A few questions:
Some are asking whether or not it's responsible for Sarah Palin to get involved in public life when she has problems at home to deal with. Funny, they don't seem to ask this question of male politicians or business executives.
Secondly, others (on the left exclusively, at least from what I've seen) are saying, "See, see, this just goes to show something is really wrong inside the Palin family. That matters to us." Sorry, not buying. It may signify that there's something really wrong inside the Palin family. But I've known pretty solid families who have had to deal with teen pregnancy because -- news flash! -- teenagers have minds of their own. I'm thinking of one particular conservative Christian family I know that's a loving, open, prayerful family. One of their daughters rebelled against her folks, and part of her rebellion included promiscuity. She got pregnant. Her family rallied around her. She ended up marrying the father, and they've gone on to have a loving marriage and a happy family.
It doesn't always work out that way, and none of us welcome unwed motherhood. Still, the idea that bad things don't happen to good people is childish. Nobody believes that. Moreover, if you teach your children that stealing is wrong, but your teenage son gets caught shoplifting, that doesn't automatically make you a hypocrite or a bad parent. My parents taught me not to drink and drive, but I did it as a teenager. I failed them and the standards they taught me. My failure was my own, not theirs.
Now, it certainly could be true that the Palins are a screwed-up family, and that Sarah needs to be attending to business. But we don't know that at all, and the willingness of Palin's political enemies to exploit this family crisis for their own ends is just appalling. What we know so far reveals nothing about the character of Sarah Palin, or the childrearing skills of her and her husband. Nothing. Barack Obama is right: people's families should be off limits.
And even if it does, is the left now saying that we have to take into consideration whether or not our political leaders are good mommies and daddies before we judge them fit for higher office? Because if so, very damn few men and women will be left to serve. Winston Churchill was a lousy father.
I ask again: why is it that some liberals saying that Sarah Palin needs to leave public life and take care of business at home? Would they apply the same standard to male politicians whose children get into trouble? If not, why not?

Add to Newsvine
Add to StumbleUpon
Well, gosh, Bonnie, if your sister seems overwhelmed to you, then I have to wonder why the rest of the family isn't pitching in to help out with the father who has dementia. Why is the only answer that comes to mind, "She should quit her job!" Maybe there are some alternatives--like, other family members could take turns, or they could pay for some live-in help for the dad, to take the load off her. I don't understand why you'd say the best husband in the world doesn't mitigate this type of burden. It seems to me that a good husband (and father) can make almost anything a lot easier!
Please forgive me, sigalitis. I don't know what came over me. The discussion has been civil and I blew it with my disrespectful tone... so I asked for this type of response... So, okay, I guess I could be a sport and defend myself, personally. I will simply state that the siblings in our family are spread throughout the country and that we all determined he should not be isolated in his home where his late wife would be conspicuously absent, even with caregivers, and my sister agreed to take him because he adores her kids. She does the best she can. You think her husband has no conflicts? He has aging parents of his own and no siblings. Do you really want to know all this about me? I personally expect to take in my mother-in-law, so cut me some slack. I never said my sister should quit her job. It probably keeps her sane.
What we're talking about here is the person who might very well become the leader of the free world. I like Joe Biden...after he lost his wife, he said you can always get another senator, but not another Dad. People have been telling me all my life that I can have it all, but after living some years, I sincerely believe that is the exception, rather than the rule. Life gets in the way.
I'm sorry, too, Bonnie--I wish I had not put my comment in a way that sounded as if I was accusing you of not doing enough. There is no reason for you to have to defend yourself to me or anyone else. I understand that these circumstances are difficult to handle for everyone, and all families manage their responsibilities as best they can. I should have stated my views in a more general way that wouldn't have made you feel put on the spot.
Honestly, I could not do what Sarah Palin has signed up for, and I don't think I could do what your sister does, either. I have my doubts, personally, about the wisdom of trying to balance so many things. It's just that I don't think Palin should be denied the opportunity to try it simply because I don't feel that I can. What I would really like to see is a society where help was available to those who feel overwhelmed by the amount of care that must be given to children and elderly relatives, while still meeting the demands of making a living. I'm afraid Obama's characterization of the Republican platform here as "You're on your own" is all too apt. Although, as Clare Krishan has pointed out, the Democrats aren't doing such a great job either.
But I still maintain there is an element of fantasy involved, believing that Palin can do all these things.
Well, you could be right about that. Certainly I think the adulation of her as a sort of female Davy Crockett ("kilt her a b'ar when she was only three!") combined with beauty queen, pro-life heroine, foreign policy expert ("Alaska is the closest state to Russia!") and corruption fighter smacks of unrealistic fantasy.
Post a Comment
By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.