Kids these days are embracing all over the place. Boys with boys, girls with girls, hetero-hugs, menage-a-hugs. It’s all good with teens. Who knew the text-message and
Facebook generation was capable of expressing so much physical affection? (Or perhaps it’s exactly
because they spend so much time interacting with techno-toys that good old-fashioned physical contact with their peers is so desirable?)
Apparently, it’s not only a hot new trend, it’s also a somewhat controversial one. According to the article, several schools have banned hugging in the hallways, perhaps fearing sexual harassment, peer pressure, encouraging too relaxed of an academic atmosphere, disco dermatitis, rabies, and/or a virulent outbreak of
cooties.
I get that. But is it ethical for schools to impose such bans?
Uniforms, behavioral codes, locker searches… all these things made my hackles rise when I was in high school. (Perhaps this is why I wore combat boots and stomped around in a funk so much.) I hated it that my school imposed so many restrictions on my rights when I was a teen, and I still carry a resentment over a lot of that stuff. I tend to think that, on the whole, if school officials would allow students a little responsibility, they’d show they were up to it.
But I also understand that peer pressure can make kids feel they have to do things (like hug) they’d rather not. Heck, even now I have friends who are not ‘huggy’ and feel apologetic about it, sometimes squirming if they have to endure an embrace when that’s just not their thing. Kids might understandably have a much harder time just saying “No thanks, hugging isn’t my bag” than an adult would. Removing the option–and thus, the dilemma–by mandating a ‘no-hug’ policy on school grounds could save some teens uncomfortable moments.
What do you think? Should hugging hit the high road in high school?
posted May 28, 2009 at 11:02 pm
I think it’s worth kids experiencing a bit of discomfort so they learn what their own boundaries are and how to communicate them to others. Otherwise, the message is two-fold: “hugging” is somehow inappropriate (of course, it CAN be, but that’s true for any type of touch, communication, gesture etc); and that kids aren’t competent enough to set these boundaries themselves. I suppose there may be specific incidents of inappropriate “hugging” (hands venturing lower than they should, for example), but that’s something that has to be dealt with individually, just as it has for a long time.
posted May 29, 2009 at 12:35 am
If I were a parent I would be making life very difficult for those administrators.
posted May 29, 2009 at 12:54 am
Next thing you know there will be a ‘friend approval committee’ made up of school board members and school administrators and of course someone from legal. All this while here in California, we have schools and teachers who are using physcial and emotional abuse to ‘train’ disabled kids to behave, where bad teachers can keep their jobs inspite of how abusive they are and the schools are in the dumps. Seems to me these districts should be more concerned about the lesson of fearmongering and censorship the are teaching by example then how much these kids are showing some affectiong. Perhaps the energy could be spent teaching some training in ‘saying no’ if tey are worried about harrassement suits or in making sure that they have open communication among the students. But this?
How absurd is this!
posted May 29, 2009 at 8:12 am
Sounds like a breeding ground for Martial Law. Banning what has become a natural greeting for teens is ridiculous. School policies already do a good job turning our children into automatons. Imposing restrictions on healthy affection would only serve to further disconnect feelings from actions. Perhaps including presentations on appropriate displays of affection and ‘how to say no’ in Life Skills classes would better serve our teens.
posted May 29, 2009 at 8:15 am
When I was in HS (I graduated in ’06), my friends and I would hug every day in Spanish class. The profesora must have decided she was uncomfortable with this, because after about two weeks of greeting each other in such a way, she informed us that it was PDA and we could be written up for it.
Of course, I only refrained in her class and continued my hugging anywhere else. No one seemed to mind. I gave a good friend a hug in the hallway, and another student told one of the teachers, “PDA, PDA!”
She said, “Shut up ____! It’s just a hug, it’s not like they’re making out!”
Obviously, she became a favorite.
Today, in college, I give hugs to almost everyone I know – friends, staff. I only refrain from hugging Profs because I feel it may be awkward. But janitors? Oh yeah, they get hugs.
One of my friends bought me a “free hugs” pin for on my purse.
What’s so bad about hugs?
posted May 29, 2009 at 2:24 pm
I think as a society, we hug too much. I don’t think it is necessary to hug (or kiss) every time we see someone. Hugging for everything in life is actually new to our society. I think it is because we have become such a needy immature society. Perhaps it’s because everything we do is so impersonal (i.e. electronic devices for communicating) that we crave human contact. Should hugging be banned? No. But should we move away from needing that emotional assurance 10 or 20 times a day? Yes!
posted November 4, 2009 at 2:25 pm
We live in such a violent and depressing society. Im 16 and I get bombarded everyday by media stories of teen violence. If teens hug alot, hey whats the harm, they are creating peace in such a chaotic society.
posted February 5, 2010 at 12:02 am
When can we start having sex as a way to say hello and start the day? I mean if hugging is a natural way to say hello, then sex must really be natural. What can it hurt?
posted October 25, 2010 at 9:34 pm
Virginia Satir, family therapist, says that humans need 4 hugs a day for survival, 8 hugs a day for maintenance and 12 hugs a day for growth. I believe that the greatest poverty is not of food or money, but rather the lack of embracing the human soul. God made us creatures that require deep doses of intimacy to stay emotionally, physically and mentally healthy. Hugging is a healthy and wholesome habit that is endangered by the speed and hustle of our modern American lifestyle and further endangered by the fear of being accused of something other than our pure intentions to simply express our appreciation of one another.
I vote that as long as the hugs are wholesome that they should keep it up.
posted February 15, 2011 at 5:46 am
this site has a very interesting topic that I wanted to reply to so it made me drop by and im glad to be here! Anyways, here are some interesting links Ways to Become a Millioner