
Over the next couple of weeks or so I would like to look at two books, not new but fairly recent, that think through some ideas on body and soul. The first is by Kevin Corcoran, Rethinking Human Nature: A Christian Materialist Alternative to the Soul where he develops a constitution view of human persons. Professor Corcoran is a philosopher teaching at Calvin College specializing in philosophy of mind, metaphysics, and philosophy of religion - a philosopher who tries to connect philosophy with bible, theology, faith, and science.
The second book is by Joel Green, now a professor of New Testament interpretation at Fuller Theological Seminary. His book Body, Soul, and Human Life: The Nature of Humanity in the Bible looks at a biblical view of human nature and argues that a dualistic view of the human person as material body and immaterial soul is inconsistent with both science and Scripture. Green is a biblical scholar who works to connect bible, theology, and faith with philosophy and science.
I, on the other hand, am a scientist who would like to connect science with philosophy, bible, theology, and faith. Join us it should be interesting.
To get this going let's start simple, with a little question.
What kind of things are we?

In their new book,
Hidden Worldviews: Eight Cultural Stories That Shape Our Lives
, Steve Wilkens and Mark Sanford examine cultural scripts that work against the gospel work in the Church.
Our theme today: scientific naturalism.
The motto: "Only matter matters."
We are back to the world of RJS: Where do you draw the line with the empirical and the natural for explanations? Is there God? Is there Spirit? Are we more than our chemicals and matter?
Another worldview script shaping culture and church is the one that claims that only what is scientifically demonstrable is true knowledge, and all things important can be reduced to the natural. The supernatural is hereby excluded. All we have are the perceived laws of nature -- eternal, unchanging, and somewhat deterministic. But also this makes the world reasonable. Naturalism is salvific as it guides humans into the good life.

We began a discussion Tuesday on the real and perceived barriers to the acceptance of an evolutionary mechanism of creation amongst evangelical theologians. The basis for our discussion is a recent survey by Bruce Waltke (or here), an Old Testament scholar, author of a Genesis commentary and other books. The results of his survey are available here: Waltke Scholarly Essay.
Waltke has a few conclusions and a few
suggestions. These are well worth considering in some depth. The presentation that follows below is a paraphrase - not a quote from the white
paper. The material is reorganized around three main themes according to my thinking at this time.
First - The caricature of evangelicalism as demanding Young Earth Creationism (YEC) is a gross oversimplification Some 46% of the evangelical theologians surveyed are comfortable with evolutionary creation. More than half are comfortable with some form of old earth creation, evolutionary or progressive. Many have nuanced and carefully considered views. The same general trend is found in other surveys as well. But it is a deep divide, and in some respects the division increases the heatedness of the discussion.
Like many evangelical OT scholars, Waltke sees a truth in Genesis that is goes beyond literal historicity. Reflecting on the first barrier and the 44% who found the interpretation of Genesis 1-2 to be a barrier to acceptance of evolutionary creation Waltke notes:
The first barrier can be lowered, I suggest, by recognizing the two levels of literature: the historical story level and the interpretive, creative plot level. On the story level the accounts of creation in Genesis 1 and 2 are historical; on the plot level they are creative representations of the historical reality.
[He uses an illustration of a glass half full of water, half full of air and continues] ... the additional creative element expresses truth beyond the historical reality. Similarly, the accounts of creation are based on real history, but presented creatively, using the form of ancient Near Eastern cosmogonies.
This is a big question for many of us these days.
What are the barriers to the acceptance of evolution amongst evangelicals? Can we (or should we) dismantle the "Great Wall" and overcome these barriers?

Biologos has planned a working group symposium (exclusive and invitation only or I would have it on my calendar as a must) to look at just this issue. The workshop will bring together 15 leading scientists, 15 leading pastors and 15 leading theologians to explore this issue. Tim Keller, Francis Collins, and Alister McGrath are among the "names" involved.
This is a critical conversation as we move forward - although I am convinced of both an old earth and an evolutionary mechanism of creation, this is not the end of the story. The theological ramifications must be considered thoughtfully, prayerfully - and with pastoral sensitivity. We must have conversation amongst sisters and brothers - fellow believers.
As part of the preparation for this workshop Bruce Waltke (or here), Old Testament scholar, author of a Genesis commentary and other books, was commissioned to write a white paper identifying barriers for the typical evangelical theologians to accepting the possibility of creation by means of an evolutionary process. The results of his research are available here: Waltke Scholarly Essay. The results of his survey provide the focus for the discussion I would like to have today (and Thursday).

[We've added the captcha text because we were bombarded by a spammer Monday. We hope the captcha text will disappear with the spammer soon.]
Last week I posted a question by a reader asking about categories of biblical literature and their "wooden historicity". There was another aspect to the comment though, and another question well worth consideration.
The original comment continued...
Speaking of that RJS, this reminds me of something that you've
said before in response to my question on why you believe a certain
thing to be the case. Your response, on occasion, has been to say that
this is what has been handed down in Christian tradition, from the
early church on. But, following our discussion here, surely the early
church and
much of Christian tradition thought the weather was directly, and in
real-time, controlled by God. So if we so easily question that
assumption now, why not others? The tradition argument alone seems
rather weak in that regard.
This leads to the question for today.
What role does tradition play in our interpretation of scripture and understanding of the faith?
(The picture above is the Church of the Holy Sepulcher in
Jerusalem, the traditional site of the crucifixion and burial. We
visited fall 2001 - when the lines were rather short.)
A "spam storm": of a hundred comments an hour or more requires the catcha back on for a time. Bear with us and join the conversation. (Copy a long comment before posting, so you won't lose the thought if the...
Did you see the new report about the piece in Science? Anyone read the article and have anything to add or say?Scientists in Ethiopia have found a 4.4 million year old human predecessor that promises to upend long-held notions of...
A couple of weeks ago I had a brief post asking why the scientific theory of evolution was a challenge for faith, but a scientific theory explaining weather was not a problem. (See here for the post: God, Science,...
Last week I posted on an article from Discover Magazine on the science of sin (Part One and Part Two). This article described a number of studies where the human brain was imaged as a function of external stimulus. These...
"Why does being bad feel so good?" Studies of brain response to various situations may provide important insights to this question.In the last post in this series we considered some of the science pertaining to lust, gluttony, and sloth...
While much of the furor over the conflict between science and faith centers on the question of origins and evolution - it is not limited to these questions alone. The sciences also impact our understanding of human behavior and...
Chapter 11 of Simon Conway Morris's book Life's Solution: Inevitable Humans in a Lonely Universe is titled Toward a Theology of Evolution, and to this we now turn.Conway Morris suggests that the view - common among many educated westerners steeped...
Several weeks ago we began a series looking at Simon Conway Morris's book Life's Solution: Inevitable Humans in a Lonely Universe. After a brief hiatus I will come back to this book with two final posts; today a discussion of...
Yesterday we finished off a discussion of John H. Walton's fascinating look at The Lost World of Genesis One. In the discussion of scientific explanations of origins in proposition 16, p. 136 Walton draws an analogy (He uses a few...
This is my last post on Walton's book, but RJS will have one tomorrow ...We come today to the end of John Walton's (professor at Wheaton) new book, The Lost World of Genesis One: Ancient Cosmology and the Origins Debate,...
Scot has handled most of the discussion on John Walton's (professor at Wheaton) new book, The Lost World of Genesis One: Ancient Cosmology and the Origins Debate, but I am going to jump in with a post on his next...
In John Walton's (professor at Wheaton) new book, The Lost World of Genesis One: Ancient Cosmology and the Origins Debate, we have yet another proposition to discuss:Current debate about Intelligent Design ultimately concerns purpose.Walton thinks Genesis 1 is about...
I will return to consider the next chapters of Conway Morris's book Life's Solution: Inevitable Humans in a Lonely Universe next week. Today I would like to take a brief detour and consider another question. Many authors - Dawkins and...
In John Walton's (professor at Wheaton) new book, The Lost World of Genesis One: Ancient Cosmology and the Origins Debate, we have yet another proposition to discuss:God's roles as creator and sustainer are less different than we have thought.Big...
In John Walton's (professor at Wheaton) new book, The Lost World of Genesis One: Ancient Cosmology and the Origins Debate, we have yet another proposition to discuss:The difference between origin accounts in science and Scripture is metaphysical in nature.Many...
We are in a conversation and discussion about John Walton's (professor at Wheaton) new book, The Lost World of Genesis One: Ancient Cosmology and the Origins Debate. We have been waiting for this day, or at least some of...
Chapters 2-5 of Simon Conway Morris's book Life's Solution: Inevitable Humans in a Lonely Universe ramble through a description of the rather tight constraints required for the formation of life and the lack of current understanding as to how life...
David Bentley Hart, a historian of ideas, Atheist Delusions: The Christian Revolution and Its Fashionable Enemies , puts the New Atheists -- Dawkins, Hitchens, Harris -- to the test in the theories that are at work to prop up...
We are in a conversation and discussion about John Walton's (professor at Wheaton) new book, The Lost World of Genesis One: Ancient Cosmology and the Origins Debate.Proposition 11: "Functional cosmic temple" offers face-value exegesis.In John Walton's view, his reading...
David Bentley Hart, a historian of ideas, Atheist Delusions: The Christian Revolution and Its Fashionable Enemies , examines how "faith and reason" were related in the Medieval Age in order to provide historical context for what has happened with...
We are in a conversation and discussion about John Walton's (professor at Wheaton) new book, The Lost World of Genesis One: Ancient Cosmology and the Origins Debate.Proposition 9 is another big one:The seven days of Genesis 1 relate to...
Today I start in earnest a series focused on Simon Conway Morris's book Life's Solution: Inevitable Humans in a Lonely Universe. This book is an exploration of the evidence for evolutionary convergence - the idea that there are islands...
We are in a conversation and discussion about John Walton's (professor at Wheaton) new book, The Lost World of Genesis One: Ancient Cosmology and the Origins Debate.Proposition 8 of Walton's book, and one that can reorient everything one sees...
We are in a conversation and discussion about John Walton's (professor at Wheaton) new book, The Lost World of Genesis One: Ancient Cosmology and the Origins Debate.Each chp in Walton's book is a "proposition" and today we look at...
We are in a conversation and discussion about John Walton's (professor at Wheaton) new book, The Lost World of Genesis One: Ancient Cosmology and the Origins Debate.Proposition 6: Days 4 to 6 install functionaries."... in most cases the functionaries...
What place can evolution have in a world created by a personal God?The Darwinian paradigm of random mutation and natural selection seems to suggest that the development of life in the universe and sentient beings on our planet is a...
We are in a conversation and discussion about John Walton's (professor at Wheaton) new book, The Lost World of Genesis One: Ancient Cosmology and the Origins Debate.What about Day 1 to Day 3 in Genesis 1? Is this about...
Yet another academic year approaches - yet another set of fresh new faces on campus. As we approach a the start of term I would like to renew the conversation on campus ministry we began last spring (You can find...
We are in a conversation and discussion about John Walton's (professor at Wheaton) new book, The Lost World of Genesis One: Ancient Cosmology and the Origins Debate.One reason why this book will be read, digested, and influential is because Walton...
We are in a conversation and discussion about John Walton's (professor at Wheaton) new book, The Lost World of Genesis One: Ancient Cosmology and the Origins Debate.(By the way, if you'd like a wonderful and God-shaped exposition of Genesis...
We finish off this series on Alister McGrath's book A Fine-Tuned Universe: The Quest for God in Science and Theology with a brief look at his conclusions, tying his major themes together. First a reiteration of what a robust natural...
We are in a conversation and discussion about John Walton's (professor at Wheaton) new book, The Lost World of Genesis One: Ancient Cosmology and the Origins Debate.What does it mean when we say "create"? John Walton argues that the...
Chapter 15 of Alister McGrath's book A Fine-Tuned Universe: The Quest for God in Science and Theology is entitled "An Emergent Creation and Natural Theology." This chapter presents some rather interesting ideas.First McGrath returns to Augustine - not to his...
We at the Jesus Creed blog, both Scot and RJS, have already invited one and all to enter into a conversation and discussion about John Walton's (professor at Wheaton) new book, The Lost World of Genesis One: Ancient Cosmology...
Chapter 14 of Alister McGrath's book A Fine-Tuned Universe: The Quest for God in Science and Theology deals with the question of teleology and directionality in evolution. The neo-Darwinian paradigm, (that popularized by Richard Dawkins for example), is that evolution...
There is a new book out Why Us?: How Science Rediscovered the Mystery of Ourselves by James LeFanu (HT TG). I have not read this book (yet anyway) - but it has received a fair bit of attention lately. It...
Is there evidence for design in biology? Or for that matter, what would constitute evidence of fine-tuning in biology?This is the next question arising as we continue on with Chapter 13 of Alister McGrath's book A Fine-Tuned Universe: The...
The July/August issue of Books and Culture contains an interview by Karl Giberson with Francis Collins on his views of science and faith - now available on line: Evolution, the Bible and the Book of Nature.Here is a brief taste...
RJS points us here to a major, major issue in the relationship of science and faith: the necessary distinction between "evidence" or "facts" and "interpretation." Not all, including Richard Dawkins, are careful to distinguish the two and this post...
Over the last year or so I've written a number of posts that have reflected on various aspects of the intersection of science and faith. These are issues and questions that I've thought about and wrestled with most of my...
Can These Bones Live? This is the question posed in Chapters 10 and 11 of Alister McGrath's book A Fine-Tuned Universe: The Quest for God in Science and Theology where he gives a brief overview of the chemical requirements for...
The second section of Alister McGrath's new book A Fine-Tuned Universe: The Quest for God in Science and Theology deals with fine-tuning and natural theology in the context of a number of scientific theories and observations. The first of...
For those who don't know this, this post is written by our friend "RJS," a professor in the sciences at a leading American university. She regularly posts here about issues intersecting science and faith.Last week in A Fine Tuned...
This a brief excerpt from another Beliefnet.com blog, called Science and the Sacred, by Darrel Falk. OK, we're all really proud that Falk begins by giving kudos to RJS for her posts on science and faith on Jesus Creed.I have...
Chapter eight of Alister McGrath's new book A Fine-Tuned Universe: The Quest for God in Science and Theology deals with the views of Augustine of Hippo on creation. Augustine and the relationship of Augustinian thought to evolution and Darwinian natural...
The first section of Alister McGrath's new book A Fine-Tuned Universe: The Quest for God in Science and Theology deals with his vision of a Trinitarian natural theology. As is typical in almost anything by McGrath the section rambles...
Today we begin a series of posts looking at Alister McGrath's new book A Fine-Tuned Universe: The Quest for God in Science and Theology. This book is an enlarged version of his 2009 Gifford Lectures in which McGrath examines the...
Nay, fly to Altars; there they'll talk you dead;For Fools rush in where Angels fear to tread.The Fool referred to by Alexander Pope was the literary critic of his day. Fear not - I intend no literary criticism. Yet the...
SMcK foreword: RJS's question below stunned me this morning. Did God create in such a way that the laws of nature were how he created, so that expecting something outside the laws of nature is looking for the wrong thing?...
A couple of months ago we had two posts based on a book Darwin and the Bible: The Cultural Confrontation - (first, second). This book was designed (with only modest success) to "help readers understand the nature, history, and passions...
This is a two-part series by Logan Paul Gage, of the Discovery Institute, about Intelligent Design. We posted part one last week -- this is part two, and today's post covers two themes: God and beauty.Intelligent design and the deity...
In volume one of Essentials of Evangelical Theology (2 Volumes in 1), Donald Bloesch has a chapter entitled The Primacy of Scripture and a section in his chapter on Total Depravity dealing with The Story of the Fall. We have...
SMcK comments up front: This is one of the most interesting posts we've seen from RJS, and I hope you read it, take it in, and offer your observations. Anyone who talks about evolution needs to talk about these...
This two-part series on Intelligent Design, in part a response to our ongoing discussions about evolution, is by Logan Paul Gage, a policy analyst at the Discovery Institute and who has written extensively on evolution.Intelligent Design and the Artist's Soul,...
A few years ago NT Wright published a short book on the authority of scripture: The Last Word: Scripture and the Authority of God--Getting Beyond the Bible Wars. Scot posted on this book when both the book and his blog...
Over the last several posts we have been considering approaches to interpret scripture that take seriously the nature of the text we have, the information from historical and scientific research, and the inspiration of scripture. This is, in my...
Kent Sparks's book God's Word in Human Words (GWHW) was the subject of a session organized by Peter Enns at the Society of Biblical Literature meeting last November. Dr. Enns has made some of this session available to a...
We have been working through Kent Sparks's book God's Word in Human Words (GWHW). A couple of posts ago (here) I suggested a way of looking at scripture as light rather than foundation; a change in perspective that I...
Scot linked to an article earlier this year: Obama moves to separate politics and science. When Scot brought this up (see here) he emphasized and directed conversation toward the issue of stem cell research - clearly an important issue and...
One of the commonly invoked arguments in any discussion of natural theology and the evidence for God is the Anthropic Principle - or put simply, the fact that the universe in which we live is incredibly finely tuned to support...
We continue our discussion of Kent Sparks's book God's Word in Human Words (GWHW) moving into Chapters 2 and 3: Historical Criticism and Assyriology and The Problem of Biblical Criticism. Before diving into the topic of Biblical Criticism, Sparks considers...
I don't ever jump in to introduce posts by RJS. But this post today is a summary and sketch of a very serious proposal for how to understand the doctrine of Scripture and our knowledge of Scripture/theology. Give this a...
In a post a couple of weeks ago (here) we opened a discussion on Kent Sparks' thought-provoking, and somewhat controversial book God's Word in Human Words (GWHW). Over the next several posts we will delve into this book more deeply.In...
At the Following Christ Conference this last December Francis Collins announced his coming BioLogos website and foundation. I was not at the conference, but several who were mentioned it in comments on various posts on this blog, so I've been...
The fourth chapter of Darwin and the Bible: The Cultural Confrontation is a contribution by Martinez Hewlett and Ted Peters entitled The Science of Evolution and the Theology of Creation. Peters is a Lutheran theologian who has written on science...
A couple of months ago Peter Enns posted on his blog part one of a review and discussion of Kenton Sparks' recent book God's Word in Human Words (GWHW). Although in writing part one Enns expressed hoped that part two...
Science and faith - Darwin and the Bible; these topics have excited a great deal of interest in our culture of late - and the spate of books on the topic shows little sign of abating. Several resources have...
We discussed the creation narratives in Genesis 1-3 in a series of posts earlier this year. The questions on the proper interpretation of Genesis don't stop with Genesis 3 however, and I received an e-mail last week with the following...
For many Christians the creation narratives in Genesis 1-2 and the fall in Genesis 3 are key passages in conversations concerning science and faith. The significance of our knowledge of the age of the earth and the theory of...
Several years ago John B. Cobb Jr. Professor Emeritus of the Claremont School of Theology organized a conference on evolution and religion. This conference eventually gave rise to a book of essays exploring various scientific and philosophical questions: Back...
We started a discussion a while ago on University Ministry - a discussion I would like to continue today. And I think the initial question to shape thinking is quite simple:What is the purpose or aim of a College or...
In the second chapter of his book Beginnings: Ancient Christian Readings of the Biblical Creation Narratives Peter Bouteneff discusses the uses of the creation narrative in the New Testament. The most important New Testament references are in the Pauline...
Scot has been presenting a series of related posts pondering the future of evangelicalism and the importance of youth ministry - something that may cover anyone from 12 to 30 or so these days. There are many aspects to this...
I am currently reading a book by Peter Bouteneff, a theology professor at St. Vladimir's Orthodox Theological Seminary, entitled Beginnings: Ancient Christian Readings of the Biblical Creation Narratives. This book explores the use of the creation narratives in Second Temple...
We have spent several posts looking at Gen 1-3 and at Paul's understanding of Genesis and its role in his atonement theology in Romans 5. In the course of this discussion several different people have brought up Romans 8, especially...
Michael Kruse brought these articles to my attention earlier this week. An ancient temple at Gobekli Tepe in Turkey revolutionizes thinking about ancient human culture and thought. A prehistoric construction, a "temple" dating from some 8000-12000 years ago. This...
Romans 5:12-21 is a great passage - and at the center of the passage is the achievement of Jesus through his death and resurrection. In his commentary on Romans NT Wright notes:Though the word "cross" is not mentioned, and though...
We started a conversation on Tuesday that touched on the subject of the nature of inspiration and the nature of scripture as the inspired word of God. Many have serious questions about the intent and interpretation of the Old Testament...
Romans 5:12-21 proves to be one of the key texts in any discussion of science and faith these days. We began a discussion of this passage last week with a consideration of the meaning and nature of the death...
Romans 5:12-21 proves to be one of the key texts in any discussion of science and faith these days, and the problem hits full force with v. 12:Therefore, just as through one man sin entered into the world, and death...
John Calvin of course was one of the principal leaders of the reformation in the 1500's. Calvin got many things right and, like everyone, many things wrong. In the protestant church in general and in the more reformed branch of...
Genesis 3 is one of the cornerstone passages of the Bible. Bill Arnold in his commentary on Genesis reflects that Gen 3 starts a new subject and introduces a new character, the serpent or snake. The significance and identity...
Genesis 2 begins another view of creation; another voice; a narrowed focus.First a context: We have discussed the issues of evolution and common descent in several different posts on this blog. The mounting evidence, most importantly the molecular genetic...
Genesis 1 has been studied, debated, and expounded as much as any text in world history. Scholars and amateurs alike have poured over this text for twenty-five hundred years, and it continues to demand our attention because of its arresting...
Bill T. Arnold, Director of Hebrew Studies and the Paul S. Amos Professor of Old Testament Interpretation at Asbury Theological Seminary has a new commentary out, Genesis (New Cambridge Bible Commentary Series) . This commentary is described as "an innovative...
One of the serious challenges facing many in our church today - in fact our church for the last couple centuries - is the interaction between reason and faith. How can we reconcile our increasingly sophisticated knowledge of history, of...
In this last post on Karl Giberson's excellent book Saving Darwin: How to Be a Christian and Believe in Evolution I would like to concentrate on two questions. This is probably one too many, but we will give it a...
Karl Giberson in his recent book Saving Darwin: How to Be a Christian and Believe in Evolution has devoted several chapters to discussion of Darwin's dark companions and to the history that has led to the culture war we find...
It is common in some circles to extol Darwin as one who makes it possible to be a fulfilled atheist and in others to vilify him as the servant of Satan who set out to destroy the faith. The truth,...
Scot having tried his hand at science a couple of weeks ago (here), I (RJS) will step up to bat once again and start to tackle what may be the toughest question in the science and faith discussion.We have been...
Most of the time I hand off anything about science to "RJS" but the next two chps in Adam Hamilton's Seeing Gray in a World of Black and White: Thoughts on Religion, Morality, and Politics are about Galileo and evolution and...
In the last post in this series I suggested that one of the important issues in the current discussion of science and faith in our culture deals with knowing; how do we "know" and understand? None of us can know...
As those who read this blog regularly will know, I (RJS) am a scientist and a professor - at a secular University, not a Christian college. This perspective and expertise plays a major role in my view of scripture...
One of the aims of our conversation on this blog is to grapple with the issues of reasonable faith. As a professor and a scientist, I (RJS) find this a crucial and unavoidable discussion. It is a fact of our...
I (RJS) saw Ben Stein's "documentary" movie EXPELLED: No Intelligence Allowed over Thanksgiving on DVD, or I saw parts of it anyway - some of the family saw the entire movie. I have also been asked about this movie at...
This post is from our scientist friend, RJS. She often blogs about science subjects here at Jesus Creed.I (RJS) have been accused on occasion, on this blog as a matter of fact, of arrogance for dismissing the young earth arguments...
I was listening recently to a recording of a public conversation between two Old Testament scholars, Dr. Peter Enns and Dr. Stephen Chapman, held at Duke and advertised as Is the Bible Ever Wrong? It is a fascinating conversation - well...
On the Jesus Creed we have been engaged in a brief discussion of original sin using Henri Blocher's book Original Sin: Illuminating the Riddle (New Studies in Biblical Theology) as a guide. This series is part of an ongoing attempt to wrestle...
Chapter 3 of Henri Blocher's book Original Sindeals with discerning the mind of Paul on the issue of Adam and the Fall. Any Christian discussion of the evolution life, the evolution of homo sapiens, and the doctrine of Original Sin...
The scenario sketched in our previous post leads to a deep question for Christians. How should we understand the Fall and Original Sin? Is the Adamic fall history or myth â albeit myth conveying theological truth? Is Adam everyman or...
Pastor (Park Street Church Boston) Daniel Harrell's new book, Nature's Witness: How Evolution Can Inspire Faith (Living Theology), is the book we need. Here is someone who can translate science into theology and theology into science, and do so in...
We had a good series of Friday posts on Alan Jacobs' excellent book "Original Sin." The essays in his book are outstanding and explore many facets of Original Sin in history and in contemporary thought. But Jacobs is an English...