Last night, the final four American Idol contestants performed rock songs, and it’s a toss up who was the best: Adam or Allison. Sure, Adam killed Led Zepplin’s “Whole Lotta Love,” but Allison proved on her duet with Adam of Foghat’s “Slow Ride” that she can match him note for note in this genre, even if the judges thought her individutal performance Janis Joplin’s “Cry Baby” wasn’t the best song choice.
Kris and Danny were definitely at a disadvantage last night. The judges weren’t thrilled with Kris’ rendition of The Beatles’ “Come Together,” although I thought he did a great job. And Danny gave Aerosmith’s “Dream On” a good try, but he really wasn’t able to pull off the high note at the end. Kris and Danny had amazing harmonies on their rendition of Styx’s “Renegade,” but their individual vocals on the duet were lacking.
So who goes home tonight?
My gut tells me Danny might be in trouble; Simon pointed out that he’s the only one who hasn’t been in the bottom three. But we’ll find out tonight when we get the results live. Tonight, Chris Daughtry and No Doubt will be performing, and we’re supposed to see Paula Abdul perform her new single, “I’m Just Here For The Music;” will she actually perform or will we get video like last time?
See you here tonight for the results show!
8:55 PM – watching the end of America’s Next Top Model. I figured they’d send Celia home. They’ve been making such a big deal about her age – yeeesh, she’s only 25!
9:00 PM Here we go! Idol starts with a recap of last night’s performances and Slash’s comments. I forgot that Simon said watching Danny was like watching a horror movie, LOL. i also forgot how horrible Kara’s hair looked last night. Ick.
Can you believe that we’re down to the final 3 this season? The weeks have flown by! Ryan says that there were 65 million votes cast – or was it 67 million? Oh, Kara cut her bangs. At least it’s better than that horrid look from last night.
Looks like Paula is actually going to take the stage tonight. That should be interesting.
Watching the recaps and even the Ford video, I’m thinking Danny’s in trouble. We’ll see after the group performance, complete with Slash on lead guitar. I know I predicted Kris winning a couple of weeks ago, but man, Allison and Adam are looking like a hot final 2. But what do I know? All four of them are super talented, especially in their own genre of music.
After the break, Paula’s going to perform. Really? She’s going to perform live? We’re not going to see a video? I’ll believe it when I see it.
First we check in with the contestants. Danny says Wednesday nights are the most tiring. Kris says he never expected to make it this far and it’s surreal. Simon tells Kris they “don’t want humble any more.” Adam was thrilled with rock week and being the first to perform a Zepplin song, and he loved his outfit. Danny says that when they’re on stage the sound is drowned out, but when he listened to it later he laughed out loud all night, and that that final note was maybe his funniest moment on Idol. Allison says she’s not the kind of person who talks back, but she just had to speak up.
OMG, she’s actually going to perform live. She’s doing the Adam Lambert stair entrance. She looks great, but is she really singing? Doubtful. I can’t imagine she can sing and crawl around on the stage in that get up. At the end, when she says, “I’m just here for the music,” she’s clearly out of breath. It all begs the question: is this her last season and is she going out with a bang?
No Doubt is singing “Just A Girl.” Wait, isn’t this an old song? Wow Gwen Stefani is doing push ups on stage. Ryan says she was making him nervous because it’s been a high risk week. Ah, No Doubt is going on tour just so Gwen can get out of the house, even though the band doesn’t have a new album – yet. That explains the old song.
So the judges are back at their table – the weren’t there for No Doubt. Probably so Simon could have another cigarette? The four are waiting backstage while we’re reminded that the final three get to go home for a super hometown celebration. So who’s not going to have that experience? Ryan explains that the finalists are being announced in random order tonight, so we’ll only know got the least number of votes. He starts by recapping each contestant’s performance and the judges’ critiques. The first contestant safe tonight is Kris. I KNEW IT. He’s clearly shocked, but he deserves to be there.
After the break, Daughtry performs their new single and Adam, Danny and Allison can sweat out which one is going home – and not for a parade.
Daughtry’s debut was the fastest selling rock album in Soundscan history, and with good reason. It’s a great album, and I can’t wait to see what Daughtry’s got for us next. The song you’re hearing, “It’s No Surprise,” is off of the band’s upcoming but yet untitled album, scheduled for release in July. Getting voted of Idol was probably the best thing that could have happened to Chris Daughtry, and should be good comfort to whoever goes home tonight that tonight is just the beginning, not the end.
Chris tells Ryan that the night he was voted off is still vivid in his mind, and at the time, he thought the world was ending. “But I got over it about 30 seconds later,” he says. Kris brings out the plaque celebrating the sales of 5 million copies of Daughtry’s debut album. Amazing.
After the break? Someone’s heart will be broken.
Adam, Allison and Danny are on the stage, and Ryan sends Adam to sit with Kris, leaving Danny and Allison standing. He emphasizes that this is in random order. And the final person in the top 3? Danny. (So Allison IS leaving, Ben! Wow, how did you know that?) I was hoping she’d pull out a final three, even thought it would have meant Danny going home.
Watching her perform her “swan song” it’s clear that she’s just starting her career. She’s grown so much just in this competition; it’ll be great to see her soar.
And wow, did I predict the final three weeks ago? Sure, with rock week Adam totally dominated over Kris and Danny, but next week is another week, and it’ll be an exhausting one, sa the contestants go home for a parade and hometown celebration. And they each sing two songs next week, one a judges’ pick and one their own pick. (Question: which judge doesn’t get to pick, with only three contestants?)
RELATED POSTS
American Idol’s Top 4 Perform – Blogging Live
American Idol Poll: Who Would You Vote For If The Finale Was Today?American Idol Winner Prediction – I’m Going Out On A Limb With Kris Allen
4 Reasons Why There Are So Many Christian Contestants On American IdolMore on American Idol contestant Danny Gokey and wife Sophia
More American Idol Posts
Get the Gospel Soundcheck headlines delivered daily to your email inbox. Just sign up for the RSS feed by going to the “Subscribe” box on the right hand side of this blog and entering your email address. And follow me on Twitter!



posted May 6, 2009 at 1:59 pm
Hahahahahahaha!!! Hehehehehehehe!!! Hihihihihihihi!!! Hohohohohohoho!!! We were all dying of laughter at horrible Gokey!!! He was trying to clone Adam as he himself said he’s been learning from the performance of some one he didn’t want to name. Everyone already has a clue who.
And last night he confirmed it and trying so hard: from looking and following the camera, to the swagger in the stage, to the conducting the band, trying to thank the band (with hand gestures when Ryan was talking with him and Kris), the handling of the mic, and the almost kneeling while mimicking the signature “passaggio” of Adam!!!
But OMG! What HORROR!!! What a DISASTER!!! He totally completely failed miserably! It’s the scream from Silence of the Lamb! We could not stop laughing.
Hahahahahahaha!!! Hehehehehehehe!!! Hihihihihihihi!!! Hohohohohohoho!!!
Stay true to yourself Gokey. Don’t trespass where you know it’s not your turf. You believe in yourself too much you can do an Adam all the way. Know who you really are. Don’t be a FAKE.
It shows your arrogance and insincerity. But thank you for giving us reasons to have a good laugh!!!
It’s historic as the WORST final note on AI all 8 seasons!!!
By GOKEY! A poor classless Adam imitator. See how Kara tried so hard to keep herself from bursting out laughing!
posted May 6, 2009 at 9:11 pm
Okay… so we’re off and running with “School’s Out for summer…”
I think Ryan said that there were 60 million votes last night!!
That’s amazing!!
I voted as many times as I could for Kris…
I was happy when I got through…but when I got thru quickly 2 times in a row… I was worried no one was calling his number~~
Well, it’s out of our hands… (like anything’s ever really in our own hands)
posted May 6, 2009 at 9:18 pm
is Paula lip-synching?
posted May 6, 2009 at 9:19 pm
Noooo!!!
I was reading Wikipedia and say that Allison was eliminated tonight!
it’s true!!!!!
Please don’t tell me that is true!!!!!!
posted May 6, 2009 at 9:24 pm
Ben, they haven’t had the eliminations yet so unless someone leaked the info we don’t know yet!
Joanne
host of the GS blog
posted May 6, 2009 at 9:24 pm
How can Wikipedia know??? HOW???
posted May 6, 2009 at 9:26 pm
I think she was!
Joanne
posted May 6, 2009 at 9:30 pm
No Doubt.. Gwen Stefani’s hair… the tutu on one guy!!???
she looks… uhmmmm… odd?
posted May 6, 2009 at 9:32 pm
Ben, I’m looking at the Idol entry on Wiki and it says the elimination is TBA. Not sure where you read that!
Joanne
posted May 6, 2009 at 9:39 pm
Kris is safe!!!!! OMOMOMOMO!!!
I’m so happy!!!!
posted May 6, 2009 at 9:44 pm
I think Kris thot he was going home…
I’m glad they told him first so he can enjoy Chris’s performance!
posted May 6, 2009 at 9:46 pm
But is there!
here’s the link!!!!!
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Idol#Season_8_2
posted May 6, 2009 at 9:50 pm
Is not there!!!
Maybe they are playing tricks with my mind!!!!! XD!
Sorry about that!!!!
posted May 6, 2009 at 9:57 pm
Well, whether it was there or night… Allison is going home… Top 3 are all guys…
posted May 6, 2009 at 10:01 pm
awww. Idol viewers got it wrong tonight. That girl deserves to stay.
posted May 6, 2009 at 10:03 pm
WOW… what an exit. Allison sounded great…again….
but I guess it’s the boys in the final 3.
She’s gonna have a career… and a good one!
I’m just so glad Kris is safe.
posted May 6, 2009 at 10:08 pm
The Americans voted for Bush even twice, but sent Allison home. Something is wrong with the Americans.
posted May 6, 2009 at 10:09 pm
Ben, either way, you totally had it right!!
Joanne
posted May 6, 2009 at 10:11 pm
I actually thought Allison should have stayed and Danny would probably go. But in reality? Going home tonight is not a bad thing for Allison. She’s got a huge following and will go on to sell lots of records.
Joanne
posted May 6, 2009 at 10:49 pm
Boy, did the voters get that wrong. I like Danny but he should have been the next to go. Oh Well – sing on Allison!
posted May 6, 2009 at 11:59 pm
im really shocked that the voters voted the way they did. but on second thought– think about the reality of the viewers– the majority is the younger crowd, and mostly females drooling over the gorgeous male singers onstage. what young guy is going to stay home during the week to watch american idol and vote??? come on now.
allison, should not have left, but like everyone else said, she will come out on top from this show.
most of the winners, and runner-ups are like one hit wonders, so
GO ALLISON, show america they screwed up!
posted May 7, 2009 at 12:40 am
In my opinion America got it right. The genre was made for Adam(especially) and Allison, both rockers. Allison did good, but not as well as she should have for the genre, same old, same old nothing original. Danny and Kris are both better singers than Allison and eveybody knows that.(maybe not in a couple years though, she does have a lot of talent!!)
posted May 7, 2009 at 7:56 am
I hate this part of American Idol. I don’t want to see anyone eliminated.Usually I dislike at least one contestant but that hasn’t happened since Tatiana. UGH!
I predict the winner will be… whoever Ben thinks!!!! I love the name BEN!
posted May 7, 2009 at 10:47 am
Joanne, I am “your name”. Hmmm must’ve not been awake!
aunt kathy
posted May 7, 2009 at 11:47 am
Just a note: the performances by Paula Abdul and No Doubt were recorded on Tuesday night. In one sense they were live, since they performed in front of a crowd. But Seacrest was very careful last night to say that Daughtry would be performing “live here tonight.” Both pre-recorded performances had multiple takes and extensive set-up. That’s why it appeared that the judges disappeared: they were long gone by that time on Tuesday!
posted May 7, 2009 at 12:17 pm
JDubs – wow, I did not know that! That explains it, then. Thanks for the inside info!
Joanne
host of the GS blog
posted May 7, 2009 at 2:26 pm
Allison is such a stunning singer — if I were Simon I’d have a contract and a pen right under the table. That girl is scary. To be honest, I still just see Adam as a bit of a freak show – look what I can do! I can sneer and sing high notes. Prediction: if he wins, his schtick will becoming tiring very quickly (anybody remember Taylor Hicks?). I think that Allison and Danny have the real sustainable talent. BIG BEEF: The duets were incredibly unfair at this point. You have two males in one song and a male/female pairing on the other. Obviously, there’s a bigger potential dynamic going on with a male/female duet. Whoever got paired with Allison would’ve come off better. The wrong move….