Gospel Soundcheck

Former Planetshakers' Michael Guglielmucci admits porn addiction, faking cancer

Monday August 25, 2008

Categories: Christian music news
The Planetshakers City Church in Melbourne, Australia has seen incredible growth since it founded in 2004, believing, as their website says, that "God has the power to transform and revolutionise the lives of all people, propelling them into their God-given...
Advertisement
Comments
Chris C
August 25, 2008 3:12 PM

As always Joanne, I appreciate your perspective! I'm amazed that it would even be possible to fake such a debilitating disease, and that such a supportive environment would know so little of his direct care. As you stated, someone would have to know about insurance coverage, a dr's name, visiting him in hospital stays (surely not every treatment would be an outpatient visit!!--SOMEthing!

I also agree completely that leaders of these large megaplex superdome churches tend to take attention away from their own message, and the followers are blinded. Maybe your next blog should be on Joel Osteen's wife :)

Dave Weiss
August 25, 2008 4:14 PM

This is sad and tragic. Please keep this guy in prayer.
I've had people fake these kinds of things on me but in a much more transparent (no one was fooled long) kind of way. It's a move of desperation coming out of a profound hurt. As to this being an indictment of the mega church, I am not sure that's the case. Sorry as a pastor I've been "lumped" too many times to go there. This will give us a black eye and make reaching out harder, but at the same time, we are all broken and we live in a fallen world with a powerful enemy who knows where we're weak. I think the best thing any of us in leadership (especially) can do is hold on to the Lord and realize almost no man is bullet proof on sexual sin. When we are tempted we need to take the way out. I will not sit in judgement of this man or his church. Instead I pray that he will get the help he needs and that his church will recover and be one of the few churches that doesn't shoot it's wounded.

Anonymous
August 25, 2008 4:23 PM

I agree that the "fame" style can be fun to live in and your aspects on what your really suppose to be doing CAN change; being that we are human. It is tempting but, its a mind conceptive that takes ahold of you and begins to forget in SOME cases the true reason of why your singing or worshpping God. But, what we as Christians need to realize is that God didnt come to condemened the world but to set it free and our dear friend Mike is a child of God just like us who God needed to set free and the truth is that he is. Yet, we must not criticize him for we are not God but, because he's not the only one strugging out there and it doensn't even matter the size of the church as well. For some pastors might be suffering the same thing as well and probably have a congregation of 30. The truth is there are alot of sheep that need help and our suffering but, are too scared to confess or just tell anybody what is there going through because of media or sites like this and we not being perfect as well should try to help because at some point in our lives we might need it as well.

David H
August 25, 2008 4:35 PM

What a powerful song? It is very hard to imagine that the deception was going unnoticed. I am sure that the family had to have questions about the secrecy and discrepancies in the lies. We are witnessing the aftermath of an ordeal that has probably unraveled behind closed doors for months. My heart goes out to Michael and especially his wife.
The words to the song are still true! It is God who reveals truth, and in the midst of the devastation that this family is facing, I am sure that Michael for the first time in months is turning to God in true repentance and brokenness. The Healing is now needed for his family and not cancer.
It for us to keep our eyes on Jesus, and not men. All leaders are just wretched sinners at best. We all needed a savior. He is getting his punishment for sure. I am on the side of puring out mercy on those who need mercy! This family needs mercy!!!!! Let's lift them up and not throw stones!!! He obviously recognizes his fault!!!!

In response to the comment about Victoria Osteen made by Chris C, I would like to point out that there is always another side of the story. I work for Continental Airlines in Houston, TX. The reported incident happened at my gate, C24. It was a flight headed to Washington, D.C., and the story from flight attendant differs from every other crew member on the gate that day. This entire ordeal was merely an attempt to exploit the Osteen family, and make some quick cash! The pilot of the aircraft even stated in court that if Victoria would have struck a flight attendant, Continental representatives would have escorted them off of the flight and notified police. It was Joel and Victoria that asked to be rebooked on the next flight. The media's story is absurd!!!!

Joanne Brokaw
August 25, 2008 5:34 PM

Dave, you're probably right. The two questions don't necessarily need to be linked.

I am bothered by the proliferation of mega church products, and in some way I think the huge ministries make it easier for someone to hide something like this - altho I can't believe he hid it all this time.

His bad behavior shouldn't necessarily be an indictment of his church. Just two issues that happened, today, to be on my mind at the same time.

PS: people, go over to today's posts to see Dave's visual art video
http://blog.beliefnet.com/gospelsoundcheck/2008/08/check-out-this-amazing-video-t.html

Joanne
host of the GS blog

Joanne Brokaw
August 25, 2008 5:38 PM

Dave, one more thing - you mention that you hope they don't shoot their wounded. I think they just erased him. He's completely gone from the website, and from what I've read the album with his song Healer was removed from the Planetshaker store.

Not sure how that all works or what they do next.

Joanne

SteveG
August 25, 2008 6:21 PM

Sad how some people are already looking for ways to make it all seem not all THAT bad. He worked a con to enrich himself, plain and simple. He should be prosecuted to the full extent of the law be ordered to pay full restitution.

Joanne Brokaw
August 25, 2008 7:13 PM

Oh, it's bad, Steve. That kind of deceit spoils everything and everyone he touched, even if it wasn't or they weren't involved in the lie. That church, the ministry, everything will have to deal with the fall out from this one.

Joanne
host of the GS blog

Kathleen
August 25, 2008 8:28 PM

As a former member of Planetshakers, I have to say that I sensed something was wrong with the church.

Going there was a bit intense. People working for the church would come around with drums for people to toss money into, as well as credit card slips so the church could make a transaction out of people's accounts. People would come up and proclaim they were healed of something, and most of the services were all about hype and not enough about educating the populus on the word of God.

The thing is, I won't deny that I was caught up in that hype, but once my eyes opened up to the money-grabbing and all that I left. To read this didn't surprise me much, as something seemed a little two-faced with Guglielmucci. All we can do is pray that he will see the error of his ways and be honest with himself.

Joel Wiggins
August 25, 2008 10:16 PM

I know what he did was wrong and i am a member of the edge church but who are we to judge we should just leave that up to God. people make mistakes maybe not to that extent but he is only human after all. most men have lustful thoughts at least once in there life unfortunately his were consistent for 16 years. but we just need to pray for his family so that they can come through this with there dignity still in tact.

Garret Cook
August 25, 2008 11:33 PM

I know all of this is crazy and completely wrong but at the same time we need to just forgive the man for we have all fallen short of the glory of God and SIN is SIN no one greater then the next. WE all just need to pray for Mike and make sure to keep our faith.

Tim
August 25, 2008 11:44 PM

Im sick of people like Kathleen who all of a sudden come out and say "i always thought something was a bit off" yeah sure as if u did! u would have said something, and please dont use public forums to trash the local church, i don't go to the planetshakers church but i live in the same city and they are doing great things for the kingdom, if u have a problem with them thats fine, maybe they're not ur flavour but don't be so spineless to kick them while they're down

barry
August 25, 2008 11:52 PM

I think as Michael has committed FRAUD on the public he should face the consequences of the law of the land.(I was at Acer Stadium concert, and it then did not look true)
He should be tried for blatent fraud and go to goal as have other fraudsters.
I think "praying" for forgiveness etc is a big cop-out, a deceipt of the people, and the church has a responsibility to uphold the law of the land, as we would say for any other abuse.
I cannot accept, the churches attempt to diminish the abuse of honesty,and truth.....just not good enough.

The Churches associated with this fraud, need accountability in the lands courts as well, re their involvement in defrauding thousands of citizens.

barry
August 25, 2008 11:57 PM

"Porn addiction" since age 12......that is a farce to try and use to excuse FRAUD....a nonsense. Its an insult to any one in psychology/medicine.Denial seems to be alive and well in your church.
You going to protect CRIMINAL behaviour with that excuse then test it in a court of law.

Ross
August 26, 2008 12:06 AM

We should take a hard look at the system that brings about this kind of deception and all that surrounds it. It is sad and I feel for the families caught up in this. To further this tragedy and shame is to belittle the issues with excuses of the devil temped me, etc.. Mike is responsable for his actions and should pay the price, Let the Grace of God show through as every person and organisation takes full responsibility for thier part in this while making ammends.

Ross
August 26, 2008 12:22 AM

Just to clarify, I was a victim of a church system that protected the Guilty Leaders of worse than what Mike did. How they respond and face up to responsability is how the community will judge this event.

c
August 26, 2008 1:35 AM

Mike is a sick man, but a good man. He has problems and we don't have the right to judge him, only God does. Yes, he will suffer the consequences of his actions, but don't judge him. We have no idea what he's really been through and going through.
As for Planetshakers City Church, Mike hasn't even lived in Melbourne since January 2007. Planetshakers is an incredible church. Ps Russell and Sam and all the pastors always point people to God first.
As for the deception, I don't know why we weren't granted the discernment to see what was really going on. The only thing I can say is that it truly must be God keeping our eyes closed to this, that's the only way I see possible for this to occur. All the church Mike was involved with have incredible leaders, people who know God and for some reason they weren't granted the discernment to know about this. God's in control.
Mike confessed, he was not found out. He did not try to deceive people for money, he was simply caught up in a web of lies that he himself created and saw no way out except to keep going with it or face the consequences, to face the truth, disappoint and shock his family and friends all over the world. He did the right thing. He did the hard thing. Pray for him, his soul, his family, his wife.
Love you Mike.

barry
August 26, 2008 3:13 AM

For Gods sake Mike conned thousands.....irrelevent about that issue eh?,murderers confess too, so lets forgive them...its irrelevent++,... the church perpetuated the "act" so well.....GIVE ME A BREAK!!! A crime was committed....he and his associates should be prosecuted....there should be NO excuses for any type of religious/racial group under the law. Child abuse in a church can also be excused bt praying for the perpetrator??? NO WAY.....their are victims.
Those good decent "christians" should demand the law do its job, in a democracy that we are so lucky to enjoy.

Planetshaker
August 26, 2008 3:52 AM

I would like to make 1 thing clear.

Michael Guglielmucci has not been a pastor at Planetshakers church for over 19 months, recently relocating to Sydney.

Michael and his wife & family need all our prayers and support as he comes through this time of pain and suffering.

By the grace of God he is forgiven, and set free of this terrible act.

Please don't judge, you are too a sinner.

me
August 26, 2008 4:49 AM

Amazing. I have watch this family along with other "superstar" pastors, totally wipe people off when they have stuffed up in their personal lives. I have seen first hand and expierenced the bullying from these pastors. People being kicked out of churches and loosing friends over night because these pastors have told people to have nothing more to do with them. Leaving peoples lives shattered.
NOW one of their own does the wrong (and worse than any of these others that I am talking about). And what do we hear. Forgive. I just goes to show, its not what you know.. but who you know/ are that matters. Even in the church.

Ronnie Williams
August 26, 2008 5:39 AM

I guess this makes Pastor Mike a 'porn again' Christian!
He can redeem himself by paying attention to the following Australian inspirational song: "Why Don't Bees Go to Heaven?".

Rissa
August 26, 2008 7:04 AM

Just because his family are mega-church celebrities does not make him a good or innocent man. While I do believe that Mike is mentally ill, i do not believe that his family and wife could have no idea as to his deceit - unless they were in denial over his illness. I believe perhaps that his family helped hide his illness through their own shame and therefore enabled him to continue his deceit.
I hope that they as a family get the help that they need and that Mike finds his path and becomes well. I hope that their church rallies around them and supports them.

gordon filingcabinet.
August 26, 2008 8:25 AM

Barry... I STRONGLY recommend you reconsider your stance on this issue. Pray about it, and see how God changes your heart on this issue and other issues like it. Don't just jump out there and judge those involved. It's not your or my place to question another man's place with the Lord. What gives you the right to call question Mike and his family's place with the Lord? This news just goes to show how we all are human and we are sinners. Your comment would be valid if you could HONESTLY say that you NEVER HAVE and NEVER WILL lie in your life. Hierarchy of sin is man made - So I recommend you uphold Mike in prayer now, rather than posting hateful, judgmental comments to his situation.

Michael Austin
August 26, 2008 8:30 AM

I reckon Mike Guglielmucci is such an awesome man of God. I forgive him. I love him as a brother, and I reckon you all should too. If you feel you can't, ask God to help you to find it in your heart to do so. 100% everyone in Australia are liers and therefore are in the same boat. Mike is just a high profile so he suffers more for it.

Mike.

PS - Mike you're NOT a douchebag.

Ewan
August 26, 2008 8:37 AM

I'm sick of all the people who keep telling us "don't judge". It's true we can't judge motives but we can judge actions and clearly his actions were wrong.

Ewan
August 26, 2008 8:46 AM

To gordon filingcabinet. So you think sins like murder, rape, child molestation, etc., are morally equivalent to jay-walking? Give us a break.

Joanne Brokaw
August 26, 2008 8:54 AM

Thanks for clearing up that fact, Planetshaker. In all the news reports I read (and I read a lot yesterday!) no one mentioned whether or not he was working at the church at the time this happened. There isn't a mention of him at all on the Planetshaker's site, and I read in another story that was because his name had been taken off not only the site but any info about album credits for songs he'd written, and that album with Healer had been taken out of the Planetshaker store.

Appreciate that info!

Joanne
host of the Gospel Soundcheck blog

Planetshakers Insider
August 26, 2008 9:25 AM

The commenter by the name of "Planetshaker" is not 100% correct...

They're almost correct, but some important details are missing.

Mike Guglielmucci left Planetshakers 18 months ago (not 19) - However, this was still several months after his cancer deception began.

It was in January 2007 after the Planetshakers conference was over, and after "Healer" had been performed there (with a live album and DVD of this performance recorded).

Yes, the deception continued long after he left - but it began in the final few months of Mike Guglielmucci's time at Planetshakers. So it is wrong to claim that Planetshakers was not involved because the deception began AT Planetshakers.

It is correct to say that Mike Guglielmucci left the covering of Planetshakers in January 2007 though.

Planetshakers has since tried to distance itself from Mike Guglielmucci.

They have removed references to Mike Guglielmucci from their web-site that relate to his work as a prolific songwriter - accounting for MOST of the songs on MOST of the albums Planetshakers has released in the past 4 years.

And in church services, they repeated two claims several times:

1) "Nobody / none of this knew this was happening - not even his wife and family", and;

2) "Mike Guglielmucci left Planetshakers a long time ago" ...but not long enough that Planetshakers was not involved.

It's now more than ever that we need to be wary of the lies and half-truths of the enemy.

Joanne Brokaw
August 26, 2008 9:52 AM

Planetshakers Insider - are you the host of the Planetshaker Insider blog? You had a ton of really great information on the blog:
http://planetshakersinsider.wordpress.com/

Thanks for sharing info, and please feel free to share again! Clearly, you know more about this than I do, so your input is appreciated.

Joanne
host of the Gospel Soundcheck blog

Gabriel
August 26, 2008 10:11 AM

Ewan, no matter how one looks at it, sin is sin. gordon was right in saying that the hierarchy of sin is man-made. All of us are sinners - no matter how good we lived our lives. That is the reason why Jesus paid the price! Jesus died for all sin and we are all forgiven. That is the whole reason why many have chosen to forgive Mike. I believe that Mike will ultimately be judged for what he has done, but he has been forgiven and set free - and we should do the same.

I'm also disgusted at how some of the 'former members' of Planetshakers City Church choose times like these to 'reinforce' their claims that the church "is a bit off." Planetshakers City Church has always made it clear that nobody is under compulsion to give their money. The study of the Word has always been part of the life of the church. Perhaps the 'former member' really only got caught in the hype and did not actually attend the church's membership formation classes.

Mike, as Christ has forgiven you, I also forgive you. I do not condone your sin but because you were brave to admit your sin and choose to accept the consequences and change, I believe you will find forgiveness.

Michael shorey
August 26, 2008 11:01 AM

Ok so when i hearld that he had cancer i was so touched and was upset but amazed how he was coping. Now that i have found out that it is i lie i dont hate him or the song that he wrote. I think that at a time like this we need to think why he done this and i no it says that he has an addictoin. But i think there is more to it then that i still think he loves jesus because of the song and we must hate the sin but we need to remember to love the sinner and continue to pray for healing mental now then phsicaly and at the end off the day who r we to judge lets leave that up to the big guy .

Ps Khim Ang
August 27, 2008 10:56 PM

It is so sad that this happened. Coming from South East Asia, where our young people are so influenced by the culture of PlanetShakers and others like Hillsong, you cannot comprehend the damage it does to our efforts to reach the lost.
1st, the reputation of our God is tarnished
2nd, it is ammunition for those against Christians to throw accusations at the cjurch.
3rd, even without the scandal, the kind of music culture that makes many Asian Christians uncomfortable but reluctantly accept because of the youths that "worship" it,will be regarded with even greater suspician.It causes a great divide between the older and younger generation.
4th, It makes witnessing to the unsaved a more uphill task.
What should we do after all this?
1. Pray for the gift of discernment from God to operate more.
2. Be less gullible. Do a check-up of claims. We have the same people problem but a simple quiet check on the person has saved us from many fraudulent claims.
3.

Jane Bradley
August 28, 2008 5:12 AM

Please tell Mr. Guglieucci, if no one already has, that there's a wonderful program, with a spiritual foundation, that can help him.

It's called Sex & Love Addicts Anonymous
There are also Sex Addicts Anonymous, and
Sexaholics Anonymous

I am a member of one of these, and have received amazing help in two years, after many years of expensive and time consuming psychotherapy which did little to help me.

Details can be found of websites, and if he wishes to remain anonymous, all meetings are bound by anonymity - no one speaks outside the group abt who is there or what is said. If he requires even further anonymity, he can join an online group, but I have no personal experience of them, and they may be less effective.

Many people in these groups had troubled families or problems unresolved in childhood, or too-early exposure to sexual information for which they were not ready or mature enough. I will pray for you, and know that God can help.

All the very best to all your family in this difficult time. JB

Joanne Brokaw
August 28, 2008 9:06 AM

Ps Khim Ang - thanks for that great input from SE Asia. Those are great points.

Joanne
host of the GS blog

SteveG
August 28, 2008 9:10 AM

Too many people in Blogs all over the net seem to be confusing 2 concepts.

'Forgiveness of sin' is not synonymous with 'Not having to deal with the consequences' - (for want of a better term).

Absolutely Mike should be forgiven by man and has been forgiven by God (assuming repentance). But there are earthly consequences to his actions and they will be dealt with in one way or another.

So...

Forgiven? - Yes
Getting off scot-free? No

Pat
August 28, 2008 9:15 AM

Wow. Those last few comments came out from left field.

Though, it's not surprising to see Christians take any chance they can to tear each other down.

Joanne Brokaw
August 28, 2008 10:09 AM

Pat, I don't know which comments you're talking about that came from left field.

The one that says when a well-known ministry suffers something like this it damages not only their reputation but makes it harder for Christians living in areas of the world not open to Christianity and gives nonbelievers fuel for the "all Christians are hypocrites" argument? Or the one that says we should forgive him but he should have to pay for his deceit? Those are the last few comments I see.

I don't see anyone tearing each other down. Those are both very valid issues, and I think the commenter from SE Asia makes an excellent point. We forget that there are places in the world where Christianity isn't accepted happily, but tolerated at best and persecuated at worst. Those in the government are looking for any chance to persecute or remove that tolerance.

And honestly, we can offer all the sympathy for someone's who has screwed up royally (and be grateful for that same sympathy when we screw up ourselves), but none of us gets off scott free from the consequences. Michael Guglielmucci deceived people. I don't know about laws in Australia, but I would guess that there is some legal ramification for fraud. Should he not have to answer to those?

If I've got the wrong comments that you're referring to, let me know.

Joanne
host of the Gospel Soundcheck blog

Jan Marè
August 28, 2008 2:10 PM

"Forgive those who trespass against you". Matt 6:12

Mike, you are forgiven! Who are we to condemn?

Joanne Brokaw
August 28, 2008 2:16 PM

Jan Mare - go read his own words, and then tell me what you think:

http://blog.beliefnet.com/gospelsoundcheck/2008/08/michael-guglielmucci-talks-abo.html#comments

Joanne
host of the GS blog

Brad
August 28, 2008 3:24 PM

After much thought and consideration on the issue at hand, I sat back and realized that maybe Mike Guglielmucci wasnt praying for his healing of cancer like he asked but rather than his isses with his pornography addictions. Here is a man who is in a very powerful leadership role, leading others, mentoring others, praying for others, and just listening to others. Satan must have been doing battle with him daily and we all know that Satan can be a very powerful opponent. I wonder how many times, that Mike Guggliemucci wondered who would understand his problems. Satan problem invaded his mind, heart, and soul, telling him that know one would care or even understand how a man like this could fall to such terrible addiction. Sometimes when we are backed into corners we lie, steal, destroy and even hurt others not realy meaning to. I don't think Mike intentionally did this. I think that Satan was such a powerful force and Mike made up a lie and his lie went to far. That is exactly what Satan wanted to happen. Satan wants everyone to look bad upon Mike. Instead, we as Christians need to embrace Mike, love Mike, PRAY for Mike's TRUE HEALING and help Mike and his family to come back from this mighty attack. We all have been in a similar situation as Mike. We need to pray for warrior angels to surround everyone who is close to Mike or has some connection with Planetshakers or Hillsong. He is still true and he will see everyone through this time of grief. Let us all remember that God is the same Yesterday, Today, and Forever. One day, Mike can stand a say for certain that He is healed and that God truly is his HEALER and God is all he needs. We are human and God forgives us know matter what.

For those Christians out there who are trying to oust Mike and criticize him remember:

Matthew 7: 1-6

Judge not, that ye be not judged.

2 For with what judgment ye judge, ye shall be judged: and with what measure ye mete, it shall be measured to you again. Mk. 4.24

3 And why beholdest thou the mote that is in thy brother's eye, but considerest not the beam that is in thine own eye?

4 Or how wilt thou say to thy brother, Let me pull out the mote out of thine eye; and, behold, a beam is in thine own eye?

5 Thou hypocrite, first cast out the beam out of thine own eye; and then shalt thou see clearly to cast out the mote out of thy brother's eye.

6 ¶ Give not that which is holy unto the dogs, neither cast ye your pearls before swine, lest they trample them under their feet, and turn again and rend you.

Brad
August 28, 2008 3:24 PM

After much thought and consideration on the issue at hand, I sat back and realized that maybe Mike Guglielmucci wasnt praying for his healing of cancer like he asked but rather than his isses with his pornography addictions. Here is a man who is in a very powerful leadership role, leading others, mentoring others, praying for others, and just listening to others. Satan must have been doing battle with him daily and we all know that Satan can be a very powerful opponent. I wonder how many times, that Mike Guggliemucci wondered who would understand his problems. Satan problem invaded his mind, heart, and soul, telling him that know one would care or even understand how a man like this could fall to such terrible addiction. Sometimes when we are backed into corners we lie, steal, destroy and even hurt others not realy meaning to. I don't think Mike intentionally did this. I think that Satan was such a powerful force and Mike made up a lie and his lie went to far. That is exactly what Satan wanted to happen. Satan wants everyone to look bad upon Mike. Instead, we as Christians need to embrace Mike, love Mike, PRAY for Mike's TRUE HEALING and help Mike and his family to come back from this mighty attack. We all have been in a similar situation as Mike. We need to pray for warrior angels to surround everyone who is close to Mike or has some connection with Planetshakers or Hillsong. He is still true and he will see everyone through this time of grief. Let us all remember that God is the same Yesterday, Today, and Forever. One day, Mike can stand a say for certain that He is healed and that God truly is his HEALER and God is all he needs. We are human and God forgives us know matter what.

For those Christians out there who are trying to oust Mike and criticize him remember:

Matthew 7: 1-6

Judge not, that ye be not judged.

2 For with what judgment ye judge, ye shall be judged: and with what measure ye mete, it shall be measured to you again. Mk. 4.24

3 And why beholdest thou the mote that is in thy brother's eye, but considerest not the beam that is in thine own eye?

4 Or how wilt thou say to thy brother, Let me pull out the mote out of thine eye; and, behold, a beam is in thine own eye?

5 Thou hypocrite, first cast out the beam out of thine own eye; and then shalt thou see clearly to cast out the mote out of thy brother's eye.

6 ¶ Give not that which is holy unto the dogs, neither cast ye your pearls before swine, lest they trample them under their feet, and turn again and rend you.

Joanne Brokaw
August 28, 2008 3:54 PM

Brad,

On the point about Guglielmucci perhaps praying for healing of his other problems instead of cancer, I actually agree with you on that. The song is generic enough in it's lyrics that the healing could apply to anyone. And he is truly emotional when he sings, so I would agree that he could be singing of his own internal need for healing, spiritually and mentally. The only thing that gives me pause is that when you listen to him talk on the video - and in this case all you have is my transcription - he says that he wrote the song after getting the diagnosis of cancer. Big, fat lie.

As to the "The Devil made me do it" defense: I'm sorry, but I'm sick and tired of Christian who willingly and knowingly do bad things and then turn around and say Satan made me do it. You "don't think Mike intentionally did this" - you're kidding, right? LOL Because I'm pretty sure Satan didn't show up at the event venue with an oxygen tank for him. Guglielmucci had to go get that for himself, which took planning and forethought.

I don't mean to be venomous about this, honest I don't. But I saw that video and heard him speaking about getting his diagnosis, and going through his fictitious treatment, and being at the Hillsong event and being in pain and forging on ... and I'm sorry, it made me really, really angry. Have you ever been sitting with a doctor and had him tell you that your test results might indicate a terminal disease? Do you know someone really dying of cancer? How many ministries are tarnished because of that lie? How much more fodder did he give to the nonbeliever who already thinks Christians are hypocrites?

Yes, we need to pray for him. The man is sick - physically and spiritually. Yes, his confession was incredibly brave, knowing what the fall out would be. (I wonder, though, what prompted it ...) But I'm not going to make excuses for him, not after watching him talk on the video about how he battled a fictitious terminal illness by worshipping God. Sorry, we don't worship God by lying.

If you haven't already, you can go here and read the transcript of Guglielmucci talking, in his own words, about getting his cancer diagnosis and being anointed by God at the Hillsong event:
http://blog.beliefnet.com/gospelsoundcheck/2008/08/michael-guglielmucci-talks-abo.html

Joanne
GS blog host

Brother Philip
August 28, 2008 4:47 PM

Hi ALL;

Lots of opinion here, but not much Scripture.

We should all be interested in what difference, if any, there is, between what Mike believes and what Hillsong preaches.

Hillsong teaches that it is WE who make a difference in the world:

In Hillsong’s Solution lyrics it’s all about our hands and feet.
We are the hands and feet of God.
We are the solution.
This is nothing more than the lie of Satan (2Thes. 2:9);
which would have us showing ourselves as God (2:4);
This is nothing but the mystery of iniquity @ work (2:7);
Rather than be into this self-glory,
we should be in the glory of our Lord Jesus Christ (2:14);
We have hope through grace, NOT this delusion (2:16 & 11).

In Hillsong’s Break Free lyrics, God will never hold us back,
so break free. Why don’t you break free.
Get up and dance in His love.
This is not what the Scriptures say:
For the word of God tells us that
JESUS Christ needed to MAKE us free (Gal. 5:1);
And this freedom is to love (5:13);
AND to love is to speak the truth (Eph. 4:15; 1Cor. 13:6).
I don’t see singing and dancing herein!

InHillsong’s Lead Me To The Cross lyrics, their cross is all about
Christ crucified without us crucified with Him (Gal. 2:20).
Christ crucified without us crucified with Him
frustrates the grace of God (Gal. 2:20-21).

We are not sufficient,
it is the grace of God that is sufficient (2Cor. 12:9);
AND if it is grace then it is no more works,
otherwise it would not be grace (Rom. 11:6).
It is grace, NOT we in our works, which makes the difference!
Those who fail this doctrine of God @work,
fall as Mike has done, and do so by their own works.

My guess is that they Hillsong and Mike are on the same page;
and their page, as we can now see,
is very different from the word of God.

When Christianity is measured by what we can do
instead of what God is doing;
God makes us fail,
so that everyone can see that we have fallen from grace.

Hillsong has failed the grace of God;
And we shall see it,
and all who follow it’s faulty example FALL.

GOD is JUDGING.

Joanne Brokaw
August 28, 2008 4:53 PM

Not sure if you all saw this, but just so you don't think I'm putting words in Guglielmucci's mouth:

Video of him on Australia's Today Tonight
http://blog.beliefnet.com/gospelsoundcheck/2008/08/guglielmuccis-confession-on-au.html

My transcript of 7 minutes of him talking on the new Hillsong video about his cancer diagnosis, and how he battled his illness by worshipping God
http://blog.beliefnet.com/gospelsoundcheck/2008/08/michael-guglielmucci-talks-abo.html

Joanne
host of the Gospel Soundcheck

Michelle
August 28, 2008 11:45 PM

I am not an avid fan of Planetshakers nor will I say that I have been following this story extremely closely.

However, I will say that him coming forward and make public his faults, and as a man with a reputation, thousands of fans and so on, is truly a brave move. We all make mistakes, some big and others small. And when it all comes down to it, we can only hope that others will forgive.

Perhaps we should learn to forgive, and let God do the judging. For in the end, we are answerable to no one but Him. Why he did what he did, no one may know, but if He turns back to God and makes right his ways, then I believe he is a true testimony of a sinner saved.

MAN
August 29, 2008 7:05 AM

Please allow me to repeat what I said…
“LEADER?” “LEADERSHIP”?????!!!
IS THAT IN THE BIBLE????

Just wondering,
the word “LEADER” how many times was it mentioned in the NEW (Jesus) TESTAMENT,
1-The KJV/NKJV/ASV/NIV I found NONE,
BUT in other translations I found a mention to the word leader couple of times and here it is:
-Mt 23:10 “Do not be called leaders; for One is your Leader, that is, Christ.
- Lu 22:26 “BUT IT IS NOT THIS WAY WITH YOU, but the one who is the greatest among you must become like the youngest, and the leader like the SERVANT.
Well now we understand that Jesus did not come to recruit leaders….leadership maniacs, you wanna be a leader because off course you are TALENTED, FIND somewhere else to show off but not in the house of PRAYER.

BY the way, I here you asking, the word “SERVANT”, how many times was mentioned in “GRACE (NEW) TESTAMENT..you wouldn’t believe it!! Mr. “me me me I wanna be a leader in the church because I am talented”…..WHAT?!!
1- in KJV is 79 times
2- in NKJV is 80 times.
3- The American Standard Version 82times.
4- in NIV is 97 times
5- The Good News Translation 106 times!!!!!!
WATDDAA??!!!! 2:106

Was that an accident?! well Jesus did not come to recruit “talented/awesome/handsome/gifted..etc LEADERS”
HE (Jesus)discipled his followers to SERVE SERVE SERVE
IN HUMILITY depending completely on their ONLY LEADER, JESUS THE SERVANT KING…..

STOP LEADING THIS LIFE STYLE BY SERVING AND ONLY SERVING…

A LEADER has followers, and when he falls……!

It would have been much better, if they followed the only MASTER AND a LEADER….the one that said “”"Which of you convinceth me of sin? And if I say the truth, why do ye not believe me?”"John 8:46

here is THE true leader that was not believed…
and here is a fraud that every one believed…..Irrrronic…!!

I think what happened recently confirms the credibility of THE ONLY LEADER…
when he said Matthew 24:24 “For false Christs and false prophets will appear and perform great signs and miracles to deceive even the elect–if that were possible.”

IT IS A SIGN FOR HIS SECOND COMING!! here is a positive for what happened…
also the only teacher “LEADER” said:
IN Matthew 24:19 “How dreadful it will be in those days for pregnant women and nursing mothers! ”

Is that literally??? or may be he meant the vulnerable like the youth and that are not taught proper biblical teaching from Church Servants…

PLEASE READ MATTHEW 24. it is good..
Read it just read it… MATTHEW 24
A Saved sinner!
ans embarrassed Christian

Joanne Brokaw
August 29, 2008 9:48 AM

Man -

That's a great point for us to think about. I've always been bothered by the "worship leader". Several of the worship artists that I have interviewed and whom I respect have all emphasised their role as servant to others, not center stage - like Paul Baloche (you can read that interview excerpt with him
http://blog.beliefnet.com/gospelsoundcheck/2008/08/my-interview-with-paul-baloche.html)


Joanne
host of the GS blog

Brother Philip
August 29, 2008 2:50 PM

Hi MAN;


YOU ASK:
Please allow me to repeat what I said…
“LEADER?” “LEADERSHIP”?????!!!
IS THAT IN THE BIBLE????
Just wondering,
the word “LEADER” how many times was it mentioned in the NEW (Jesus) TESTAMENT,
1-The KJV/NKJV/ASV/NIV I found NONE,

Thank you for the opportunity to answer your question is the concept of Christian leadership in the Bible?

ANSWER: YES!

A synonym of leader is RULER: Strong’s Greek # 4291. This word is used in the context of the ministry of teaching. Wherein those who are being taught are being ruled over (Rom. 12:7-8). This rule is in full accordance with GRACE (12:6). This rule is acceptable unto God, because it is within the reasonable service (12:1). This word for service would be better translated as worship. Those who are serving God are given rule over those who do not know how to serve God. While there are many members in the one body, NOT all members have the same OFFICE (12:34). Grace therefore allows for an officer, who has leadership/rule over others.

The whole concept of leadership is found in leading, and those who lead are followed. The evidence that there are leaders in the body of Christ is true if we can find men of God being followed: Wherein we should KNOW how to follow those who behave orderly (2Thes. 3:7). These have the power [leadership] to present themselves as examples unto those who should then follow their commands (3:9-10). Which commands are in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ (3:12). If anyone does not obey these commands have nothing to do with them, for they should be ashamed (3:14). Admonish them to see their shame! (3:15-14). All of this is in the grace of our Lord Jesus Christ (3:18).

Remember those who have rule over us are those who speak the word of God to us [without errors], whose faith we should follow (Heb. 13:7). This truth has always been the same, and shall always be the same, even for ever (13:8). Without which YOU are in some strange doctrine, which cannot establish YOU in grace (13:9). God is well pleased with those who have this rule over others: AND we should submit ourselves to this rule, which is the watch that is appointed over our souls, and which is accountable to God (13:16-17). YOU should be praying for these rulers (13:18). I therefore plead with YOU to suffer these words of exhortation, which I have now written unto YOU (13:22).

I plead with YOU again, BROTHER, YOU need to know someone who can rule over you in the Lord, who can admonish YOU (1Thes. 5:12). These rulers should be esteemed very highly for their work, which exhorts the brethren, and warns the who are without rule [the unrulable;- the unruly] (5:14).

Another word for these rulers, who are leaders, is BISHOP. This is where leader-SHIP comes from. The office of bishop is one of teaching (1Tim. 3:1-2). Those in this rule are those who are taking care of the church of God (3:5). These men have servants who execute their commands beneath them, who are herein called deacons (3:8). These men work together, so that others might know how to behave in the church of God (3:15). These rulers are also called elders, who are worthy of double honor, if they are laboring in the word with doctrine (1Tim. 5:17).

IN CONCLUSION:

YOU SAID: It would have been much better, if they followed the only MASTER AND a LEADER….the one that said “”"Which of you convinceth me of sin? And if I say the truth, why do ye not believe me?”"John 8:46
I SAY: You cannot be following JESUS, if you are not under the above rule, which has been appointed in the name of Jesus Christ our Lord. The only outstanding question is: Seeing that I have set forth the truth, which is against your error, can YOU believe this truth?


Blessings in His grace through this mercy,
which has the full authority that should not be despised (Tit. 2:15).


MAN
August 29, 2008 9:52 PM

Hi Brother Philip..
Is the Concept of Christian leadership in the Bible?
WAS THAT MY QUESTION?! Brother Philip???? No Brother Philip....

BUT thank you for answering your OWN question "Is the Concept of Christian leadership in the Bible?"

And your answer is flawless, and biblical...

I can see you are a leader, teacher or from the brethren church...correct me!!!

from your writing I see that you missed the whole point..

it is very important to teach the concept of Christian leadership, as the bible taught, instead of encouraging church goers to chase a title that fulfills personal ambition and self gratification, which is very very evident in churches this days when teaching the Concept of Christian leadership is not taught..

Service is an act of worship, yes, as well as to lead by the holy spirit when it is with a serving attitude (heart)..

also you as well go back to your bible, and find also the verses that talks about the requirements for the "leaders" according to Paulus's teaching.

In Love I say,

WRONG answer for a legitimate question. OR RIGHT answer for the wrong question..

Laughable

MAN
August 29, 2008 9:53 PM

Hi Brother Philip..
Is the Concept of Christian leadership in the Bible?
WAS THAT MY QUESTION?! Brother Philip???? No Brother Philip....

BUT thank you for answering your OWN question "Is the Concept of Christian leadership in the Bible?"

And your answer is flawless, and biblical...

I can see you are a leader, teacher or from the brethren church...correct me!!!

from your writing I see that you missed the whole point..

it is very important to teach the concept of Christian leadership, as the bible taught, instead of encouraging church goers to chase a title that fulfills personal ambition and self gratification, which is very very evident in churches this days when teaching the Concept of Christian leadership is not taught..

Service is an act of worship, yes, as well as to lead by the holy spirit when it is with a serving attitude (heart)..

also you as well go back to your bible, and find also the verses that talks about the requirements for the "leaders" according to Paulus's teaching.

In Love I say,

WRONG answer for a legitimate question. OR RIGHT answer for the wrong question..

Laughable

Brother Philip
August 30, 2008 1:21 PM

Hi Laughable MAN;

A very good attempt to deflect the truth, which came against your error. Let me give it [your error] to you again, so that you can come clean, because spin is sin.

YOU SAID: AND THIS WAS YOUR MAJOR POINT:
-Mt 23:10 “Do not be called leaders; for One is your Leader, that is, Christ.
Well now we understand that Jesus did not come to recruit leaders…. wanna be a leader[s].

DID YOU SEE THAT: Don’t be called leaders; only Christ is leader.
YOU ADDING AGAIN: IN HUMILITY depending completely on their ONLY LEADER, JESUS THE SERVANT KING…..
IN CONCLUSION YOU DIRECT: STOP LEADING.

IN answer to your error I said the concept of Christian leadership is in the Bible, and then answered that statement with the Scripture.


FINALY YOU OPINE: “it is very important to teach the concept of Christian leadership, as the bible taught, instead of encouraging church goers to chase a title that fulfills personal ambition and self gratification, which is very very evident in churches this days when teaching the Concept of Christian leadership is not taught..”

I did not see any of this is your first communication. However, I do find it strange that you love to opine rather than use the Scriptures to make your point. The problem with this [your stated opinion] is the Bible is not against ministers being gratified with their work (2Cor. 8:9), nor is it against us having the ambition to lead others (1Tim. 3:1). Paul even adding that it is a good thing to have a zealous desire for spiritual gifts, so that we could excel in the deification of the church (1Cor. 14:1 & 12). Amazingly Paul says that we can even COVET EARNESTLY the best gifts (12:31).

Notwithstanding, I do get your minor point, there is a danger that many in leadership do allow their ego’s to get into the business at hand. But the Lord is much more interested in what is being said than any amount of smugness. King David was a teacher of a whole nation, and as long as he was dealing with his sin between him and God, God was not overly interested in his inflated ego. In time even this was adjusted.

I do hope that you can see that the importance of correct teaching is the main leading of God in Christ, now that people believe in Jesus. May I suggest that you don't look at the outward FIRST AND FORMOST, and rejoice in the word of God that is coming out of their mouths, which is for the grace and the glory of God. I know that personality traits can rub us up the wrong way, but we have to get past this, and look to the message FIRST AND FORMOST. I believe that Jesus wanted this more than anything Himself. I know that I do too, and I believe that you are herein interested also.

Blessings in forbearance, and patience, because God is strong, and willing to suffer with us for a long time.

EPS> No, sorry, I am not part of the BRETHREN movement. I'm in leadership, as the managing director of a Christian foundation for the education of the church, and body of our Lord Jesus Christ.

Just call myself BROTHER Philip, because believers called one another BROTHERS AND BRETHREN in the Bible.

Didn’t come to faith in the church, came to faith reading the word of God, then ministered the truth to the church. The grace of God abounding, so that I can minister to all churches, because of the message not the denomination. Don’t expect believers to like me at first, because the message gets to them, but in time, God willing, enemies can become friends. Sorry if I am getting to you, but it was not me, it’s the MESSAGE.

In much love in the truth for your edification.

MAN
August 31, 2008 8:34 AM

Brother Fil,

Again I find you answering your self-made question..this is not laughable..that is sad...
________________________________
You said "I do find it strange that you love to opine rather than use the Scriptures to make your point" Actually I did in my first post..
__________________________________
You said "N CONCLUSION YOU DIRECT: STOP LEADING."..is that What I said?? .....??
again you are manipulating what I said so you can create an argument for yourself to win...

Again I see you SPINNING and SINING as you said before...
______________________________________
And for a minister of religion or similar like you self, I feel embarrassed and ashamed for you Buddy, Manipulating what I said = not telling the truth = Lying = that's not honorable at all B. Fil

and let me ask u 1 Q, d you really need to create an enemy first to have a friend...I do not need 2b your enemy, but you want,,,y? is that a pattern you follow in building ur relationships with others???

Suggesting you are from the brethren Church -Not because "Brother Philip" but it was from the way you wrote- was actually a compliment that you probably did not value or may be deserved...
------------------------------------------------------------
My prayer would not be for you to have more knowledge, which any one can have, or not for revelation as you can ask for yourself...but for the unblocking of the impaired intelligence, so you see that U R answering a questions that was not asked from anyone but yourself...

God bless your heart!
-----------------------------------------------------------------
ALSO
-Mt 23:10 “Do not be called leaders; for One is your Leader, that is, Christ.
- Lu 22:26 “BUT IT IS NOT THIS WAY WITH YOU, but the one who is the greatest among you must become like the youngest, and the leader like the SERVANT.
was that my own sayings, or the saying of you "Buddy"?!
___________________________________________-
It is because of people with an attitude like yours teaching the word of God, believers lead for the wrong reasons....
________________________________________________
I am sorry if I deflated your inflated ego with my first post, may be U felt threatened???!! that was not intended anyway it is only in your mind...do not take it personal buddy seriously
PLEASE PRAY 4 ME FIRST AND FOREMOST, not to get frustrated next time seeing you insist to answer the wrong question.....or not quoting completely what I said...

Honestly I am just embarrassed to have such a conversation

Have enough sleep Buddy "will help"


Locke
September 1, 2008 9:23 AM

I think you make a good case for the whole church-as-commerce thing. If you watch the video of him singing with the tube in his nose, you'll notice that the shots of the audience show only the "beautiful people", especially the women. They are all beautiful, and not a single ugly person made it into the video.

Does that make us think?

Brother Philip
September 1, 2008 1:43 PM

Hi MAN;

Nothing in the Spirit here, just a MAN likened after mocking MAN. Now there are MEN who are full of railing and anger abounding. Only a MAN of anger could deal as strangely as you O MAN (Pr. 14:17). There is no way that anyone in Christ is led to make a friend with an angry MAN (22:24).

Thank God an angry MAN is not impacting anyone but his own self. This is because they are self-willed into anger, because they do not love good men, who are called bishop’s (Tit. 1:7-8).

If I am getting to you O MAN, it is not me, it’s the MESSAGE. The Lord rebuke you, and heap coals of fire upon your head; the Lord reward you and drive you away as He does with every angry MAN (Pr. 25:22-23).
All I have done is hold fast to the faithful word as I have been taught, so have I in God given ability set forth sound doctrine (Tit. 1:9). However, this is never good enough for those who are unruly and vain in their talk, because they are deceivers (1:10).

We ALL know what you should NOT be teaching; by your own words you say that my testimony was right-on; the Lord stop your mouth, lest you end up as a subverter (Tit. 1:11). Now you suggest that my witness is not true: you make yourself to be a prophet of your own, and on your own. This is because you are not sound in the faith (1:12-13).

AND SO, NOW YOU DENY THAT YOU TAUGHT THIS GROUP NOT TO LEAD. Everyone knows that this is not the truth, we can all read your initial position, and it was without doubt anti-leadership. You placed doubt in the mind of Joanne by this unsound point:
“That's a great point for us to think about. I've always been bothered by the "worship leader". (Joanne).

The Scripture goes on to tell us that MEN like you are going to turn away from the truth (Tit. 1:14). These profess that they know God, but in works they deny Him, because their works are abominable, in that they are disobedient unto every good work: Those who do this are reprobate (Tit. 1:16).

REMEMBER you have already said that my work was good; now you turn from it in pure disobedience. This work of yours is not in the common faith, which has grace and mercy and peace from God our Father and the Lord Jesus Christ our Saviour (Tit. 1:4). I have manifested His word unto you, which has commanded you to be subject to it, if you wish to be seen as of the common faith (Tit. 1:3-4). It is now up to you, to show us where you stand, for the truth and against it. I as a servant of God and an ordained leader over men, the Bible adds that the faith of God’s elect can acknowledge the truth (Tit. 1:1).

This is my last admonition unto you O MAN. Failure to respond positively, shall leave me with no alternative but to let you have your last rail, which shall not be responded to.

Blessings in the grace to see the truth and acknowledge the truth.

MAN
September 1, 2008 9:03 PM

No comments!

Ps.
1- Thank you for making laugh!
2- I LOVE BISHOPS
2- Please keep recruiting leaders..ur way, otherwise you might lose your income..or may be people will stop buying your books....BIG LOSS...
3- please note, you still Lying..."apostle Philip"..I wounder if your initials are MG??????

"My prayer would not ......................yourself...but for the unblocking of the impaired intelligence, so you see that U R answering a question that was not asked from anyone but yourself...
God bless your heart! "

I can see you getting more angry or may be I should say "zealous"...sorry Fell

+++++++Joanne please say something, please say you understand..I know you are enjoying it...

-MATTHEW 23:10 (the gospel of Matthew)(new testament)“Do not be called leaders; for One is your Leader, that is, Christ.
- LUKE 22:26 (the gospel of Luke)(new testament)“BUT IT IS NOT THIS WAY WITH YOU, but the one who is the greatest among you must become like the youngest, and the leader like the SERVANT.

???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????

MAN
September 2, 2008 6:29 AM

THE WORD “LEADER?” “LEADERSHIP”?????!!!

IS THAT IN THE BIBLE????

Just wondering,
the word “LEADER” how many times was it mentioned in the NEW (Jesus) TESTAMENT,
1-The KJV/NKJV/ASV/NIV I found NONE,
BUT in other translations I found a mention to the word leader couple of times and here it is:
-Mt 23:10 “Do not be called leaders; for One is your Leader, that is, Christ.
- Lu 22:26 “BUT IT IS NOT THIS WAY WITH YOU, but the one who is the greatest among you must become like the youngest, and the leader like the SERVANT.
Well now we understand that Jesus did not come to recruit leaders….leadership maniacs, you wanna be a leader because off course you are TALENTED, FIND somewhere else to show off but not in the house of PRAYER.

BY the way, I here you asking, the word “SERVANT”, how many times was mentioned in “GRACE (NEW) TESTAMENT..you wouldn’t believe it!! Mr. “me me me I wanna be a leader in the church because I am talented”…..WHAT?!!
1- in KJV is 79 times
2- in NKJV is 80 times.
3- The American Standard Version 82times.
4- in NIV is 97 times
5- The Good News Translation 106 times!!!!!!
WHAT??!TTT!!! 2:106

Was that an accident?! well Jesus did not come to recruit “talented/awesome/handsome/gifted..etc LEADERS”
HE (Jesus)discipled his followers to SERVE SERVE SERVE
IN HUMILITY depending completely on their ONLY LEADER, JESUS THE SERVANT KING…..

STOP LEADING THIS LIFE STYLE BY SERVING AND ONLY SERVING…

A LEADER has followers, and when he falls……!

It would have been much better, if they followed the only MASTER AND a LEADER….the one that said “”"Which of you convinceth me of sin? And if I say the truth, why do ye not believe me?”"John 8:46

here is THE true leader that was not believed…
and here is a fraud that every one believed…..Irrrronic…!!

I think what happened recently confirms the credibility of THE ONLY LEADER…
when he said Matthew 24:24 “For false Christs and false prophets will appear and perform great signs and miracles to deceive even the elect–if that were possible.”

IT IS A SIGN FOR HIS SECOND COMING!! here is a positive for what happened…
also the only teacher “LEADER” said:
IN Matthew 24:19 “How dreadful it will be in those days for pregnant women and nursing mothers! ”

Is that literally??? or may be he meant the vulnerable like the youth and that are not taught proper biblical teaching from Church Servants…

PLEASE READ MATTHEW 24. it is good..
Read it just read it… MATTHEW 24
A Saved sinner!
ans embarrassed Christian

PS.

JESUS Said......in
---MATTHEW 23:10 “Do not be called leaders;....
&
---LUKE 22:26 “BUT IT IS NOT THIS WAY WITH YOU,.....and the leader like the SERVANT.....

Joanne Brokaw
September 2, 2008 9:54 AM

OK, Brother Phillip and MAN? It's time to realize that we've all - myself included - gotten really worked up over this story and need to take a step back. Hopefully you both read my column on Friday.

I appreciate that you guys are having a .... um, spirited? ... debate, but it's time to either call it quits, start debating without the anger (and caps), or move it to another venue. Share emails and go at each other off list, LOL.

Please, please continue to share, but try and do it a little more ... calmly? The folks in admin who monitor the comments will appreciate it, too, LOL.

Thanks!
Joanne
host of the GS blog

Liston Lee
September 3, 2008 9:40 PM

Do we have the right to judge others as we all too have struggles and failures that for some, may still be hidden? We have to be careful of how we respond to this situation.

As for Mike, let's pray for restoration and that he'd be able to finish the race. God is just and merciful.

MAN
September 3, 2008 10:30 PM

All churches have flaws..not just the Pentecostal.. as well as Me & U. BUT beloved, I think U R missing the point here…

- Unfortunately people in Authority or(influence) can not avoid the SEVERE consequences of their action…(lucky I am not a leader)
———————————————————————–
They need to be 4given but as in the story of David…
- THE SWORD never departed from his house, (Amnon, Abshalum)
-(Lust) (Adultery) never left his house(Thamar, Abshalum )

“This is what the Lord says: ‘Out of your own household I am going to bring calamity upon you. Before your very eyes I will take your wives and give them to one who is close to you, and he will lie with your wives in broad daylight.”

Isn’t that very harsh from the God of all mercies..?!

BUT LISTEN TO THIS

“12:13
Then David said to Nathan, “I have sinned against the Lord.” Nathan replied, “The Lord has taken away your sin. you r not going to die”

12:14
But because by doing this you have MADE THE ENEMIES OF THE LORD show utter contempt, the son born to you will die.”

I think if I were god at that time, I would’ve really forgave him…

- Israel was divided severely as a consequence of his action….(not simple)
and much much more….
Very sad isn’t it??? BUT it is the truth….

We R called to 4give the Porn Addict, as well as the deceivers, and ourselves as we can also be deceived by deceivers that the bible has warned about…..

————————————————————————–
SAMSON for example…you know what happened to Samson, when he disgraced his God’s Name…..he was severely humiliated….and the amount of humility that he brought to God’s name….

DU KNOW what the enemies said…”Our god has delivered Samson, our enemy, into our hands.”…….SHAME ON SHAMSON….

WHAT I LOVE ABOUT THE BIBLE IS THAT IT SAYS THE TRUTH ALL TRUTH..DOES NOT HIDE
But if we are a lie we will hide it….
—————————————————————–
thats what happened to real prophets of God, and if they are not from the first place, why would be any consequences….
——————————————————————
Jesus Asked us 2 4give everyone…But …in
John 2:12-22
14. In the temple courts he found men selling cattle, sheep and doves, and others sitting at tables exchanging money. (DID JESUS 4GAVE THEM?? I BET HE DID) 15. So he made a whip out of cords, and drove all from the temple area, both sheep and cattle; he scattered the coins of the money changers and overturned their tables.

Where is the forgiveness of Jesus..the life giver and the sin forgiver????

16. To those who sold doves he said, “Get these out of here! HOW DARE YOU turn my Father’s house into a market…..

also Jesus said “WATCH OUT for FALSE prophets. They come to you in sheep’s clothing, but INWARDLY they are FEROCIOUS WOLVES.”

Even though he taught to forgive, but that did not stop him from telling us to watch out from the wolves….GRACE doesn’t null the truth…Never
————————————————————————
The problem is we preach an incomplete “false” gospel, teaches forgiveness priceless…which is not true, our forgiveness is way too expensive to be taken 4granted….

Chris
September 4, 2008 6:27 AM

You know, I will be so very interested to see the daily lives of each individual here who is so readily throwing stones at this wounded brother.

Christopher Hwang
September 4, 2008 8:09 AM

I think that many a time when people in this forum state "we forgive you", they actually refer to the fact that the Lord forgive's Mike. Not to say that you cannot sympathize but honestly the sin was not committed against you, just a technicality. Cheers.

Mike, the higher you stand, the longer the fall, now look on the bright side, you get to start again, with the rest of us. Climb back up there and serve as a Leader to the people brother. It won't be easy, but well, life never is.

Christopher Hwang
September 4, 2008 8:31 AM

can you imagine how horrible he felt, preaching a gospel he couldn't fulfill. i have to sympathize with him, Healer still remains one of my favourite songs, top 3 no less. to have the honesty to hold his own, and own up. this man remains a man of God. it is not possible he did not know the controversy that was about to befall him. not within the shadow of a doubt. he owned up because he wants to change, and i think, that's important to all of us. we have to start owning up. we're sinners too

MAN
September 4, 2008 9:21 AM

"can you imagine how horrible he felt, preaching a gospel he couldn't fulfill." WHATTTT????

Did he have to preach?!!...mate if it was horrible why did he?????

But you know what?!!! I 4give him only 4 one thing, because he looked awesome in the Oxy tubes..I must admit that was original...I loved it, I guess it is all about "Jesus" no no no, sorry it is all about p.e.r.f.o.r.m.a.n.c.e....

I wounder if Jesus did the same thing, as other religions say that it was not him it was Michael the angel that died on the cross instead, Wow Jesus tricked us to get to our hearts and to make us feel sorry for him...yes..so we can love him and follow him....would you still be a Christian...I say with all confident I will not..I will forgive him but I will never trust him...would you?!

Anonymous
September 5, 2008 6:28 PM

Hi ALL;

MAN is at it again:

NOTE HOW MAN rails at men of God, who were in leadership:

MAN SAYS: SAMSON for example…you know what happened to Samson, when he disgraced his God’s Name…..he was severely humiliated….and the amount of humility that he brought to God’s name….

DU KNOW what the enemies said…”Our god has delivered Samson, our enemy, into our hands.”…….SHAME ON SHAMSON….

WHAT I LOVE ABOUT THE BIBLE IS THAT IT SAYS THE TRUTH ALL TRUTH..DOES NOT HIDE
But if we are a lie we will hide it….


______________________________________________


I am so grateful that the word of God did not hide, as MAN has done, the truth about Samson:

Let us all read it together: Hebrews 11:32 puts Samson with David, and Samuel and all the prophets of God: What more needs to be said?

MAN hid this truth, and by his own words he makes himself as one who is against the truth.

What did MAN call those who hide the truth, meaning;- all the truth?

MAN ANSWERS: WHAT I LOVE ABOUT THE BIBLE IS THAT IT SAYS THE TRUTH ALL TRUTH..DOES NOT HIDE
But if we are a lie we will hide it….

My question is similar to others on this blog: Why are we allowing this MAN to act in this backbiting manner, wherein he is acting as some self-appointed attack dog? The last word of God on Samson in the word of God was not shame on Samson, as MAN alleges, but instead it was to honor Samson, as a hero of the faith (Hebrews 11:32).

No one in Hebrews chapter 11 has any shame on them, nor did they shame God, no matter what the likes of MAN might say, they are all perfect with those in Christ (Heb. 11:40).

MAN must think that church leadership has to be without sin to be perfect in the sight of God and those in Christ. What a wicked error this is. This wickedness should not be allowed to continue spouting off in its off-hand manner, which is without mercy, because of faith.

The issue, now that we have repentant faith is not about sin, it's about errors against the truth.

Who here is without sin?

Praise God that the sin of most believers’ follows behind them; but also praise God, when for whatever reason, He allows other believers sins to come before them. None of this is about shame on them or God, it’s about mercy rejoicing over a judgmental manner (James 2:13). Faith which does not have this work [rejoicing against judgment] cannot save us (2:14). I pray that there are others on this site that can sound off in this manner: In that they too can rejoice against judgment, because of mercy . . .

Joanne Brokaw
September 5, 2008 8:58 PM

Brother Phillip? MAN? Again, I ask you with the utmost appreciation for your passion to please keep the discussion to Christian music, or take the Bible verse war to another forum. We need to direct the conversation back to topics involving Christian music. Last warning before the folks who monitor the comments start unpublishing them ...

Thanks!
Joanne
host of the GS blog

Franco
September 6, 2008 12:34 AM

I am saddened, like most of you, about what happened to Mike G. But what grieves me most is the reaction of the "modern time x-tians" in treating other christians who, like all of us, made mistake. First of all, Mike G. was not caught and was later exposed (as many media has published). He confessed his wrongdoing to his family and that's where i admired him most. I have no approval of his lies but the fact that he faced the consequences of confesing his wrongdoing is a godly thing to do. Most of us, if not caught sinning, will pretend everything is well and under control and live an "ideal" christian life as a costume or a facade (somebody may comment on this and will tell me, "that's only you. PLS. STOP THE HYPOCRISY). I am also saddened by the decision done by HILLSONG removing the song Healer even from their latest audio album. In the video album, it's reasonable because of the nature of the video. But in the audio/cd album, in my opinion, it is not necessary. It's like removing part of the book of Psalms because the author is a murderer/adulterer servant of God. But, that's their business. What bothers me of their action is the thought that i'm sure is not intentional; that is if you are a servant of God, and publicly you confess that you commit a sin and with a repentant heart you are asking for forgiveness, instead of extending/lending a helping hand and a shoulder to lean on, you will be disowned, mock, set aside, erased, forgotten so better keep your sin to your self and God and live "victoriously." If there is any moment that Mike is to sing his song Healer, that is now. Having an illness that is more dangerous than cancer (sexual sin if not repented can lead to eternal damnation) is the right time to ask God for help. And that's what Jesus is all about, Gracious Savior. And to those who momentarily lost the knowledge of God's grace because of gruesome, judgmental and arrogant thinking, read again the lives of King David (a man who's after God's heart yet sinned) and Apostle Paul on how they experienced God's grace. And if it's not enought, read again your life story and how God found you and make you whole again....and again.....and again....God bless you all.... >>> franco of Roxas City, Philippines & Montreal, Canada

MAN
September 6, 2008 8:32 AM

Hey Phell....

"....Again, I ask you with the utmost appreciation for your passion to please keep the discussion to Christian music,..."

1- Please obey the leader of this blog...
2- Please go and listen to some Christian music, I think that will cool you down, and may be help u 2 hav enough sleep..
3- Please Keep your word .. be a man "This is my last ad.... Failure to respond..............., which shall not be responded to." ..Well, I guess only a man would keep his word...Also only a man wouldn't be so frightened to put his name under his poor comments..man that was funny..

4- "some self-appointed attack dog"??..is that biblical? I think you're scared from dogs..also dogs are brave, unlike some human..

5- Also Thank you for mentioning my nick name "MAN" around 10 times, in your last precious writings that just show me how much you adore me...God Bless you Mate..

The God of peace be with you all..

Anonymous
September 7, 2008 6:28 AM

he came to my school and he talked. he said when he was in school he walked around with his bible...but as if, if he was addicted to porn.

He got the whole school to stand in front of this cross.

he was crying. he told us he was dieing aswell. he asked to see picture of his wife and it was already in a frame like planned

Dr Paul Tiffin
September 8, 2008 5:01 AM

I feel very sorry for the man- even as he was deceiving people his turmoil must have been massive to have manifest such powerful physical symptoms. I pray that he and his family find lasting healing and peace.

Anonymous
September 8, 2008 2:47 PM

Hi ALL:

I'd like to praise God that we are all back on subject, and in the Spirit of grace by thanking Franco for the following:

What bothers me of their action is the thought that I'm sure is not intentional; that is if you are a servant of God, and publicly you confess that you commit a sin and with a repentant heart you are asking for forgiveness, instead of extending/lending a helping hand and a shoulder to lean on, you will be disowned, mock, set aside, erased, forgotten so better keep your sin to your self and God and live "victoriously." If there is any moment that Mike is to sing his song Healer, that is now. Having an illness that is more dangerous than cancer (sexual sin if not repented can lead to eternal damnation) is the right time to ask God for help. And that's what Jesus is all about, Gracious Savior. And to those who momentarily lost the knowledge of God's grace because of gruesome, judgmental and arrogant thinking, read again the lives of King David (a man who's after God's heart yet sinned) and Apostle Paul on how they experienced God's grace.

I would like to add to Franco’s sound advice: I and many just like me believe that Mike G is now armed with a contrite admission of his transgression; and as such he can expect God to work with him for the furtherance of the gospel; and Mike can expect to have a blessed ministry.

Although a fall is optional, it does have the benefit of a lively witness of how graciously merciful God is, and helps us to see how precious mercy is for the gracious God of sure mercies. For now Mike G has much more than a song to sing, he has something to say. I expect that God has allowed all of this to come about, so that a man of music and song, might become a man of the word of God, who celebrates what God can do in speaking the song of grace (Eph. 5:19; Col. 3:16).

I’d be interested in hearing any comments on Eph. 5:19 and Col. 3:16. Such as how do we hear the singing from the heart? And why is the melody to be in the heart, rather than out in the open?

To Joanne, could you find the grace to work with me here, rather than just flip me off, as you have done before? I truly am interested in your input. Remember I am not against music; I am interested in what you have to say about the content of these two verses of Scripture. Sorry for asking, but I am trying to work with you, and believe that herein we can find more to agree on than to disagree about. The alternative of just ignoring me or being flippantly against these Scriptures is not very spiritual.

Blessings to you ALL

Joanne Brokaw
September 8, 2008 3:17 PM

Brother Phillip, I didn't realize I was flipping you off. I certainly didn't mean to do that. I didn't realize you were waiting for a response from me. I have not been agreeing or disagreeing with you; just trying to reign in the comments and convice the admins not to delete them.

Ephesians 5:19, 20 - Speak to one another with psalms, hymns and spiritual songs. Sing and make music in your heart to the Lord, always giving thanks to God the Father for everything, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ.

I'm not exactly sure what you're asking me to comment on in this verse? The Bible says that from the heart the mouth speaketh, so music in the heart obviously pours forth from the mouth.

Colossians 3:16 - Let the word of Christ dwell in you richly as you teach and admonish one another with all wisdom, and as you sing psalms, hymns and spiritual songs with gratitude in your hearts to God.

I think that the music is to be sung with gratitude, and that we're to teach and admonish each other. Again, I don't know what more you're asking from me about these two verses.

Again, I'm not trying to flip you off, but I really don't know what more you are asking of me. You keep posting on the very first post, so I hope you've been following the entire story, including my two very personal musings on the Christian music industry, which may answer a lot of your questions:

http://blog.beliefnet.com/gospelsoundcheck/2008/08/a-musing-a-confession-and-the.html
http://blog.beliefnet.com/gospelsoundcheck/2008/09/a-monday-morning-musing-on-the.html

Thanks!
Joanne
host of the GS blog

MAN
September 10, 2008 5:58 AM

Hi,
music music music, who does not love music....!!! but

Can we or - is it easy to - distinguish between emotional vs spiritual worship....?!

Do we really need music to get us into the worship spirit?! since when God needs an emotional worship enhancement drugs!

I wounder also -I say that with the utmost respect to the holy spirit-, but did the healed pastor also speak in tongues?! could that be unreal “fraud” too?! how can you speak(pray) in/by the “holy spirit” in the presence of deception, if we are/he is praying in tongues to edify self, what sort of spiritual edification is that??!!

or how can you lead worship being led by the holy spirit, in the presence of deception...please note that we are in the new testament, not the old testament- so please do not use the example of Elijah, or David, or Samson - and also do not mention (or argue the point of) the difference between the anointing and the integrity...

Please WAKE UP AOG….

THE LORD IS NEAR
and most of what you offer is not for the spirit heart but only for the eye and EAR.
It’s much more than just to cheer,
but it is love after GOD’S fear.

Lots of emotions and tears, and deception year after year!

GOD HELP US the shepherd voice HEAR, AND to the truth ADHERE.

GLORY BE TO YOUR NAME ONLY from a loving heart and sincere!

.

P.S. before judging what I said, I would like to say that I am not against music, I love and adore/listen to music....also I play music in church...

Brother Philip
September 10, 2008 12:29 PM

Hi Joanne;

Thank you for your response to my request for input on Eph. 5:19; Col. 3:16. You were not exactly sure what in particular I was asking for. This may be because you overlooked my direct questions:

How do we hear the singing from the heart?
And why is the melody to be in the heart, rather than out in the open?

YOU gave the following: The Bible says that from the heart the mouth speaketh, so music in the heart obviously pours forth from the mouth.

And this much I appreciate, and thank you for. However, I was very interested in what you think about SPEAKING songs? And if you knew of any Christian performance, which speaks songs? I believe there is something interesting going on in these verses, which you and I would not see as a normal musical performance.

Thank you in advance for your help.

Joanne Brokaw
September 10, 2008 1:41 PM

I'm sorry, you're right. I misunderstood the question.

Are you referring to spoken word performances? Where the lyrics are not sung but spoken to music? I don't actually know off hand any artists who do spoken word, but that is what they call it. I'll see if I can come up with something.

I do think that a lot of what comes out of our mouths is centered around the idea that out of our hearts our mouth speaks, and obviously what is in our hearts is in correlation to what is in our spirits and our minds. So the verses you pointed out do raise the notion that our words, either spoken or sung in my opinion, would be a reflection of our hearts, and I think you'd see that in how many artists' lives and music line up. Then again, our lips are deceitful so you have artists who say one thing and do another ... honestly, I don't have a better answer than that. It's kind of circular.

And you raise an intersting point: if you speak a song, instead of singing it, is it still a song? Or is it poetry?

Spoken word is really outside the box, artistically (I think the Christian music industry tends to shy away from anything "artsy," which is a whole other discussion about arts and the Church throughout history) so you won't find a lot if it in the industry. But I'll see what I can find.

Thanks!
Joanne
host of the GS blog

Joanne Brokaw
September 10, 2008 5:55 PM

Brother Phillip,

OK so I've done some googling and as I expected, I don't see a lot out there about spoken word. I think you may find more about spoken word if you look for poets? Or rappers, LOL? Rap is a mix of music and poetry.

I think that the best answer I can give to how we hear singing from the heart is ... I don't know. What comes out of our mouths, I suppose.

I wish I could be more help! I will keep my eyes out for spoken word artists, though.

Joanne
host of the GS blog

Post a Comment

By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.



Please type the text you see in the box below to verify your post and help us prevent spam. You have a limited time to type - you may wish to compose your comment in a separate document and paste it here upon completion.

Type the characters you see in the picture above.

Advertisement

Search This Blog

feed icon Subscribe

RSS Feed

Receive updates from Gospel Soundcheck

About Gospel Soundcheck

Award-winning freelance writer and columnist Joanne Brokaw covers entertainment for The Christian Examiner newspapers, The Minnesota Christian Chronicle, and The Ozarks Christian News. Her other writing credits include Breakaway and Brio Magazines, OnCourse Magazine, ChristianMusicPlanet.com, BuddyHollywood.com and AGreaterFreedom.com. Her humor column, A Big Slice of Life, appears monthly in the Christian Voice Magazine and she pens a regular humor column on The Writing Life for ByLine Magazine. Joanne lives in Western New York with her darling husband David, their Border collie Scout and their cat Murphy. Their almost adult daughter Cassie drops by often. Find out more about Joanne at JoanneBrokaw.com.

chmusic_promo.gif

Calendar

Categories

Advertisement

Advertisement


About Beliefnet

Our mission is to help people like you find, and walk, a spiritual path that will bring comfort, hope, clarity, strength, and happiness. More about Beliefnet.

Legal

Copyright © Beliefnet, Inc. and/or its licensors. All rights reserved. Use of this site is subject to Terms of Service and to our Privacy Policy. Constructed by Beliefnet.

Advertisement

Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.