While I wasn't really that surprised when I read that theabortion debate somehow wormed its way into the release of the big screen adaptation of "Horton Hears A Who", you could have knocked me over with a tiny, purple flower when I read former NBA player Kareem Abdul-Jabbar's commentary on the same movie. In what I can only describe as a very articulate but ridiculous knee-jerk reaction, "Horton," according to Abdul-Jabbar, is sexist and racist and much of Hollywood and middle America is too ignorant to realize it.
According to Kareem, the sexism is embedded in the subplot of the Mayor of Whoville and his many daughters and only son. The son saves Whoville, while the daughters are merely on the fringe of things, neglected by their dad. And, his logic goes, if we are willing to allow this sort of "social injustice," then we will simply turn a deaf ear, if you will, to other forms of injustice—including racism.
Are you as confused as I am about that broad leap in logical reasoning? "Horton" has numerous themes in the story including respect for others' differences and the need to find your own voice. Picking on a relatively small moment in the film to make a huge broad social statement seems a bit of a reach to me.
But perhaps the real purpose of his editorial is found in the final paragraph, where he ties his commentary back to where the article actually started—a pitch to vote for Barack Obama.
Add to Del.icio.us
Add to Technorati
Add to Digg
Add to Newsvine
Add to Facebook
Add to StumbleUpon
Subscribe
Whether or not you "Horton" is sexist and racist....sexism and racism are all serious problems in our society. If nothing else KAJ has got us talking about them. As for involving children in politics.....it happens, that's just the way it is.
This story was written many years ago when children could just enjoy a story that's entertaining and with a simple moral instead of having to worry about whatever political and social subplot the movie may have. What's wrong with that?
I think it is advisable to actually read what he said in context and see the movie before commenting.
1) to the woman who mentioned but it is a childrens story written a while ago. If you read Kareem's editorial from the link. He addresses your comment as have quite a few critics. That is in order to make a movie out of a short story they added to the "dialogue". The movie is not the story book.
I did take my 8 year old daughter to see the movie, I can tell you the only remotely positive female image is the who-ville scientist. His wife thinks he may be going crazy. His daughters jabber on. And of course, Carol Burnett plays a terrific meanie!
So yes, the original plot gets a little lost in drawing out the story to make a movie.
Having said that, I enjoyed it way more than my eight year old. Who simply responed The mayors' daughters were way louder than the son, how come they couldn't save Whoville?
My point, the movie makers did not do justice to this very cute story and the message from the book was not adequetely transerred to the movie. And perhaps Kareem is correct, the movie is sexist. This from stay at home mom.
To Ricky re Kareem's stint as a Bruin (from a proud female Bruin), the times were different and Kareem was a lot younger. Not making excuses. Just stating facts. What 20 year old man-child will care if there's a Title 9 for women's sports? In the early 1970s, was there even such a thing? I don't follow sports that closely so I don't know. Do you? Most people become wiser as they age and see things with more clarity. That could be how it is for Mr. Abdul-Jabbar now.
I haven't seen the movie. I'm not a Jim Carey fan and listening to his voice is too much for me. I won't take Kareem's word as gospel, but before I whine about his statements, I will do some research. The story was written years ago when certain stereotypes were considered the norm. There's no excuse for it now. Mr. Abdul-Jabbar has a good point about the 96 girls versus the one savior boy. If today's writers feel they can take liberties with certain aspects of the story, why not use the opportunity to enlighten and empower our future generation?
Why are you so adamant that Kareem doesn't have a point? What are you so afraid of?
It is just a movie! The messages in the movie can be discussed at home with the children and opinionators like Jabbar can have their opions as this is a free country.
Post a Comment
By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.