Anti-Obama criticism racist bleg
The pretext many defenders of the more extreme racial statements of Limbaugh and others on the right use for racializing their criticism of Obama is that liberals started it. That is (they say), liberals have been calling any and all...
Don't expect too much here. When people are shamed they tend to skulk away, and there's no question that this is a shameful example of racism in America in the 21st century.
Some Republicans are going to say, in this very thread, "We're not all racist! It's just a few on the fringe!" And that *might* be true. If so, then the non-racist Republicans need to deal with the racists in their midst: publicly criticize at every opportunity, kick them off committees and mailing lists, publicly apologize for their behavior.
Until these things happen on a widespread basis, the R party is racist.
Limbaugh predicted in early 2009 if things started to go bad for Obama Democrats would start playing the race card. He has been proven right!!
William R....thank you for demonstrating Rod's point.
It is equally plausible that that ridiculous poster was created by leftist agent provocateur as it is by a unhinged freeper or Angelqueen.
It is equally plausible that that ridiculous poster was created by leftist agent provocateur as it is by a unhinged freeper or Angelqueen.
...or maybe it was done by the Illuminati in order to further a joint plan they have with the Knights Templar. I smell a Truther!
From Representative Clyburn:
"“The governor of Louisiana expressed opposition. Has the highest African-American population in the country. Governor of Mississippi expressed opposition. The governor of Texas, and the governor of South Carolina. These four governor’s represent states that are in the black belt. I was insulted by that,” Clyburn said. “All of this was a slap in the face of African-Americans. It had nothing to do with Governor Sanford.”…
Source Link:
hotair.com/archives/2009/02/19/clyburn-opposing-the-stimulus-is-racist-or-something/
Then there were the stupid whines over the NY Post cartoon:
www.portfolio.com/views/blogs/mixed-media/2009/02/18/ny-post-in-obama-chimp-stimulus-racism-flap/
That took me all of 15 seconds on Google, oh great journalist.
As for the graphic you posted, it shouldn't be used. If it isn't outright racist, it can certainly be construed as such. But why the vapors? You can find this thing on both ends of the spectrum. How many "Me so horny" gags are thrown at Michele Malkin, or tranny comments towards Anne Coulter? Or racist graphics of Condoleeza Rice?
serr8d.blogspot.com/2009/09/witch-doctor-obama-racist-african.html
No, two wrongs don't make a right, but the two wrongs show that the right side isn't somehow uniquely evil.
Racism stinks, and I agree that the image is offensive. I say if something is overtly racist, call it out and condemn it.
Sadly as long as you have human beings, you will have racism. You will probably find racist elements in any movement or party. However, I have far better reasons for denouncing leftist politics than Black Panthers or Jeremiah Wright. Just as I have far better reasons to side with Tea Party folks than to blow them off on account of wingnuts that attach themselves to the movement.
Clearly, the fear of appearing racist is being used by the Left as a tool to suppress criticism. Jesse Jackson and the Democratic party are masters of this. It is their MO. To expect any different behavior regarding President Obama is not realistic.
That took me all of 15 seconds on Google, oh great journalist.
Look, stop being a jackass, or get off this blog. I put this post up because I have other things to do today, and a deadline to meet. I wanted to ask others to look for them. Thank you for doing so. Now get it together, or get out of here.
That is one disgusting image, but I am curious about its provenance. It looks too much like a stereotypical angry white male's worst nightmare to seem authentic to me.
Both ideological wings of the Uniparty practice disinformation, although its often disguised as "spin" or even "news."
Rod, I think the most interesting part of all this for me is that after 9/11 Bush had what - a 90% approval rating. Which means that vast numbers of liberals lined up with Bush and Republicans in solidarity. I just can't imagine conservatives/Republicans doing the same thing with Obama under any circumstance.
A quick internet search:
1. Sherri Goforth, administrative assistant to state Sen. Diane Black, R-Gallatin admitted she sent the e-mail May 28 with the title "Historical Keepsake Photo." (a collage containing portraits of the previous 43 U.S. presidents and President Obama as two cartoonish white eyes peering from a black background.) Sen. Diane Black leads the Tennessee Senate Republican Caucus.
2. the Chaffey Community Republican Women, Federated sent the October newsletter declaring that if Obama is elected his image will appear on food stamps -- instead of dollar bills like other presidents. The statement is followed by an illustration of "Obama Bucks," featuring Obama's face on a donkey's body surrounded by a watermelon, ribs and a bucket of fried chicken.
3. Dean Grose, the Republican mayor of Los Alamitos CA, sent an email to Local businesswoman and city volunteer Keyanus Price (who is black), depicting the White House lawn planted with watermelons, under the title "No Easter egg hunt this year."
4. Florida's state committeewoman, Carol Carter, sent an email to email to her Republican colleagues around Tampa Bay asking this question about the inauguration, "How can 2,000,000 blacks get into Washington, DC in 1 day in sub zero temps when 200,000 couldn’t get out of New Orleans in 85 degree temps with four days notice?"
5. Danny Funderburk, the former Republican mayor of Fort Mill SC, passed a chain email suggesting the Book of Revelations points to President Obama as the anti-Christ.
6. David Storck, head of the Hillsborough FL GOP, sent an email from a Republican Party volunteer about Obama voters in the upcoming 2008 elections, "This is their chance to get a black president and they seem to care little the he is at minimum a socialist and probably Marxist in his core beliefs. After all he is black- no experience or accomplishments but he is black."
Chris and Joel,
Maybe you can explain why I like President Obama more than I like Pete Stark, or Noam Chomsky, or Bill Ayers, or Andrew Bacevich. And why I like Clarence Thomas a lot more than I like John Paul Stevens. And why I like Condi Rice more than I like Madeleine Albright. And Thomas Sowell more than Bob Herbert. (Do I need to keep going?)
If this proves too difficult, I'll provide a hint . . . It's the same reason I prefer Clint Eastwood to Harry Belafonte.
Rod, I was going to post the very same comment re: fears that people on the liberal side of the spectrum would start screaming racist at any Obama opposition. I absolutely agree that it has not happened. (The fact that it hasn't happened may, in large part be due to the efforts of the Obama Administration.)
My brother, who supported Bush twice, agreed with me that "coded" racism is behind much of the opposition to Obama. As I said below, I abhor the racist demagoguery of a Jeremiah Wright, and I equally abhor that of Rush Limbaugh, Glenn Beck, or any of these other demagogues.
I also wonder if all this hysteria on the right is being ginned up in an attempt to push "No-drama Obama" off his game? It may have a strategic purpose, but it is nonetheless dangerous.
Rod says: "Maureen Dowd wrote her column last week calling some of the Tea Partiers racist, and now Jimmy Carter has said he sees racism behind the protests."
Rod,
This isn't true. Well, maybe it is but I don't know about it.
Dowd and Carter said that Rep. Joe Wilson was a racist when he said to the President "You lie!". And it's not new. The New York Post printed a political cartoon where cops shoot a mad chimpanzee that represented Obama's policies. The Post was accused of ACTUALLY publishing a cartoon equating Obama with a monkey (the cartoon was referencing a crazed chimp that had recently ripped a woman's face off).
Before that in the South Carolina primary, Bill Clinton was accused fo racism for saying Obama wasn't ready to be president. This has been the standard M.O. whenever Obama needs help.
You simply don't seem to know what you are talking about.
(BTW "Obama's America" was a reference to the "Robert Bork's America", "Reagan's America", and "George W. Bush's America" declarations over the last 20 years. The reference is linked to the promises of post-racism by Obama's supporters. I'm pretty sure Lieberman never implied that if he were elected senator, then anti-semitism would end.)
I am going to actually respond to Rod's bleg. This is what I found in short order. This is not meant to be definitive or exhaustive. Also, many of the following links are right-wingers wining about the "all criticism of Obama is racist" notion. But within those complaints one can find some evidence for their complaint.
http://hotair.com/archives/2009/09/08/olby-pretty-much-all-criticism-of-obama-is-racism/
http://www.cato-at-liberty.org/2009/08/07/the-boys-who-cried-racist/
http://sayanythingblog.com/entry/any_criticism_of_obama_is_racist/
http://tpmdc.talkingpointsmemo.com/2009/07/obama-haters-becoming-increasingly-racial-in-their-rhetoric.php
http://blogs.abcnews.com/johnstossel/2009/08/every-critic-a-racist.html
http://newsbusters.org/blogs/noel-sheppard/2009/04/16/garofalo-tea-partiers-are-all-racists-who-hate-black-president
http://article.nationalreview.com/?q=OTRmYmJlMzc4ODc0ODk1ZGY0YWViNWE1NjFlZmNjNzc
Horst,
I've been pleased with a number of President Obama's decisions in the national security arena. Notwithstanding that little fig leaf saying we're going to close it within a year, Gitmo remains open for business. We continue to prosecute the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, and renditions remain in the playbook. Most recently, our C-in-C explicitly ordered Special Forces into Somalia to whack Saleh Ali Saleh Nabhan. Well done, Mr. President!
Alicia
Rod, I was going to post the very same comment re: fears that people on the liberal side of the spectrum would start screaming racist at any Obama opposition. I absolutely agree that it has not happened. (The fact that it hasn't happened may, in large part be due to the efforts of the Obama Administration.)
I would argue that it hasn't happened even to the extent it should happen, in that clearly racist attacks are being ignored by Obama.
But I'm fairly certain he's doing that on purpose, the same reason he's ignore the birthers and all sorts of stuff...it's making his opponents look like loons and idiots. And, oh man, the election in 2010. There are going to be some interesting clips played of Republican congressmen.
I just wish he'd repeat the hilarious 'attack on Republicans via Rush Limbaugh' gag he did earlier. Possible via the Nazi stuff Rush keep talking about.
My brother, who supported Bush twice, agreed with me that "coded" racism is behind much of the opposition to Obama. As I said below, I abhor the racist demagoguery of a Jeremiah Wright, and I equally abhor that of Rush Limbaugh, Glenn Beck, or any of these other demagogues.
I personally am starting to find 'real Americans' a rather suspicious term. I find it offensive regardless of any racial connotation, but I can't help but wonder if that's the new codeword for 'white'.
It is fascinating to see conservatives attempt to spin the response to the NYPost chimpanzee cartoon as "liberals playing the race card." That cartoon was not one iota less obviously racist than the White House watermelon cartoon or the witch-doctor photo shown at the top of this post. It's odd to see people concede that one might be racist but not the other. Did they just flip a coin?
"No, no, there's nothing racist about watermelons on the White House lawn--see, it's a joke about Obama being too close to the green movement and his wife having to actually help around the house for a change! Yeah, that's it...."
I agree, DavidTC. Ignoring the "loons" as, for the most part, Obama has done seems in the short run to make them even loonier.
As I've said before, I'm not sure that many of the initiatives Obama is supporting will work. I want to have a constructive discussion about what will work and what will not. But, the more these Republican leaders and their King-maker Limbaugh keep inciting these "loons" the less I want to have anything to do with the Republican Party. Some day, the party of adults may return. Until then, I'm a proud, if occasionally critical, supporter of President Obama.
Witch-doctors have more to do with primitive healthcare methods than well-established stereotypes like watermelon cliches. If Obama didn't personally draft the stimulus package, then how could the dead chimpanze cartoon depict him (or did another African American congressman draft it?) This isn't rocket science, triple T.
And that's not all...
7. Chip Saltsman, candidate for RNC Chair, sent a Christmas CD to GOP committee-members featuring the song, "Barack the Magic Negro"
8. Adam LaDuca, former executive director of the Pennsylvania Federation of College Republicans, resigned after writing on his Facebook page that Obama has "a pair of lips so large he could float half of Cuba to the shores of Miamii (and probably would.)"
9. Rusty DePass, a former Republican county chairman in SC, sent this tweet in response to a report that a gorilla escaped a local zoo; "I’M SURE IT’S JUST ONE OF MICHELLE’S ANCESTORS—PROBABLY HARMLESS."
10. At a TX Republican state convention, a booth hosted by Republicanmarket was sold a pin that said, "If Obama is President will we still call it the White House."
11. Curis Coleman, businessman and GOP Senate candidate, told the Arkansas Times that, "You go from here to southeast Arkansas, and you might as well get a visa and shots because I'm telling you the world changes." - a region with a sizable African-American population. He then tried to explain he wasn't being derogatory, but that he was trying to "accentuate or maybe even celebrate the enormous diversity we have in Arkansas."
12. Bobby May, McCain campaign chair in Buchanan County VA as well as treasurer and former correspondence secretary of the Buchanan County GOP, wrote an article in the local paper saying that Obama, if elected, would have "Mandatory Black Liberation Theology classes taught in all churches - raise taxes to pay for this mandate. Put Rev. Jeremiah Wright in charge" and "Hire rapper Ludacris to 'paint [The White House] black.'"
...the point is, how much evidence do you need before you honestly consider racism as a motivating factor in the Republican Party?
Yes, dismissing critics of the president as racists is wrong. Just as it was wrong when supporters of the previous president so often dismissed his critics as unpatriotic.
No few people I know who dislike or hate Obama and being rudely vocal (including those piously posing are Patriot Libertarians...the crowd Rod addressed in his Sunday column) are completely unaware how, to any extent, the sub-text is increasingly becoming racial. One told me: 'I would have approved Colin Powell or even Condie Rice'. They did not see that as being revealing....how that black man or woman might have been okay but not this one? You either get that or it’s right over your head………..
Moving on……….I am sure this is a losing discussion destined to become an argument but one that needs to be made.
Many of the people I know currently BEING racist are not actually 'racists' but rather, people whose worst unresolved deep-rooted demons had no prior hatch from which to escape. They had no prior echo chamber for their words to reverberate and boomerang. With President Obama's election, they do.
It's like the person the other day who told me they felt 'safer' in their neighborhood than mine when I mentioned a darling house for sale CHEAP! She felt ‘safer’ where she is despite her area having several times the violent crime rate of mine. The difference? Her area is predominantly white upwardly mobile with some Hispanic segments. Mine is heavily Hispanic and about 20-30% black and 20? white. Yet her immediate area has 1) rapist on the prowl 2) a cop murdered in our friend’s street 3) shootings in their ‘upscale’ strip center 4) car breakins so many that my friend does not lock her car anymore. Theft. Assault.
Meanwhile I was able for 7 weeks to have the workmen leave their three $300 dollar ladders propped up against my home during reconstruction….25 ft. from the street…., and their tools in the front yard, and the material stacked at curbside....weeks. Nothing taken. Whereas nothing would have NOT been taken in her 'good' area. That is predominantly white. Whereas whites constitute maybe 30% of my area. That has a low crime rate. Where my friend who voted for Obama and is surrounded by crime would not move because she would not feel safe? Connecting the dots? Bingo.
In other words, they have no idea that they are being racist, nor any interest in hearing it. It is subliminal racism, not intentional or overt as in days of old. The New Age racism. Take a bow…………….
I can't help but wonder if that's the new codeword for 'white'.
I think that the charge resonates more when deployed against African-Americans, but that I don't think it's used exclusively for African-Americans. I'm pretty sure it was used against Clinton in connection with his (admittedly sketchy) anti-Vietnam War position. I think that the Right sees itself, still, as in opposition to the various Sixties movements that were often explicitly critical of the US. So "real Americans" are Americans who fall into that class of people who wouldn't have criticized the US in the Sixties and would have been offended by those who did. African-Americans were obviously quite critical--for pretty good reasons--so the charge resonates more. Of course, we're more than forty years past 1968.
No few people I know who dislike or hate Obama are completely unaware how, to any extent, the sub-text is increasingly becoming racial. One told me: 'I would have approved Colin Powell or even Condie Rice'. They did not see that as being revealing....how that black man or woman might have been okay but not this one? You either get that or it’s right over your head………..
Moving on……….I am sure this is a losing discussion destined to become an argument but one that needs to be made.
Many of the people I know currently BEING racist are not actually 'racists' but rather, people whose worst unresolved deep-rooted demons had no prior hatch from which to escape. They had no prior echo chamber for their words to reverberate and boomerang. With President Obama's election, they do.
It's like the person the other day who told me they felt 'safer' in their neighborhood than mine when I mentioned a darling house for sale CHEAP! She felt ‘safer’ where she is despite her area having several times the violent crime rate of mine. The difference? Her area is predominantly white upwardly mobile with some Hispanic segments. Mine is heavily Hispanic and about 20-30% black and 20? white. Yet her immediate area has 1) rapist on the prowl 2) a cop murdered in our friend’s street 3) shootings in their ‘upscale’ strip center 4) car breakins so many that my friend does not lock her car anymore. Theft. Assault.
Meanwhile I was able for 7 weeks to have the workmen leave their three $300 dollar ladders propped up against my home during reconstruction….25 ft. from the street…., and their tools in the front yard, and the material stacked at curbside....weeks. Nothing taken. Whereas nothing would have NOT been taken in her 'good' area. That is predominantly white. Whereas whites constitute maybe 30% of my area. That has a low crime rate. Where my friend who voted for Obama and is surrounded by crime would not move because she would not feel safe? Connecting the dots? Bingo.
In other words, they have no idea that they are being racist, nor any interest in hearing it. It is subliminal racism, not intentional or overt as in days of old. The New Age racism. Take a bow…………….
What is happening is very simple. The word "racist" has lost its power to scare. No one really cares any more.
"how do you explain this image making the rounds on the right?"
Easy one, Rod. It's because, bloggers "on the right" (um, like YOU) post them, and keep them in circulation.
Please, do us all a favor and look in the mirror every once in a while.
What is happening is very simple. The word "racist" has lost its power to scare. No one really cares any more.
I'm not sure it has had much power to scare for nearly thirty years. The language being used now with regard to Obama is a step back, but things were worse in the Eighties, I think.
Even if us liberals did "start it," does that make it right for the conservatives to take up the loudmouth torch? No. Ever hear of "two wrongs don't make a right?" Or "Do not repay evil with evil?" I don't get it, man.
I've been paying some attention to the tea party type protests, even attended one, and I haven't seen anything that is overtly racist about them. Around here they seem to be harping on about a lot of the hard-core libertarian they've been on about for years.
This liberal hasn't called the opposition racist because what I've seen doesn't appear racist.
That said, the incoherence and lack of positive message combined with extreme passion suggests there's quite a bit of hate in many of them. I tend to think its not so much hate towards a black president as hate towards their unhinged, demonized notion of "liberals."
Once again, Rod, you show rare and admirable intellectual honesty.
Rod: "If racism isn't behind at least some of the hostility to Obama, how do you explain this image making the rounds on the right?"
Rod, shame on you for playing in the muck with this. You speak of this truly offensive "image making the rounds" but I have not seen it anywhere else.
You put something as racially offensive as this image on your blog which you found God only knows where ... and then you blame conservatives for being racist.
If this is a stunt to drive up blog traffic, then it has succeeded, judging by my stupidity in allowing myself to be outraged if not puzzled at your lack of discernment.
Oh come on, Rod. I think the picture is appalling. But if a conservative painted a word picture calling Obamacare "voodoo" health care I can't see that it would be. Remember when Reagan was accused of "voodoo" economics?
As for the administration playing the race card, are you serious? Obama raised it again and again during the campaign saying "they" were trying to scare people because he "looked different" and "had a funny name." Accusing his opponents of racism has been a staple from the very beginning.
I'm sure someone will accuse me of being racist for this post, so let me put you straight. My husband and I were foster parents for a time and had a precious little black kindergartener who lived with us for about four months. He's now an adult and we were so racist that he called us recently to say hello.
Dig deeper dude. The "conservative" movement has always had a major racist component.
Regardless of Goldwater's personal beliefs, (and I was there) his followers were all white and most hated their unwhite neighbors and especially their unwhite coworkers.
Other examples are easy to find.
Well, Limbaugh seemed to be greatly offended by this Newsweek story -- http://www.newsweek.com/id/214989 -- headlined "Is Your Baby Racist."
Having read the first page of it, at least, it appears his umbrage has no relation to the story.
Dig deeper dude. The "conservative" movement has always had a major racist component.
Regardless of Goldwater's personal beliefs, (and I was there) his followers were all white and most hated their unwhite neighbors and especially their unwhite coworkers.
Other examples are easy to find.
Hey Rod, I'm a conservative leaning libertarian (or maybe vice-versa). I keep up with the news, keep up with many of the blogs. This post is the first time I've seen the Obama-as-witch-doctor photo, though I had heard of it.
Do I get to call you a racist now for posting it? Seems to me you'd adding fuel to the fire. (Racist!!)
Also, how dare you suggest that African cultural conceptions of the world and spirituality are somehow less sophisticated than non-African ones. (Racist!!! How dare you!!)
Remember, you believe that a particular man was both human and divine (despite the contradictions involved in), you believe this person rose from the dead and performed other sundry miracles (despite the utter lack of evidence, besides question-begging assertions). You believe in a colorful cosmology that includes angels, demons, arch-angels, hellfire, the efficacy of petitionary rites/ritual, etc.
Yet you somehow think this is any more plausible than the content of the witch-doctors’ equally non-evidence based claims? The nerve! (Racist!! Imperialist!!)
The only difference between an African witch-doctor and a priest is the style of dress and particulars of wishful thinking. (Which might help explain why it’s been so easy for so many recent would-be witch-doctors to change uniforms, re-jigger their wishful thinking, and becomes priests. In record numbers.)
I’m tired of your racism Rod.
Wow - a really long read here. Honestly. Don't know why I bother anymore. I sure as sh-t aint voting for Pelosi and gang. But this party - My Party - and that of my father and mother and grandfather - is descending into madness. 1950's, hysterical, races mixing, n-hating madness. When so many of us can no longer see the difference between policy disagreements and racial prejudice. Its time to leave the GOP, for ..?.... I know, don't let the door hit me on the way out.
Rod, Paul Krugman and Maureen Dowd have written articles critical of President Obama and the administration. One must examine the spirit in which criticism is given, whether it is helpful or harmful, and context. For example, Bob Inglis and Joe Wilson are both Republicans of the South Carolina House Delegation. But Bob Inglis has carried himself in a far more respectful and manner than his colleague, Mr. Wilson. Further, Mr. Wilson also accused Strom Thurmond's Black daugher of 'smears'. Though it had been proven that she was Mr. Thurmond's child.
Both Congressmen are conservative but only one carries himself in a respectful and yes...non-racist manner.
Mary Ann, Reagan was accused of practicing Voodoo economics by George H.W. Bush. This was during the primaries, not the general election.
You just gained yourself a reader. I bookmarked your page to read again. Even as a lifelong liberal Democrat, I respect true conservatives and anyone willing to buck their party's conventional thinking (what can I say, it is oppositional defiance disorder).
Your piece on Limbaugh and follow up with the Lieberman America bit was really brilliant. It is apparent to me that your's is an important voice.
Kudos.
Paagle: "That said, the incoherence and lack of positive message combined with extreme passion suggests there's quite a bit of hate in many of them."
Thanks for your thoughtful and honest comment. I agree with most of it, except the passage I quoted above. I don't think hate is the right word, judging by the motivations of those of my friends who have attended these tea party meetings. Probably "disgust" towards the system and towards the the hypocrisy of so many in the political class is what drives the "tea party" people I know.
Whatever anger they have towards Obama, it is about his duplicity on many issues, including the way he and Rahm/Pelosi/Reid used the understandable economic anxiety to jam through the $1 trillion "stimulus" bill through Congress. The bill had very little to do with near-term economic stimulus and was just a whole lot of useless pork that will be born on the back of their grandkids. And that's just one example of how Obama has demonstrated the objective truth of S.C. Congressman Joe Wilson's retort of last week.
Rod,
I am an African who has lived here ( Dallas) for over a decade. We Africans are always divided along tribal lines & we occassional fight each other but never have I seen this kind of vernom directed against an individual, leave along a sitting President. I am truly lost for words. I am however heartened by writers like you calling out brain-dead hatemongers like Limbaugh. Thank you for standing up for our Country!
Thanks to Jon S. at 2:14 pm for taking a stab (which you noted was cursory and not exhaustive) at Rod's actual request; however, so far it's pretty weak tea. Two of the links refer to Jeanine Garofolo who is not a prominent commentator; two refer exclusively to the Gates incident, and one is from March 2008 re: Jeremiah Wright.
I agree with the link criticizing Paul Krugman for calling the "Obama as Joker and Socialist" poster racist. The poster was too ideologically incoherent to be anything more than stupid.
And thanks, Rod, for posting the "witch doctor" photo, thereby shutting down the loonies from the last two threads. A picture is, indeed, worth a thousand words.
I'm a liberal and I support Rod for speaking out like this. We may disagree on political or ideological grounds, but I want to tell all of you conservatives who have grown disillusioned or disgusted with what's going on with the right, like Dan in SC, that I understand and agree with your pain. At a certain point, political differences become either simple differences of thought and belief, or blinding dogmas that can bring out the worst in our fellow human beings. If we don't give in to fear and fearmongering now, we may turn this negative into a positive in the long run.
I too found your blog through a link and am so glad I did. You give me hope for our political future. Your blog is now getting great mentions across the web in large part for your willingness to stand up against wrong. Keep up the good work.
Mr. Dreher:
I followed the link posted by a "fringe nut at Daily Kos" to this wonderfully written, thoughtful piece by you . I also note that Steve Benen at Washington Monthly linked to it. I must warn you that I am a progressive Democrat, but I hope that I can still have your ear. I commend you for having the courage to speak your mind and conscience. I lament the fact that so few conservatives have spoken up about the dangerous trend that Beck and Limbaugh are setting. I'm sure that you and I would disagree about many things were we to talk across a dinner table, but what a delightful and thought-provoking exchange that would be. It's a pleasure, sir, to read your work.
Limbaugh didn't say anything racially extreme. Rod is smearing the man. He has been reduced to David Frum Andrew Sullivan status I hate to say!
Reaganite from NYC said: "Probably "disgust" towards the system and towards the the hypocrisy of so many in the political class is what drives the "tea party" people I know."
While I certainly don't know the minds and motivations of those you purport to know, I would ask you this: Where were you when Bush cut taxes the very wealthiest Americans? Where were you when the Bush administration led us the fiscal and moral morass we all know as Iraq?
Rod is right on target, when in an earlier post, he points out that it was those policy decisions made by the Bush administration that created this "economic anxiety" as you call it (really a near Great Depression as it is commonly understood).
Reaganite from NYC also said: "The bill had very little to do with near-term economic stimulus and was just a whole lot of useless pork that will be born on the back of their grandkids."
You know, I think that Jindal, Cantor, and McConnell may have missed that message. On account of them handing out rather large checks (directly provided by the stimulus package).
And finally, Reaganite from NYC said, in response to DMS: "Well, of course, DMS, you find Rod to your liking. He peddles the racist filth like the photo he posted here and passes it off as typically conservative and then shakes his head and clucks his tongue and wags his finger at those bad, naughty conservatives"
Seriousely?! And how do you reconcile that with the latest from Limbaugh, Lou Dobbs, Pat Buchannon, Bachmann?
Your Name @ 3:28 PM
This story broke in late July and the photo has been circulating since then. It's been on Free Repbulic, Little Green Footballs, Conservative Underground, StormFront, many newspaper and news sites, and of course left/liberal sites like dailykos and huffington post.
Do a Google search for "Obama witch doctor" and then select the images tab* That's just for starters...
---------
http://images.google.com/images?hl=en&safe=off&client=firefox-a&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&q=obama%20witch%20doctor&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&tab=wi
Progressive Black Democrat from Texas signing in to thank you for speaking truth to power. I found a link to your blog over on DailyKos and want you to know that no matter our ideological differences, we must all stand for decency and civility, or we're doomed. If your conservative counterparts can't handle the truth, it should tell you something about their true motivations. Keep up the good work!
Maybe you can explain why I like...
I honestly have no idea what you're driving at, Scurvy. Sorry.
Your Name (3:55 PM): "I followed the link posted by a 'fringe nut at Daily Kos' to this wonderfully written, thoughtful piece by you."
Congratulations, Rod!! You've become a useful tool for "fringe nut at Daily Kos." Are you happy now? I would advise you to get an agent and stand by the phone to await that call any minute now from the booker at the Rachel Maddow Show.
Bravo from another liberal. The left simply has not been shouting charges of racism when President Obama has been criticized. Carter isn't saying anything new here...this country has a long history of racism and it's inevitable that those feelings are playing a part in the extraordinary anger against this president.
People of Limbaugh's age don't even understand what it means to be called a racist. They're living in another era and this is demonstrated by their constant calls of "reverse racism" now that whites are becoming or on the verge of becoming a minority in some part of the country.
The Republicans have, for too long, depended upon a separate, advocate run media, with folks like Limbaugh a large part of that. This media, free from the pressures of competition, have allowed Republican thinking, and the policy and political tactics that proceed from them, to degenerate into something that does not stay healthy outside the hothouse of the Right-Wing Media.
The Republicans need to redevelop a positive relationship with the rest of the country. They need to quit idolizing themselves as a heroic minority, and realize that their difficult place in today's politics owes itself to their having made themselves the antagonists on so many issues, pitting themselves against majority public opinion.
The Republicans need to realize that they have to earn the Public's trust. They can't simply excoriate and smear their way back into the good graces of the American people. At best they will set themselves up to remind the rest of Americans why they kicked them out in the first place.
(I forgot my handle before, I'm "Your name" from 3:28
Okay. So what I want to know is, why is it racist to portray Obama as a witch doctor? The answer must involve the assumption that witch-docory is inherently "lesser than" other forms of spirituality/religiosity. That it's more primitive.
So...what I want to get across is that that very assumption can be viewed as "racist".
I.e., how dare you all judge witch-doctory? I'm dead serious. How do you know it's false, and how dare you presume that your culture is "superior" to the witch-doctors? It is only through the lens of your own superiority that you see racism. And that itself is racist.
(Ah...the perils of the logical inconsistency of multiculralism.)
Reaganite in NYC,
Here is one for you, from one of the original supply-siders:
The GOP's Misplaced Rage
Leading conservative economist Bruce Bartlett writes that the Obama-hating town-hall mobs have it wrong—the person they should be angry with left the White House seven months ago.
"Where is the evidence that everything would be better if Republicans were in charge? Does anyone believe the economy would be growing faster or that unemployment would be lower today if John McCain had won the election? I know of no economist who holds that view. The economy is like an ocean liner that turns only very slowly. The gross domestic product and the level of employment would be pretty much the same today under any conceivable set of policies enacted since Barack Obama’s inauguration.
Until conservatives once again hold Republicans to the same standard they hold Democrats, they will have no credibility and deserve no respect."
http://tinyurl.com/qobp7w
Allow another liberal to say "Well said." I am encouraged that someone would take the stand that not every criticism is motivated racism, but where it is motivated by racism - or reveals the speaker's racist beliefs, it must be challenged by ALL good people.
Of course the left has been screaming racism for years. It is their bread and butter.
Rod,
I appreciate what you're trying to do and have much respect for it.
I incline a bit more to the left than you do, I suppose, but can recognize a careful thinker when I see one. Times are tough for that sort, though, and I commend you all the more so.
Frankly, I've mostly been reading liberal blogs because, in part, they seem much less incendiary. I will stop by your site again, though. I'm interested in your attempt to attack political correctness with fairness and honesty.
A-Bax's argument is so self-servingly strained and circular that you can't help but watch as it circles around behind him ready to sink its dull fangs into A-Bax's own behind. And, yes I think there's unconscious racism lurking underneath his silly display of handwringing. Methinks he definitely dost protest way too much to be taken seriously as anything but a racism apologist.
That being said, I believe it's the economy's collapse that's to blame for most of the anti-Obaman vitriol and blood-libel-hyperbole, but riding "shotgun" with those lies and slander is the kernel within the nut, namely the racism that dares not speak its name, the upstanding libertarian's sterling ideological impulse that unfortunately couldn't help over the years but absorb and internalize the white racism lurking within society, historically and currently, and blame the victim as have the overt racists been doing all along. And then there's the hot mouth-fart air of Limbought's hate speech providing incitement to murder beneath the wings of the anti-Obama tirade.
Funny how Limbaugh has been edging closer and closer and now has finally arrived at his own Radio Rwanda status. I'm sure he'd never think of himself in the same business and genocide-urging Africans, but it just goes to show: We're all the same under the skin.
R Hampton at 4:02 addressed this upthread. Here's a link to a TPM article on the picture: http://preview.tinyurl.com/nwkr7o
@William R. Maybe its time you reconsider the Southern Strategy and its intended outcome (as per the words of Nixon's own strategist). The Left has been "screaming" racism (others would call it acknowledging or pointing out) for years because the Right has been peddling in racism for years to rile up its base and contributions.
http://www.nytimes.com/packages/html/books/phillips-southern.pdf
Ironically, when the RNC 'fessed up to this ( http://www.usatoday.com/news/washington/2005-07-14-GOP-racial-politics_x.htm ), it was Limbaugh who took them to task for even acknowledging that ( http://mediamatters.org/mmtv/200507140004 ).
I've been in search of some sanity and balance on the Right, and I think I just found it. Thanks for staying true to your convictions and writing about them, Mr. Dreher. I just added your blog to the gaggle of RSS feeds I read daily.
And yes, there are spots here and there where I find conservatives speaking calmly and articulately, speaking truth with minimal omission and exaggeration. I would, and I'm sure you would, wish that those spots were instead a vast flood, the norm rather than the exception. I guess it makes me cherish them all the more when I find them.
I found your comment "I don't read nearly as widely on the left as on the right" to be poignant and heartbreakingly familiar. I have tried to read right-wing sources, to watch Fox news, to listen to talk radio, but I find I really can't stomach it, at least not very much of it. I assume the same is true for you and the left. I don't know why that should be, because I suspect that you and I are really not all that different in our core values.
This polarization has become a cancer on our country, and I don't think we'll begin to heal until more of us get down off our high horses and admit that above all we are Americans first, and only incidentally are we red/blue/prog/con/etc./etc. I see that you've gotten an outpouring of liberal praise for this thread (which I found linked from Daily Kos), and I believe that's because you were man enough to take the first step off the path of rabid partisanship. I commend you, and I commit myself to following your example, and trying to steer future conversations toward common ground even if others are screaming at me to veer sharply in one direction or the other. I'll try to step up and take it on the chin *first*, like you did, and see if that helps.
I think it is the msm who are ramping up the "racism" thing and they've been at it a while. Most egregious example: Contessa Brewer trying to make it look like a black man at some rally carrying a gun was actually a threat of white racism: http://independentelephant.blogspot.com/2009/08/msnbc-oppose-obama-racism.html
Summertime Tea Partiers: "Racism, straight up" http://newsbusters.org/blogs/noel-sheppard/2009/04/16/garofalo-tea-partiers-are-all-racists-who-hate-black-president
If you don't find the Obama/Joker poster racist, you're racist: http://hotair.com/archives/2009/08/14/la-weekly-if-you-object-to-calling-the-obama-joker-poster-racist-youre-probably-racist/
Interesting take from a black journalist: http://news-political.com/2009/06/10/the-politics-of-blackness-obama%E2%80%99s-takeover-of-auto-industry/
Chris Matthews: http://hotair.com/archives/2009/08/06/chris-matthews-to-kathleen-parker-is-sarah-palin-the-poster-girl-for-racism/ Is Saray Palin the Poster Girl for Racism?
Huffpo: opposing Obama's speech to school, racist http://www.huffingtonpost.com/mario-almonte/republican-critics-of-oba_b_279533.html
Frank Rich in August: Racists. http://www.nytimes.com/2009/08/02/opinion/02rich.html?_r=1
Opposing healthcare: racist http://www.rhrealitycheck.org/blog/2009/08/10/antihealth-care-reform-racism-not-just-wrong-but-stupid
It just takes a few minutes on google. And yes, it seems to be the press and the pundits who are creating this narrative. I wonder if President Obama will tell them to stop. I think he should.
And....there it is! I've been accused of racism!! (For defending African tribal practices no less!) Really didn't take very long. You guys been training?
What's circular is multiculturalism and the left's reflexive cry of "racism" any time a black person is criticized.
It’s the tale of the Boy Who Cried Racist. No one listens to the left anymore, even when there really is racism, since y’all have played that card so often.
Remember, less is more.
PS – Carter is doint his part to link himself to Obama’s presidency. Sweet.
Hampton and others, thank you for collecting these appalling examples. I'm dismayed. What possesses people?
I do not think the liberal media were discussing the racist issue until after Glen Beck called Obama a racist with a deep-seated hate of white people. It has been incorrectly reported that Jimmy Carter said Joe Wilson's "You Lie" was racist. Maureen Dowd is considered by most to part of the "fringe." I do not think her comments were helpful because it is pure conjecture. As Rod said, the right is now using Carter and Dowd to justify blaming every criticism of Obama on racism.
Press Secretary Robert Gibbs had been rejecting the racism charges. Gibbs provided examples of the right's attacks on the Clinton health care plan to say it was not racism.
Tea Party leader Mark Williams said Obama was a "racists in chief - Indonesian Muslim and a welfare thug - on a CNN panel on "Anderson Cooper 360"
After listening to Williams, Anderson Cooper said, "What you're saying makes sense to me here when I'm hearing what you say but then I read on your blog, you say, you call the President an Indonesian Muslim turned welfare thug and a racist in chief."
Williams shrugs and responds, "Yeah, that's the way he's behaving." An incredulous Cooper asks Williams if he really believes Obama is an Indonesian Muslim and a welfare thug. The tea party leader digs the hole a little deeper: "He's certainly acting like it. Until he embraces the whole country what else can I conclude."
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5fymdNxn82M
What part of the country does Obama not embrace. The remarks are similar to Palin's vile during the campaign about "real America" and Obama not being one of us. The statements are designed to instill and promote fear and hate.
The right's talk of (to quote A-bax) "The boy who cried racism" has always struck me as a preemptive strike against what the right assumed would happen. It didn't. Not in any meaningful widespread way. As a lefty, I never heard anyone of my fellow bleeding heart pinko commies ONCE say anything about a racist being the root of right-wing attacks on Obama until very recently.
Frankly, the whole tea party movement seems so devoid of a clear message or purpose (at least of things that weren't either enacted under Bush, or exactly what Bush had done), and so incredibly vitriolic that they are either incredibly hypocritical or racist.
I don't want to think this way, and I don't even think its conscious in most cases, but none the less, people need to really examine why they are so furious at Obama. Has he really been that bad? Was he not left with two failed war, a ruined economy, and a looted treasury? Do you not believe that the country can survive a ever-so-slight move the the left without threatening armed uprising or acting like a general election is a coupe?
And it's not like he didn't campaign on this stuff, he very much did! And he won the election. Give the guy a chance. He deserves that.
Inaccurate, too...He's dressed up as a fellow from New Guinea.
Short on time this afternoon, but thought these were interesting in light of the racism discussion:
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/26803840/
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2008/10/09/MNB313DUTE.DTL
http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/story?id=4918487&page=1
Bottom line, Rod and his fellow liberals have not been able to point out any of Limbaugh's racial extremist. To make my point, both Clarence Paige and Al Sharpton have defended Limbaugh in the past when he has been accused of racism by the racial huckster crowd. Paige did it on the McLaughlin Group and Sharpton on Hardball with Chris Matthews.
Limbaugh runs parodies that upset lots of people especially if they don't have a sense of humor. Over the years his biggest two targets have been Ted Kennedy and Bill Clinton. Now with Obama as President Limbaugh is running some hilarious stuff that some people are going to find offensive, but that's what political satire is supposed to do. The fact that Rod is now smearing him doesn't show Rod in a good light I'm afraid.
All of Erin's links go to pre-election articles. Obama received Security Service protection earlier than any other candidate because the death threats started immediately upon his announcing his candidacy.
It has been reported that Obama receives about 400% more threats than the threats against Bush. It is impossible to know how much is attributable to racism, but it is safe to say that racism is the cause for many of the threats.
Racism is the most powerful spell they can cast. If that doesn't work they got nothing left. I suspect it's lost its kick from extreme overuse, like antibiotics.
As usual the opponents of any kind of restriction on the illegal immigration, is playing the race card? It's a forgone conclusion that the benefactors of promoting a mass invasion of our shores, such as religious groups, unions, ACLU, radical ethnic caucuses and even our own US Chamber of Commerce, will mouth epithets that doesn't benefit big business, that doesn't advocate a continuous force of illegal cheap labor. Now they are really livid because their objection to E-Verify was thrown out of court. Now all federal contractors and subcontractors must adhere to the law. They have conspired against the American worker and people for too long, and now we are fighting back ourselves against corrupt politicians and other elected officials nationwide,
Rep.Joe Wilson was actually telling the truth at the time, and now Democrats have placed restrictive language in the Health care reform package as a reluctant afterthought by public demand. This was nothing to do about bigotry or racism, but the American workers and family survival. None of the business community who hire them wants their labor, but forces the taxpayer to carry the financial load. The US labor force should not have to be in competition, with people from other countries. Businesses have already offshore American jobs, because it's cheaper? So every illegal foreign national and family member should be exempt from government run health care, jobs and all the billions of taxpayer dollars secretly allocated to pay for their support. Twenty million plus illegal people compromised themselves, when they entered a sovereign nation without permission. Find out the truth at NUMBERSUSA, JUDICIAL WATCH and contact your politician at 202-224-3121 demanding no weakening conditions to E-Verify or any other law authored by Congress.
William R
Essentially, your argument is "It isn't racist because I choose not to recognize Limbaugh's statements as such....and Thomas Sowell said so a few years ago. I think."
A little bit self serving, don't you think?
Rod posted comment from Rush that, well, looked pretty inflammatory...and the only defenses offered was that it was all a really brilliant sarcastic parody, and that you apparently needed a Secret Squirrel Special Decoder Ring to understand the beauty of it.
Uh huh.
Still more...
13. Diann Jones, a vice chairman of the Collin County TX GOP, sent an email to local Republican clubs that included the statement, "Another terrific idea from the black house and its minions."
14. The home page of the Pemberton NJ GOP site had a banner that declared, "Obama loves America Like OJ loved Nicole!" until Burlington County Democratic Chairman Rick Perr complained.
15. Audra Shay, vice chairwoman of the Young Republicans, wrote on her Facebook page "You tell em Eric! lol" in response to a Eric Pike's comment, "...need to take this country back from all of these mad coons... and illegals."
16. Rep Geoff Davis (R-KY) said at a Northern Kentucky Lincoln Day dinner (a GOP dinner) "I'm going to tell you something: That boy's finger does not need to be on the button."
17. When asked at a public forum about GOP prospects in light of a Democratic controlled Congress and the nation's first black president, Rep. Lynn Jenkins (R-KS) said that, "Republicans are struggling right now to find the great white hope."
18. Jill Jackson, a Republican and the former top election official of Johnson County IN, distributed "literature" to two county employees that included statements such as, "He is proud of his 'African heritage' (a father who got a white girl pregnant and deserted her)" and "The U.S. citizens are just not ready to give up their country to this young, black 'Adolf Hitler' with a smile, poor direction and absolutely no experience!"
It is possible that the NW is truly different from everywhere, and almost all my family live in Washington, but what I see and what they tell me is that they are totally amazed and bemused, insulted and disgusted by all this race stuff. We don't see it, we would be ashamed to express it, and minority people are just other folks around here.
Go interview any junior high or high school kid around here (Seattle suburbs) and they would tell you the same thing, and they are not politically sophisticated enough to dissemble. They have family members and close friends of mixed race, they go to school with American and immigrant kids from all over, and this is totally a non-issue for them. Ask their parents and they are equally amazed and disgusted at this becoming an issue.
They may not have voted for Obama, but it was not because of race, it was because of what was laid out in the campaign as his policies. They were probably dismayed too that all they had as an alternative was McCain. I was too.
Most of us are feeling very uncomfortable that we have been pushed to become so cynical about government, since both sides appear to be both corrupt and inept. Are we really differnt from all the rest of the country?
"He (Obaman) is in danger, however, of allowing race to be the principal political weapon used by Democrats against Republicans. A failure to show presidential leadership by calling a halt to this folly could fuel opposition to the Obama agenda – and unpick the scab of racism just as the old wounds were beginning to heal."
http://bit.ly/vtyti
as for the image you posted Rod all I can say is nice cherry picking. I've been collecting images of Obama since last year. The one who posted is in definitely in the minority. The vast majority are based upon his iconography or played off against Communist/Fascist style posters.
"if Obama got elected, the left would racialize all policy differences with Obama, making any criticism of him out to be racism."
it may not have come from the leaders of the Left but i have experienced from the footsoldiers. What you want is for us to disprove a negative. Go back to Limbaugh's monologue and look at who he quotes
"Suddenly it seems on the right, there's a powerful meme holding that the left has been doing this since the Inaugural, and the right has finally, finally started to fight back."
Jeez, Rod, haven't you noticed yet? That's ALWAYS the meme on the teabagger right. Playing the victim is their stock in trade.
Dan
Frankly, the whole tea party movement seems so devoid of a clear message or purpose (at least of things that weren't either enacted under Bush, or exactly what Bush had done), and so incredibly vitriolic that they are either incredibly hypocritical or racist.
When the left gets pissed about things, we get pissed about specific things. In fact, we specifically single-issue target stuff...protesting warrentless wiretapping, or the war, or pro-gay rights, or, yes, bank bailouts, or whatever, but not a hodgepodge of things. Heck, we even have protests that are specifically about one war and not the other.
This serves two purposes...first, it assures everyone that the people protesting all actually agrees with the specific aim of the protest, and aren't just standing around because they hate Bush, and second it means you get more people, who might agree with one thing but not another. In fact, a lot of the protests are bipartisan. (Admittedly, this usually doesn't work very well, but the protest organizers at least make the attempt.)
No, these aren't the specific protests we're used to. This is more akin to the 'general anger protests' done in the 60s by the left. General anger protests don't really have anything to do with the issues, they are because a segment of society feels totally ignored.
'The left' in the 60 (Actually, the 'young' left...let's not forget what happened at the 1968 DNC.), had a specific issue they could focus on 'Being sent off to die in a war', and civil rights. But in actuality the issue was the world not changing fast enough for them, them not knowing what to do with themselves in the real world, and feeling voiceless. (There have been entire shelves of books written on the hippie movement, I don't need to get into it, and I'm nowhere near the expert.)
But if you think it was utterly silly, and you think the issues were dumb, and that hippies were just 'acting out'...well, you're actually agreeing with me. It was not about the war, it was a 'we think society is broken' protest. That is what 'general anger protests' are about.
I don't want to think this way, and I don't even think its conscious in most cases, but none the less, people need to really examine why they are so furious at Obama. Has he really been that bad? Was he not left with two failed war, a ruined economy, and a looted treasury? Do you not believe that the country can survive a ever-so-slight move the the left without threatening armed uprising or acting like a general election is a coupe?
Now that the right has started 'general anger protests'. And I truly am trying to see the best of them, but the only change I really can see to have triggered these protests is 'Obama taking office'. Seriously, someone give me some other change to have trigger this.
Granted, they could be angry about some lack of change, like the hippies were supposedly angry about the lack of civil rights and the lack of ending the war, but I'm not actually seeing anything they wish to end except 'deficit spending', and this is way too much protest, way too fast, to be caused by that.
It would be possible for them to be pissed off about the mortgage crisis, that's certainly something that could be (and is) causing general malcontent. Or unemployment, or the general recession, or all sorts of things. But those would only work if any of the tea party people even slightly seemed to want to address that issue.
And, no, health care reform hasn't actually happened that, and thus has not affected society in any manner yet. Likewise, neither did TARP. I'm not saying they aren't valid complaints, I'm saying that it can't possibly be causing the general anger protests, which require people to feel harmed to start with.
The nicest version of this is that the change they're objecting to was a Democratic president, instead of the other attribute of Obama.
Which, frankly, isn't much better. Actually, I personally consider it worse. As you said, their unwillingness for the country to move slightly to the left when it elected the left by overwhelming electoral success who campaigned on exactly those issues indicates no respect for the democratic process at all.
A couple of quick examples:
Here's a CNN story detailing when Geraldine Ferraro stepped down from the Clinton campaign due to racial controversy. Her quote:
"Any time anybody does anything that in any way pulls this campaign down and says let's address reality and the problems we're facing in this world, you're accused of being racist, so you have to shut up," she told the Daily Breeze of Torrance, California.
http://www.cnn.com/2008/POLITICS/03/12/ferraro.comments/index.html
Here's Obama himself stating that his opponents will bring up the fact he's black:
http://www.reuters.com/article/politicsNews/idUSN2040982720080620?feedType=RSS&feedName=politicsNews&rpc=22&sp=true
I guess you could consider a vice-presidential candidate and the current US President as "non-fringe" figures. Obama suggesting that criticism of him will rely on race to stoke fear, and Ferraro saying that "racist!" is/was the stock defense of the Obama campaign. All from early 2008.
Never posted links here before so hope these work.
The claim that criticism of President Obama is largely a function of racism seems to have become more widespread as his favorability poll numbers have declined, an observation for which I owe credit to someone I've forgotten and so who regrettably must go unnamed.
I don't have time to find links, but you might want to remember the "don't look like other presidents on the dollar bills line," or all the brouhaha about "kill him" at Palin rallies (this never actually happened, at least not that anyone can confirm), or the accusations of racism during the Bill Ayers and Jeremiah Wright controversies. And at this point, it's just ridiculous--I just read a Slate piece claiming that Glenn Beck was a white separatist. How'd the guy come to that conclusion? Based on two signs at a rally somewhere. I'm not sure the MSM, or at least the most liberal part of it, were as blind to race as you think they were.
The art of Parody is dead. We can do parody of anyone and its comedy. Do parody of Obama and it's racism. They have managed to divide and conquer. Would not surprise me if the parody came direct from the White House. Me, I am about fed up with this racism hysteria, put a sock in it. Obama as the Witch Doctor and his Obama Care is fair game. Remember the skits with the Witch Doctors standing around a big pot with a white person in it, was that racism or hungry Witch Doctors?
This morning's revelations about the Hofstra "gang rape" allegations are interesting, especially when you look at the reaction to the original story over on FreeRepublic.com. Check out the comments through the thread as more and more people make their assumptions about the alleged rapists, and then see what happens with comments from this morning.
www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/2340093/posts
No...no racism there at all.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/09/14/AR2009091403369.html
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/09/13/opinion/13dowd.html (I think this is a different column from the Dowd column you referenced)
http://thehill.com/blogs/blog-briefing-room/news/59015-waters-media-must-investigate-right-wing-protesters-for-racism
Incidentally, to this day, the left accuses Sarah Palin of consorting with witch doctors, when what actually happened was that she had an African pastor, known for opposing witchcraft, pray over her at church. I'm not saying that makes the "Obama witch doctor" poster okay -- it doesn't. What I'm saying is that racism may be a little more widespread than you realize.
Daniel Ruwe, a year ago (approximately) I was posting frequently about what I thought was the racist demagoguery of Jeremiah Wright, and I was very happy that Obama disassociated himself with that man and his church.
This year, in my judgment, what underlies much of the hysterical opposition to Obama (he's a Muslim, he's not an American, he's Hitler, he's a Communist/Socialist/Facist) is racism, pure and simple.
All of the stuff about spending is a red herring - this spending wouldn't have been necessary if the global economy hadn't been on the verge of collapse due in large part to the policies of Bush and the Republican leadership. (And, yes, there is blame to go around.)
Also, a number of posters have offered examples of racist quotes by people from various state and local Republican governments. These are the kind of people that are driving this moderate to write off the Republican Party.
Alicia,
I guess all that spending will pay for itself since you've found some racists on the right. Thanks, I'll sleep a lot better tonight knowing that.
ScurvyOaks,
I think you missed my point. There is nothing wrong with opposition to Obama's proposals/policies, but moderates such as myself are so turned off by the hysteria of the Tea Party/Birthers/etc. folks that it is becoming much harder to hear those who have legitimate criticisms. It's not possible to have a debate about policy if one or both parties are not acting in good faith.
It gives me no pleasure to say that much of the hysterical opposition (as opposed to the rational opposition) to Obama is based on racism.
Obama cut his ties with Reverend Jeremiah Wright and his church, which was the right thing to do; perhaps it is time for Republican leaders to stop legitimizing the hysterical voices on the right.
That's interesting, because moderates such as myself are so turned off by the hysteria of people who use the race card to explain EVERYTHING that it is becoming much harder to hear those who have legitimate criticisms.
Gina -
Anyone who prays over another person to protect them from witchcraft, is a witch doctor. That's not racist - if anything it's anti-religion. But I prefer to call it "sanity."
Mdgiest55 -
You're falling into the same trap that this article warns against. If you think that racism is being used to explain every opposition to Obama's policies then you're either oversimplifying, overcompensating, or just plain not paying attention. I am on the left and I have legitimate complaints about Obama. But when you see nutballs like the birthers and the teabaggers getting national media attention, it becomes difficult if not impossible to pay attention to any legitimate concerns.
About that image that is supposedly "making the rounds on the right": how did YOU get a hold of it? As a far-right free-thinker myself, I have never seen that image before and I almost suspect that some liberal made it up just to make the right appear racist.
Post a Comment
By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.