Academics are known to get geeky about popular culture, especially if we’re talking about the mythologies of Joss Whedon across his many shows, especially Buffy, or anything to do with Lord of the Rings, Harry Potter, and lately, professors are jumping on the “let’s talk about the greater significance of Twilight” bandwagon.
But black metal? Not to be confused with the likes of Alice Cooper and Marilyn Manson, black metal is “all scoured howls, nonsyncopated blast-beat drums, and cold, trebly guitars. It sounds like it’s rotting, and that’s the point: black metal represents decay, radical individualism, misanthropy, negativity about all systems, and awe of the natural world…In a way, black metal runs on a very old cultural motor: loss of faith, and the hysterical fear and sadness that come with it,” writes Ben Ratliff of the New York Times in his article, “Thank You, Professor, That Was Putrid” about a recent, academic symposium that explored the greater significance–especially the spiritual and the religious–of black metal music.
Paper titles at the conference included Emory Professor Eric Butler’s “The Counter-Reformation in Stone and Metal: Spiritual Substances” which “talked about black-metal music — in its second-wave, largely Norwegian form — as a cryptic expression of Roman Catholicism,” and the University of Central Lancashire Professor Niall Scott’s lecture which discussion of how, “black metal as part of the ritual of confession”:
“The black metal event is a confession without need of absolution, without need of redemption,” [Scott] said. It is, he added, “a cleaning up of the mess of others.” He invoked the old English tradition of sin eating by means of burial cakes, in which a loaf of bread was put on a funeral bier or a corpse, and a paid member of the community would eat the bread, representing sin, to absolve and comfort the deceased. “Black metal has become the sin eater,” he intoned. “It is engaged in transgressive behavior to be rid of it.”
Not my cup of tea music wise, but the article about the phenomenon itself is fascinating.



posted December 16, 2009 at 7:24 pm
Note that podcasts and texts of several papers presented are now available on the blog: http://blackmetaltheory.blogspot.com/
Nicola Masciandaro
posted December 17, 2009 at 7:49 am
“Not my cup of tea music wise, but the article about the phenomenon itself is fascinating.” Really? I wasn’t sure. Here’s a suggestion tho, don’t write about things you have no idea about then. Non syncopated blast beats? Trebly guitars? Do you even know what you are talking about? Most Black Metal is Math metal. Carefully calculated beats at key intervals. Sorry its too fast for you to comprehend, I am sure your Kenny G cd’s are getting worn by now. Please forgive my humour. Just remember there is a difference between Black metal and what some of us consider punk. Loss of faith, hysterical fear, and sadness huh? Well I guess it would take a long time to explain how off you guys are. It’s actually a commitment to faith, No fear at all, and the pure joy of religious freedoms. And as most of us metal musicians are Pagans, of course we are in awe of nature and natural phenomenons. I think it important to state that the true breakdown in society would be at the hands of the christians. The bible states “love not the world more than thy God” And that seperation of and detachment frpm all commitments to the environment, is causing rifts and eco breakdowns everytime a happy meal bag is thrown out the window. Let’s clean up after ourselves and maybe there will be a world still habitable for our grandchildrens children. Love and peace and a happy Yule to you all!! Blessed Be ~UDK~