Crunchy Con

P.Z. Myers hates Christians exclusively

Monday July 14, 2008

Categories: Christianity (general)

Or so it would seem, per this discovery by Frank Beckwith, who found that Myers criticized the Danish newspapers for publishing the Muhammad cartoons. Here's part of what Myers said at the time:

Muslims represent a poor and oppressed underclass, and those cartoons represent a ruling establishment intentionally taunting them and basically flipping them off. They have cause to be furious!

Ah, simply publishing a cartoon drawing of Muhammad in a non-Muslim country causes Prof. Myers to sympathize with the Islamic fanatics. But it's okay to solicit someone to steal the most precious thing to tens of millions of American Christians -- what they (we) believe to be God in the flesh -- for the sake of publicly desecrating it.

This is no surprise, of course. For men like P.Z. Myers, there is no infamy that Christians don't deserve. I am not the least bit surprised, or offended, when someone doesn't believe in the religious doctrines I hold. Why should I be? Why should anyone be? If Myers wrote a paper saying the doctrine of the Eucharist is the worst kind of nonsense, and people are idiots if they believe it, so what? He's wrong, but it's a fair argument to put, and there's nothing wrong with him making that argument.

But I am honestly shocked that a university professor would engage in an act of such outright bigotry and contempt as what Myers has done here: to deliberately seek to profane what many Christians hold sacred, simply for the sake of offending them. Myers is, of course, perfectly within his legal rights to undertake such a stunt. I don't believe in the concept of "hate crimes," so I would oppose any attempt to use the state to sanction him. Nevertheless, it is impossible to believe that a professor could engage in this sort of disgusting bigotry against Jews, Muslims or any other religious group without strong censure from his institution, and others. If Myers asked people to bring him a Koran or a Torah scroll so he could film himself defiling them, I would be outraged, and would expect other decent people to be as well.

I invite readers who agree with me to contact the University of Minnesota, Morris chancellor and respectfully make your views known to her. Does she find Myers's actions in this matter to reflect the values of U of M-M? What are the values of U of M in this respect? According to the UMM-M mission statement:

UMM attracts and serves a student body, faculty and staff reflective of our multicultural society. The college empowers the campus community to participate fully and thoughtfully in a diverse society, regionally, nationally, and globally.

And a professor asking people to steal a consecrated Host from a Catholic Church so he can videotape himself desecrating it is consonant with that mission how? Please tell us, Chancellor Jacqueline Johnson.

Filed Under: anti-Christian bigotry, P.Z. Myers

Comments

I call BS.

Search for that quote, the only place it exists is where some 'Bill C' once said PZ said those words. (the day after this article appeared)

I read his blog daily. Those statements contradict every other statement on Islam that I've ever read by PZ.

I think Rod is breaking the 9th commandment.

Shame on you.

Aha....

Found the ENTIRE quote... it is so much different when you get the whole thing in context. That is some really dishonest editing there.

I'll let it speak for itself.
http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/2006/02/poxridden_houses.php

No, Professor Myers does not hate Christians exclusively! He desecrated Dark Knight. Batman is my savior and Batmania is my religion. After he tossed a frackin' cracker in the trash with some coffee grounds and banana peel, he ruined the work of other false prophets like Mohammed and Dawkins--that was all well and good with me, but the very next day he trashed *my* god, Bruce Wayne/Batman! Shame on Myers.

Houghton writes: "Those who think of themselves as "brights" will now start behaving in increasingly nakedly aggressive ways in America and the rest of the West. There won't be a need to "spiritualize" at that point, because the snarling rage and violent attacks we'll witness will be quite open for all to see."

But it's not Myers who has promoted violence or criminal activity, it's the Catholics who have been sending him death threats and threats of violence against his children, yet where is your condemnation of that?

A "Fr. J", posting at Pharyngula, made a similar remark to the above, and tried to claim that the recent attempted attack on a Christian radio station on College Station, PA was by an atheist--when in fact the man was a mentally ill Christian off his meds. Similarly, the attack on the Unitarian Universalist church in Tennessee was a Christian who thought the UU's were "too liberal" and because they aren't anti-gay. And the FBI's primary suspect for the 2001 anthrax attacks who just killed himself was a Catholic.

Francis Beckwith: "According to PZ, Catholic outrage is unwarranted, but Muslim outrage is, though the latter hurt their cause because they resort to violence. Muslims are portrayed as victims, albeit irrational and misguided, who harm their cause by overreacting. Catholics are told by PZ to remain completely silent and speak only when spoken to as they sit in the back of the secular bus."

Where has P.Z. Myers criticized Catholics for being outraged, as opposed to criticizing them for issuing death threats, threatening the lives of his children, trying to get him fired from his job, trying to get Webster Cook and his friend expelled from the University of Central Florida, and for saying things that are idiotic, like the Confraternity of Catholic Clergy's laughably absurd statement about the meaning of the First Amendment. You should give that statement a read.

Correction to my last--Jim Adkisson, the UU shooter in Tennessee, appears to have been some sort of conservative anti-Christian as well as anti-gay and anti-liberal. Substitute for him Chad Conrad Castagana, arrested last year for sending fake anthrax and death threats to Rep. Nancy Pelosi, Jon Stewart, David Letterman, Sen. Charles Schumer, and Keith Olbermann.

Read All Comments

Post a Comment

Are you aware of our Rules of Conduct?


(won't be made public)



Ad tag

Advertisement

Search

About Crunchy Con

Rod Dreher is an editorial columnist for the Dallas Morning News, and author of "Crunchy Cons" (Crown Forum), a nonfiction book about conservatives, most of them religious, whose faith and political convictions sometimes put them at odds with mainstream conservatives. The views expressed in this blog are his own.

feed icon Subscribe

RSS Feed

Receive updates from Crunchy Con
Enter your email address below.