The monologue of the Religious Right is over and a new conversation has begun! Join the God's Politics dialogue with Jim Wallis and friends Brian McLaren, Diana Butler Bass, Becky Garrison, Gareth Higgins, Shane Claiborne, Mary Nelson, Gabriel Salguero, Tony Campolo, and others.

Get e-mail updates



About Jim Wallis
Read His Bio
Events
Press Coverage
Multimedia
Books
Get Sojourners

May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006

Subscribe
RSS Feed
On Beliefnet
Blog Heaven
Quizzes
Prayer of the Day
Inspiration
Meditations
Prayer Circles
Memorials
News & Society
Home
Huffington Post
Crooks and Liars
TalkingPointsMemo
Street Prophets
Andrew Sullivan
Cross Left
Think Progress
Emergent Village
Bene Diction Blogs On
Chuck Currie
Commonweal
Connexions
The Parish
Faith and Policy
Faith in Public Life
Faithful Progressive
First Born Son
Gathering in the Light
I Am a Christian Too
Imitatio Christi
Jesus Politics
Latino Leadership Circ.
Perspectives
PhaithofStphransus
Philocrites
Pomomusings
Prodigal Sheep
ProgressiveChristianAl
Public Theologian
Talk To Action
The Corner
The Wittenburg Door
Theoblogical
Waving or Drowning
Willzhead
XpatriatedTexan
 
 
 

Elizabeth Palmberg: Not So Fast

Last week Congress started to inject just a bit of sanity and morality into the discussion about proposed trade agreements with Colombia, Peru, Panama, and South Korea. A congressional proposal, whose full text has not been publicly released, would seek to incorporate labor standards, and some recognition of environmental concerns and poor countries’ right to generic lifesaving medicines, into trade agreements.

It’s a great start – but the House Ways and Means Committee Chairman, Charles Rangel, is signaling that he thinks Congress can work out a deal with the White House on those trade agreements soon, possibly as early as this week. That accelerated timetable is a spectacularly bad idea: There’s no way that the agreement texts, which are deeply flawed, can be fixed in so short a time. Here are a few reasons why:

1) In trade agreements, the devil is in the details. Who knew, when NAFTA was being considered, that a single phrase among the text’s hundreds of pages would give corporations the right to sue governments when health and environmental laws affected profits? (Hey, overworked congressional staffer – what part of “tantamount to expropriation” did you not understand?) It’s great to talk about labor, the environment, and essential medicines in a press release, but you can’t put all that in enforceable trade-agreement writing in a few weeks.

2) The congressional press release doesn’t mention many important problems with the current trade agreement model, including conventional trade agreements’ devastating effect on other countries’ small farmers (many of whom will be pushed to undocumented migration or coca farming in order to feed their families).

3) Current trade agreements are the result of a deeply flawed process, in which corporations get privileged input into negotiations, while advocates for the poor are shut out. No last-minute deal between Congress and the president can represent all the voices that need to be at the table.

So keep all of those affected by trade agreements in your prayers and thoughts – and watch for Sojourners’ special issue on trade justice, released next month!

(Note: Unlike normal bills, trade agreements are rejected or approved by Congress after they are negotiated by the executive branch; the fact that the president has signed the trade agreements with Colombia and Peru simply means he has sent them to Congress, not that they are a done deal).

Elizabeth Palmberg is an Assistant Editor for Sojourners.
 

Comments

Post a Comment

Are you aware of our Rules of Conduct?







 

 
Recent Posts
The Lion of the Senate (by Jim Wallis)
Things Fall Apart: Prayer Requests for South Africa and Zimbabwe (by Nontando Hadebe)
Daily News Digest (by Duane Shank)
'New Year Baby' Documents Khmer Rouge Survivors (by Anna Almendrala)
Why We Can’t Wait & Why We Must: The Radical Timing of God’s Movement (by Jonathan Wilson-Hartgrove)
Daily News Digest (by Duane Shank)
Senators Stall Bush's AIDS Relief (by Jim Wallis)
Video: Immigration Raids and Church Response (by Patty Kupfer)
Voice of the Day: Francis de Sales
Daily News Digest (by Duane Shank)
 
 
 

 
Explore Beliefnet
News & Society
Today's Headlines
Complete Politics Coverage

More Faith & Politics
Interview with Jim Wallis
Conservative Blogger Rod Dreher
Responding to a blog post? Read our Rules of Conduct first.