"Slumdog Millionaire" has certainly made it to many end-of-the-year top 10 movie lists and even here at Idol Chatter there has been heaps of praise for its inspirational storyline.
So, when I finally braved yet another snowstorm to go see it, I was not only disappointed in the film, but I also realized I was now going to seem like a heartless Scrooge for criticizing thie numerous flaws of this movie. While the premise is somewhat clever, the story is not entirely successful as a romantic drama, a social commentary, or even a root-for-the-underdog melodrama.
"Slumdog" takes audiences into the harsh world of Jamal, a boy living in the slums of India who, as a young man, finds himself on the Indian version of "Who Wants to be a Millionaire?" Through flashback after flashback after...yawn...another flashback, the audience learns how he ended up on the game show and how an uneducated kid from the slums knew all the answers to the quiz show's questions.
It's not that I don't feel empathy for the main character, Jamal. It's not that I have zero compassion for the impoverished of India, but "Slumdog," for all its good intentions, does not give me new insight into India. This movie didn't work for me because it repeatedly beat me over the head with graphic images of torture and abuse inflicted by cartoonish, one-dimensional characters without giving me any sense of adding to the deeper thematic elements the film seems to be striving for.
"Slumdog" does have what will be considered a happy ending even though there is only the slightest of growth in Jamal's character. after such a long personal ourney That's the other issue I have with this movie. If this movie is to be admired for a story of redemption or hope, the story needs more substance that leads to character -and audience -transformation. Winning lots and lots of money does not equal transformation and neither does finally getting the girl--both key points to the movie's resolution.
Even as I write this, I feel I am being a bit harsh on an unlikely movie that has clearly touched many people. Then again, I have so many other quibbles with this film that I am going to let this review be my final answer.
Add to Del.icio.us
Add to Technorati
Add to Digg
Add to Newsvine
Add to Facebook
Add to StumbleUpon
Subscribe
It was decent but no Oscar worthy reasons to vote as the top movie. I liked 7 Pounds much better. That was a good movie.
You all are wrong. Seven Pounds is THE movie of the year. What a good film that is. Keeps you guess for most of the way too. Will Smith did an excellent job, though Brad Pitt should win Oscar for his role.
http://rednow.com/film/feature/slumdog-millionaire-as-sacer-ludus
Link above has an explanation as to why this film has merit.
I am also looking forward to Deliverance, Star Trek and Terminator. There are some decent movies coming out.
Post a Comment
By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.