Everyday Ethics

Recently in News Category

Monday November 2, 2009

Things Don't Add Up in Wal-Mart Scuffle

Wal-Mart seems to be playing a much larger part in our blog than usual lately, but apparently that's where all the news happens. 

Actually, the incident I'm referring to in this case actually occurred three years ago, but the trial is approaching soon, and CNN recently hosted a small panel interview with John King to discuss whether or not this was a case of racism. 

Here's the backstory: Heather Ellis, a Wal-Mart shopper, became involved in a verbal tussle with a cashier -- she claims the cashier asked her for id even though she was paying cash and refused to hand over her change. The cashier claims she cut in line (wow, I've wanted to call the police on line-cutters, but this is ridiculous). From any account, it sounds as though things went from bad to worse quickly. The cashier called for the police, tempers rise, the situation turns into he says, she says. 

Tuesday October 27, 2009

Gang Rape after Homecoming: Bystanders Snap Photos

"I bet this is a learning incident." 

This is a quote from West Contra Costa Unified School District spokesman Marin Trujillo, in regards to the gang rape that occurred on school grounds after a homecoming dance. I actually felt chilled as I read this account -- gang rape of anyone, let alone a teenage girl after her homecoming dance is beyond words. So what words do we use to describe the gang rape of a girl with multiple bystanders watching, snapping photos and not lifting a finger (let alone a cell phone) to help? 

We've discussed getting "involved" on this blog quite a bit. I think most of us are similar in the sense that we want to make the right choices in life, both for our own sake as well as for others, but often are unsure when it's the right time to step in if it doesn't directly involve us. I couldn't even bring myself to interject my opinion in a verbal scuffle between a passenger and airport shuttle driver

Tuesday October 13, 2009

Should Smokers' Lungs Be Used?

I recently had an interesting debate about health care with my brother, a doctor in the Navy. As debates between the two of us generally go, we circled around a number of topics before ending the call. One such topic ended with the shared opinion (a shared opinion is mighty rare when it comes to we two siblings) that we wished more people accepted, medically, that sometimes bad things just happened.

I thought of this conversation when reading this story about a soldier who died after receiving a transplant of cancerous lungs -- the lungs of a heavy smoker.

Initially, I assumed the sad story was a tragic mix-up, a mistake. And as I said before, perhaps a case in which a bad thing just happened. However, as you read further into the story you see the hospital defends its' use of smokers' organs in transplants.

Their defense is that, if smokers were excluded from the donation process, the number of available organs would drop dramatically. Personally, every Brit I know is a smoker, so I can only assume this is true.

Still, is the risk worth it? I'm sure the many saved by a smoker's organs would say yes. Plus, according to the hospital, this was a very rare case. So did the hospital act unethically? My inclination is to say yes, they did. Legitimate defense or no, surely a *very* heavy smoker should have been excluded from donating his organs -- this was a man who apparently smoked up to 50 cigarettes a day!

What do you think? Should this be an accepted practice?

Friday October 9, 2009

Surprise! You've...Won the Nobel Peace Prize?

Update: Perhaps the move wasn't such a surprise to everyone. Reuters reported on Wednesday about rumblings that the Nobel Committee was trying to return to its activist roots, and quoted Kristian Berg Harpviken, head of the International Peace Institute in Oslo, "It's quite likely this committee will reward somebody who is engaged in current processes."

Well, if that was their intention, I'm much more on board. See below for my original entry.

-----------

In a move that seems to have taken everyone by surprise (White House included), the Nobel Committee announced that it has awarded President Obama the peace prize this year -- only 9 months into a tumultuous presidency. 

First, I have to say, I'm a big fan of Obama. However, I'm wondering if they should call this the preemptive peace prize. 

Has Obama truly earned this honor just yet? I'm convinced he will eventually earn it. But I say give the man a chance. If I were the president (ooohh if only), I wouldn't feel any joy receiving the award; I'd feel undeserving and a bit inadequate.

It's early days in the firestorm of discussion that is sure to follow, but the only rebuttal I've read that works for me comes from Thorbjorn Jagland, the chairman of the Norwegian Nobel Committee and a former prime minister of Norway who says, "We have to get the world on the right track again."

We really do, and I honestly believe Obama will work with the world to do that. But...he hasn't done it yet.

What do you think? 

Wednesday September 30, 2009

Not in My Backyard--but Perhaps the Woods Behind It ?

My sense of justice vs legal ethics goes a bit askew when it comes to sex offenders. On the one hand, I believe in crime and punishment as well as rehabilitation; on the other hand, I don't know many other crimes that are so offensive to the soul.

In Georgia, sex offenders were pushed literally the edges of society, sent to an unsupervised and unofficial camp colony in the woods because of the state's strict laws restricting a convicted sex offender from living, working or loitering within 1,000 feet of schools, churches, parks and other spots where children gather. At least they were until Tuesday, when it seems authorities started rounding the inhabitants back up and trying to find them emergency temporary housing - I can only assume there was an outcry from local citizens after the first report was published.

Obviously, there are the inevitable safety concerns -- surely an unsupervised colony of sexual predators feeding off each other's baser instincts is a bad idea? But safety aside, was their treatment ethical?

Sunday September 27, 2009

Polanski Arrested En Route To Zurich Film Festival: Belated Justice?

According to CNN, legendary film director Roman Polanski was on his way to receive a lifetime achievement award in Switzerland when he was grabbed up by police on a warrant issued in 1978. Said the Zurich Film Festival that is now sans...

Saturday September 26, 2009

Here's To "Justice!" Harvard Moral Philosophy Class To Appear On PBS!

Fascinating news! I just read that PBS will air a series based on an edited version of a wildly popular Harvard philosophy class on ethics and morality. The class, called "Justice: What's the Right Thing to Do?" is the brainchild...

Wednesday September 16, 2009

What-If Wednesday: Would You Get In The Middle Of A School Bus Fight?

In the news yesterday, a video surfaced of a kid getting viciously beaten on his school bus in Bellville, Illinois. Other children watched, some cheering, others standing by, others still laughing. One or two looked like they possible wanted to step in,...

Tuesday September 15, 2009

Kanye West, Serena Williams, Joe "You lie" Wilson: A Trifecta of Public Figure Tantrums

Paddy and I thought we'd toss in our two cents on the whole civility debate. After all, we'd hardly be an "Everyday Ethics" blog if we didn't have an opinion on everyday cultural behavior trends. So here goes. Hillary:...

Tuesday September 15, 2009

If Obama Calls Kanye A Jackass Off The Record, Does It Make A Sound?

It does if Terry Moran (Moron?) tweets it.So, the civility debate rages (ironically) on. And as everyone's buzzing, the president's now caught up in it, having remarked off the record in a CNBC interview that he thought Kanye West was...

Wednesday September 9, 2009

Is It Our Civic Duty To Watch President Obama's Health Care Speech To Congress?

Whether you're for it or against it, odds are, you feel passionately about health care reform. But how many of us have even made the attempt to dive into the 1,000-odd page health care reform bill H.R. 3200 "America's Affordable...

Friday September 4, 2009

Man Irritated by Crying Toddler in Wal-Mart, Slaps Her

I just have to say, completely unrelated to ethics or dilemmas, thank you Virgin America, for in-flight internet. I love multi-tasking a 5-hour journey and work! (I'm completely serious). Now, on to more interesting things. Talk about an ethical fail...

Tuesday September 1, 2009

Sigh. My High School Re-Opens the Scopes Trial

Yep. This is my high school...and my marching band (any fellow former band nerds out there?)I have to say, I loved going to high school in little ol' Sedalia, Missouri. Sure it's a small town, but small towns are the...

Wednesday August 26, 2009

Kennedy's Example: Ethical, Not Perfect

Normal 0 I agree wholeheartedly with Hillary's eloquent argument (see post below) that we should remember a person for who they are, not simply who we wanted them to be.I'd also like to add another point - I see...

Wednesday August 26, 2009

Remembering Ted Kennedy: Are We Doing It Right?

It is seldom that we lose someone of such legendary stature as Senator Edward M. Kennedy. Though the media may try to play up every death as a Cronkite or a Mother Theresa, I honestly don't feel the need...

Sunday August 23, 2009

Caster Semenya: Should We Take "Her" Word For It?

What is gender? Apparently, as the case of South African runner Caster Semenya is proving, it's less absolute than penis versus vagina. As controversy swirls over whether the gold-medal-winning 18-year-old is wholly female, I wondered, should it even matter? Assuming...

Thursday August 20, 2009

Lockerbie Bomber Freed: Is Showing Compassion Ethical?

Compassion and ethics. Can they co-exist? I say yes, though certainly not in every situation. Take this one, for example: Today, Scottish authorities released Abdel Baset al-Megrahi, the convicted Libyan "Lockerbie bomber" on compassionate grounds. Al-Megrahi was sentenced in 2001...

Wednesday August 19, 2009

Barney Frank Town Hall Video: Was His Response Appropriate or Unethical?

I have to admit, I got quite an ethically-challenged guffaw out of Barney Frank's comments to the woman who compared President Obama's healthcare plans to a 'Nazi policy'. Take a look at the video and see for yourself: I don't mind...

Wednesday August 19, 2009

Google Forced to Reveal Blogger's Identity After "Skank" Comment Riles Model: Ethical Or Anti-Freedom Of Speech?

Liskula Cohen, a NY model whose face has graced the cover of Vogue, among other mags, didn't appreciate being called a "skank" - and worse - by an anonymous blogger on the website "Skanks In NYC" (since defunct). So she...

Tuesday August 18, 2009

Woman Pregnant With 12 Babies: Outrageous Or Awesome?

Never mind the stretch marks; what on earth is this woman thinking? If the UK's Sun can be believed, a Tunisian woman is vowing to carry all twelve fetuses to term after having several heartbreaking miscarriages in the past.Honestly, in...

Monday August 17, 2009

NFL Forgives Vick's Sins

Time to re-visit the question of Michael Vick, now that he's been signed by the Philadelphia Eagles. In my original post, I asked if--having paid his dues-- he should be welcomed back into the NFL with open arms.The reaction (on...

Thursday August 13, 2009

Is the Burqini Unethical, or is Banning It?

The burqini, a full body swimsuit, may have been created to allow Muslim women the freedom to partake in the joy of cavorting in the water alongside everyone else, but in France it's causing another flare-up in controversy over Muslim...

Tuesday July 28, 2009

Michael Vick Reinstated - Did the NFL Act Ethically?

Professional sports and I do not go together like peanut butter and jelly - my eyes take on a lovely shade of "glazed" when my male friends start down the road of player stats, fantasy leagues and rankings.  But Michael...

Saturday July 25, 2009

Racism -- Not as Important as Healthcare!?!

When Hillary wrote her post about Obama speaking out on Skip Gates' arrest, I mentally applauded her for tackling the topic- from beginning to hopeful end, the whole fiasco gives me a headache.However, many of the responses to the story...

Thursday July 16, 2009

Rwandan Genocide Leaders Get a Whopping Sentence in Court...

Not.On Tuesday, the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda sentenced a former governor of Rwanda to life imprisonment for his role in the 1994 genocide. This is the third such ruling this year; previous convictions by the U.N. court include 25...

Wednesday July 15, 2009

World's Oldest "New" Mother Dead at 69

Back in 2006, Maria del Carmen Bousada gave birth to a set of twins - at the ripe old age of 66. Three years later, she's passed away, leaving behind two young children. After Bousada became pregnant using in...

Tuesday July 14, 2009

Soldier Refuses to Deploy; Says Obama Isn't President

I love a good conspiracy theory. U.S. Army Maj. Stefan Frederick Cook is refusing to deploy to Afghanistan because he doesn't acknowledge President Obama as the rightful president of the United States. Cook is being represented by Orly Taitz, who...

Monday July 13, 2009

Athlete Pimps His Way to 2012 Olympics

Normal 0 Should a legal brothel be allowed to fund a man's bid for the 2012 Olympics? New Zealand's Logan Campbell says yes. The Taekwondo athlete needs $300,000 to train his way to London, and by golly, he'll do...

Advertisement

Search This Blog

feed icon Subscribe

RSS Feed

Receive updates from Everyday Ethics

About Everyday Ethics

This blog is all about ethics. It's also about us--ordinary people facing ordinary situations. It's about asking ourselves the hard questions: What responsibility do we bear in our interactions (and yes, confrontations) with the people we meet? How do we best respond to those around us in a way that leaves us feeling good about ourselves and confident our behavior has done no harm? Have we helped or hurt our fellows in these moments? It's our belief that by asking some big questions (and some little ones too) we can grow as humans. We're glad you're along for the ride!

About the Authors

Hillary Fields
Hillary Fields is a New York-based writer, editor and web producer.
» Posts by Hillary Fields
Padmini Mangunta
Padmini Mangunta is a writer and editor with a Journalism degree from the University of Missouri-Columbia.
» Posts by Padmini Mangunta
More »

Ethics and Family

Islam
Beliefnet's Family Values Toolkit offers age-specific resources to help kids navigate difficult decisions.
View the Toolkit

Advertisement


About Beliefnet

Our mission is to help people like you find, and walk, a spiritual path that will bring comfort, hope, clarity, strength, and happiness. More about Beliefnet.

Legal

Copyright © Beliefnet, Inc. and/or its licensors. All rights reserved. Use of this site is subject to Terms of Service and to our Privacy Policy. Constructed by Beliefnet.

Advertisement

Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.