Not long ago, my family and I went out for pizza. The restaurant, like so many these days, is covered with big-screen TVs--but they only play sports, and they keep the volume off, so it's not as annoying as some places can be.
My husband and I were talking. One of the girls grabbed his arm, and said, "Dad, look!" pointing at the TV. His gaze followed her insistent pointing to one of the TV screens, which was playing a commercial.
"No!" he gasped in astonished annoyance, while the girls giggled--they knew Dad would react this way. I turned to look, and saw that the commercial was for Six Flags--and the character on the screen was that creepy faux octogenarian, the guy people everywhere find mind-bogglingly unpleasant: Mr. Six.
Why did Six Flags bring him back? Time wonders, too:
This could be a make-or-break summer for Six Flags. And in the current economic environment, families will likely sacrifice thrill-ride screams for savings. So why, in the face of such serious challenges, would Six Flags respond by rolling out an ad campaign featuring a widely mocked character that the company's own chairman once said is "misguided" and "weakens the brand." Why, just when the stakes are at an all-time high, is a bankrupt company putting that creepy dancing old guy back on our TVs?
His name is Mr. Six -- clever, right? -- and his troll-like antics may prevent you from ever setting foot in a Six Flags park, no matter how exciting that Batman ride is. He first popped up in Six Flag ads in 2004, a geriatric sideshow obviously played by a younger actor. Mr. Six dementedly shimmied to the equally annoying late-'90s dance song "We Like to Party" while in the confines of a Six Flag facility. Dressed in a floppy tuxedo and wearing black-rimmed glasses larger than most skyscraper windows, Mr. Six has a wrinkled face, a victim of makeup malpractice, that looks like "someone left a dead turtle in a stagnant pool of water for a month," in the words of one advertising blogger. A New York City radio host wondered if Mr. Six was actually "Junior Soprano out on a bender." [...]
The new commercials are receiving scathing reviews. "It's a pretty miserable piece of advertising," says Barbara Lippert, a critic for Adweek, the trade publication. "It's as dumb as can be, and talks down to us. He's like an Elmer Fudd who never made it out into the country." Every moment of a 30-second spot is valuable. Why sacrifice precious time to a character with no natural connection to an amusement park? And how, exactly, does a creepy old man in a bow tie appeal to the kids that drive Six Flags' business? "I don't think many 11-year-olds relate to George Burns types," says Lippert. Hey, don't insult a late, great funnyman by comparing him to Mr. Six.
Six Flags has talked to parents, Vieira Barocas insists. And for the most part, their children give Mr. Six rave reviews. "It's not about his age," she says. "It's about his spirit." According to the company, market research shows Mr. Six has fans of all ages. "We know he's a polarizing character," Vieira Barocas says. "But on any day I would rather that someone have an opinion about us and our brand than for him to just melt into the background with all the other advertising that is out there. Would I prefer that you and other critics find him appealing? Absolutely. But I will take the fact that you notice, that you hear our message and that you have a point of view."
The buzz can surely help, but to a point. Is Mr. Six actually driving incremental traffic to Six Flags? Viewers are already cash-strapped. Why potentially turn them off with your spots? "Sure, the ad sticks Six Flags in your mind," says Lippert. "But it's wedged in the area that causes extreme anxiety and annoyance. You're saying, 'Get this out of my lobe.'"
I read my husband that last paragraph when he called from work, and he agreed wholeheartedly with that perspective. Mr. Six does not cause a desire to go to Six Flags, at least not in him; Mr. Six causes him to want to throw things at our TV and swear he'll never expose our kids to the kind of people who think that guy's a hoot.
And that made me wonder about other supposedly "beloved" advertising campaigns or characters that have possibly done more harm than good. Anyone here share my oldest girl's dislike of Ronald McDonald? Anybody (besides me) remember Spuds McKenzie, or thinking he was kind of stupid? The Taco Bell Chihuahua just died on Tuesday--I remember hearing that some people initially thought the ad campaign was insulting, but that seemed to have died away long ago. Thoughts?
How about some insurance characters: Erin Esurance, the Aflac duck, or the Geico gecko? Do the Serta sheep make you think of matressess and a good night's sleep? Do the Chik-fil-A cows make you want chicken--or does the campaign backfire and make you desire a nice porterhouse?
I know there's one "character" that makes me react with almost as much hostility toward our TV as my husband does when Mr. Six appears--and that's the Mucinex, er, thing. When I've got a bad case of congestion from a flu or allergies, the last thing I want to do is visualize little green blobs arranging living-room furniture in my bronchial passages, thank you very much.
It's your turn to rant about the advertising characters you just can't stand! I'm betting some of you have some I haven't thought of in a long time.