A good case can be made that the Latino vote in Texas put Hillary Clinton over the top. Blacks broke heavily for Obama here, but they were only 19 percent of the overall Democratic electorate -- down from 21 percent...
I think any rifts between Latinos and African Americans can't be assumed to mean Latinos are going to run off and support a party that is outright hostile to Latino issues. Republicans lost Latinos for at least a generation over the opposition to immigration reform, and McCain will be pulled to the right on the issue to maintain his anti-immigrant base in the GOP.
Latinos and African Americans often have competing interests. The Clintons have a long history with Latino voters and leaders. What Latinos and African Americans are forced to fight over in the Dallas City Council is not the same as a national agenda.
M.Z. Forrest
March 5, 2008 3:13 PM
I would say no, at least not anywhere it is going to make a difference. I'm going from memory, but I believe Obama did fine with Hispanics in Arizona. Where there seems to be an issue is where you have black and hispanic integrated populations. California and Texas immediately come to mind, but I don't think anyone believes that either of those will be flipped. New Mexico and Colorado look to be swing states this year, and hispanics could play a role in both those States. I think McCain will get the former and Obama will get the latter. The last state with a decent Hispanic influence would be Florida. I think McCain has that one in the bag against Obama, because the Cuban, Jewish, and elderly votes will all probably swing to McCain.
Eric W
March 5, 2008 3:16 PM
Which will be harder for McCain to beat:
A Clinton(P)/Obama(VP) ticket, or an Obama(P)/Clinton(VP) ticket?
Other Jim
March 5, 2008 3:31 PM
I don't understand the immigration issue. I've seen polls that show at least one third of Hispanics are against illegal immigration, and the illegals can't vote. You can't lose voters who can't vote!
Daniel
March 5, 2008 3:41 PM
If two-third of Latinos support comprehensive immigration reform and believe there is a blacklash from the right's rhetoric, that's a powerful force. Even those who support tougher enforcement are impacted by complaints about people speaking Spanish, comments about the Hispanicization of communities, targeting of Hispanics who are assumed to be illegal. The anti-immigrant rhetoric has been ugly and offensive, and even Latinos who support enforcement hear the ugly rhetoric which is often used broadly against Latinos.
RCM
March 5, 2008 4:15 PM
I don't think this is just about immigration. There is a deep racism within the Hispanic community. NPR just had a whole segment on it and it certainly matches my experience living in Latin America. Most of those in power in Latin America are white Hispanics with Black Latinos and Natives at the bottom of the power structure, much like America for a very long part of her history.
Very sad. Though, the racism tends to fade by 3rd generation immigrants become Americanized.
Mike
March 5, 2008 4:16 PM
Rod
I agree with you that the racial between Latinos and African-Americans has been largely ignored by the media. My wife was a teacher at a South Dallas public school while we lived there several years ago. She was shocked at the racial hostility between the Latino and African-American teachers. She was also amazed at how openly the teachers made racist comments, especially the Latino teachers. My brother lived and worked in the Valley (South Texas) for a year, and he also noticed the open hostility many Latinos have toward African-Americans. In other words, this story could have been easily uncovered, but it doesn't fit into the media's stock characterization of minorities.
Larry Parker
March 5, 2008 4:26 PM
One of the reasons I support Barack Obama, ironically, is that his MULTIRACIAL background personally, and EXPERIENCE (having lived his childhood in Indonesia and Hawaii, two avowedly multiracial places) may give him an advantage in at least starting to loosen this increasingly Gordian knot.
I've always been honest that African-Americans as well as whites share resentments against Latinos, legal and illegal, stirred up in this talk radio/Minuteman raging brushfire by the ultra-right. Little surprise, human nature being what it is, that some Latinos would be cruel/prejudiced in response.
And that's not even getting into the dicey racial politics of the Asian-American community, where affirmative action might better be called negative action.
I dated an Asian woman a couple of years ago, and her ultra-traditionalist mother was very complimentary towards me when I met her for the first time. I was quite surprised (given my well-known heterodoxical ways), but of course pleasantly so.
"R.," I said to my then-girlfriend, "wouldn't your mother rather have you date a fellow Asian?"
"Definitely not unless he was (in my specific ethnic group)," she said. "And even then, she'd rather have me date someone white. IT'S A STEP UP."
That floored me. So my next question was, "OK, so what if I was African-American?"
"Oh, I'd be disowned," she replied sadly yet nonchalantly.
sad but true
March 5, 2008 4:36 PM
I'm married to a Hispanic (although I hate the term and she doesn't use it). I won't say what country she's from.
I'm Caucasian, and her in-laws love me. I enjoy their company.
But when it comes to race, they are like Southerners from the pre-Civil Rights era. They hate blacks, and talk openly about their contempt for them. I don't dare say a contrary word, because their minds will be unchanged and it will damage their relationship with my wife. They are still her parents, and I'm not willing to provoke family strife. In many other ways, they are honorable people.
One time someone asked my mother-in-law to get something for them. Her response: "Do I look black to you?"
My impression is that this is very, very typical.
sad but true
March 5, 2008 4:39 PM
Oops, by "her in-laws" I meant "my inlaws" - her parents.
rebeccat
March 5, 2008 5:08 PM
Larry, unfortunately hispanic's negative attitude doesn't stem from much of anything that has happened to hispanic here in american. My husband has hispanic friends, several of whom are (legal) immigrants and they openly admit that even back in their countries of origin hispanics generally have an extremely negative view of black people. Several of them have told us that their parents always taught them that if they could, they should marry a white person because "it improves the race".
Years ago I was talking with a hispanic man at a diner I was working at (he openly admitted to being here illegally) and when he found out that I had a mixed race son he said, "oh, we mexicans can't stand black people. They're lazy and dirty and violent." (It didn't seem to occur to him that this might be offensive to me.) I asked him if he knew any black people and he said, "no. But you see it all the time on TV and the movies. That's just how black people are. Everyone knows it."
I won't even begin to tell you stories from my husband's time in Miami. Let's just say that having people refuse to speak to him in English and throwing change and merchandise towards him in stores was pretty run of the mill.
Again, we have hispanic friends and obviously this isn't universal. But it's definitely there.
Daniel
March 5, 2008 5:55 PM
Racism is an ugly thing, regardless of how it is learned. No one should be surprised that immigrants or people outside the U.S. adopt the racist beliefs of the dominant U.S. culture. And no one should be surprised that oppressed groups--forced to battle over limited resources--are going to be in conflict and not necessarily have affinity for each other.
M.Z. Forrest
March 5, 2008 6:04 PM
Let's take a slight step back here, because there are a couple things being combined.
a) Mexican/South American cultural racism: Yes, there is discrimination against mestizos and lighter skin is more desirable. It traces itself back to do the days when the Spanish elite ruled. Depending on the place, actual African descendents (as opposed to Indian) were considered a lower class due to slavery. Being half-white, I'm not sure Obama is being hit so much with this form of racism.
b) More established racism in LA, San Diego, Houston, etc: This traces itself to two minority communties often being played against one another. In part it has to do with gang violence. Add in the spoils systems of local governments. This is the part that is hurting Obama at this point.
I won't even begin to tell you stories from my husband's time in Miami. Let's just say that having people refuse to speak to him in English and throwing change and merchandise towards him in stores was pretty run of the mill.
Never heard of the change being thrown at someone part, but when I lived in south Florida in the mid-1990s, it wasn't uncommon for Anglos, even, to be in situations in which they would be spoken to in Spanish, defiantly, even though the person serving them in the bank, restaurant, wherever, made it clear he or she spoke English. But wouldn't. It was laying down a marker, and it was really quite something.
Ostrea
March 5, 2008 10:35 PM
Daniel: "No one should be surprised that immigrants or people outside the U.S. adopt the racist beliefs of the dominant U.S. culture."
That's B.S. What is true is that no one should be surprised that immigrants or people outside the U.S. bring to the U.S. their own racist beliefs from their own countries. I have been amazed at the racist comments regarding blacks I have heard from Europeans (in Eurpoe), Asians (in the U.S. and Southeast Asia) and Latin Americans (in the U.S.). Racism is not an American phenomenon. It is universal. Americans face it and deal with it better than most.
Daniel
March 5, 2008 10:43 PM
Americans face it and deal with it better than most.
Oh, I completely agree. But racism is different in each country. The U.S is a multicultural success unmatched anywhere in the world (with maybe the exception of Canada). Still, we aren't post-racist. The way Black people are treated in this country is a uniquely U.S. experience and, as the dominant cultural powerhouse, those views get transmitted.
Grumpy Old Man
March 6, 2008 5:31 AM
This is getting closer and closer to a race war in Los Angeles. Nobody wants to admit it, least of all the pro-immigration crowd.
It's what the black community gets for 75 years of being voting cattle for the liberal Democrats.
Rod Dreher
March 6, 2008 8:58 AM
It's what the black community gets for 75 years of being voting cattle for the liberal Democrats.
Huh? The greatest wave of illegal immigration in our history began in 2000, with the ascendancy of a Republican president and a GOP Congress, aided and abetted by religious conservatives being "voting cattle" for the Republicans.
sigaliris
March 6, 2008 11:04 AM
It's interesting that we can have an open discussion about the role that Latino racism may play in the upcoming election. I'm looking forward to the equivalent discussion of what role white racism will play. I'm sure there will be a long, thoughtful post on that any day now.
Baz
March 6, 2008 11:21 AM
Don't hold your breath. Superior candidates of other races chosen instead of him are responsible for marooning Rod where he is now in life, so his payback is far from finished.
sigaliris
March 6, 2008 1:08 PM
Well, just to clarify my own position, I'm not accusing Rod of being personally a racist, or motivated by personal animosity. But I do think that obsessing over the supposed racism of this or that minority group, while ignoring the effects of long-standing majority racism, is chasing the gnat out of the room while giving a wide berth to the 800-pound gorilla parked on the sofa.
Brian Horan
March 6, 2008 5:08 PM
What's funny is that immigration wasn't an issue till the war in Iraq went South. Bush never campaigned on securing our borders (or ports) in 00/04.
Republicans continually look for scapegoats/distractions when their own policies go awry. I'd figure on them pulling out gays, Mexicans, public school teachers, ACLU members, feminists, etc. when the campaign starts going poorly for the GOP this summer.
As far as blacks vs. latinos, I can only speak for the Denver Metro area:
I'm a white who lives in a predominately black area and Latinos are moving in the neighborhoods. It seems to me that with the anti-immigrant frevor Latinos could do just as well in a black neighborhood as a mixed or a white one. And Latinos are moving into the old Stapleton airport area where I live.
Black residents don't seem to have any more hang-ups than whites in my view.
I've been a public school teacher most of the decade in Denver Public Schools. Latinos seem to emulate the hip-hop culture quite well. I've never dealt with an issue as a MS & Elementary teacher over some Latino - Black issue.
In fact, I think what the baby-boomers don't get is that hip-hop culture (a segement of African American youth culture) is the most popular thing around (even for many white suburban kids).
Maybe it's gonna be the folks after GenXers (like myself) who really are color-blind.
I'm tired of hearing about wars between races and ethnic groups. Let's instead talk about the difference between the haves and have-nots. Class disparities in the States are only making existing group tensions worse.
Fred Niles
March 6, 2008 10:12 PM
Sure, lets pretend that there is no animosity between the blacks and browns. Let's look the other way as Latino gang members target blacks in Los Angeles.
Yeah, you "don't see anything wrong."
How convenient.
JD Gent
October 23, 2008 2:39 AM
The bottom line is that latinos are harder workers, more patriotic and more intellectual than blacks. Blacks by & large do hardly nothing but whine & complain about how everyone else is responsible for their failure. Where a black will wait for someone to give him a handout, the latino, by hard work and dedication, will make the most out of every opportunity this great country provides.
popcornular
January 4, 2009 1:20 PM
So true, JD Gent! This is the elephant in the room. No one dare speak the reality, which is that blacks are genetically less intelligent, lazier, and much more agressive than other cultures. Anyone with common sense can see this.
Post a Comment
By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.
Rod Dreher is an editorial columnist for the Dallas Morning News, and author of "Crunchy Cons" (Crown Forum), a nonfiction book about conservatives, most of them religious, whose faith and political convictions sometimes put them at odds with mainstream conservatives. The views expressed in this blog are his own.
Subscribe
Sign Up: Receive Crunchy Con in your in-box every day
I think any rifts between Latinos and African Americans can't be assumed to mean Latinos are going to run off and support a party that is outright hostile to Latino issues. Republicans lost Latinos for at least a generation over the opposition to immigration reform, and McCain will be pulled to the right on the issue to maintain his anti-immigrant base in the GOP.
Latinos and African Americans often have competing interests. The Clintons have a long history with Latino voters and leaders. What Latinos and African Americans are forced to fight over in the Dallas City Council is not the same as a national agenda.
I would say no, at least not anywhere it is going to make a difference. I'm going from memory, but I believe Obama did fine with Hispanics in Arizona. Where there seems to be an issue is where you have black and hispanic integrated populations. California and Texas immediately come to mind, but I don't think anyone believes that either of those will be flipped. New Mexico and Colorado look to be swing states this year, and hispanics could play a role in both those States. I think McCain will get the former and Obama will get the latter. The last state with a decent Hispanic influence would be Florida. I think McCain has that one in the bag against Obama, because the Cuban, Jewish, and elderly votes will all probably swing to McCain.
Which will be harder for McCain to beat:
A Clinton(P)/Obama(VP) ticket, or an Obama(P)/Clinton(VP) ticket?
I don't understand the immigration issue. I've seen polls that show at least one third of Hispanics are against illegal immigration, and the illegals can't vote. You can't lose voters who can't vote!
If two-third of Latinos support comprehensive immigration reform and believe there is a blacklash from the right's rhetoric, that's a powerful force. Even those who support tougher enforcement are impacted by complaints about people speaking Spanish, comments about the Hispanicization of communities, targeting of Hispanics who are assumed to be illegal. The anti-immigrant rhetoric has been ugly and offensive, and even Latinos who support enforcement hear the ugly rhetoric which is often used broadly against Latinos.
I don't think this is just about immigration. There is a deep racism within the Hispanic community. NPR just had a whole segment on it and it certainly matches my experience living in Latin America. Most of those in power in Latin America are white Hispanics with Black Latinos and Natives at the bottom of the power structure, much like America for a very long part of her history.
Very sad. Though, the racism tends to fade by 3rd generation immigrants become Americanized.
Rod
I agree with you that the racial between Latinos and African-Americans has been largely ignored by the media. My wife was a teacher at a South Dallas public school while we lived there several years ago. She was shocked at the racial hostility between the Latino and African-American teachers. She was also amazed at how openly the teachers made racist comments, especially the Latino teachers. My brother lived and worked in the Valley (South Texas) for a year, and he also noticed the open hostility many Latinos have toward African-Americans. In other words, this story could have been easily uncovered, but it doesn't fit into the media's stock characterization of minorities.
One of the reasons I support Barack Obama, ironically, is that his MULTIRACIAL background personally, and EXPERIENCE (having lived his childhood in Indonesia and Hawaii, two avowedly multiracial places) may give him an advantage in at least starting to loosen this increasingly Gordian knot.
I've always been honest that African-Americans as well as whites share resentments against Latinos, legal and illegal, stirred up in this talk radio/Minuteman raging brushfire by the ultra-right. Little surprise, human nature being what it is, that some Latinos would be cruel/prejudiced in response.
And that's not even getting into the dicey racial politics of the Asian-American community, where affirmative action might better be called negative action.
I dated an Asian woman a couple of years ago, and her ultra-traditionalist mother was very complimentary towards me when I met her for the first time. I was quite surprised (given my well-known heterodoxical ways), but of course pleasantly so.
"R.," I said to my then-girlfriend, "wouldn't your mother rather have you date a fellow Asian?"
"Definitely not unless he was (in my specific ethnic group)," she said. "And even then, she'd rather have me date someone white. IT'S A STEP UP."
That floored me. So my next question was, "OK, so what if I was African-American?"
"Oh, I'd be disowned," she replied sadly yet nonchalantly.
I'm married to a Hispanic (although I hate the term and she doesn't use it). I won't say what country she's from.
I'm Caucasian, and her in-laws love me. I enjoy their company.
But when it comes to race, they are like Southerners from the pre-Civil Rights era. They hate blacks, and talk openly about their contempt for them. I don't dare say a contrary word, because their minds will be unchanged and it will damage their relationship with my wife. They are still her parents, and I'm not willing to provoke family strife. In many other ways, they are honorable people.
One time someone asked my mother-in-law to get something for them. Her response: "Do I look black to you?"
My impression is that this is very, very typical.
Oops, by "her in-laws" I meant "my inlaws" - her parents.
Larry, unfortunately hispanic's negative attitude doesn't stem from much of anything that has happened to hispanic here in american. My husband has hispanic friends, several of whom are (legal) immigrants and they openly admit that even back in their countries of origin hispanics generally have an extremely negative view of black people. Several of them have told us that their parents always taught them that if they could, they should marry a white person because "it improves the race".
Years ago I was talking with a hispanic man at a diner I was working at (he openly admitted to being here illegally) and when he found out that I had a mixed race son he said, "oh, we mexicans can't stand black people. They're lazy and dirty and violent." (It didn't seem to occur to him that this might be offensive to me.) I asked him if he knew any black people and he said, "no. But you see it all the time on TV and the movies. That's just how black people are. Everyone knows it."
I won't even begin to tell you stories from my husband's time in Miami. Let's just say that having people refuse to speak to him in English and throwing change and merchandise towards him in stores was pretty run of the mill.
Again, we have hispanic friends and obviously this isn't universal. But it's definitely there.
Racism is an ugly thing, regardless of how it is learned. No one should be surprised that immigrants or people outside the U.S. adopt the racist beliefs of the dominant U.S. culture. And no one should be surprised that oppressed groups--forced to battle over limited resources--are going to be in conflict and not necessarily have affinity for each other.
Let's take a slight step back here, because there are a couple things being combined.
a) Mexican/South American cultural racism: Yes, there is discrimination against mestizos and lighter skin is more desirable. It traces itself back to do the days when the Spanish elite ruled. Depending on the place, actual African descendents (as opposed to Indian) were considered a lower class due to slavery. Being half-white, I'm not sure Obama is being hit so much with this form of racism.
b) More established racism in LA, San Diego, Houston, etc: This traces itself to two minority communties often being played against one another. In part it has to do with gang violence. Add in the spoils systems of local governments. This is the part that is hurting Obama at this point.
Of course I could just e wrong.
It's going to be a fun election.
There is some African ancestry in Mexicans.
http://isteve.com/2002_Where_Did_Mexicos_Blacks_Go.htm
I won't even begin to tell you stories from my husband's time in Miami. Let's just say that having people refuse to speak to him in English and throwing change and merchandise towards him in stores was pretty run of the mill.
Never heard of the change being thrown at someone part, but when I lived in south Florida in the mid-1990s, it wasn't uncommon for Anglos, even, to be in situations in which they would be spoken to in Spanish, defiantly, even though the person serving them in the bank, restaurant, wherever, made it clear he or she spoke English. But wouldn't. It was laying down a marker, and it was really quite something.
Daniel: "No one should be surprised that immigrants or people outside the U.S. adopt the racist beliefs of the dominant U.S. culture."
That's B.S. What is true is that no one should be surprised that immigrants or people outside the U.S. bring to the U.S. their own racist beliefs from their own countries. I have been amazed at the racist comments regarding blacks I have heard from Europeans (in Eurpoe), Asians (in the U.S. and Southeast Asia) and Latin Americans (in the U.S.). Racism is not an American phenomenon. It is universal. Americans face it and deal with it better than most.
Americans face it and deal with it better than most.
Oh, I completely agree. But racism is different in each country. The U.S is a multicultural success unmatched anywhere in the world (with maybe the exception of Canada). Still, we aren't post-racist. The way Black people are treated in this country is a uniquely U.S. experience and, as the dominant cultural powerhouse, those views get transmitted.
This is getting closer and closer to a race war in Los Angeles. Nobody wants to admit it, least of all the pro-immigration crowd.
It's what the black community gets for 75 years of being voting cattle for the liberal Democrats.
It's what the black community gets for 75 years of being voting cattle for the liberal Democrats.
Huh? The greatest wave of illegal immigration in our history began in 2000, with the ascendancy of a Republican president and a GOP Congress, aided and abetted by religious conservatives being "voting cattle" for the Republicans.
It's interesting that we can have an open discussion about the role that Latino racism may play in the upcoming election. I'm looking forward to the equivalent discussion of what role white racism will play. I'm sure there will be a long, thoughtful post on that any day now.
Don't hold your breath. Superior candidates of other races chosen instead of him are responsible for marooning Rod where he is now in life, so his payback is far from finished.
Well, just to clarify my own position, I'm not accusing Rod of being personally a racist, or motivated by personal animosity. But I do think that obsessing over the supposed racism of this or that minority group, while ignoring the effects of long-standing majority racism, is chasing the gnat out of the room while giving a wide berth to the 800-pound gorilla parked on the sofa.
What's funny is that immigration wasn't an issue till the war in Iraq went South. Bush never campaigned on securing our borders (or ports) in 00/04.
Republicans continually look for scapegoats/distractions when their own policies go awry. I'd figure on them pulling out gays, Mexicans, public school teachers, ACLU members, feminists, etc. when the campaign starts going poorly for the GOP this summer.
As far as blacks vs. latinos, I can only speak for the Denver Metro area:
I'm a white who lives in a predominately black area and Latinos are moving in the neighborhoods. It seems to me that with the anti-immigrant frevor Latinos could do just as well in a black neighborhood as a mixed or a white one. And Latinos are moving into the old Stapleton airport area where I live.
Black residents don't seem to have any more hang-ups than whites in my view.
I've been a public school teacher most of the decade in Denver Public Schools. Latinos seem to emulate the hip-hop culture quite well. I've never dealt with an issue as a MS & Elementary teacher over some Latino - Black issue.
In fact, I think what the baby-boomers don't get is that hip-hop culture (a segement of African American youth culture) is the most popular thing around (even for many white suburban kids).
Maybe it's gonna be the folks after GenXers (like myself) who really are color-blind.
I'm tired of hearing about wars between races and ethnic groups. Let's instead talk about the difference between the haves and have-nots. Class disparities in the States are only making existing group tensions worse.
Sure, lets pretend that there is no animosity between the blacks and browns. Let's look the other way as Latino gang members target blacks in Los Angeles.
Yeah, you "don't see anything wrong."
How convenient.
The bottom line is that latinos are harder workers, more patriotic and more intellectual than blacks. Blacks by & large do hardly nothing but whine & complain about how everyone else is responsible for their failure. Where a black will wait for someone to give him a handout, the latino, by hard work and dedication, will make the most out of every opportunity this great country provides.
So true, JD Gent! This is the elephant in the room. No one dare speak the reality, which is that blacks are genetically less intelligent, lazier, and much more agressive than other cultures. Anyone with common sense can see this.
Post a Comment
By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.