Crunchy Con

The new survivalism

Sunday April 6, 2008

Categories: Decline and fall

NYT story today about how survivalist thinking isn't just for armed paranoids anymore:

The traditional face of survivalism is that of a shaggy loner in camouflage, holed up in a cabin in the wilderness and surrounded by cases of canned goods and ammunition.

It is not that of Barton M. Biggs, the former chief global strategist at Morgan Stanley. Yet in Mr. Biggs’s new book, “Wealth, War and Wisdom,” he says people should “assume the possibility of a breakdown of the civilized infrastructure.”

“Your safe haven must be self-sufficient and capable of growing some kind of food,” Mr. Biggs writes. “It should be well-stocked with seed, fertilizer, canned food, wine, medicine, clothes, etc. Think Swiss Family Robinson. Even in America and Europe there could be moments of riot and rebellion when law and order temporarily completely breaks down.”

Survivalism, it seems, is not just for survivalists anymore.

Faced with a confluence of diverse threats — a tanking economy, a housing crisis, looming environmental disasters, and a sharp spike in oil prices — people who do not consider themselves extremists are starting to discuss doomsday measures once associated with the social fringes.

They stockpile or grow food in case of a supply breakdown, or buy precious metals in case of economic collapse. Some try to take their houses off the electricity grid, or plan safe houses far away. The point is not to drop out of society, but to be prepared in case the future turns out like something out of “An Inconvenient Truth,” if not “Mad Max.”

“I’m not a gun-nut, camo-wearing skinhead. I don’t even hunt or fish,” said Bill Marcom, 53, a construction executive in Dallas.

Still, motivated by a belief that the credit crunch and a bursting housing bubble might spark widespread economic chaos — “the Greater Depression,” as he put it — Mr. Marcom began to take measures to prepare for the unknown over the last few years: buying old silver coins to use as currency; buying G.P.S. units, a satellite telephone and a hydroponic kit; and building a simple cabin in a remote West Texas desert.

“If all these planets line up and things do get really bad,” Mr. Marcom said, “those who have not prepared will be trapped in the city with thousands of other people needing food and propane and everything else.”

It's the Zeitgeist, fellers. OK, that's it. Time to quit blogging so damn much, and make real progress writing my "Benedict Option" book!

Seriously. I think it is, or should be, becoming more apparent to sensible people that the high-wire act we've been acting out is coming to an end. That doesn't mean Apocalypse Pretty Soon, but it does mean that we should be thinking about new and more sustainable ways of living at every level.

UPDATE: More on Biggs's "Wealth, War and Wisdom.":

Biggs is no paranoid survivalist. He was chief global strategist at Morgan Stanley before leaving in 2003 to form hedge fund Traxis Partners. He doesn't lock and load until the last page of this smart look at how World War II warped share prices, gutted wealth and remains a warning to investors. His message: Listen to markets, learn from history and prepare for the worst.

``Wealth, War and Wisdom'' fills a void. Library shelves are packed with volumes on World War II. The history of stock markets also has been ably recorded, notably in Robert Sobel's ``The Big Board.'' Yet how many books track the intersection of the two?

The ``wisdom'' in the alliterative title refers to the spooky way markets can foreshadow the future. Biggs became fascinated with this phenomenon after discovering by chance that equity markets sensed major turning points in the war.

The British stock market bottomed out in late June 1940 and started rising again before the truly grim days of the Battle of Britain in July to October, when the Germans were splintering London with bombs and preparing to invade the U.K.

[snip]

Mankind endures ``an episode of great wealth destruction'' at least once every century, Biggs reminds us. So the wealthy should prepare to ride out a disaster, be it a tsunami, a market meltdown or Islamic terrorists with a dirty bomb.

The rich get complacent, assuming they will have time ``to extricate themselves and their wealth'' when trouble comes, Biggs says. The rich are mistaken, as the Holocaust proves.

``Events move much faster than anyone expects,'' he says, ``and the barbarians are on top of you before you can escape.''

Here's a PDF of Biggs's first chapter. After reading that chapter, I really, really want to read that book!

Filed Under: Benedict Option, survivalism

Comments

On Rod's other point - would this Benedict Option book look at the foundation of new, traditional, self-sustaining, Benedictine monasteries (such as Clear Creek) and the communities that have grown up around them?

Absolutely. Absolutely.

"... DC or NYC..."
if there's a "collapse of civilization"...
and the 10+ million people in NYC must move out to survive...
then New England, upstate NY and Penn will be overwhelmed...
so we could think that living in a small agricultural town is the way to prepare...
but not if that small town is too close to the fleeing masses...

but hey, have a nice day!

faith hope love joy peace to all...
Forgive God...

fear not... be not afraid...

Wow, miracles DO happen! Godisaheretic actually said something intelligent and coherent.

It IS worth wondering how Kunstler thinks he's going to manage in upstate New York once all the millions of people fleeing societal collapse reach his doorstep, and want to steal the food and provisions he's been presciently storing.

I'm not woried about that in the least, because I don't see any such collapse happening. But if I were Kunstler, I'd be collecting a huge stash of weapons.

Rod, just a thought: 9/11 was, for me, another example of the human spirit in the aftermath of calamity. My personal exemplar (and heroine) was the friend who spent two weeks of her PTO, risked her general and respiratory health, and brought her EMS skills to help wherever they put her.

The lesson is not that we must fear and vainly try to protect ourselves. The lesson is that we are neither so vulnerable nor so unprepared as we are lead to believe.

... I know that looks like an implied political dig, but I don't intend it to be one. I just wish we could emphasize our strengths instead of our fears.

thanks, astorian... ;-) ...
I sure hope you're right about no such collapse... though...
if it comes to the need for a "huge stash of weapons"...
just think...
that would probably mean a catastrophic collapse...
and after that chaos...
there would be little left to counter the spread of any Myths...
so...
your personal favorite Myths would most likely find a ready audience...
Myths most likely would do much better in civilizational collapse than in the continuing increase of modern societies...
anyway...
have a nice day!

faith hope love joy peace to all...
Forgive God...

Read All Comments

Post a Comment

Are you aware of our Rules of Conduct?


(won't be made public)



Ad tag

Advertisement

Search

About Crunchy Con

Rod Dreher is an editorial columnist for the Dallas Morning News, and author of "Crunchy Cons" (Crown Forum), a nonfiction book about conservatives, most of them religious, whose faith and political convictions sometimes put them at odds with mainstream conservatives. The views expressed in this blog are his own.

feed icon Subscribe

RSS Feed

Receive updates from Crunchy Con
Enter your email address below.