Kingdom of Priests

David Klinghoffer: July 2009 Archives

Friday July 31, 2009

Categories: Personal

Restore our Counselors: Remembering William Hall

Strange how the mind works, isn't it? For some reason this morning I got up and was thinking about William Hall, a teacher I had in my sophomore year of high school who passed away tragically and quite young when I was in college. This was at Miraleste High School in Rancho Palos Verdes, California. When I think about people who seeded my spiritual life, such as it is, he would have to be at the top. Some things were troubling me today and I had the strongest feeling that if Mr. Hall were alive, 26 years after I last saw him, he would be the exact right person to turn to. I got all misty about him, which I don't normally do.

He taught Western Civilization and opened each year ritualistically by throwing an old black Holy Bible, with a little cross on the cover, clear across the room. The Bible would land, splat, on the floor and a girl could be counted on to gasp, "It's the Bible!" I can't recall what his point was exactly, but he would then declare, "It's only a book!"

He had a big grey beard and glasses, walked with a limp, and wore corduroy pants and fisherman smocks. He had phrases he would use, that he was known for: "Get with the program!" "Tough as nails! This test is nails, I tell you!" He led us through a survey of Western civ with incredible enthusiasm and a special attention to religious developments. In a unit on medieval cathedrals, he would demonstrate "Sooaaring buttresses! Sooaarring!" with great upward swoops of his arms.He was just back from a year's sabbatical in England and was all jazzed up for socialism. He never called anyone, at least not a boy, by his first name, only his last. I was "Kaye" (this was before I changed my family name back to its original form).

You got a very strong religious vibe from him but it was hard to nail down. He often bashed the Catholic Church. When my friend Bennett and I pestered him to know what religion if any he himself professed, he wouldn't say. The next year, we took his comparative religion class, and kept pestering him. Somehow, it seemed important to me to know. My guess was that he must be Jewish. Did I mention he and Mrs. Hall were known to have a huge number of kids? Something like seven or eight.

There was nothing pious or showy in Mr. Hall's personality but there was something -- I don't know how else to put it -- good about him. Just good. Once I lied to him about why I had missed class and I learned later that he knew differently from Bennett. Neither the lie nor the real or pretended reason was at all interesting, but the thought of lying to him now still makes me cringe. He never said a word about it.

Friday July 31, 2009

Categories: News & Politics

Can You Trust a Guy Who Doesn't Drink?

afterbeers_LJ-0110.jpg

The Hebrew Bible includes both praise for and warnings about alcohol. Even a Nazirite has to bring a sacrifice at the end of his vow period (which includes a prohibition against wine) to atone for having given up a legitimate worldly pleasure. In Jewish observance, you really can't be fully part of the program if you abstain. Maimonides includes drinking wine as a required feature of festival observance, for men, not only on Passover with its required four cups. Chabad Chasidic custom leans toward vodka, as do I.

I thought of this in light of yesterday's beer summit at the White House. As I was driving home from work, a caller to the Michael Savage show (which I find myself increasingly enjoying, to my surprise) noted that at the Obama-sponsored meeting between Professor Gates and Sergeant Crowley, only Crowley appeared to be drinking his beer. Obama and Gates each sipped delicately or not at all from a light beer. Biden had a low-alcohol brew, and appeared to disdain even that. At least this is how things went before the press was escorted away.

Thursday July 30, 2009

Categories: Jewish Holidays

Synchronicity and Tisha b'Av Amid Record-Breaking Heat for Seattle

When I got home last night ready to start the 25-hour fast of Tisha b'Av (no food, water, or bathing from sunset till dark the next day), mourning the destruction of the two Jerusalem Temples and much else that's tragic in Jewish history, the temperature was 105 degrees. Amazing! In Seattle, where thanks to the mellow, cool weather, nobody but the rich have air-conditioning in their homes! Today's not much better -- as I write at 6 pm it's 97 degrees. Still more than three hours left to go. Both our home and our synagogue are cooled only by fans, though thank God the office where I work is nicely air conditioned. My wife is having a less easy time of it at home. Luckily, our kids, who are too young to fast, don't seem much bothered. 

I believe in synchronicity, the idea that juxtapositions of time and events not only may seem meaningful but do in fact convey real meaning. See Jung on that. If a tough fast comes on a day of record-breaking heat, I assume there's meaning in it for me, and I don't see it as a congratulatory "Job well done!" sort of pat on the back from the Holy One Blessed Be He. 

You can't read the book of Lamentations, whose chanting represents the centerpiece of Tisha b'Av, without seeing suffering as a message. The book recounts the suffering that accompanied the destruction of Jerusalem by the Babylonians in 586 BCE. Much of it had to do with physical deprivation. When you fast, you neither feel nor look your best. So this verse from Lamentations caught my attention, referring to the Nazirites who previously had been specimens of health; now, "Their visage is blacker than a coal; they are not known in the streets: their skin cleaveth to their bones; it is withered, it is become like a stick" (4:8). That's about how I think I must appear right now.

Wednesday July 29, 2009

Robert Wright's Evolution of God

It's hard for a religious believer not to appreciate, at least in part, the spirit in which Robert Wright presents his new book The Evolution of God. On one hand, he regards the history of religion as the history of an illusion. On the other hand, he argues that the evolution of that illusion represents humanity's groping toward a truth about the universe that may include the existence of a force operating in human lives, a force that it may even be fair to call God.

He writes admittedly as a materialist -- for whom the most basic postulate holds that reality can be explained in purely material terms. He sees an "evolution" in the Bible where relatively primitive even polytheistic concepts are gradually replaced by more enlightened ones. His case for religion, such as it is, is about as compelling as you can expect, given the postulation of materialism.

I like the person I see in Wright's writing. Other materialists, on the basis of their own faith in such an arbitrarily constricted picture of the world, leap to demand the dismantling of religion, the mockery of religion's defenders, and their exclusion from public office. We have the example of bestselling atheist author Sam Harris attacking poor old Francis Collins, Obama's pick for the National Institutes of Health, on the New York Times op-ed page. Why? Because Collins is an enthusiastic Evangelical Christian. And we have Jerry Coyne in the New Republic belittling Wright himself as peddling "creationism for liberals." Wright must find such insults unsurprising. 

In his Afterword, he notes that following the Islam-inspired attacks of 9/11, faith as a whole acquired a foul odor. Many who previously would have been content to keep quiet about their atheism chose to go on the offensive. Today voicing even the mildly religion-friendly view that Wright does would invite mockery at, "say, an Ivy League faculty gathering unless you want people to look at you as if you'd just started speaking in tongues."

Luckily, Wright is not a professional academic but a scholarly journalist. He has also taught at Penn and Princeton, so he knows that terrain. What I like about him, apart from the fact that he writes wonderfully readable yet learned prose, is his generosity to people of faith. I'm not being ironic. He writes that he finds it "nice" (and I think there he is being ironic) that some people can lead morally exemplary lives without God. Yet he also finds this surprising: "the natural human condition is to ground your moral life in the existence of other beings, and the more ubiquitous the beings, the firmer the ground." It's for that reason that he wants to find, again given his materialist premise, the most compelling case for faith that he can.

Monday July 27, 2009

Categories: Jewish Community

A Morality Crisis in Orthodox Judaism?

Jeffrey Goldberg thinks there is such a crisis and conducts a very interesting interview with Erica Brown on the theme. You knew people would begin asking such questions, and answering them in the affirmative, when the Syrian Orthodox Jewish community centered in Deal, New Jersey, suffered its very public humiliation last week. 

My own answer is that the Jewish community suffers from a worldview crisis. There's too little discussion of the big questions that Judaism address, the answers to which the Torah deputizes the Jewish people to serve as priests in promulgating to the world. 

We've sold ourselves to the Enlightenment's promise of liberation through secularism. On the liberal end of the Jewish community, the sell-out to secularism is complete and entire. On the traditional end, we are too intimated to look Judaism's vision for us directly in the face, because that vision demands that we confront the secular world with its view of men as animals. 

This is the painful irrelevance of Orthodox Judaism. It's demoralizing in every sense of the word. I'm able to write about it with some authority because I feel the effects of that demoralization myself.

Monday July 27, 2009

On Jewish Atheists I

I've been mulling the fact that some of the leading figures in the New Atheist movement are born-Jews, at least according to their own accounts. Christopher Hitchens is Jewish through his mother's mother (and proud of it, which I find...

Friday July 24, 2009

Darwinists and Their Strategy of Intimidation

Some commenters on an earlier post have expressed doubt that believers in Darwinism seek to intimidate dissenters. Give me a break! Of course that's exactly what Darwinists try to do whether in academic life or in the humbler context of...

Thursday July 23, 2009

Categories: The Way We Live Now

Shocked by Littering: How a Civilization Crumbles

I was waiting in line at a drive-thru Starbucks here in Redmond just now, as the third car in line. The occupants of a black pickup at the head of the line seemed to be taking an incredibly long time...

Thursday July 23, 2009

Categories: Jewish History

The Romantic View of Sephardic Jews Runs into a New Jersey Pothole

That's Deal, New Jersey, I refer to, the scene of the arrest of some rabbis associated with the Syrian Sephardic community. The Syrian Jewish community there and in Brooklyn is often referred to as an "enclave." Being an enclave generally...

Thursday July 23, 2009

Deuteronomy on "Poor-Mouthing"

"Poor-mouthing" means talking about yourself as if you were poor, or poorer than you are, in order to engage other people's sympathy. I won't hide from you that our family continuously and increasingly faces issues of insolvency -- yet the...

Thursday July 23, 2009

Categories: Housekeeping

Why Darwinists Have a Hard Time Being Civil

It's been so illuminating to me, dealing with Darwinists all the time on this blog -- cleaning up after them (unpublishing their rude comments, personal insults, etc.). Their purpose is intimidation. Normal people don't enjoy dealing with rudeness, so they...

Wednesday July 22, 2009

Categories: Jewish Philosophy

Francis Collins Mangles Maimonides -- Following Leon Wieseltier?

When I complained a couple of days ago about people who misrepresent Maimonides as a proto-Darwinist, then cited a newish biography by Joel Kraemer on the subject as solid evidence that Maimonides would be an intelligent-design advocate and that the...

Wednesday July 22, 2009

Categories: Israel

George Gilder's Israel Test

Can the case be made in purely secular terms that Israel's continuing existence should urgently matter to the United States? Because if not, Israel is in serious trouble. The Jewish state can't rely exclusively on Evangelical Christians and, secondarily, Jews...

Tuesday July 21, 2009

Rashi's Importance for Christians

Regarding Elie Wiesel's new biography Rashi, on the great medieval French commentator on the Torah, the Hebrew Bible, and the Talmud, I mentioned that he's important not just for Jews but for Christians. His name is an acronym for Rabbi Shlomo...

Tuesday July 21, 2009

It Is Rashi Speaking

Today is the Yahrtzeit (death anniversary) of Rashi, whose massive commentary on most of the Hebrew Bible and Talmud defines much of the meaning of those documents not only for Jews but for Christians too. I've been reading Elie Wiesel's sweet...

Tuesday July 21, 2009

Categories: Housekeeping

New House Rule: No Sock Puppetry

My purpose here as always is to make sure that anyone with an idea or response to share will feel comfortable participating in any discussion sparked by this blog. Turmarion, a thoughtful reader and oftentimes critic of what I write,...

Tuesday July 21, 2009

A Challenge to Intelligent Design-Bashing Regulars on this Blog

You know who you are. Rather than go on grousing about how there's no evidence for intelligent design, it's not science, and so on and so forth, here's my challenge to you personally. Read Stephen C. Meyer's new book, Signature...

Monday July 20, 2009

Categories: Jewish Philosophy

Maimonides on Intelligent Design, According to New Biographer

Gosh, I get so tired of cliches from religion-friendly mush-heads. According to one such cliche:Maimonides was a physician. A physician is a kind of scientist. Maimonides was therefore a religious scientist. Consequently any attempt to merge any science-flavored idea, such...

Friday July 17, 2009

Categories: Other Faiths

2012 -- End of the World?

The Mayan calendar runs out at the end of 2012, a purported signal that the world will then either face an apocalyptic end or realize a complete transformation of consciousness. Author Daniel Pinchbeck did a lot to popularize the idea, and...

Friday July 17, 2009

Categories: Jewish Observance

Jewish Dating Advice -- Confidential! (And Keep It That Way)

I'm kicking myself right now. An old friend from the East Coast got in touch with me about setting up her brother-in-law with an eligible and attractive single Jewish woman here in Seattle, and did I know of such a...

Thursday July 16, 2009

The Real Enemies of Israel and the Jews

What group, movement, or country is it that Jews really have to worry about and devote energy to combatting? Is it Iran? Palestinian anti-Semites? Terrorists generally? Neo-Nazis? If you go on the ADL website, you'll see a big tribute to...

Thursday July 16, 2009

Necromancy and Alzheimer's Among Darwin Faithful

That's my subject at Evolution News & Views, where I take on a response to the Thomas Jefferson/intelligent design connection from University of Chicago biologist Jerry A. Coyne. Read the rest there. Excerpt below:On his blog, Coyne lashes out at "young-earth...

Wednesday July 15, 2009

Categories: News & Politics

Peace for Our Time! With Dr. Collins, How Far Is Too Far?

When it comes to capitulating to secularism, how far is too far? I'm serious. This is not a rhetorical question.Washington Post columnist Michael Gerson, an Evangelical Christian and former Bush speechwriter, writes glowingly of Obama's Francis Collins nomination for NIH:Collins's appointment...

Wednesday July 15, 2009

Boston Globe, Den of Theocracy!

There must be a nest of theocrats over at the Boston Globe, ready to spring Christianist rule on us all. Someone call Andrew Sullivan! On today's op-ed page they publish Stephen C. Meyer who argues that if you like the Declaration of Independence,...

Tuesday July 14, 2009

Categories: Israel

Jews at the White House -- A Thought Experiment

Just imagine: If the American Jewish community were known to stand predominantly for something grand, cosmic, eternal, permanent, and universal in significance, don't you think the President of the United States would be likelier to listen to us when we...

Tuesday July 14, 2009

Categories: Jewish Mission

Jews at the White House -- What Are "Jewish Concerns"? Just Israel?

Yesterday, 16 top American Jewish leaders, representing 14 major Jewish organizations, met with Barack Obama in the White House. They had the ear of the president of the United States. From news reports, it seems they chose to talk about...

Tuesday July 14, 2009

Ode on a Grecian Flypaper Strip

Is beauty in the eye of the beholder? This bears upon our earlier discussion of whether a horribly vile Lovecraftian creature would satisfy God as the ultimate product of an undirected process of evolution as imagined by Darwin. Impoverished island-dwelling...

Tuesday July 14, 2009

A Staff in God's Hand: On the Approach of Tisha b'Av

A final thought on hate and the condition to which traditional religious believers are subjected in this world. Judaism encourages us to look closely at the name of the Torah reading each week, always drawn from a word, sometimes a seeming...

Monday July 13, 2009

Categories: News & Politics

Let's Retire the Word "Fundamentalist"

It sometimes happens that a word outlives its usefulness and has to be put out to pasture along with other terms like "Negro," for example, or "Oriental." Or maybe the preferable metaphor would be partial retirement. We can still appropriately...

Monday July 13, 2009

Categories: Housekeeping

On Being Hated (at Brown): A Postscript

Yesterday I wrote about the personal viciousness that issues from the Left in a way it doesn't from the Right. This actually played a big role in the development of my own thinking, both religious (toward Orthodox Judaism) and political...

Monday July 13, 2009

Categories: Jewish History

A Jewish Pope?

There are certain things we take for granted about Judaism that turn out not to be so. Like that Jews never proselytized. That they don't have a mission to the world. And that, for another example, Judaism after the destruction...

Sunday July 12, 2009

Categories: Housekeeping

On Being Hated: A Note to -- and About -- Readers

Good news: As I know from the weekly reports I get from Beliefnet, traffic on this still relatively new blog keeps going up. That's heartening. Yet if you follow the comments box at all here you will have noticed something...

Friday July 10, 2009

Categories: Jewish Observance

Why the Jews Worshiped a Golden Calf

Yesterday, groggy from fasting, I read a draft of an essay for a friend. I hope I was helpful in giving some comments to him. I can go relatively easily without the food and maybe the water (from dawn to dark) but...

Friday July 10, 2009

H.P. Lovecraft, Darwinism's Visionary Storyteller

Picture a majestic T. rex receiving the tablets of the Ten Commandments in its undersized forelimbs, or an elegant octopus crucified on an old rugged cross with four crossbars instead of one.Such images are what Kenneth Miller presumably has in...

Wednesday July 8, 2009

Categories: News & Politics

Francis Collins on Abortion: Obama's Pick for NIH and His "Devout" Views on Terminating Down Syndrome Children

Do you ever notice how religious believers are always cited by the media as "devout" precisely when they are equivocating on basic Judeo-Christian moral and theological tenets? Dr. Francis Collins has some startling ideas on abortion. Startling, that is, from an...

Wednesday July 8, 2009

Categories: News & Politics

Francis Collins: Picked by Obama, Attacked by Atheists, Wrong on Theology

Genome scientist and Evangelical Christian Francis Collins got the nod from President Obama today to head up the National Institutes of Health. Atheists are already on the attack. Thus Jerry Coyne at the U. of Chicago pronounces himself "worried": "I'd...

Tuesday July 7, 2009

Categories: Moral & Moralesque

Full Female Crudity (& Gay Marriage)

Herodotus in his Histories describes the primitive tribes that lived on the western shore of the Caspian sea in ancient times. Some, he reported, were said to "couple in the open...like animals in herds." Perhaps that's what we as a culture are...

Tuesday July 7, 2009

Jewish Mysticism Meets Intelligent Design: Whose Signature in the Cell?

My op-ed in the Jerusalem Post today discusses the eerie anticipation of ideas about the genetic code by Jewish mysticism, or kabbala. I cite the Tanya (1796) but the tradition on this -- creation through the combination of letters --...

Monday July 6, 2009

What Idolatry Isn't

Everyone thinks they know what idolatry is. Do they? Something I came across in the Talmud this morning prompts me to ask.As my friend Rabbi Daniel Lapin puts it, the Talmud is best understood as a spiritual-intellectual laboratory where instead...

Friday July 3, 2009

Categories: Jewish Mission

What Jewish Mission?

A remarkable opinion piece by Joel Alperson and carried by JTA includes this observation:I've collected the mission statements of the largest 17 Jewish federations in North America, and not one mentions "God," "Torah" or "Judaism." Nor do the mission statements...

Thursday July 2, 2009

Categories: Moral & Moralesque

Why Gay Activists like Dan Savage Get Mad When You Point Out the Truth

The truth, that is, about the impact on women if Savage's dreams of men marrying men come true. In the gay marriage debate, heterosexual women are a crucial swing vote. Every poll I've looked at shows this: men are more opposed...

Wednesday July 1, 2009

"Worldview-Induced Blindness," Intelligent Design, & the Ashes of the Red Heifer

Chuck Colson's formulation, "worldview-induced blindness," that I noted yesterday helps explain a lot of things. It explains, for example, why believers in Darwinism can't open their eyes and see when presented with scientific evidence of design in nature. (Note to...

Advertisement

feed icon Subscribe

RSS Feed

Receive updates from Kingdom of Priests

About Kingdom of Priests

David Klinghoffer is an author and senior fellow in the Religious, Liberty & Public Life program at the Discovery Institute. His writing has appeared in the Los Angeles Times, The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, the National Review, the Weekly Standard, and the Jewish Forward. A California native, he currently lives on Mercer Island, Washington, with his wife and five children.

Advertisement

Advertisement


About Beliefnet

Our mission is to help people like you find, and walk, a spiritual path that will bring comfort, hope, clarity, strength, and happiness. More about Beliefnet.

Legal

Copyright © Beliefnet, Inc. and/or its licensors. All rights reserved. Use of this site is subject to Terms of Service and to our Privacy Policy. Constructed by Beliefnet.

Advertisement

Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.