J-Walking

Rev. Wright

Friday March 14, 2008

Categories: Faith, Politics

Rev. Jeremiah Wright is just another political rorschach test.

My very conservative white evangelical friends - friends who smile and say, "golly" when someone like the late Jerry Falwell said gays and abortionists and people who had them were responsible for 9/11 - are aghast, appalled, by Wright... appalled by the notion of "black empowerment," saying it is just positively racist.

Liberal African American friends are smiling and saying, "well, this doesn't sound too off to me." Poor friends in the center city who deal with crumbling schools and education that aspires to be substandard hear Wright's sometimes ferocious words and shrug their shoulders and say it sounds about right to them.

And so this is nothing even remotely new in America - it is our classic division by race. The division of wealth and privilege and status mixed up with a heated political season in a horrid economy amidst a failing and floundering war.

We are a broken country. That is our reality. Everything else is makeup. We will not be better off if Sen. Obama denounces Wright. It simply doesn't matter.

What does matter is the substance of the accusations. What matters is the sense of African American disenfranchisement. What matters is the reality of deep and brutal mistrust between the races. This is not about Wright and it is not about Obama. It is about us.

How are WE going to deal with these things?

To the degree our debate and discussion focuses on the political process - on what Obama says - we will fail for nothing will have changed. To the degree that we focus on substance something good will have come of this.

No, I am not endorsing the incendiary and un-Christlike words that Rev. Wright has spewed. I am just saying that if this is indeed a moment of change then we should change the way that we approach and talk about this matter and deal with the substance of it.

Advertisement
Comments
meh
March 15, 2008 6:19 PM

Wright's language and tone only serve to re-open wounds and not heal them.

You assume that since white folks have "gotten over" the last 400 years that the wounds are healed. Last I checked, the white folks haven't suffered many wounds in that time.

Pardon the rest of us if we don't pretend your millimeter-deep scratches are as important as the flaying other folks have taken.

Purple rain
March 15, 2008 8:21 PM

Last time I looked, it was white people that fought for centuries to end slavery. Slavery is alive and well and in African countries engaged in by Black African-Africans. Hello, Reverend Wright? And why is it, that of the vast majority of the missionaries going to the African continent, helping the poverty stricken Africans in all those different African countries are usually white evangelical Christians? Mr. Wright?

ando
March 15, 2008 10:01 PM

"Last time I looked, it was white people that fought for centuries to end slavery. Slavery is alive and well and in African countries engaged in by Black African-Africans." Apparently, White people have not, nor are now, engaged in any form of slavery, sexual or otherwise. And some Africans are now sending missionaries to this and other White-dominant countries. White Euro-Americans have done a lot of good in this world. But let's not lump them all together as saints. Corporate greed is alive and well. We still are the dominant power in the world. Let's be a little more moderate in our praise of all things White

Jacqueline Dukes
April 6, 2008 8:10 AM

I am 60, black, female, and agnostic. Missionaries have been some of the front persons for colonizer's who ended up with the land, and the people of the countries ended up with a new religion and a bible. Please do not use them as examples of virtue. Some are, but many have not been. Trying to change others to something they are not is a hostile act, as far as I'm concerned. I was raised Baptist, and during the Civil Rights days, the ministers may not have spoken so "energetically" but the civil rights movement was often organized within the church community. My grandparents always subscribed to the periodicals that contained information about the real situations for blacks--not just information that was deemed important by mainstream news.

During my youth, I would be instructed at school on the many "myths and legends" of American History, only to watch children being attacked by dogs as families sought to gain the rights that were supposed to be afforded to all American citizens on the nightly news. Billy Holiday was not singing about a banana tree that grew in an unexpected area, when she sang about "Strange Fruit." The Voting Rights Act was passed in the 1960s--not the 1860s. People were still being killed for trying to vote when I was in high school. If all was going well in this country, there would have been no need for the songs and the stories or the civil rights movement.

It is uncomfortable to consider actions of forefathers, but those actions have indeed been less than humane from the onset. Most Presidents during the early years, were slave owners, and no matter what spin is put on that truth--it is the truth. Had the mistreatment of the Native Americans and the slaves stopped at that time, we probably wouldn't be exchanging these words today. The fact is that for all persons of color, and many white people who were not perceived of the "right" background, the US experience has been painful for centuries. Yet these same people have been some of the most loyal citizens. Discrimination has been nonstop--even in the armed forces. Medals have been withheld. Acts of bravery have been surpressed, etc. Soldiers have survived war only to be killed after returning to the US. The deaths have been directly attributed to "isms." Stating what other groups or countries do does not excuse the "Great Democracy" from its behaviors. If the country wants to promote itself as the land of insensitive SOBs who don't care about anyone or anybody, then the behaviors won't be questioned. When a country tries to offer itself as the example of democracy, then the citizens can't be alarmed, when behaviors are questioned. People see through the hype.

From the very beginning, the Federalists believed that a few knew what was best for the masses as they sought their own success. That sounds so much like today. The wealthy have "legacy" entrance into the most prestigeous universities, and GPA is not a consideration, but the masses worry about whether or not a few people of color or gender difference have an opportunity that has been denied in the past. The tax laws have been skewed to allow the wealthy to keep what they have even into the next generations while paying a disportionate amount of taxes, and the middle and lower economic class is worried whether or not a minister stated some uncomfortable facts, and offered a possible theory about how HIV was initiated. The fact is that veneral disease was given to blacks in Tuskegee, Alabama. Drugs were taken into the Black community to fund initiatives overseas. Those facts can't be denied. A ten minute sound bite out of more than thirty years of ministry hardly presents a total range of the topics discussed. Where are the other messages--thirty plus years of them?

There are no appologies needed when truths are told to a constituency that needs to know history in order to survive. Being angry that these ugly truths are aired in church is a waste of energy as the country is spiraling downward economically and is emeshed in a war that there was never a chance of winning. I knew that based upon studies I had done in my twenties. Last election, the distraction was who was marrying and/or sleeping with whom. Now a key issue is whether or not a person should have quit their church.

First of all, Obama is neither white nor black. He is biracial and bicultural. Therefore, he is GREY! Furthermore, from childhood through education, Obama had limited black experiences. Being raised by a white mother and his white grandparents in Hawaii, would hardly prepare Obama to know how to interact within a black community. He had to learn how to things were in the lower 48. He needed to attend a church such as Rev. Wright's plus get involved in a neighborhood that would enable him to gain that understanding. Little about his early years would have prepared him to survive in any way in a typical black community. You don't know the expectations by DNA--those come from living within context. Obama's dad was African, not American. His step father was Indonesion. By life experiences, this man has a more global perspective than most candidates at any time. It is what makes him so unique. He is a brilliant and charismatic person, who looks through a different lens. If whites don't want to claim him because half of his DNA is non white, that's their loss. His other family wasn't even born in the US. I will gladly welcome him into my family--the human family. The ancestors to most African Americans would not have come from Kenya. That we don't share ancestry, but he resembles me matters little. I vote for white people frequently. That Obama might just be that person who can help us come together as a nation, and regain allies throughout the world is all that matters to me.

In order for conflicts to be resolved, the issues have to surface, and the emotions have to be considered before communication can take place and problems resolved. That is the standard conflict resolution model. These steps are too long overdue. Healing in the country cannot occur until this process is allowed to take its needed and natural course. If we are to survive, we have to think outside ourselves to the extent that our needs are addressed, plus the needs of someone else are addressed too. There has to be consideration of the greater good.

KAREN JOHNS
May 1, 2008 10:39 AM

Jaqueline I appreciate your comments I am not as literate as you, but I want to comment too. My children, both adult males, are bi-racial black and white. They have experienced prejudice in theire lifetime. They know what it is like to be black, even though one of them is as fair as me. All through school I had to fill out emergency contact cards that requested race. They were either black or white, they could not be both. After complaing of this for a few years, I was once told it was for some sort of benefits the school got. My children know what it is like to be black and white, from going camping/fishing with theire white country (but not prejudice uncles) to eating neckbones andplaying and watching sports with theire black uncles. They would never go againsnt either side of theire race, they do have different perspective on things though than if they were all white. A friend of mine told me that there is no way Mr Obama didnt know what the reverend wrights views were after attending his church for twenty years. I was always told you have to keep your eyes on God and not on man, and now I guess Reverend Wright is an example of why we are supposed to do that. I hope it does not hurt Obama's chances for being this country's thats made up of variety of God's children next president.

Read All Comments

Post a Comment

By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.



Please type the text you see in the box below to verify your post and help us prevent spam. You have a limited time to type - you may wish to compose your comment in a separate document and paste it here upon completion.

Type the characters you see in the picture above.

Advertisement

About J-Walking

This blog is no longer updated and is closed for comments. We welcome your comments about Christianity in our Christianity forums.

Read David Kuo's bio

Search This Blog

Advertisement

Advertisement


About Beliefnet

Our mission is to help people like you find, and walk, a spiritual path that will bring comfort, hope, clarity, strength, and happiness. More about Beliefnet.

Legal

Copyright © Beliefnet, Inc. and/or its licensors. All rights reserved. Use of this site is subject to Terms of Service and to our Privacy Policy. Constructed by Beliefnet.

Advertisement

Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.