Roger Ebert says the case is closed on 3D — it can never work. He has some powerful support for his position, a letter from Walter Murch, “the most respected film editor and sound designer in the modern cinema.” Murch says that “horizontal movement will strobe much sooner in 3D than it does in 2D. This was true then, and it is still true now. It has something to do with the amount of brain power dedicated to studying the edges of things. The more conscious we are of edges, the earlier strobing kicks in.” He says our brains are not capable of processing 3D movie technology, because “the glasses “gather in” the image — even on a huge Imax screen — and make it seem half the scope of the same image when looked at without the glasses.”
I’m not sure I agree; I expect a glasses-free 3D technology is possible, for one thing. But I do agree with Ebert that there is a much less gimmicky and much more powerful enhancement — Ebert’s counter-recommendation — called Maxivision48.
Movies “move” because we see a series of still pictures so quickly that it fools our eye through something called “persistence of vision.” It’s the same technology as a flip-book, and it hasn’t changed much since it shifted from 16 frames per second to 24 when movies added sound (this is why silent films often seem jerky). Unlike current digital equipment, which replicates the 24 frames per second standard, Maxivision combines digital and film to eliminate wasted space and project at 48 frames per second to give the audience a fresher, clearer, more distinct image.
I love their tagline: “See What You’ve Been Missing.”
-
Advertisement
-


click here to see all of our uplifting newsletters» Movie Mom™ Reviews
Search This Blog
Sort Reviews By
Subscribe
SubscribeCategories
- Features & Top 10s
- "Gothika Rule"
- Actors
- Advertising
- After the kids go to bed
- Awards
- Behind the Scenes
- Beliefnet Highlights
- Books
- Breakthrough Perfomers
- Commentary
- Contests and Giveaways
- Cool Stuff
- Critics
- Directors
- Disabilities and Different Abilities
- Early Readers
- Elementary School
- Environment/Green
- For Your Netflix Queue
- Great Characters
- Great Movie Moments
- Interview
- Live Theater
- Marketing to Kids
- Movie Mom's Top Picks for Families
- Neglected gem
- New on DVD/Blu-Ray
- Original Version
- Parenting
- Preschoolers
- Quiz
- Quote of the Week
- Rediscovered Classic
- Smile of the Week
- Special Effects
- Spiritual films
- Spoiler Alert
- Stars
- Supercuts and Mashups
- Teenagers
- This Week at the Box Office
- Trailers and Previews
- Tribute
- Tweens
- Understanding Media and Pop Culture
- Writers
- Festivals
- Genre
- 3D
- Action/Adventure
- Animation
- Based on a book
- Based on a play
- Based on a television show
- Based on a true story
- Based on a video game
- Biography
- Classic
- Comedy
- Comic book/Comic Strip/Graphic Novel
- Courtroom
- Crime
- Date movie
- Documentary
- Drama
- Epic/Historical
- Family Issues
- Fantasy
- For all ages
- For the Whole Family
- Gross-out
- High School
- Horror
- Independent
- Inspired by a true story
- Musical
- Mystery
- Politics
- Remake
- Romance
- Satire
- School
- Science-Fiction
- Series/Sequel
- Spies
- Sports
- Stories About Kids
- Superhero
- Talking animals
- Thriller
- Tragedy
- War
- Western
- Holidays
- Internet, Gaming, and Apps
- Kids
- Lists
- Media Appearances
- Music
- Opening This Week
- Q&As
- Reviews
- Television
- The Real Story
- Features & Top 10s
About Movie Mom
Movie Mom's Archives
Movie Mom's full archives of more than 1,400 reviews (including her 200 best films for families) and 400 blog posts is now on Beliefnet for searching.- Movie Mom is a registered trademark of Nell Minow.
Copyright 1995-2012 Nell Minow. All Rights Reserved. -
Advertisement

