Note from Beliefnet About Commenting

Am I being too meta if I comment on this comment about commenting?

Good one, Travis!

Thanks, Beliefnet, for taking our concerns into account. I have noticed that numbers have appeared with the comments!

I am hopeful that the posting time goes down some...it took a full 50 seconds for my last (short) post to process.

I am wondering whether you (Scot) can discern whether there is a decrease in comments since coming over here? I certainly only comment 10 percent of what I used to -- mainly because of the delay in comment posting and the difficulty in viewing both the original post and all the comments.

Shalom....

I have no objection whatsoever to proving I'm a real human being, and welcome the change.

Thanks for the update. There is a thing called "learning resistance" where people usually tend to wish the new thing was more like the old thing - it's a constant problem in software - people always push back when you change and make things different. I have tried to remind myself of this and not complain too much.

The basic scenario for me used to be:
1) Click the link to see the entire post and all comments.
2) Type in a comment and submit. The fields would remember my name and information from past comments.

The basic scenario now is:
1) Click the link the read the whole post.
2) Click the link to read all comments. But now I can't see the whole post. Usually I have to click again to see the post, and then again to see the comments (although RJS's suggestion to use two tabs, one for post and one for comments would help with this.)
3) Type in a comment, remembering to enter my name and info. ctrl-A, ctrl-C to copy my comment.
4) Captcha says I typed it in wrong. Go back and try again. Comment munged, so I will paste what I had copied.
5) Type new captcha and submit comment, forgetting to re-enter name and information. Post is submitted under "Your Name."

I have benefited greatly from JesusCreed and have not paid one dime. I realize it takes a lot of time and effort and I am truly very grateful for it. I feel like Beliefnet is trying to coerce me to click more often so that their ad view counts go up. Why else should I have to click to see post, then comments, then post, etc.? But perhaps it is a fair price to pay.

I don't intend this comment as a complaint. I am just trying to quantify one person's experience with the new as compared to the old, in case it can be of any help for the beliefnet folks in understanding where some of the JesusCreeders might be coming from.

Oh Matt complain! There is a time to complain and not to complain ... I realize I sounded threatening above, which wasn't my intent, but now I think "I'll take my business elsewhere" isn't a bad thing to say when we're dealing with a business entity like Beliefnet that is profting from us ... not that I'm angry about the economic meltdown and all the groups that have taken the money and run or anything like that ... that wouldn't be angelic would it? :) I want to be as far off the grid as I can right now and now I'm on the grid via Beliefnet ... my dilemna: Scot or off the grid, Scot or off the grid. Scot is winning thus far, but no, not happy ... Anyway, you describe my posting problems well, except that I also suffer from the endlessly rotating beach ball problem that seems to come up everytime I click ...

Amen Amen to Matthew S.

I haven't been hanging out here nearly as much, due to the awkwardness of not being able to simultaneously read the post and the comments...
and
I haven't posted here at all b/c when I finally was able to have the time AND patience (good grief, both at once!) to read through the blog post and all the comments and write a semi-coherent one myself, I got an error message and it disappeared into the black hole of blog-o-land.

Doubly frustrating that I'd already read the warning to copy before clicking "post", and of course, I forgot. Arggghhh. Admittedly, I am an old dog and new tricks don't come easily.

I suspect there are new post-ers here since beliefnet expands the audience, and I also suspect that I'm not the only oldie who is posting way less often b/c of these issues. I think I understand why Scot wanted to switch over to this site and I appreciate all that he has given me/us over the years, but to be honest, I am frustrated.

And as I finally go to post, I see the frustrating message that "this captcha has expired". When I hit refresh, it took me to that old post that I referenced above. Good thing I remembered the "copy" feature. Argghhh..... Let's try one more time....