I read this story yesterday about Juanita Bynum, the black Pentecostal evangelist who is apparently a battered wife, with sympathy. She came to fame with a mighty sermon called "No More Sheets," in which she spoke of her own sexual...
Oh please - just another one making a profit and a living off of religious entertainment
sigaliris
September 21, 2007 6:39 PM
Kim has a point. I agree with you, Rod, if what you’re saying is that all of these so-called “pastors” should get a day job, and we should shut down all the fancy buildings funded by donations from working people. If people want to get together and pray, they can do so very conveniently in each other’s houses, or rent a gymnasium or something. Then if they want to take up a collection, they can use the money to help widows and orphans, or pay each other’s medical bills, or something. It won’t be wasted on large edifices, vestments, and salaries.
We don’t need so-called spiritual shepherds. If people have mental problems, send them to a psychiatrist. If they want prayer, let everyone pray for them. If they need advice, let them call an older, wiser member of the congregation. You don’t need a full-time minister to do these things.
So, let’s get busy and call for the abolishment of all those big mainline Protestant churches, as well as the Baptist and independent ones. What makes someone like D. James Kennedy or James Dobson less of a charlatan than Juanita Bynum? Come to think of it, I’d be a lot happier if Cardinal Rigali, for one, moved out of his mansion and into an apartment in Upper Darby or some such place. He could give up the limo and walk to the corner to pick up his morning coffee, and take the SEPTA downtown to say Mass . . . oops, no, wait, they’d probably have to sell off that big ol’ white elephant of a “cathedral.” Just the way they sold off all the little ethnic parishes that weren’t bringing in the donations any more. The Cardinal could say Mass in the cafeteria of one of the big suburban high schools that get subsidized so middle class Catholic kids can avoid the public schools.
Yep, I’m one hundred percent with you on this one, Rod. I just hope I haven’t misunderstood you again . . . ; )
Anonymous
September 21, 2007 8:20 PM
its easy to mis-understand a liberal who wants to be billed as a conservative
DavidTC
September 22, 2007 12:29 PM
Kim has a point. I agree with you, Rod, if what you’re saying is that all of these so-called “pastors” should get a day job, and we should shut down all the fancy buildings funded by donations from working people. If people want to get together and pray, they can do so very conveniently in each other’s houses, or rent a gymnasium or something. Then if they want to take up a collection, they can use the money to help widows and orphans, or pay each other’s medical bills, or something. It won’t be wasted on large edifices, vestments, and salaries.
People sometimes ask me why I don't show up at church anymore. Despite the fact we have several fundamental differences in theology (They are Southern Baptist, which means they about the wrongest possible church for me.), the actual reason I don't go there, or find another church, is that they built a new million dollar building.
There is a specific route I can drive, starting near the center of town and going to my grandmother's house about a mile away, that I pass a Episcopalian church, a Catholic church, that Baptist church, a Church of God, a spin-off of a mega-church youth place, a non-Southern Baptist Church, and church that I have no idea denomination of, but I think is also an unaffiliated Baptist church. Seven churches.
Of course, that route is an crazy abnormality, the rest of town isn't anything like it, but it got me thinking one day, that and the fancy new church.
On that trip, I also pass the food pantry. The only food pantry in town, operated by the Catholics. If you doubled the size, it would be maybe the size of the smallest church on that trip.
You know how many homeless shelters we have? How many meals-on-wheels programs we have for people under 60? (60-and-over programs are supported by the government.)
Churches stopped helping people a long time ago. Like 1800 years ago. People didn't notice in Rome and Christendom, because churches managed to make themselves, basically, a second government, with their own taxes and running social services.
But the second they got removed from that, the second they lost their official position and stopped being able to 'tax' people, the true colors came out. The 'help windows and orphans' from the first few centuries was completely gone. The Catholics have held on to this better than anyone, but I have to question if that has anything to do with the 'official' position they continue to hold in many countries.
DavidTC
September 22, 2007 12:33 PM
You know how many homeless shelters we have? How many meals-on-wheels programs we have for people under 60?
Doh. Somehow I forgot to answer those rhetorical questions. The answer is 'none'.
Kyralessa
September 25, 2007 4:51 PM
So...what keeps *you* from starting a homeless shelter or a meals-on-wheels program?
DavidTC
September 26, 2007 4:50 PM
So...what keeps *you* from starting a homeless shelter or a meals-on-wheels program?
...the fact I don't have any money to do so? Or the organizational skills?
I'm not saying that individuals should start those up, although I'm all for it.
I'm saying that churches should be spending money on social works before they spend it on buildings, and retreats, and all other crap my church, and everyone else's, spends stuff on first.
And that's not even talking about the scams like Operation Blessing.
Which is why my tithe ends up going to organizations like Habitat for Humanity and the American Red Cross. Habitat for Humanity is actually a Christian-based organization, but amazingly don't seem to feel that the way to do good works is to build big buildings that stand around empty 80% of the time and suck up huge amounts of resources and money just so they have somewhere to hang out.
Ann
October 9, 2008 3:53 AM
You do not need as lot of money or a lot of skill to start doing something right where you are. That is not theory it is experience. Ours and that of other folks who have volunteered and helped create a practical way of showing God's love for the past 13 yrs. One of the projects we do costs absolutely nothing other can be done from a library computer even by someone who is homeless, others like food and shelter do have a cost but God provides. None of us are rich but we do know Jesus helped us and helps us help others. That may sound real simpleminded but that's OK He uses the simple to0 confound the wise. I want to share this not to say hey look what we did but please see what Jesus did and is doing and can do with you in ways that are a part of where you are right now. So please come t0 http://www.caringhandsministries.com and see what Jesus has allowed us to be part of His doing. Maybe you will see things you can do too. It started with a cardboard box in the entry of a church and a sign that said please donate canned food. We have also sat outside grocery stores with thye same kind of box. Can you find an empty box?
Post a Comment
By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.
Rod Dreher is an editorial columnist for the Dallas Morning News, and author of "Crunchy Cons" (Crown Forum), a nonfiction book about conservatives, most of them religious, whose faith and political convictions sometimes put them at odds with mainstream conservatives. The views expressed in this blog are his own.
Subscribe
Sign Up: Receive Crunchy Con in your in-box every day
Standing and applauding Rod. Well said.
Oh please - just another one making a profit and a living off of religious entertainment
Kim has a point. I agree with you, Rod, if what you’re saying is that all of these so-called “pastors” should get a day job, and we should shut down all the fancy buildings funded by donations from working people. If people want to get together and pray, they can do so very conveniently in each other’s houses, or rent a gymnasium or something. Then if they want to take up a collection, they can use the money to help widows and orphans, or pay each other’s medical bills, or something. It won’t be wasted on large edifices, vestments, and salaries.
We don’t need so-called spiritual shepherds. If people have mental problems, send them to a psychiatrist. If they want prayer, let everyone pray for them. If they need advice, let them call an older, wiser member of the congregation. You don’t need a full-time minister to do these things.
So, let’s get busy and call for the abolishment of all those big mainline Protestant churches, as well as the Baptist and independent ones. What makes someone like D. James Kennedy or James Dobson less of a charlatan than Juanita Bynum? Come to think of it, I’d be a lot happier if Cardinal Rigali, for one, moved out of his mansion and into an apartment in Upper Darby or some such place. He could give up the limo and walk to the corner to pick up his morning coffee, and take the SEPTA downtown to say Mass . . . oops, no, wait, they’d probably have to sell off that big ol’ white elephant of a “cathedral.” Just the way they sold off all the little ethnic parishes that weren’t bringing in the donations any more. The Cardinal could say Mass in the cafeteria of one of the big suburban high schools that get subsidized so middle class Catholic kids can avoid the public schools.
Yep, I’m one hundred percent with you on this one, Rod. I just hope I haven’t misunderstood you again . . . ; )
its easy to mis-understand a liberal who wants to be billed as a conservative
Kim has a point. I agree with you, Rod, if what you’re saying is that all of these so-called “pastors” should get a day job, and we should shut down all the fancy buildings funded by donations from working people. If people want to get together and pray, they can do so very conveniently in each other’s houses, or rent a gymnasium or something. Then if they want to take up a collection, they can use the money to help widows and orphans, or pay each other’s medical bills, or something. It won’t be wasted on large edifices, vestments, and salaries.
People sometimes ask me why I don't show up at church anymore. Despite the fact we have several fundamental differences in theology (They are Southern Baptist, which means they about the wrongest possible church for me.), the actual reason I don't go there, or find another church, is that they built a new million dollar building.
There is a specific route I can drive, starting near the center of town and going to my grandmother's house about a mile away, that I pass a Episcopalian church, a Catholic church, that Baptist church, a Church of God, a spin-off of a mega-church youth place, a non-Southern Baptist Church, and church that I have no idea denomination of, but I think is also an unaffiliated Baptist church. Seven churches.
Of course, that route is an crazy abnormality, the rest of town isn't anything like it, but it got me thinking one day, that and the fancy new church.
On that trip, I also pass the food pantry. The only food pantry in town, operated by the Catholics. If you doubled the size, it would be maybe the size of the smallest church on that trip.
You know how many homeless shelters we have? How many meals-on-wheels programs we have for people under 60? (60-and-over programs are supported by the government.)
Churches stopped helping people a long time ago. Like 1800 years ago. People didn't notice in Rome and Christendom, because churches managed to make themselves, basically, a second government, with their own taxes and running social services.
But the second they got removed from that, the second they lost their official position and stopped being able to 'tax' people, the true colors came out. The 'help windows and orphans' from the first few centuries was completely gone. The Catholics have held on to this better than anyone, but I have to question if that has anything to do with the 'official' position they continue to hold in many countries.
You know how many homeless shelters we have? How many meals-on-wheels programs we have for people under 60?
Doh. Somehow I forgot to answer those rhetorical questions. The answer is 'none'.
So...what keeps *you* from starting a homeless shelter or a meals-on-wheels program?
So...what keeps *you* from starting a homeless shelter or a meals-on-wheels program?
...the fact I don't have any money to do so? Or the organizational skills?
I'm not saying that individuals should start those up, although I'm all for it.
I'm saying that churches should be spending money on social works before they spend it on buildings, and retreats, and all other crap my church, and everyone else's, spends stuff on first.
And that's not even talking about the scams like Operation Blessing.
Which is why my tithe ends up going to organizations like Habitat for Humanity and the American Red Cross. Habitat for Humanity is actually a Christian-based organization, but amazingly don't seem to feel that the way to do good works is to build big buildings that stand around empty 80% of the time and suck up huge amounts of resources and money just so they have somewhere to hang out.
You do not need as lot of money or a lot of skill to start doing something right where you are. That is not theory it is experience. Ours and that of other folks who have volunteered and helped create a practical way of showing God's love for the past 13 yrs. One of the projects we do costs absolutely nothing other can be done from a library computer even by someone who is homeless, others like food and shelter do have a cost but God provides. None of us are rich but we do know Jesus helped us and helps us help others. That may sound real simpleminded but that's OK He uses the simple to0 confound the wise. I want to share this not to say hey look what we did but please see what Jesus did and is doing and can do with you in ways that are a part of where you are right now. So please come t0 http://www.caringhandsministries.com and see what Jesus has allowed us to be part of His doing. Maybe you will see things you can do too. It started with a cardboard box in the entry of a church and a sign that said please donate canned food. We have also sat outside grocery stores with thye same kind of box. Can you find an empty box?
Post a Comment
By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.