Idol Chatter

Idol Chatter

Is That Anti-Semitic Kazakh Journalist Speaking Hebrew?

posted by Esther Kustanowitz

Last year, a sketch character called Borat sang a song advising the world to throw the Jews down the well so his country could be free, and in the process he managed to convince the patrons in a country-western bar to sing along. The world’s response? Some Jewish organizations were predictably fearful–worrying about the possibility that the sketch was promoting anti-Semitism–while many individuals around the world embraced the joke, and the comedian, behind the sketch. Many of Borat’s fans were Jewish, but didn’t see it as a conflict; some of them “got the joke,” that people will do anything on camera, and the “not-so-jokey” part, that people are followers who may embrace anti-Semitism if it’s compelling enough in the moment. Other people just thought it was funny.

This year, Borat’s got a new movie coming out, called “Encyclopedia Borat and the Case of the Infernally Long and Unmemorable Fake Movie Title.” (Actually, the movie’s real title is “Borat’s Cultural Learnngs of America For Make Benefit Glorious Nation of Kazakhstan.” See? Mine was easier.) So with millions of people about to be exposed to this anti-Semitic Kazakh journalist, we’ll be hearing a lot about whether the movie is good for the Jews.

While Borat’s creator, Sacha Baron Cohen, is himself Jewish–and, as a cover story in Entertainment Weekly noted, “wrote a thesis on the black-Jewish alliance in the American civil rights movement”–one of Borat’s more famous characteristics is his virulent anti-Semitism. Most recently, People reported that he expressed a wish “to meet the fearless anti-Jew warrior Melvin Gibson.” He continued, “We agree with his comments that the Jews started all wars. We also have proof that they were responsible for killing off all the dinosaurs. And Hurricane Katrina–they did it.”

But what’s that gibberish dialect that Borat speaks in the film? It’s supposed to be his native Kazakh language, but after viewing a new trailer, Jews the world over know the truth: Borat speaks Hebrew.

In the movie, according to a report in the Jewish Telegraphic Agency (the AP of Jewish journalism): “Borat takes leave of his ancestral village, telling one resident, according to the subtitle, ‘Doltan, I’ll get you a new arm in America.’ In fact, Cohen says in Hebrew, ‘I’ll buy you some kind of a new arm.’ Borat also parries with his wife in Hebrew.” (I am citing the report for journalistic reasons, but as a Hebrew-speaker, I can verify that this is true.)

The Entertainment Weekly article further noted that the “Kazakh” Borat speaks is actually a blend of gibberish, Hebrew, and Polish. And Borat’s Wikipedia entry notes that the Kazakh journalist has been known to say the lyrics of a Hebrew folk song, “Koom Bachur Atzel.” (Anyone who knows that song will now have it stuck in his or her head for the rest of the day. Sorry about that.)

Clearly, the artist behind Borat doesn’t really believe Jews should all be thrown down the well, or that Jews killed the dinosaurs, any more than the creators of South Park believe that skater Brian Boitano built the pyramids and beat up Kublai Khan. But perhaps within Borat’s choice of language, there’s an additional wink in an already parodic portrayal. Perhaps it’s even a reward for the Hebrew-speakers who can see past the “anti-Semitism” and get the joke.



You Might Also Like...
Previous Posts

New Episode of Super Soul Sunday: Oprah and NBA Legend Coach Phil Jackson
NEW SPECIAL EPISODE of ‘SUPER SOUL SUNDAY’ Oprah & NBA Legend, Coach Phil Jackson: The "Zen Master" airs FATHER’S DAY SUNDAY, JUNE 16 at 11Am ET/PT on OWN: Oprah Winfrey Network Oprah Winfrey sits down with NBA Championship coach and New York Times bestselling author, Phil Jackson, t

posted 11:40:27am Jun. 11, 2013 | read full post »

TD Jakes Presents: Mind, Body & Soul
BET Networks, a division of Viacom, brings a brand-new talk show "TD Jakes Presents - Mind, Body & Soul" with spiritual leader, educator, and humanitarian Bishop T.D. Jakes as host. Covering a wide range of topics including health and wellness, finance and relationships, Bishop Jakes unearths de

posted 11:58:56am Jun. 04, 2013 | read full post »

NEW EPISODE OF ‘SUPER SOUL SUNDAY’ THE BIGGER PICTURE WITH OPRAH, REV. ED BACON, ELIZABETH LESSER & MARK NEPO
NEW EPISODE of  ‘SUPER SOUL SUNDAY’ The Bigger Picture with Oprah, Rev. Ed Bacon, Elizabeth Lesser & Mark Nepo Airs SUNDAY, MAY 26 at 11Am EST/PST on OWN: Oprah Winfrey Network Pictured here: Rev. Ed Bacon, Elizabeth Lesser, Mark Nepo and Oprah Winfrey at Harpo Studios in Chicago, IL

posted 9:27:04pm May. 22, 2013 | read full post »

Has your favorite show been "smashed"?
I hope you weren’t too fond of “Smash” or “Go On”. It seems as though ‘Smash’ never quite found the adoring fan-dom of ‘Glee’ (you know, that other TV show based on signing and danc

posted 3:08:31pm May. 13, 2013 | read full post »

NEW EPISODE OF ‘Oprah’s LIFECLASS’ featuring Iyanla Vanzant
NEW EPISODE OF ‘Oprah’s LIFECLASS’ featuring Iyanla Vanzant – Single Moms RAISING SONS airs Sunday, May 12 at 9pm ET/PST Photo Credit ©Harpo Studios Oprah Winfrey and Iyanla Vanzant speak with single mothers raising fatherless sons and help them to overcome the challenges of being an

posted 5:17:58pm May. 06, 2013 | read full post »

Advertisement
Comments read comments(2)
post a comment
mslily

posted October 27, 2006 at 11:33 am


Just saw it, and while I would not say its a great movie (a little too gross out for me) he did recant his dislike of the Jews in the end, because during his journey he attended a Pentacostal church (which sort of pokes fun at that, too…) and has become a Christian. While he did disparage Jews, one of the funniest comments was that they should go back to NY, as there werent any Jews there! I was not offended by his asides, he poked fun at just about everything.



report abuse
 

l

posted October 27, 2006 at 10:46 pm


borat also stops mid sentence sometimes – when he tells his friend not to rape any animals, he says, in hebrew – “don’t do the…” at which point in turns in mumbo-jumbo…



report abuse
 

Post a Comment

By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.





Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.