| Audience: | Middle School |
| MPAA Rating: | Rated PG for epic battle action and violence. |
| Profanity: | None |
| Nudity/Sex: | Kiss |
| Alcohol/Drugs: | None |
| Violence/Scariness: | Intense and prolonged battle violence, arrows, crossbows, catapults, swords, scary monsters, childbirth scene |
| Diversity Issues: | Diverse characters, strong females |
| Movie Release Date: | May 16, 2008 |
The Pevensie children are back in London and contemporary life seems pale and uninvolving compared to their adventures in the magical land of Narnia. As they wait for the Tube, a wall opens up and just as happened when they went through the wardrobe, they stand before the entryway to Narnia again. This time, they know immediately where they are. What they don't know is when they are. Everything is different. "I don't remember any ruins in Narnia," one says. Lucy (Georgie Henley) confidently approaches a bear, introducing herself as though she was inviting him to tea. But he growls and charges. "I don't think he could talk at all," she says with surprise. "If treated like a wild animal long enough, that's what you become," explains Trumpkin (Peter Dinklage in heavy gnomish make-up). "You may find Narnia a more savage place than you remember."
"Everything you know is about to change," says one character and that serves as a warning and a prediction that applies to all of the great adventures before the Pevensies -- the battle for Narnia, the challenges of growing up, and the struggles of leadership, faith, and principle.
As the Pevensies explore, they find that 1300 years have passed in Narnia since they helped Aslan the lion (voice of Liam Neeson) defeat the White Witch (Tilda Swinton) and end the tyranny of Narnia's perpetual winter. It is summer, but there is no peace and prosperity in Narnia. The nearby Telmarines have done their best to wipe out all of Narnia. Those creatures who are left are in hiding, without a leader. Aslan, who seemed the answer to all questions in their first visit may have been glimpsed by Lucy, but the others are not willing to believe her. And they meet up with Prince Caspian (Ben Barnes), the rightful heir to the throne of the Telemarines, usurped by his evil uncle. Wary of each other at first, Caspian and the Pevensies join forces to battle for the freedom of the Narnians.
Like the first film, this is a grand and visually stunning epic with thrilling battle scenes and powerful themes. This one has more violence but also more humor, especially from the most welcome new character, a mouse with the heart of a lion and the voice of Eddie Izzard. Like the book, one of the less compelling of the seven-volume series, it is not as involving as the first. Barnes has a nice screen presence (though his accent sounds like he is trying out for a road show version of "West Side Story" as one of the Sharks). The pacing is strong, the effects are superb, and the battles are exciting. The themes are presented with a subtlety that encourages thoughtful consideration, with a range of possible interpretations.
Don't let the PG rating fool you. This is a long, intense, violent epic with the deaths of both good guys and bad guys, and it is not suitable for young children. The earlier film had some difficult and troubling material, including the shearing and apparent death of Aslan and the emotional corruption of one of the Pevensie children by the White Witch. But this one has a childbirth scene (with the mother in evident distress) and a retreat from battle that involves the loss of Narnians that is the fault of one of the Pevensies. The disturbing material may be darker than the first for some viewers.
Parents should know that this movie has very intense and explicit battle violence for a PG film, including arrows, crossbows, catapults, swords, knives, and various kinds of mayhem. Characters are injured and killed (including some of the good guys), including a beheading. There are some scary-looking monsters and some tense and menacing confrontations. The movie opens with a childbirth scene that shows the mother in considerable distress.
Families who see this movie should talk about why only Lucy saw Aslan. Why did he say (twice) that things never happen the same way twice? Why doesn't he help them sooner?
Families who enjoy this movie will also enjoy the original and the books
Add to Del.icio.us
Add to Technorati
Add to Digg
Add to Newsvine
Subscribe
I thought that the movie was awesome. My six year old son loved it and thought that it was better than the first one. I thought it was a very good family movie! There are certainly a lot more things I object to on Nickelodeon or other so-called kid's shows than the fighting contained in this movie. When the characters died, there wasn't any blood, they just fell down.
I did not enjoy this movie at all. They turned c.s. lewis's masterpiece into a story that cut and pasted in order to turn a bigger profit. They invented a love interest, completely added the invasion of the castle, created a feud between caspian and peter, and turned peter from a regal former king into an angsty teenager. They also added the fight at the beginning and completely changed the dispositions of many of the characters. If C.S. lewis was still alive, this movie would have been insulting to him.
This movie was GREAT! i took a group of jr high/high school kids to see it and they LOVED it. not too much violence, but enough to entertain. :) great story of overcoming the problem of having too much pride!
Took my 9yo and wish I had not. The symbolism of C.S. Lewis is completely lost. The plot is weakly developed. The violence is almost non-stop. Some have said it is bloodless, so the constant fighting, stabbing, goring, hacking is okay. I don't get that. Violence is violence. The message of the movie, other than one faint line from the little girl, is that war is the way to resolve to conflict. Blessed are the peacemakers, I thought. Special effects are intense, some scary characters, too long. I would put it in the worst 10 movies I have seen in recent years.
This is most definitely NOT a family film. It is a mind-numbing violent war movie with no charm and no redeeming value. If you want to desensitize your Middle school children to violence, by all means take them. If you want to bring up caring, responsible human beings, keep them away. Sure, C.S. Lewis' original story talks about redemption and spirituality. But it is lost in the constant battles and death.
Post a Comment
By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.