perspective of "time," recall that medieval theologians likened the "bush that burned but was not consumed" to Mary's perpetual virginity. Early sacred art promoted the perpetually "fascinating parallelisms" of the Incarnation in a distinctive four-quarter-double-overlay format in icons of the type "Mother of the Burning Bush," following quote from http://ocafs.oca.org/FeastSaintsViewer.asp?FSID=102500 (celebrated not on Pentecost but Sept 4) "The Unburnt Bush Icon of the Most Holy Theotokos is based on the miracle witnessed by Moses in the Old Testament. In Chapter 3 of Exodus God calls Moses on Mt. Horeb from the midst of a bush which "was burning, yet it was not consumed" (Ex. 3:2). Moses is informed that he will lead the Hebrews out of their slavery in Egypt, and then God tells him His name, "I am Who am" (Ex. 3:14).
The Church has always regarded the Unburnt Bush on Horeb as a type of the Most Holy Theotokos giving birth to the Savior Christ, while remaining a Virgin. This imagery is to be found in the Church's hymnography (for example, the Dogmatikon at Saturday Vespers in Tone 2), and also in iconography.
One of the earliest depictions of the Mother of God as the Unburnt Bush shows her holding her divine Son in the midst of a burning bush. Moses is shown to one side, removing his sandals, for that place was holy (Ex. 3:5).
Most icons now depict the bush in a symbolic fashion. There are two overlapping diamonds: one red (representing the fire), the other green (representing the bush), forming an eight pointed star. The Theotokos is shown in the center.
In the four corners of the green diamond are the symbols of the four Evangelists: a man (St Matthew), a lion (St Mark), an ox (St Luke), and an eagle (St John). These symbols are derived from Ezekiel 1:10 and Revelation 4:7. Archangels are depicted in the four corners of the red diamond.
The design of the icon has become more complex over time. Now we can see archangels, Moses and the burning bush (Ex. 3:2), Isaiah and the seraphim with the burning coal (Is. 6:7), Ezekiel and the gate through which only the Lord may enter (Ez. 44:2), and Jacob with the ladder (Gen. 28:12). The Theotokos is shown holding Jacob's ladder which leads from earth to heaven. Sometimes the Root of Jesse (Isaiah 11:1) is shown in the center of the icon's lower border.
There is an old story about a fire which was consuming several wooden buildings. In the midst of the fire an old woman stood in front of her house holding an icon of the "Unburnt Bush." A witness happened to see her there, and marveled at her faith. The next day he returned to the spot and was astonished to see the old woman's home completely unscathed by the fire, while all the other houses around it were destroyed. This may explain why the Mother of God, through her Icon of the Unburnt Bush, is regarded as the protector of homes from fire.
It is believed that the earliest icons of the Unburnt Bush originated at St Catherine's Monastery on Mt. Sinai." A selection of other artworks (ancient and modern, East, West and Coptic) that repeat the theme (for those of us who have lost this
Russian Oklad showing evangelist symbols (associated with visions of Jeremiah/Ezekiel) in relief, with closeups of cleaned and restored corners beneath: http://www.icon.lt/images/080d.jpg Moses on Sinai http://www.icon.lt/images/080e.jpg Isaiah's vision http://www.icon.lt/images/080f.jpg Ezekiel's vision http://www.icon.lt/images/080g.jpg Jacob's ladder Image from a recent Ebay listing http://www.tertiasp.ru/50-03.jpg Mass produced enameled cast-brass for the common man's home http://www.iconastas.co.uk/stock.asp?code=453055694 Holy Transfiguration Monastery http://www.thehtm.org/images/a-9.jpg Mosaic at Saint Gregory of Nyssa Episcopal Church, California http://www.saintgregorys.org/Arts/Objects/BurningBush.html Moses and the Burning Bush Icon from St Tikhon's Bookstore http://www.stspress.com/detail.aspx?ID=233 Icon written by Nasef Lateef at Coptic net http://www.coptic.net/pictures/Icon.MosesAndTheBurningBush.jpg Western treatment in illustrated Manuscript c 1480 http://www.getty.edu/art/gettyguide/artObjectDetails?artobj=1851
Wow, Clare. That is awesome. Thank you for the wonderful images and commentary. I never knew that before!
Glad to oblige!
I learnt after some recreational googling this afternoon that the Russian icon title is Mother of God of the Unburnt Thornbush "Matachka Bozhaja Neopalimaya Kupina" Haven't found a counterpart in Greek, it seems this motive was a Slavic innovation: after the fall of Constantinople artists relocated to the Russian Third Rome and with renewed vigor dedicated themselves to developing their sacred craft. Here's a page (translatable in AltaVista's BabelFish) with more details (angelic themes likened to the traditional eight gifts of the Holy Spirit, received at Confirmation/Chrismation, personified as virtues): http://babelfish.altavista.com/babelfish/trurl_pagecontent?lp=ru_en&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.loukin.ru%2Fstat%2Fbmkupina%2Fkupina.htm [http://www.loukin.ru/stat/bmkupina/kupina.htm I could quite easily imagine them as personifications of the eight beatitides of Christ's Sermon on the Mount ie the Gospel values by which we can live the moral law!
Interesting to note is that on the second night of the Shavuot, a memorial service for the departed is prayed-- one of four during the course of the year. On the second night of Christian Pentecost (Sunday night), in the Eastern Orthodox tradition, a long prayer for the departed is said at the Kneeling Vespers. The parallel between the Jewish Pentecost and the Christian Pentecost was especially well-known in the early Church and is seen in this parallel, among many others.
Anglicans consider Pentecost a principal feast day and celebrate it under the name Whitsunday. We attended worship at a very high, Anglo-Catholic parish in Freeport (Bahamas) -- my Presbyterian kids' first exposure to bells and smells. There was as much incense as I've ever seen. Whitsunday is such a big deal in the Bahamas that Whitmonday is an official holiday.
Post a Comment
By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.