Crunchy Con

Marcial Maciel is dead

Thursday January 31, 2008

Categories: Catholicism

Marcial Maciel, the founder of the conservative religious order the Legion of Christ, has died of natural causes at 87. He had been disciplined by Pope Benedict following multiple accusations of sex abuse from early in his priesthood. He died in disgrace, with the Vatican directing him to retire and withdraw rather than face further investigation and prosecution.

Jason Berry writes about the Maciel case here, and in many other places. Additionally, here is the website of ReGain, an organization of ex-Legionaries and others now highly critical of Maciel and his work. One aspect of the accusations against Maciel that struck me is that his nine accusers were all professionally accomplished laymen at the time they went public. They did not ask for money, and they had a lot to lose by going public as victims of molestation -- especially accusing a very powerful religious leader. Clearly by the time Benedict became pope, the Vatican had been convinced that Maciel was guilty of something.

It's in God's hands now.

UPDATE: I know this is a very sensitive topic, and my views about the Catholic hierarchy and the cover-up of sexual abuse are strong and well-known. I want to underscore, however, that I invite people of all opinions on the matter of Fr. Maciel and the LCs to express themselves here. If you believe Fr. Maciel was treated unjustly, please feel free to say so. And those who disagree, likewise. Let's keep it civil, tho'...

Filed Under: Legion of Christ, Marcial Maciel

Comments

Paul,
I'm reminded that my childhood pastor always ended conversations with "pray for me". He was invited to a private life of prayer and penance 11 years ago, and died in 1998 I think. I do pray for him and though I'm not sure how fully I can forgive him, I pray that he isn't in Hell. We're asked in the Our Father, (the prayer, not the founder) that God forgive us as we forgive. That's a one-to-one ratio, and reminds us that "the measure with which we measure, will be measured out to us overflowing" etc

I suggest everybody read Jason Berry's article that Rod linked. It makes me admire Benedict all the more. It also reinforces my contempt for JPII and the bunker mentality that afflicts all-too-many Catholics on this issue. That bunker mentality reflects the fact that these same Catholics confuse the hierarchy with Christ, and give it the deference it doesn't deserve.

That's alright, Joe D'oH, most everyone here has plenty of contempt for guys who think we should nuke Muslim population centers as a matter of course.

Franklin, it's good to know that you're a cum laude graduate of the Mark Shea Corresponsdence School of Snark, with a doctorate in Using Personal Attacks To Deflect Attention From The Truth. Congratulations!

But what they didn't teach you, Franklin, is that such tactics (and your skillful use of them) just happen to reinforce my point better than I ever could!

BTW, Franklin, do you like ice with your Kool-Aid? ;P

Read All Comments

Post a Comment

Are you aware of our Rules of Conduct?


(won't be made public)



Ad tag

Advertisement

Search

About Crunchy Con

Rod Dreher is an editorial columnist for the Dallas Morning News, and author of "Crunchy Cons" (Crown Forum), a nonfiction book about conservatives, most of them religious, whose faith and political convictions sometimes put them at odds with mainstream conservatives. The views expressed in this blog are his own.

feed icon Subscribe

RSS Feed

Receive updates from Crunchy Con
Enter your email address below.