God-o-Meter

With Palin, the Catholic Wars Heat Up

Friday August 29, 2008

Categories: John McCain
Below is a taste of the press release the conservative Catholic group Fidelis released this morning on the Palin announcement. Obama has a Catholic running mate. Now McCain does, too. The fight for Catholics is going to heat up big...
Advertisement
Comments
Charles Cosimano
August 29, 2008 6:28 PM

I'm annoyed to the point where, for the first time, if I can make my hand do it, I may vote for Obama.

ds0490
August 29, 2008 8:17 PM

I sincerely hope that Fidelis is not a 501(c)3 organization. If they happen to be, they just put their exemption in jeopardy.

Paul, seeking wisdom.
August 29, 2008 8:18 PM

Once more the Republicans will make this a one issue campaign. The will play the pro-life card for all its worth and then, like always, they will do nothing.

They know they can't win on the economy, the war, health, caring for the elderly, veterans or homeless, the mortgage failures, the FEMA mismanagement or any other issue that Americans care about so they got to stick with the one card they are famous for, the Pro-Life card.

I'm pro life. I have always been pro life and yet I am not stupid enough to think that they will deliver now. Get a life and wake up, the GOP is nothing but a song and dance club with the same old dog and pony show and snake oil sells pitch.

Vote for change.

By the way, I'm dropping out of the blog game and getting back to work.

andrew robitaille
August 29, 2008 11:44 PM

Heres my two cents worth at 55 Ive worked on many a Democratic campaign, starting by working the Mcgovern campaign on Cape Cod in 72..thru the Kerry campaign in 2oo4. Ive worked for and seen a lot of Democrats over the years but this bunch with the leaders of congress and the senate, and this continual name calling and we know it all and are MUCH smarter than any one attitude have broken this donkeys back...I have drawn the line with the push to elect such an empty suit as Obama. Not just an empty suit but one covered in more dirt thru Chicago politics, associations with people even an mobster would have the common sense to avoid . Thank you for forcing me to see you for who you really are a party intent on bringing down the America I love and have been proud of all my adult life, Ill be voting for McCain and working hard to help elect a genuine Hero not a zero this time.............

David Maddox
August 30, 2008 4:39 AM

The selection of Palin is the most inspiring action of any candidate this year. Her character is what has made her a rising star. The vision she articulates, backed by the compassion she demonstrates, will turn far more heads than folks expect. Choosing Palin is the surprise of the week, but her effectiveness on the campaign trail will be the surprise of the election season. McCain just turned a horse race into a run-away victory.

docsyl
August 30, 2008 1:00 PM

Here's the thing. Most Catholics are not mindless followers who believe that one or two issues concerning reproductive rights and mature adult relationships are the most important issues in this year's elections. Catholics have an ingrained understanding of peace and justice albeit at times veiled by other issues. They also have the ability to think critically about issues. How can someone say they are Pro life and deny working mothers an equitable salary to support and sustain the lives of her family? How can someone say they are pro marriage and continue to allow military families to suffer the absence of spouses and children to a war that has been called immoral by the last two popes?
Not all Catholics believe that live issues begin and end with abortion. Many Catholics understand that life issues included caring for all life within and outside the womb.
On election day I believe more Catholics will reflect on that way of being pro life.

John
August 30, 2008 3:11 PM

I dont know how anyone could call themselves truly Catholic and support people who have no problem with killing babies. I agree we shouldnt be one issue voters and that is easy for me because Obama is not on the right side of any issue. He simply spits out the same old liberal rhetoric that appearantly some of you believe. If you knowingly vote for a pro-abortion candidate then you have knowingly furthered the cause of killing babies. Once the baby is born ofcourse we have to still take care of it and that is the parents job. If the parent or parents cannot handle that job then they should not have sex. Its called personal responsibility, something our society is trying to do away with. I dont hear Sarah Palin complaining about unfair wages. She worked hard and made it to the top which is something all Americans have the right to do. Liberal philosophy will take these opportunities away. If you truly believe that support for the war is a violation of life issues then maybe as Catholics we should not vote at all. I believe however that this would be irresponsible.

Dave
August 30, 2008 6:01 PM

I AM CATHOLIC, AND A DEMOCRAT, AND ANTI ABORTION, BUT... THE FEEL GOOD ANTI ABORTION, COMMUNION DENYING CLERGY ARE HYPOCRITICAL. THE CATHOLIC CHURCH PUTS BIRTH CONTROL PILLS IN THE SAME CATEGORY AS ABORTION YET EVERY SUNDAY I SEE MOST OF THE YOUNG MARRIED WOMEN GO TO RECEIVE THE HOST. ALOT OF THESE SAME WOMEN ARE UPSET ABOUT ABORTION. MAYBE THEY ARE ALL USING THE APPROVED CHURCH METHODS BUT SOMEHOW I DOUBT IT. WHEN I QUESTION RELATIVES AND FRIENDS ABOUT THE PILL THEY SAY THAT IT IS NOT A SIN AND THEY WILL TAKE THEIR CHANCES WITH THE CHURCH. ANOTHER FINE EXAMPLE OF MENU CATHOLIC BEHAVIOR.

Ike Mbonu,
August 30, 2008 6:09 PM

I am a Catholic, my family is Catholic but we are not stupid,Catholic Church here in this country has been turned into the religious arm of the republican party.Now, what we have are bunch of hypocrites among the clergy and laity who on one hand have no problems defiling our children,defying the Pope on illegal wars but are all very eager to resurrect the culture-wars each election cycle just to distract people from the real issues.

The abortion issues are very simple- if you don't want abortion don't get one. If you hate gays don't be one.If you however choose to do either you have your God to answer to but I am tired of hearing from people who wants to legislate morality while people are loosing their homes, gas prices increasing, students can't afford tuition-while we are at it, how come Catholic schools rank among the most expensive. Please all these do gooders please read your Bible again and tell me if this American version of Catholism has any semblace to what Christ left for us. whoever has not sinned please let him cast the first stone.Only God himself knows between Biden and Palin who is better Catholic. Who are you to judge?

Scruffy.
August 30, 2008 11:21 PM

You can vote for your "gun totin' momma" with her five kids, digging for oil while her husband is going farther and father looking for fish that are going deeper and deeper trying to get away from the global warming she promotes.

I will vote for the man who wants equal pay, full medical benefits and protection from abusers for all American women.

Who's the better "Catholic"? that question is not on the ballot. Who will serve the Nation better? Biden. If something should happen to the president of this US of A, I would want Biden over Palin every day.

Mike
August 31, 2008 5:49 AM

I'm a practicing Roman Catholic, and I don't believe in abortion. Governor Palin is not a Roman Catholic. She is a born again Christian. A faith that has traditionally attracted former catholics to their flocks. Senator Joe Biden is a practicing Roman Catholic and worthy of our support. I am an independent and I voted for Presidents Ronald Reagan, George Bush, and his son George W. Bush. The Republicans have had their turn during the last 8 years. Gasoline prices have increased by more than $2.00 a gallon during this time period. Our country went from record surplusses and record levels of national debt under Pres. G.W. Bush. He's spending our hard earned money on Iraq and the Iraqis have tremendous surplus money available. I'm a patriot and a police officer but I wouldn't want any of my children to die in vain in Iraq. That country will never appreciate the sacrafices of our troops and will never send a single dollar back to our country. We spent billions of dollars and all that proud American blood for very little. My wife and I both work, and we're struggling to raise our four children. We are both graduates of Jesuit taught Boston College and I am a Knight of Columbus. I honestly feel the Catholic thing this election is to vote for the Obama/Biden ticket. Our country has been fighting tremendous war and killing hundered of thousands of people in these conflicts. Our country has the highest incarceration rate, and execution rate in the world. We're spending millions on wars while people are suffering in poverty in Alabama, Lousiana as Hurricane Katrina showed us. Its time to end racism permanently in this country and its time for a change. Please vote for Senator Obama and senator Biden for our nation's future, our children's future, our grandchildren's future, and in this place under God we call Earth...

Kathy
August 31, 2008 7:48 AM

Politico reported Senator McCain’s new pick for VP grew up Pentecostal, so did I, and this is the MOST extreme fundamentalist denomination there is…everyone beware! They believe in the apocalypse in the extreme and at the core of the Pentecostal denomination are fear based beliefs. Yes, they are saying she is Catholic now, but I promise everyone, this type of indoctrination based in fear shapes those individuals. The rightousnous and judgment of others that come from that upbringing can be clinical. If she has not healed from this indoctrination (brain washing) and McCain wins, and should something happen to him! God help us all. This is the most dangerous thing I have witnessed in politics in my lifetime! I don’t think the senator has done his homework on this one! Someone needs to do their homework on this one!

Bob
August 31, 2008 9:10 AM

"How can someone say they are Pro life and deny working mothers an equitable salary..?"

How can anyone (you) equivocate bad pay with killing babies? It's seems pretty obvious that one outweighs the other on the moral scale.

Annette
August 31, 2008 12:35 PM

Stop the Religious nonsense. We had the Republican Controlled Congress for 12 years, 6 of those years, with a Republican President, what did they do to stop Abortions? NOTHING! What makes anybody think there will be a change with McCain and Palin? I too am for LIFE, but, ALL LIFE. Since we elected a Republican President all we have known is WAR! In God's Eyes, do you think God only cares for the unborn babies of America, but doesn't care for the hundreds of thousands men, women and children killed in Iraq through a War created by your Republican President? Government cannot control Abortions, people's hearts must be changed, which comes from God and Him only. Instead of blaming the Government for the corruption in America, trying Reading God's Word to find the Truth. (Malachi-3-7-18) Religious Leaders rob God's Tithes and Offering while they lie to you, with their cheap grace religion, do nothing, just believe in the Name of Jesus, the Lie that removed all Fear of the Living God. The very devils believe in His Name and are as much christian as the average church member of today. (James-2-19-20) At least devils know to tremble before Holy God.
Want to see a Change in America? Get the devil and his false religious leaders Out of the Church! (11Thess-2-3-12)That the Truth of God's Word be heard Again in America! (Malachi-3-10-12)

Paul Mirski
August 31, 2008 5:23 PM

It's pretty simple. If you're pro abortion you ain't Catholic. Too bad Joe Biden, you're out.

lawhite
August 31, 2008 6:05 PM

Congress passes the laws on such things as abortion and other domestic issues. The Supreme Court judges whether the new laws are constitutional or not. The President has nothing to do with it. The subject of abortion is a red herring, not a real issue for presidential candidates.

Paul Maurice Martin
August 31, 2008 6:40 PM

In general, the Palin coverage has highlighted for me how little issues of governance count compared to "Do I like this person?" and "Does this person remind me of myself?" Maybe it's especially this way with VP candidates.

jos
August 31, 2008 11:16 PM

Does it matter if she was covering for her daughter, who was the one who really gave birth to Trig? Is it still a sin to lie? And WHEN do these wingnuts realize that abortion is NOT the president's issue, that foreign and domestic economic policies ARE, and Ms Palin is simply not ready to manage either? This country is full of uneducated boobs.

Tim
September 1, 2008 12:01 AM

The American Council of Catholic Bishops have released a statement calling on Catholics to vote on ALL the issues. While abortion is important, it is only one issue. The Bishops are clearly concerned with the Republican's Pro-War stance. The Vatican is clearly against the current war. So... it is no more inconsistent with Catholic teaching to vote for a Pro-choice OBAMA/BIDEN ticket than it is inconsistent with Catholic teaching to vote for a Pro-war McCain/Palin ticket.

eegor
September 1, 2008 11:08 AM

There is no issue more important than life. For anyone to dismiss any life as not worthy because of convenience is committing sin. There is no argument that makes it right to kill for convenience.

BeeJay
September 1, 2008 1:39 PM

The issue of life is at the central of this election. A Catholic running mate for a Pro-War Presidential candidate defies reason. The stance for Pro-War cancels out the individual belief about Pro-Life. This election has more important issues than what is ultimately between a woman and her GOD. Just as we choose to become Christians, we should let our conscience be pricked prior to making decisions of that magnitude. If we are so Pro-life, why do we have the Death Penalty. Killing is killing no matter what the arena.

suzie stephen
September 1, 2008 2:43 PM

I am a Catholic who is pro-choice support abstinence, ,sex education to prevent unwanted pregnancy ,disease and HIV. I am against war especially the one back up by lies and death penalty .I would never vote for somebody like Sarah Palin she is an hypocrite, fake like all the evangelical christian. Watch those kkk who will lynch people because of skin color or race I would like them to tell me what Christ they worship because My Jesus Christ is love and compassion merciful.This is why I said Merciful Jesus I trust in You

PS I am sorry for Bristol Palin her mother did not do the job to educate her about sex. Teenage pregnancy is a disaster for society. Thanks God it is pregnancy it could easily be Hiv.

Ike Mbonu
September 1, 2008 5:42 PM

The greatest wrath of God awaits those like the Fidelis Political Action Group that capitalizes on the very unsophiscated voters to convince them on voting for Politicians who leave children in dept and endless wars rather than those who will make America better.Their sins are worse than those of the Pharasees and Saducees of the Bible

Pro-life is all well and good but, thou shall not kill is only one of 10 commandments. And thou shall not kill is not limited to unborn babies. It also include death penalties, "collateral damages" of wars and even those who die for lack of medical insurance.

Bill Tiernan
September 1, 2008 9:12 PM

I am a pro-choice Catholic. It amazes me that those who are "for life", lead the charge to ban teaching of simple birth control to our young, and to ban programs promoting condoms and family planning education in third world areas ravaged by AIDS. Why are they afraid of teaching simple biological truths to prevent unwanted pregnancies and disease?

This mindset has caused more abortions of innocents and death from AIDS than "pro choicers" ever have.

Yet, pro-lifers smuggly label us "murderers". It is time our society decided whether abortion is a felony or a moral choice. If a felony, pro-lifers should be consistent and demand life imprisonment or the death penalty for frightened young pregnant females and their doctors and nurses...for they have committed pre-meditated first degree murder. If they lack the courage for such logic, they should stop telling me to vote for political parties advocating war around the globe.

Bill Tiernan
September 1, 2008 10:10 PM

As a a pro-choice Catholic, I am weary of being labeled a murderer by so-called "pro-lifers". They have suppressed teaching simple family planning and birth control, to both our own youth and AIDS-ravaged parts of the Third World. This stance has caused many abortions and misery.

If first term abortion is truly murder, the Far Right should be intellectually honest and call for life imprisonment for frightened young mothers who abort, on grounds that pre-meditated murder has been committed. If they cannot summon the courage to take this logical stance, let them stop insisting I vote for a political party who advocates waging war on other nations.

Pro-life they are definitely not.

Dave Henson
September 1, 2008 11:22 PM

All of you pro-choice people forget a major difference between abortion and the other causes you mentioned (war, death penalty.)

Abortion occurs on a helpless victim. The fetus has no choice in the matter, and no power to resist. The mother has all of the power. Is it fair or right of her to use it to terminate her child? Why couldn't she be more responsible in the first place, and not have sex if she didn't want to be pregnant. Or, why doesn't she carry to term and offer the child up for adoption? Are any of you aware of the long-term psychological effects of abortions on women?

In a war, both sides make decisions that escalate a conflict. Further, in this country, you are free not to join the military, thus making your own life safer. War is a necessary thing - the loss of life is usually worth the price of greater freedom and security the world over. Go ask a veteran of WW2 is the sacrifice was worth it. In Iraq, for example - Saddam Hussein could have complied with the UN resolutions. He could have come clean about his lack of WMDs. He could have allowed us or the UN to chase al-Qaeda out. He chose to resist, instead, and we had this war.

And the death penalty - there is no comparison to abortion. The death penalty is the ultimate punishment for taking a life. It is designed to be a deterrent to future would-be offenders. Do you think it's easy for an executive to order the death of someone? Do you think they don't understand the responsibility? And, it's perfectly consistent with a pro-life view. People who are executed could have prevented the entire ordeal in the first place, by not committing murder. A baby can't prevent being aborted by not being conceived - only a mother can do that.

Lastly - if you want to fight for abortion so hard, go for it. I'll be more concerned with Social Security, or taxes, or the military, or the economy. Besides, most Christian, right-wing people don't have abortions. Usually, only liberal left-wingers do. And I don't want them breeding and producing more liberals, so have all the abortions you want. And then, in about 20 years, when we greatly outnumber you, we will vote in the right people and remove all of this nonsense from being.

Fiona Black
September 2, 2008 12:57 AM

""I'm looking at him right now, and I see perfection. Yeah, he has an extra chromosome. I keep thinking, in our world, what is normal and what is perfect?" Palin

But if that same child had been born with a genetic quirk that made him/her gay, would MS. PALIN think he/she was PERFECT?
Quote:
"A... what does it say about natural selection when a species allows the portion of itself that harbors the most ignorant and repugnant ideologies (pro-life) to reproduce uncontrollably and it"s smartest most responsible side (pro choice) to die out. The pro-lifers are making litters. And because they believe in only teaching abstinence, the baby factory is self-perpetuating. Meanwhile, the pro-choicers are more educated, waiting longer and producing a more responsible numbers of children, ones that we commit to taking care of (instead of say, accepting a nomination for v.p when you have a special needs child, for example).

I suppose this is unlike China, where due to it"s one child policy, only the wealthy and well-connected are allowed to sneak in another kid.

I continue through the rainbow of emotions... from euphoria, to dread.

Fiona Black
September 2, 2008 1:00 AM

"Abortion occurs on a helpless victim. The fetus has no choice in the matter, and no power to resist. The mother has all of the power. Is it fair or right of her to use it to terminate her child?
"

RAPE also occurs on a helpless victim - for the most part. And if a pregnancy should result, both helpless victims, the unwilling helpless mother and the child suffer and the PROLIFERS insist that this is not grounds for abortion.

So forget about the helpless fetus, who by the way is as helpless as a tapeworm living in your gut. The fetus is a parasite, living off the mother and actually GROWS an entire new ORGAN, the PLACENTA to feed itself.

Fiona Black
September 2, 2008 1:30 AM

Can someone ask the GOvernor to have a tubal ligation please? No matter how happy she is to have a Down's Syndrome baby - may be his siblings won't be when it dawns on them that this will be their responsibility later on in life.

I am sure they will do the right thing, but why tempt fate? TUBAL LIGATION NOW FOR ALL LACTATING GOVERNORS!

Bill Tiernan
September 2, 2008 6:46 AM

In a televised debate, I recall Dan Quale, GHW Bush's Vice Presidential pick, asserting he was pro-life. When asked how he would counsel his young teenage daughter if she became pregnant out of wedlock, he replied he would be supportive of whatever she decided. I suspect 8o% of avowed pro-lifers would take this hypocritical stance. Talk is cheap.

This same voting bloc generally opposes head start programs, increased funding for public education, national health care, and most any other program to assist families and mothers in need. They call it "starving the beast of big government", and insist on borrowing from foreign nations to keep their taxes low. They do support vouchers for private schools for their own kids however, which would further weaken public schools.

Challenge a pro-lifer to say how much he personally donated last year to help unwed single mothers, and I can almost guarantee he will stammer some meaningless platitude and walk away.

God-o-Meter
September 2, 2008 9:36 AM

Paul writes:

If you're pro abortion you ain't Catholic. Too bad Joe Biden, you're out.

By pro-abortion, GOM presumes you mean pro-abortion rights. A recent TIME poll found that 59-percent of Catholics are pro-life. Does that mean that the other 41-percent are not really Catholic? Would the Catholic church take the same view, considering tens of millions of self-identifying Catholics to be mistaken?

notehound
September 2, 2008 6:04 PM

I think that Palin's poor judgment in accepting the nomination with an unwed pregnant daughter might be her undoing. She should step down "for the good of her family" in order to remove her daughter's extracurricular activities from the spotlight.
If McCain wanted a Pro-Life, Pro-Drilling, Anti-Earmark fiscal conservative, he should have picked a more conventional choice like former Congresswoman Melissa A. Hart of Pennsylvania. Plus, Melissa Hart is practicing Catholic - a plus in my book!
There's plenty of room under the bus with Obama's granny and Rev. Wright. It's a big bus.
Take one for the home team, Sarah... step down for the sake of the party!

Post a Comment

By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.



Please type the text you see in the box below to verify your post and help us prevent spam. You have a limited time to type - you may wish to compose your comment in a separate document and paste it here upon completion.

Type the characters you see in the picture above.

Advertisement

About God-o-Meter

This blog is no longer updated and is closed for comments. We welcome your comments about politics in our Politics forums.

The God-o-Meter (pronounced Gah-DOM-meter) scientifically measures factors such as rate of God-talk, effectiveness—saying God wants a capital gains tax cut doesn't guarantee a high rating—and other top-secret criteria (Actually, the adjustment criteria are here). Click a candidate's head to get his or her latest God-o-Meter reading and blog post. And check back often. With so much happening on the campaign trail, God-o-Meter is constantly recalibrating!

God-o-Meter blogger Dan Gilgoff is Beliefnet's Politics Editor. A former political correspondent for U.S. News & World Report, he is author of The Jesus Machine: How James Dobson, Focus on the Family, and Evangelical America are Winning the Culture War.

Search This Blog

Advertisement

Advertisement


About Beliefnet

Our mission is to help people like you find, and walk, a spiritual path that will bring comfort, hope, clarity, strength, and happiness. More about Beliefnet.

Legal

Copyright © Beliefnet, Inc. and/or its licensors. All rights reserved. Use of this site is subject to Terms of Service and to our Privacy Policy. Constructed by Beliefnet.

Advertisement

Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.