So, now that the last Harry Potter book has been out for a few weeks, what do you Potterheads think about the way Rowling ended the series? As you know, I'm not a Potter reader, so I've got no opinion. But I know we have lots of Potter fans int he CC blog readership, so y'all who want to discuss the Potter finale, please consider this an open thread. Spoilers allowed, indeed expected, so if you haven't read "Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows" and expect to, don't visit the comboxes below.

Add to Newsvine
Add to StumbleUpon
voldermort comes bak 2 life after 3 yrs, umbridge and lucius bring him bak. then he dusnt come 2 power but mangaes 2 kill ron b4 proffessor mcgonagal kills him with the killing curse. then a few yrs later, all the death eaters are dead and hermione ends up finding the ressurection stone.
I hoped at the end that she'd left us with a new set of characters for further adventures in the wizarding world when she introduced the children of the Harry/Ginny and Ron/Hermione families.
I hoped that Snape was still a good guy and what a reward it was to see that he was! I almost cried when I read that Harry and Ginny included his name in one of their children's names.
Joey, I woke up this morning and found myself, half-asleep, thinking, "Well, Dumbledore was going to die anyway so maybe it's not so bad..." I'm just reminding myself that it's a work of fiction set in an imaginary world and will probably ask my kids what they think about D's decision to kill himself for the greater good. Now that I'm fully awake, I think I'd better quit mulling this over and mop my living room floor.
I think it is a shame that J K R did not put Harry Ron's and Hermoine's jobs in the ending. I thought the saddest part was the death of Lupin and his wife after the birth of their baby boy. Wonder who the baby Teddy's girlfried Victoire was at the end, perhaps Bill's daughter (therefore niece of Ron and Ginny) don't remember the exact explaination of who she was and/or her birth.
By the way did anyone else notice when Harry visits his parents grave/s how young they were when they were killed (when Harry was 1 year old). As I think Harry was supposed to be about 17 or 18 at that stage, the story would have occurred in the late 1990,s according to my calculations but maybe I am wrong.
Jolesley: You're bang on--Deathly Hallows takes place in 1997-'98 and the epilogue takes place in 2016/17 (depending on whether it's nineteen years from '97 or '98--I'm not quite sure).
I think my favourite parts were that sort of dream sequence (pages 705 - 723) and when Harry was telling Voldemort all the stuff he didn't want to hear (pages 737 - 743--I think everyone should read that part even if they're not really into the series).
I was also really surprised at how Voldy was finished off (page 743) and that Hermione and Ron got married--and they bickered all through Hogwarts!!!
Oh, and that Harry was the final Horcrux, which was probably the most shocking of all.
Happy Monday, everyone. I spent part (ok, most) of the weekend rereading the book. Anyone who can read the "King's Cross" chapter towards the end and think that JK Rowling isn't religious really isn't paying attention. I really liked the symbolism of the "abandoned infant" which was what Voldemort actually was from the start.
An unloved abandoned baby. More thoughts about Snape. He was a neglected child, and to me, it is obvious that his interest in "the Dark Arts" was to compensate for his feelings of inadequacy by dreams of power. The difference is that Snape had one connection to life through his friendship and love for Lily and that made all the difference. He was still an unhappy and miserable person, but he managed to make choices that were for the good because he had one experience of being loved.
Rereading the book, what occured to me was that JK Rowling was just trying to keep too many balls in the air at once, in terms of all the plot elements. The Horcruxes were enough without throwing in the Hallows. There were too many pages of explanations (or exposition) in the midst of the action which basically felt to me like she was dropping the balls she was juggling and then picking them up while dropping new ones, and it definitely detracted from the forward momentum of the book. But, her flaws as a writer don't prevent this from being a wonderful series.
Post a Comment
By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.