Crunchy Con

Deo gratias, and thank you, Benedict

Friday April 18, 2008

Categories: Catholicism

I had to sit back and read this three times for its full impact to sink in, and to deal with the emotions it brings forth. From the Boston Globe:


"I asked him to forgive me for hating his church and hating him," said Olan Horne, 48, of Lowell, who gave the pope a picture of himself as a 9-year-old boy, just before the Rev. Joseph E. Birmingham started molesting him. "He said, 'My English isn't good, but I want you to know that I can understand you, and I think I can understand your sorrow.' "

This is what so many have been waiting for, for so long. Not even John Paul, for all his courage and charity, could bring himself to do this. Benedict did it, God bless him. I can tell you from personal experience that you can read tens of thousands of words in the newspaper and in books about the clerical sex abuse scandal, but nothing, nothing, can match talking personally to human beings who suffered abuse, and their family members. I have faith that Benedict understands that now.

Thank you, Cardinal O'Malley, for making this happen. I pray that the seeds those victims planted in his heart bear good fruit. Soon.

UPDATE: Though as Ross Douthat, a Catholic, reminds us, let's not get too carried away about Benedict's meeting with victims. Excerpt:

But a meeting like yesterday's should have happened much, much sooner, and that it did not speaks to a fundamental problem facing the Catholic Church today -- the extent to which the Vatican aspires to remain above the grubby, frenetic fray of modern life, even as its local representatives adopt the worst habits of modern business executives and politicians. ... [The U.S. bishops] didn't need direction or wise counsel or even fraternal correction: They needed to be to be taken to the woodshed by an outraged, scandalized and engaged Papacy, and the discipline needed to happen swiftly and above all publicly. And because it didn't -- because in most cases bishops were allowed to get away with sacrificing the Body of Christ's most innocent members to protect, though of course only temporarily, their finances and prerogatives and reputation -- the Roman Catholic Church ended up looking like an institution prone to all of the evils of a modern government or corporation, but with none of the accountability.

Be ye therefore wise as serpents, and innocent as doves, Christ told his followers. But the Church during the sex scandals has often seemed like a company of serpents -- the American bishops, and the perverts they protected -- presided over by a company of otherworldly, out-of-touch doves. The Pope's words and actions this week are an important step toward changing that perception. But only a step.


Advertisement
Comments
SusanF
April 19, 2008 10:27 AM

Thanks for the sermonette, goodguyex. I know I'm a sinner. What that has to do with the issue at hand, though, I'm not certain.
The Washington Post had some very nice photos, and an editorial by E.J. Dionne yesterday focusing on the Pope's message. Even the horrible "Style" section of the WaPo had a piece by one of its snarkmeisters showing just a glimmer of understanding. If you read carefully, you sense a longing and a question, "What is it with this Christ our hope stuff? What if there's a 'there', there?"
I've been pleasantly surprised to find more than 8% of media attention focused on the Pope's ultimate message.

Roland de Chanson
April 19, 2008 12:03 PM

SusanF,

To respond to your question about the "true Mass": by that I mean the pre-V2 Mass, in fact probably even before. Mind you, I am no expert on liturgy and heresy, but when my son, on a business trip, went into an Episcopal (i.e. Henry VIII-ish) church for a "mass" and thought it was "Catholic" with some local differences, then it seems to me that the twin cancers of inculturation and oecumenism have metasticised to the point of terminality. As even Paul VI said, "the smoke of Satan has entered into the temple of God." And Benedict, a V2 peritus, needs must bear a portion of the blame.

I am not sure whether Benedict's motu proprio, Summorum Pontificum, was intended as a step toward redressing the abuses of V2 or developing a revenue stream from the disaffected (and affluent) older generation. The Vatican knows whence cometh the oboli. Of significance is the fact that he won't be celebrating any "Tridentine" Masses while here. Locutionem efficit nec ambulationem! Which is as close as I can Latinise "he talks the talk but doesn't walk the walk."

In my opinion, the Mass was gutted at Vatican II. A second lance into the flank of Christ. The introduction of the vernacular and its mistranslations and "inclusive language", along with the perversion of the rubrics of the ancient rite, indeed the concoction of a new cult, all of which were engineered by a freemason, Annibale Bugnini, and a coterie of heretical Protestant advisors, resulted in a liturgy (if one can call it that) essentially indistinguishable from that Henrician / Elizabethan circus. Ratzinger himself has called the service a "fabrication." Certainly a man of his devout spirituality, intellectual profundity and artistic sensitivity could not have foreseen what a botch the Protestantisers would have made of the liturgy in the wake of the council.

It is my hope that B16 will quash this heretical "service" and restore the Mass. But Rome works slowly and I'm a patient guy. If I lose a fan, I will be sorry.

Roland de Chanson
April 19, 2008 12:12 PM

Although I don't want to interpose myself in the spirited exchange among various posters regarding the penalties, canonical or criminal, to be visited upon the heads of miscreant bishops, I will just make the a couple of observations.

(1) Thomas Reilly, Attorney General of Massachusetts, found that there was insufficient evidence to proceed criminally against Bernard Law; he expressed his regret about the lack of evidence but chastised the former archbishop severely. The Boston Globe has an archive full of past coverage for those interested.

(2) Pope John Paul II deserves to be denounced for having elevated Law to the archipresbyterate of the ancient Roman basilica of St. Mary Major. I cannot disagree with those who saw this as rubbing salt into the wounds of those abused. Further, Law occupies some half-dozen or so curial positions, including one in which he advises on the appointment of bishops. That this continues is an unmitigated disgrace for the Church.


Roland de Chanson
April 19, 2008 12:24 PM

I agree with Rod about the Gaillot affair. One might also add JP2's crackdown on so-called "liberation theology", the revocation of Küng's licentiate, the excommunication of Lefebvre (not for supporting the old mass, which was never made illicit or invalid, indeed cannot be, but rather for consecrating four bishops without papal sanction.) If JP2 could be decisive when his authority was challenged, it is a shame he could not be so in the face of an evil far more satanic than mere heresy.

Rod Dreher
April 19, 2008 12:49 PM

Sorry, I got distracted and forgot to close the comments earlier this morning. They should be closed now.

Read All Comments

Advertisement

Search This Blog

About Crunchy Con

Rod Dreher is an editorial columnist for the Dallas Morning News, and author of "Crunchy Cons" (Crown Forum), a nonfiction book about conservatives, most of them religious, whose faith and political convictions sometimes put them at odds with mainstream conservatives. The views expressed in this blog are his own.

feed icon Subscribe

RSS Feed

Receive updates from Crunchy Con

Advertisement

Advertisement


About Beliefnet

Our mission is to help people like you find, and walk, a spiritual path that will bring comfort, hope, clarity, strength, and happiness. More about Beliefnet.

Legal

Copyright © Beliefnet, Inc. and/or its licensors. All rights reserved. Use of this site is subject to Terms of Service and to our Privacy Policy. Constructed by Beliefnet.

Advertisement

Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.