As I said on the Dallas Morning News blog, far be it from me to mourn the trials and tribulations of Jesse Jackson, a public figure I consider to be one of the real villains of American public life. I'm...
"Do interview subjects now have to worry about every single thing they say once they enter a studio?"
I think they do, Rod. I'm not defending Fox News either, but haven't we had enough "open mike" incidents on both side of the political spectrum for the average person to realize that anything said in the presence of the media, especially anything that might be recorded, will be considered fair game for airing or publication?
Don WIley
July 9, 2008 7:54 PM
It ain't beanbag. But, you know that, Rod.
Question is, will it break large into the MSM at large, or one day and into the Memory Hole?
I'll predict the latter.
Rod Dreher
July 9, 2008 7:54 PM
It didn't used to be that way. I think we in the media make it harder for the people we interview to be human beings. They always have to keep their guard up now. You ought to read the comments over on the Dallas News blog -- so many conservatives who would have gone berserk had CNN done this to Rush Limbaugh thrilled that Fox did it to Jesse Jackson. I find it depressing that we live in a political culture in which anything is justified so long as it advances the defeat of the Enemy.
Reaganite in NYC
July 9, 2008 7:58 PM
Will this work to Obama's short-term advantage?
Yes, because the Jesse Jackson blooper pushes off the radar Obama's nitwitted comment in Georgia yesterday that ... "You need to make sure that your child can learn to speak Spanish." You can check it out here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BZprtPat1Vk
That comment -- and not the injudicious choice of words by "Reverent" Jackson -- would have led the news tonight. A lucky break for BO.
The substance of Jackson's comment, however, addresses one of BO's more irritating habits: his tendency to lecture Americans. Whether it is lecturing black fathers about their parental responsiblities (Jackson's point) or his ham-handed comment about the need for non-Hispanic parents to get their kids to learn Spanish, BO often comes across like the Headmaster-in-Chief lecturing the great unlettered masses.
Anonymous
July 9, 2008 8:13 PM
his ham-handed comment about the need for non-Hispanic parents to get their kids to learn Spanish
He wasn't saying that at all.
I watched the clip, and Obama's main point is that we should, as a country, encourage kids (and adults too!) to be at least bilingual, whether they learn Spanish, or French, or German, or whatever other language they choose to learn. Not only because it's better for us in the long run, but because it also improves our image abroad by making Americans appear more educated, since they'd know more than just English.
Speaking personally, my first language was Spanish. I didn't learn English until just before I started kindergarten. I still speak both languages fluently today at 35, and I think the advantages of knowing a second language are massive. My Spanish skills helped me all through Europe when I spent a summer there. And because French and Italian are also Romance languages, I was able to translate in my head without relying on a dictionary, and I was able to pick up phrases here and there to better communicate with people I met on my travels.
Knowing more than one language, especially in today's more connected world, is invaluable. We *should* encourage it in kids, and in others.
Joe
July 9, 2008 8:16 PM
Well, does this mean that people will have to watch what they say in public. Always! This is the same dumb thing that we all do from time to time. Open mouth and insert foot. The real problem here is that people will still listen to Jackson and call him a great man. He is and always will be someone that brings down the same people that he is trying to elevate. It's sad that the black community will still look up to him and Sharpton for that matter. I will not vote for Barack but, I still think he is a very intelligent man and he is smart to rise above the fools.
Reaganite in NYC
July 9, 2008 8:17 PM
Rod,
By the way, I appreciate that you feel queasy about what Fox News did. I agree, of course, that the other networks would have willingly done this to one of their guests -- especially if the guest was a cultural conservative. Nevertheless your qualms speak well of you. You're a good man.
LJG
July 9, 2008 8:19 PM
Oops. The 8:13PM comment is mine. I forgot to put in my name. :)
On a more general note, Jesse Jackson just gave Obama a huge gift, and entirely through his own carelessness. For Obama to be able to publicly distance himself from Jesse Jackson? It's his own Sista Souljah moment.
The Man From K Street
July 9, 2008 8:33 PM
Poor Jesse. White America has such an abiding need to find one African American and anoint him as 'King of the Negroes', the One Who Speaks For Those People. And he was it for so many years, so it must gall him (and Al) to see the crown being so rudely usurped.
Reaganite in NYC
July 9, 2008 8:37 PM
"anonyonous" at 8:13 PM quotes me and says: " 'his ham-handed comment about the need for non-Hispanic parents to get their kids to learn Spanish' He wasn't saying that at all. I watched the clip, and Obama's main point is that we should, as a country ..."
Listen, we don't need your analysis of what he said ... or mine. He said what he said: "You need to make sure that your child can learn to speak Spanish."
LJG
July 9, 2008 8:43 PM
Listen, we don't need your analysis of what he said ... or mine. He said what he said: "You need to make sure that your child can learn to speak Spanish."
You're taking one sentence out of what he said and drawing the wrong conclusion from it. It wasn't just about Spanish. It was about learning a second language in general, and why we should encourage it in kids.
What is so bad about teaching your kids more than one language? Why is that so wrong? I don't get it.
pb
July 9, 2008 8:58 PM
Interesting that his son felt compelled to say something publicly about his father's statements. Like father, like son? (As in, not knowing when to not say something--I find the comments to be against the virtue of piety.)
Chris L.
July 9, 2008 9:00 PM
What is so bad about teaching your kids more than one language? Why is that so wrong? I don't get it.
Because that really isn't what he meant. People are duly concerned about the fact that Spanish is being used as a primary language by many people in this country. He pretty much only gave lip service to that concern. Notice the tepid clapping when he said people need to learn Spanish. Only then did he switch into the vein of everyone learning a second language in general. No one says there is a problem with learning a second language. All he did was stand up a straw man to knock it down. Then he has to insult his fellow countrymen about how they act overseas.
Additionally, his comment is way off base about Americans traveling overseas. I wish I could find the survey from about six years ago. Basically Americans were one of the top nationalities at trying to speak the native language of the country they were visiting.
Reaganite in NYC
July 9, 2008 9:03 PM
LJG,
I had the opportunity to study two languages and to live overseas and use those languages. Good for me ... but I wouldn't inflict my love of languages and foreign cultures on others.
It is monumentally fatuous for a Presidential candidate -- who himself can't speak a foreign language -- to start lecturing parents about the need for their English-speaking kids to learn another tongue.
Moreover, Obama made the comment in the context of the discussion over requiring English competency for immigrants seeking citizenship. He equated the need for the children of immigrants to learn the language of this country with the need for Americans in general to learn a second language. Frankly, this is silly.
The point Jackson made about BO and blacks (that he talks down to them) is true of BO in general towards all Americans. The Headmaster-in-Chief -- the child of two PhDs -- can't overcome his tendency to condescend and lecture all of us like errant pupils.
LJG
July 9, 2008 9:12 PM
who himself can't speak a foreign language
Er, not quite. Obama is actually still somewhat proficient at Indonesian, since he lived there as a child.
While it's true he doesn't speak Spanish or French or German, he's not completely monolingual.
The point Jackson made about BO and blacks (that he talks down to them) is true of BO in general towards all Americans. The Headmaster-in-Chief -- the child of two PhDs -- can't overcome his tendency to condescend and lecture all of us like errant pupils.
Bah. Jesse Jackson's point is wrapped up in jealousy over the fact that Obama has done what Jesse could never do-- win the Democratic nomination for president. And because Obama has repeatedly rejected the victimization card that Jackson was so fond of playing for many years.
Getting criticized by Jesse Jackson was a gift from above for Obama. It's the best thing that's happened to him all day, especially since Fox News is going to be running with this story for a while, keeping it alive.
Reaganite in NYC
July 9, 2008 9:31 PM
LJG: "Obama is actually still somewhat proficient at Indonesian, since he lived there as a child."
Wow, good for him. I'm sure most voters will be jealous when they learn that BO can speak some Indonesian.
By the way, regarding Fox News, it appears that Bill O'Reilly decided NOT to air the most scatological part of Jackson's comment in his broadcast tonight. Good of him and Fox News ... and bad of all the rest of us for assuming that they would.
John E.
July 9, 2008 9:34 PM
What is so bad about teaching your kids more than one language? Why is that so wrong? I don't get it.
Posted by: LJG | July 9, 2008 8:43 PM
Oh, sure, you probably also think American kids need to learn the metric system - you commie!
Rock
July 9, 2008 9:53 PM
As a strong opponent of having a Republican in the White House while the Democrats control both houses of Congress, I am rooting for Obama.
But too many more mistakes like this one and McCain might win this thing.
Dave
July 9, 2008 10:03 PM
Bye Jesse, You just nailed the lid on your viable political casket!
Resist Liberalism
July 9, 2008 10:18 PM
Jesse Jackson has so much egg on his face, I'm surprised he hasn't turned yellow.
Jim
July 9, 2008 10:47 PM
Jesse Jackson is the real racist and is crying because he is jealous of another Africian Americans success. sorry Jesse,but some blacks need to be talked down too..same as whites..again, Jesse thinks this should be all about blacks..whats the matter Jesse?..you and sharptons bank accounts getting low..haven't you scam the black people out of enough of their hard earned money for your selfish agenda.
Mark in Houston
July 9, 2008 11:01 PM
"Will liberals now go to Fox News studios in the same spirit as US businessmen traveling in Soviet Russia -- assuming that everything they say is being listened to and might be used against them?"
Yes, liberals should go to Fox News in that spirit, and should have done so long before this incident. Fox News may be a great place to get airtime, but they are no friends to anyone liberal.
Also, I concur that this is great for Obama. Jackson basically Souljahed himself. A Souljahcide?
LJG
July 10, 2008 12:07 AM
Wow, good for him. I'm sure most voters will be jealous when they learn that BO can speak some Indonesian.
It may not sound like much to American ears, but it's a valuable skill for two reasons-- 1. Indonesia is the fourth largest country in the world, and 2. It's also the most populous Muslim-majority country, though it's not an Islamic state.
Having a president that can speak to and understand people over there would be important in terms of diplomacy and in getting them to help us in our fight against Al Qaeda.
Sure, he may not speak Spanish or French, but what he can speak will be an asset in our foreign policy, IMO.
Also, I concur that this is great for Obama. Jackson basically Souljahed himself.
Yes, it is. Jackson handed him a very precious gift, and my hope is that Obama takes advantage of it.
Max Schadenfreude
July 10, 2008 12:15 AM
I agreed with Obama when he said we should learn other languages. I've thought so myself for many years.
What irritated me was he said he was "embarassed for my country."
Screw that. I don't want to vote for someone who's embarassed because I don't speak Spanish, like my guns, and go to church. He essentially looks down his nose at the things I value (like, well, ah, America).
Robert Morwell
July 10, 2008 12:17 AM
I am an Obama supporter and I AM thrilled to have Jesse caught in this unguarded moment. (Though I share Rod's discomfort over the lack of journalistic ethics involved in its release...but hey, it's Fox. The same network that eagerly ballyhooed reports that Obama had attended a madrasa in Indonesia.)
The truth is that many in the African American community regard Jackson as a one-time hero who has been seduced by the lights of publicity and reduced to a vainglorious camera chasing buffoon.
Tragically the majority of African American men are avoiding their responsibilities as fathers. I have heard African American woman sigh with resigned frustration over the possibility of having a man in their lives who will be anything more than a transient babymaker.
Jackson would have us believe that this is solely because of racism. I know that this is a factor. But, poverty and persecutuon have not led every other culture to the same disastrous dysfunctional results. Obama and Cosby are pointng that out, and this undercuts Jackson's tired rant that every black problem has only white roots.
I suspect that Obama will gain votes thanks to Jesse.
Stephanie
July 10, 2008 7:53 AM
Why shouldn't Fox show the tape? They didn't break the news - Jackson himself apologized and had a press conference about it earlier in the day. It was a news story reported on CNN, etc. - they just didn't have the tape.
Nick the Greek
July 10, 2008 8:57 AM
Where I come from, there's no such thing as "off the record", as Samantha Power found to her cost. Why does the inside-the-Beltway media feel such need to coddle public figures and allow them to dictate the terms of debate?
Alicia
July 10, 2008 9:19 AM
Here's the headline:
"Jesse Jackson expresses solidarity with Klan; advocates castration for uppity black boys."
Seriously, how dare Jesse Jackson open his foul, race-baiting, opportunistic, hypocritical mouth? He deserves 0 sympathy and 0 forgiveness.
The b*stard is hoist on his own petard.
Roland de Chanson
July 10, 2008 10:00 AM
John E: Oh, sure, you probably also think American kids need to learn the metric system - you commie!
The metric system is a product of the French Revolution! The Bolshies coopted it when they changed from furlongs and farthings. No, wait, that was the Brits. Well, versts and poods, then. ;-)
Just as an opinión incidental, I have no objection to the acquisition of Castillian competency by the "Anglo" masses. Spanish is a beautiful language in its own right and its literature among the jewels in the crown of Western culture. But the latent agenda here is that the English-speaking majority must cater to the Spanish-speaking minority. That is a canard. I would mandate at least two years of Latin rather than Spanish; the laggards would be spared the vararies of the imperfect subjunctive.
As a lover of languages, I myself would attempt to learn Chinese. But because el tiempo es de suma importancia, I will defer starting my lessons until the Beijing Bolshies relieve their slaves of the onus of analphabeticity.
In the meanwhile, my French-accented Spanish is considered encantador y por supuesto divertido in the local bodegas.
To return to the main topic: interesting language from a so-called "reverend". Perhaps he thinks Mubarak Hussein Obama has a falsetto worth preserving?
Simon
July 10, 2008 10:25 AM
1. This is a huge gift to the Obama Campaign. It puts real distance between him and the despised Jackson/Sharpton wing of his party, and doesn't even require Obama to play hardball a la "Sister Souljah." A strong antidote to electoral poison of Jeremiah Wright.
2. What a nasty piece of work that Jackson family is. First we see the "Reverend's" ego and pettiness on display. Then ... get a load of this denunciation of the Reverend by his own son, a man who owes his political career entirely to his father:
The reverend’s son, Congressman Jesse Jackson Jr., issued this rebuke of his father:
“I’m deeply outraged and disappointed in Reverend Jackson’s reckless statements about Senator Barack Obama. His divisive and demeaning comments about the presumptive Democratic nominee — and I believe the next president of the United States — contradict his inspiring and courageous career.
… “Reverend Jackson is my dad and I’ll always love him. He should know how hard that I’ve worked for the last year and a half as a national co-chair of Barack Obama’s presidential campaign. So, I thoroughly reject and repudiate his ugly rhetoric. He should keep hope alive and any personal attacks and insults to himself.”
You're denouncing your Dad in public, Junior. Wouldn't it have sufficed to give a simple, "No comment. My own strong support for Senator Obama is very well known."??
ossicle
July 10, 2008 10:28 AM
Rod, you deserve a ton of credit for that Jackson reporting you did. I hope it's benefited you at least a substantial fraction as much as it should have.
bd_rucker
July 10, 2008 10:47 AM
The truth is that many in the African American community regard Jackson as a one-time hero who has been seduced by the lights of publicity and reduced to a vainglorious camera chasing buffoon.
Very true. Jesse (as we call him in "the black community") lost a lot of credibility years ago when it came out that he had fathered a child out of wedlock. His shaking down of various corporations behind the charges of "racism" in order to get $$ for himself and his minions haven't helped his reputation either. I don't know anyone who takes him seriously anymore.
On the black boards I frequent, Jesse (and Sharpton) are regularly referred to as hustlers. The common consensus about this latest incident is that Jesse is a "hater." That's black vernacular for "someone who is extremely jealous of another."
Lord Karth
July 10, 2008 11:48 AM
I'll wager $ 1.85 to a basket of roses that this business with Jesse Jackson was staged. Someone in the Obama campaign, if not Obama himself, put Jackson up to this.
It's been years since Jesse Jackson was anything but a political non-entity, so his antics will put him back on the map---that's what Unca Jesse gets out of this, for starters. Obama gets a chance to immunize himself from the fallout over Jeremiah Wright and Compay. Jackson has been around long enough to know when to open his mouth and when not to; I find it virtually impossible to believe that he didn't know EXACTLY what he was doing.
Anyone who has been around any serious political campaign knows that you always assume that any microphone is live and that anything you say outside the most private of settings has already been taken down for use against you.
The only thing I don't know is what ELSE Mr. Jackson got for helping Slick Barry out. But the fact that this was staged is, IMO, undeniable.
Your servant,
Lord Karth
Lord Karth
July 10, 2008 11:50 AM
That last should have read "Jeremiah Wright and COMPANY". My internal spell-checker missed that one. Sorry !
Your servant,
Lord Karth
Karen Brown
July 10, 2008 11:57 AM
Yeah.
It gets him in the 'public eye' for a stupid mistake involving a live mike. He had to go apologize to Obama, and had his own son chide him publically, while just about every commentator either says this puts the nail in his coffin or that he was a nobody in the first place, at this point, so who cares.
Yep, sounds like he's back on the map.
Has anyone gotten a good career boost from a hot mike verbal faux pas?
Kinda conspiracy theory'ish.
Karen Brown
July 10, 2008 12:01 PM
Oh, and yeah. The fact that its a 'rookie mistake' actually hurts, rather than helps him. He could've as easily had it 'leaked', if he was looking for attention, without looking quite so stupid.
Though I will say, some very experienced pols have had hot mike mistakes. Were those all staged too?
Bush has had that happen more than once, for that matter.
Mr. Jackson has been in the public eye for over 30 years and has made two attempts to run for President; for someone who has his political and media experience, an error like that is simply too stupid for serious consideration. I've personally met and spoken with the man; he's nowhere near that stupid.
On the other hand, we've seen how opportunistic Senator Obama is; here's a man who throws his own grandmother to the wolves for political advantage. One opportunist, on his way up, cuts a deal with another, who wants back in the game. What's so hard to believe about that ? It's just another political deal, that's all.
Your servant,
Lord Karth
Karen Brown
July 10, 2008 12:26 PM
So, was it equally stupid when GW Bush did it? (At the time, a two term president, former governor, and been in the public eye one way or another his entire life..)?
Do you think that experience exempts people from making stupid mistakes?
Or that stupid mistakes are the way to success?
In the public eye, sure. For being an idiot and having his own son have to apologize for him. If that's the case, I expect to see Jesse Jackson with his own reality tv show any minute, because he's apparently at the
'anything to keep the cameras running' phase of his life.
Which, in my mind, makes him more a non-entity and less to be taken seriously than if he'd let himself gracefully fade into the past.
Rhonda Johnson
July 13, 2008 8:53 AM
If you really want to know about the REV. Jesse Jackson, check out the latest Judical Watch and his going to court with the Rev. Jesse Lee Peterson. This man craves power and doesn't care who he steps on.
Spurwing Plover
February 25, 2009 4:17 PM
Just last year JESSIE JACKSON and a bunch of his RAINBOW/PUSH touble makers were holding stupid protest calling for more dumb gun control laws and lying down in front of a gun store they only ended up getting themselves arrested like the usial liberal pests they are trying to keep us from exiersercising our 2nd amendment rights which only proves he isnt no real revrend just a public pest
Birdzilla
September 11, 2009 6:03 PM
Back after BUSH was elected he and his RAINBOW/PUSH wackos were planning a big protest until his own skelletons were brought out of his closets and he silenced
Post a Comment
By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.
Rod Dreher is an editorial columnist for the Dallas Morning News, and author of "Crunchy Cons" (Crown Forum), a nonfiction book about conservatives, most of them religious, whose faith and political convictions sometimes put them at odds with mainstream conservatives. The views expressed in this blog are his own.
Subscribe
Sign Up: Receive Crunchy Con in your in-box every day
Obama's Sista Souljah moment! Excellent news!
"Do interview subjects now have to worry about every single thing they say once they enter a studio?"
I think they do, Rod. I'm not defending Fox News either, but haven't we had enough "open mike" incidents on both side of the political spectrum for the average person to realize that anything said in the presence of the media, especially anything that might be recorded, will be considered fair game for airing or publication?
It ain't beanbag. But, you know that, Rod.
Question is, will it break large into the MSM at large, or one day and into the Memory Hole?
I'll predict the latter.
It didn't used to be that way. I think we in the media make it harder for the people we interview to be human beings. They always have to keep their guard up now. You ought to read the comments over on the Dallas News blog -- so many conservatives who would have gone berserk had CNN done this to Rush Limbaugh thrilled that Fox did it to Jesse Jackson. I find it depressing that we live in a political culture in which anything is justified so long as it advances the defeat of the Enemy.
Will this work to Obama's short-term advantage?
Yes, because the Jesse Jackson blooper pushes off the radar Obama's nitwitted comment in Georgia yesterday that ... "You need to make sure that your child can learn to speak Spanish." You can check it out here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BZprtPat1Vk
That comment -- and not the injudicious choice of words by "Reverent" Jackson -- would have led the news tonight. A lucky break for BO.
The substance of Jackson's comment, however, addresses one of BO's more irritating habits: his tendency to lecture Americans. Whether it is lecturing black fathers about their parental responsiblities (Jackson's point) or his ham-handed comment about the need for non-Hispanic parents to get their kids to learn Spanish, BO often comes across like the Headmaster-in-Chief lecturing the great unlettered masses.
his ham-handed comment about the need for non-Hispanic parents to get their kids to learn Spanish
He wasn't saying that at all.
I watched the clip, and Obama's main point is that we should, as a country, encourage kids (and adults too!) to be at least bilingual, whether they learn Spanish, or French, or German, or whatever other language they choose to learn. Not only because it's better for us in the long run, but because it also improves our image abroad by making Americans appear more educated, since they'd know more than just English.
Speaking personally, my first language was Spanish. I didn't learn English until just before I started kindergarten. I still speak both languages fluently today at 35, and I think the advantages of knowing a second language are massive. My Spanish skills helped me all through Europe when I spent a summer there. And because French and Italian are also Romance languages, I was able to translate in my head without relying on a dictionary, and I was able to pick up phrases here and there to better communicate with people I met on my travels.
Knowing more than one language, especially in today's more connected world, is invaluable. We *should* encourage it in kids, and in others.
Well, does this mean that people will have to watch what they say in public. Always! This is the same dumb thing that we all do from time to time. Open mouth and insert foot. The real problem here is that people will still listen to Jackson and call him a great man. He is and always will be someone that brings down the same people that he is trying to elevate. It's sad that the black community will still look up to him and Sharpton for that matter. I will not vote for Barack but, I still think he is a very intelligent man and he is smart to rise above the fools.
Rod,
By the way, I appreciate that you feel queasy about what Fox News did. I agree, of course, that the other networks would have willingly done this to one of their guests -- especially if the guest was a cultural conservative. Nevertheless your qualms speak well of you. You're a good man.
Oops. The 8:13PM comment is mine. I forgot to put in my name. :)
On a more general note, Jesse Jackson just gave Obama a huge gift, and entirely through his own carelessness. For Obama to be able to publicly distance himself from Jesse Jackson? It's his own Sista Souljah moment.
Poor Jesse. White America has such an abiding need to find one African American and anoint him as 'King of the Negroes', the One Who Speaks For Those People. And he was it for so many years, so it must gall him (and Al) to see the crown being so rudely usurped.
"anonyonous" at 8:13 PM quotes me and says: " 'his ham-handed comment about the need for non-Hispanic parents to get their kids to learn Spanish' He wasn't saying that at all. I watched the clip, and Obama's main point is that we should, as a country ..."
Listen, we don't need your analysis of what he said ... or mine. He said what he said: "You need to make sure that your child can learn to speak Spanish."
Listen, we don't need your analysis of what he said ... or mine. He said what he said: "You need to make sure that your child can learn to speak Spanish."
You're taking one sentence out of what he said and drawing the wrong conclusion from it. It wasn't just about Spanish. It was about learning a second language in general, and why we should encourage it in kids.
What is so bad about teaching your kids more than one language? Why is that so wrong? I don't get it.
Interesting that his son felt compelled to say something publicly about his father's statements. Like father, like son? (As in, not knowing when to not say something--I find the comments to be against the virtue of piety.)
What is so bad about teaching your kids more than one language? Why is that so wrong? I don't get it.
Because that really isn't what he meant. People are duly concerned about the fact that Spanish is being used as a primary language by many people in this country. He pretty much only gave lip service to that concern. Notice the tepid clapping when he said people need to learn Spanish. Only then did he switch into the vein of everyone learning a second language in general. No one says there is a problem with learning a second language. All he did was stand up a straw man to knock it down. Then he has to insult his fellow countrymen about how they act overseas.
Additionally, his comment is way off base about Americans traveling overseas. I wish I could find the survey from about six years ago. Basically Americans were one of the top nationalities at trying to speak the native language of the country they were visiting.
LJG,
I had the opportunity to study two languages and to live overseas and use those languages. Good for me ... but I wouldn't inflict my love of languages and foreign cultures on others.
It is monumentally fatuous for a Presidential candidate -- who himself can't speak a foreign language -- to start lecturing parents about the need for their English-speaking kids to learn another tongue.
Moreover, Obama made the comment in the context of the discussion over requiring English competency for immigrants seeking citizenship. He equated the need for the children of immigrants to learn the language of this country with the need for Americans in general to learn a second language. Frankly, this is silly.
The point Jackson made about BO and blacks (that he talks down to them) is true of BO in general towards all Americans. The Headmaster-in-Chief -- the child of two PhDs -- can't overcome his tendency to condescend and lecture all of us like errant pupils.
who himself can't speak a foreign language
Er, not quite. Obama is actually still somewhat proficient at Indonesian, since he lived there as a child.
While it's true he doesn't speak Spanish or French or German, he's not completely monolingual.
The point Jackson made about BO and blacks (that he talks down to them) is true of BO in general towards all Americans. The Headmaster-in-Chief -- the child of two PhDs -- can't overcome his tendency to condescend and lecture all of us like errant pupils.
Bah. Jesse Jackson's point is wrapped up in jealousy over the fact that Obama has done what Jesse could never do-- win the Democratic nomination for president. And because Obama has repeatedly rejected the victimization card that Jackson was so fond of playing for many years.
Getting criticized by Jesse Jackson was a gift from above for Obama. It's the best thing that's happened to him all day, especially since Fox News is going to be running with this story for a while, keeping it alive.
LJG: "Obama is actually still somewhat proficient at Indonesian, since he lived there as a child."
Wow, good for him. I'm sure most voters will be jealous when they learn that BO can speak some Indonesian.
By the way, regarding Fox News, it appears that Bill O'Reilly decided NOT to air the most scatological part of Jackson's comment in his broadcast tonight. Good of him and Fox News ... and bad of all the rest of us for assuming that they would.
What is so bad about teaching your kids more than one language? Why is that so wrong? I don't get it.
Posted by: LJG | July 9, 2008 8:43 PM
Oh, sure, you probably also think American kids need to learn the metric system - you commie!
As a strong opponent of having a Republican in the White House while the Democrats control both houses of Congress, I am rooting for Obama.
But too many more mistakes like this one and McCain might win this thing.
Bye Jesse, You just nailed the lid on your viable political casket!
Jesse Jackson has so much egg on his face, I'm surprised he hasn't turned yellow.
Jesse Jackson is the real racist and is crying because he is jealous of another Africian Americans success. sorry Jesse,but some blacks need to be talked down too..same as whites..again, Jesse thinks this should be all about blacks..whats the matter Jesse?..you and sharptons bank accounts getting low..haven't you scam the black people out of enough of their hard earned money for your selfish agenda.
"Will liberals now go to Fox News studios in the same spirit as US businessmen traveling in Soviet Russia -- assuming that everything they say is being listened to and might be used against them?"
Yes, liberals should go to Fox News in that spirit, and should have done so long before this incident. Fox News may be a great place to get airtime, but they are no friends to anyone liberal.
Also, I concur that this is great for Obama. Jackson basically Souljahed himself. A Souljahcide?
Wow, good for him. I'm sure most voters will be jealous when they learn that BO can speak some Indonesian.
It may not sound like much to American ears, but it's a valuable skill for two reasons-- 1. Indonesia is the fourth largest country in the world, and 2. It's also the most populous Muslim-majority country, though it's not an Islamic state.
Having a president that can speak to and understand people over there would be important in terms of diplomacy and in getting them to help us in our fight against Al Qaeda.
Sure, he may not speak Spanish or French, but what he can speak will be an asset in our foreign policy, IMO.
Also, I concur that this is great for Obama. Jackson basically Souljahed himself.
Yes, it is. Jackson handed him a very precious gift, and my hope is that Obama takes advantage of it.
I agreed with Obama when he said we should learn other languages. I've thought so myself for many years.
What irritated me was he said he was "embarassed for my country."
Screw that. I don't want to vote for someone who's embarassed because I don't speak Spanish, like my guns, and go to church. He essentially looks down his nose at the things I value (like, well, ah, America).
I am an Obama supporter and I AM thrilled to have Jesse caught in this unguarded moment. (Though I share Rod's discomfort over the lack of journalistic ethics involved in its release...but hey, it's Fox. The same network that eagerly ballyhooed reports that Obama had attended a madrasa in Indonesia.)
The truth is that many in the African American community regard Jackson as a one-time hero who has been seduced by the lights of publicity and reduced to a vainglorious camera chasing buffoon.
Tragically the majority of African American men are avoiding their responsibilities as fathers. I have heard African American woman sigh with resigned frustration over the possibility of having a man in their lives who will be anything more than a transient babymaker.
Jackson would have us believe that this is solely because of racism. I know that this is a factor. But, poverty and persecutuon have not led every other culture to the same disastrous dysfunctional results. Obama and Cosby are pointng that out, and this undercuts Jackson's tired rant that every black problem has only white roots.
I suspect that Obama will gain votes thanks to Jesse.
Why shouldn't Fox show the tape? They didn't break the news - Jackson himself apologized and had a press conference about it earlier in the day. It was a news story reported on CNN, etc. - they just didn't have the tape.
Where I come from, there's no such thing as "off the record", as Samantha Power found to her cost. Why does the inside-the-Beltway media feel such need to coddle public figures and allow them to dictate the terms of debate?
Here's the headline:
"Jesse Jackson expresses solidarity with Klan; advocates castration for uppity black boys."
Seriously, how dare Jesse Jackson open his foul, race-baiting, opportunistic, hypocritical mouth? He deserves 0 sympathy and 0 forgiveness.
The b*stard is hoist on his own petard.
John E: Oh, sure, you probably also think American kids need to learn the metric system - you commie!
The metric system is a product of the French Revolution! The Bolshies coopted it when they changed from furlongs and farthings. No, wait, that was the Brits. Well, versts and poods, then. ;-)
Just as an opinión incidental, I have no objection to the acquisition of Castillian competency by the "Anglo" masses. Spanish is a beautiful language in its own right and its literature among the jewels in the crown of Western culture. But the latent agenda here is that the English-speaking majority must cater to the Spanish-speaking minority. That is a canard. I would mandate at least two years of Latin rather than Spanish; the laggards would be spared the vararies of the imperfect subjunctive.
As a lover of languages, I myself would attempt to learn Chinese. But because el tiempo es de suma importancia, I will defer starting my lessons until the Beijing Bolshies relieve their slaves of the onus of analphabeticity.
In the meanwhile, my French-accented Spanish is considered encantador y por supuesto divertido in the local bodegas.
To return to the main topic: interesting language from a so-called "reverend". Perhaps he thinks Mubarak Hussein Obama has a falsetto worth preserving?
1. This is a huge gift to the Obama Campaign. It puts real distance between him and the despised Jackson/Sharpton wing of his party, and doesn't even require Obama to play hardball a la "Sister Souljah." A strong antidote to electoral poison of Jeremiah Wright.
2. What a nasty piece of work that Jackson family is. First we see the "Reverend's" ego and pettiness on display. Then ... get a load of this denunciation of the Reverend by his own son, a man who owes his political career entirely to his father:
The reverend’s son, Congressman Jesse Jackson Jr., issued this rebuke of his father:
“I’m deeply outraged and disappointed in Reverend Jackson’s reckless statements about Senator Barack Obama. His divisive and demeaning comments about the presumptive Democratic nominee — and I believe the next president of the United States — contradict his inspiring and courageous career.
…
“Reverend Jackson is my dad and I’ll always love him. He should know how hard that I’ve worked for the last year and a half as a national co-chair of Barack Obama’s presidential campaign. So, I thoroughly reject and repudiate his ugly rhetoric. He should keep hope alive and any personal attacks and insults to himself.”
You're denouncing your Dad in public, Junior. Wouldn't it have sufficed to give a simple, "No comment. My own strong support for Senator Obama is very well known."??
Rod, you deserve a ton of credit for that Jackson reporting you did. I hope it's benefited you at least a substantial fraction as much as it should have.
The truth is that many in the African American community regard Jackson as a one-time hero who has been seduced by the lights of publicity and reduced to a vainglorious camera chasing buffoon.
Very true. Jesse (as we call him in "the black community") lost a lot of credibility years ago when it came out that he had fathered a child out of wedlock. His shaking down of various corporations behind the charges of "racism" in order to get $$ for himself and his minions haven't helped his reputation either. I don't know anyone who takes him seriously anymore.
On the black boards I frequent, Jesse (and Sharpton) are regularly referred to as hustlers. The common consensus about this latest incident is that Jesse is a "hater." That's black vernacular for "someone who is extremely jealous of another."
I'll wager $ 1.85 to a basket of roses that this business with Jesse Jackson was staged. Someone in the Obama campaign, if not Obama himself, put Jackson up to this.
It's been years since Jesse Jackson was anything but a political non-entity, so his antics will put him back on the map---that's what Unca Jesse gets out of this, for starters. Obama gets a chance to immunize himself from the fallout over Jeremiah Wright and Compay. Jackson has been around long enough to know when to open his mouth and when not to; I find it virtually impossible to believe that he didn't know EXACTLY what he was doing.
Anyone who has been around any serious political campaign knows that you always assume that any microphone is live and that anything you say outside the most private of settings has already been taken down for use against you.
The only thing I don't know is what ELSE Mr. Jackson got for helping Slick Barry out. But the fact that this was staged is, IMO, undeniable.
Your servant,
Lord Karth
That last should have read "Jeremiah Wright and COMPANY". My internal spell-checker missed that one. Sorry !
Your servant,
Lord Karth
Yeah.
It gets him in the 'public eye' for a stupid mistake involving a live mike. He had to go apologize to Obama, and had his own son chide him publically, while just about every commentator either says this puts the nail in his coffin or that he was a nobody in the first place, at this point, so who cares.
Yep, sounds like he's back on the map.
Has anyone gotten a good career boost from a hot mike verbal faux pas?
Kinda conspiracy theory'ish.
Oh, and yeah. The fact that its a 'rookie mistake' actually hurts, rather than helps him. He could've as easily had it 'leaked', if he was looking for attention, without looking quite so stupid.
Though I will say, some very experienced pols have had hot mike mistakes. Were those all staged too?
Bush has had that happen more than once, for that matter.
http://www.usatoday.com/news/world/2006-07-17-bush-hezbollah_x.htm
Karen:
Mr. Jackson has been in the public eye for over 30 years and has made two attempts to run for President; for someone who has his political and media experience, an error like that is simply too stupid for serious consideration. I've personally met and spoken with the man; he's nowhere near that stupid.
On the other hand, we've seen how opportunistic Senator Obama is; here's a man who throws his own grandmother to the wolves for political advantage. One opportunist, on his way up, cuts a deal with another, who wants back in the game. What's so hard to believe about that ? It's just another political deal, that's all.
Your servant,
Lord Karth
So, was it equally stupid when GW Bush did it? (At the time, a two term president, former governor, and been in the public eye one way or another his entire life..)?
Do you think that experience exempts people from making stupid mistakes?
Or that stupid mistakes are the way to success?
In the public eye, sure. For being an idiot and having his own son have to apologize for him. If that's the case, I expect to see Jesse Jackson with his own reality tv show any minute, because he's apparently at the
'anything to keep the cameras running' phase of his life.
Which, in my mind, makes him more a non-entity and less to be taken seriously than if he'd let himself gracefully fade into the past.
If you really want to know about the REV. Jesse Jackson, check out the latest Judical Watch and his going to court with the Rev. Jesse Lee Peterson. This man craves power and doesn't care who he steps on.
Just last year JESSIE JACKSON and a bunch of his RAINBOW/PUSH touble makers were holding stupid protest calling for more dumb gun control laws and lying down in front of a gun store they only ended up getting themselves arrested like the usial liberal pests they are trying to keep us from exiersercising our 2nd amendment rights which only proves he isnt no real revrend just a public pest
Back after BUSH was elected he and his RAINBOW/PUSH wackos were planning a big protest until his own skelletons were brought out of his closets and he silenced
Post a Comment
By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.