Beliefnet
News

Thursday July 24, 2008

Obama Tells Israel He's Committed to Its Security

Associated Press

Sderot, Israel - From the solemnity of a Holocaust museum to a dusty village battered by Hamas rockets, Democratic presidential contender Barack Obama on Wednesday professed "an unshakable commitment to the security" of Israel, whether the threat comes from terrorists, Iran or elsewhere.

"The way you know where somebody's going is where have they been. And I've been with Israel for many, many years now," he said on a day that bore striking similarities to campaigning in the United States.

In his public remarks, Obama sidestepped a question of whether he would condone an Israeli attack to prevent Iran from obtaining a nuclear weapon. But he said he was confident that in several private meetings he had not left Israeli politicians with the impression that, if elected president, he would be "pressuring them to accept any kinds of concessions that would put their security at stake."

Obama packed more than a half-dozen meetings, a stop at the Yad Vashem Holocaust memorial, a helicopter tour of the country and a visit to a house hit by Hamas rockets into his only full day in Israel during his trip to the Middle East and Europe.

He also rode past an Israeli checkpoint into Ramallah on the West Bank, where he assured Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas of his support for a two-state resolution of the region's long animosities. Later, entering a session with Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, Obama said his talks with Abbas indicated "there's a strong sense of progress being made" toward peace. Olmert nodded and said, "Indeed."

Before dawn Thursday in Jerusalem, paid a predawn visit to the holiest place in Judaism, bowing his head in prayer at the Western Wall and pushing a small note into a crevice in the ancient wall, a custom that is observed by many.

Obama's major focus was clearly reassuring Israelis - and by extension millions of Jewish voters in the United States - of his commitment to the survival of the Jewish state. He leads his Republican rival, Sen. John McCain of Arizona, among Jewish voters, but his support falls short of what Democrat John Kerry drew four years ago.

Obama said Israelis could be certain of his commitment to Israel's security by looking at "my deeds."

"Just this past week, we passed out of the U.S. Senate Banking Committee, which is my committee, a bill to call for divestment from Iran, as a way of ratcheting up the pressure to ensure that they don't obtain a nuclear weapon," he said.

However, Obama does not serve on the banking committee, and McCain's campaign seized on the mistake.

"Not only is it not his committee, but he's not even on the committee, he didn't vote on the bill, and he had nothing to do with its passage," McCain spokesman Tucker Bounds said in a statement issued Wednesday.

Obama's trip is financed by his presidential campaign, and he flew to Israel from Jordan on Tuesday night about his chartered Boeing 757 emblazoned with his trademark slogan, "Change We Can Believe In."

If his campaign aides were looking for memorable images during the day, they got them, from Obama donning a skullcap at the Holocaust memorial, to President Shimon Peres saying, "God Bless You" outside his official residence, to a stop at a house under reconstruction in Sderot where he saw firsthand the destruction caused by Hamas rockets.

"People are committed," he said, making a fist and thumping his chest three times.

Shielded by intense U.S. and Israeli security, he then traveled a short distance to the local police station. There, Defense Minister Ehud Barak, Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni and local officials showed him racks filled with debris from Hamas rockets that have landed in Sderot in the past seven years. In 2005 Israel withdrew from the Gaza Strip a mile away.

The same racks formed a made-for-television backdrop for a news conference attended not only by U.S. reporters, but also Israelis whose satellite trucks jammed the parking lot across the street.

Eli Moyal, the local mayor, gave Obama a souvenir T-shirt - merely the latest he has received since he began running for president - and the senator also came away with a gift of a piece of rocket as artwork, attached to a wooden plaque.

Gaza Hamas official Fawzi Barhoum had a less-favorable response to Obama's visit to Sderot:

"Hamas considers the remarks of the Democratic candidate today to be part of the American policy of bias towards Israel and giving legitimacy to Israeli crimes against our people. His remarks today give cover for the occupation's nonstop crimes against our people."

The subject of Tehran's presumed drive to gain a nuclear weapon - and the threat that would pose to Israel - was a recurrent theme throughout the day.

The American presidential candidate said, "Iranians need to understand that whether it's the Bush administration or an Obama administration, that this is a paramount concern to the United States."

He said he favors both "big sticks and carrots" to persuade Iranians to switch course.

"What I have also said, though, is that I will take no options off the table in dealing with this potential Iranian threat. And understand part of my reasoning here.

"A nuclear Iran would be a game-changing situation, not just in the Middle East but around the world. Whatever remains of our nuclear nonproliferation framework, I think, would begin to disintegrate. You would have countries in the Middle East who would see the potential need to also obtain nuclear weapons."

At his news conference, Obama brushed aside a question of whether he had backed off his statement this spring that Jerusalem should be the undivided capital of Israel. Palestinians also lay claim to the city as the capital for any state they establish as the result of peace talks, and the two sides have agreed that the final decision is to be negotiated.

Criticized by Abbas after he made that comment, Obama subsequently amended it. "Well, obviously, it's going to be up to the parties to negotiate a range of these issues. And Jerusalem will be part of those negotiations," he said. He added that "as a practical matter, it would be very difficult to execute" a division of the city.

Abbas issued a statement saying he and Obama had not discussed the issue in their hour together.

Asked by an Israeli reporter about the matter, Obama said, "I continued to say that Jerusalem will be the capital of Israel. And I have said that before and I will say it again. And I also have said that it is important that we don't simply slice the city in half. But I've also said that that's a final status issue."

Obama departs on Thursday for Germany, where he is scheduled to deliver an outdoor speech before a large crowd. He also has stops planned for France and England before flying back to the United States on Saturday.

Associated Press writers Matti Friedman, Laurie Copans and Ian Deitch contributed to this story.

Copyright 2008 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Post a Comment

Comments

Neither political party will lead us into being honest brokers over the Middle East, that's clear. The best thing we could do would be to leave augmenting a peace settlement to others who are more neutral, but it's not clear who would take it up.

It is also clear a war between the US and Iran is utterly against our interests and I believe Obama is less likely to want to start one than is McCain, who's sung about bombing Iran.

It's tragic that the US political system requires a candidate to make certain unwise commitments in order to have a chance to be elected.

McCain and Obama are going to say things folks want to hear....they both want to run this country.

Obama certainly had a huge crowd (200,000)listening to him in Germany...and at least from the TV news he left them with a very good impression.

It's tragic that the US political system requires a candidate to make certain unwise commitments in order to have a chance to be elected.

If a candidate doesn't promise to help protect our family, he won't get the Jewish vote. And his chances for winning will drop dramatically.

I wonder what would happen if the Muslim vote was as important as the Jewish vote.

So if a candidate didn't promise to protect Germany he shouldn't expect votes from people of German heritage? Same for Spanish? Palestinian? Greek? Russian? Chinese? We'd end up trying to protect the whole world from itself, which we've clearly shown ourselves to be incompetent at.

rmcq you've put your finger on it.

I wonder what would happen if the Muslim vote was as important as the Jewish vote.

Then we'd be dead.

When an actual Holocaust happens to the Germans or the Spanish or the Greeks or the Poles or the Chinese - an actual attempt to exterminate them from the face of the earth - they'll understand why this is important to us. Until then, well, we know how they think on this matter.

In the meanwhile, every Jew anywhere is family to every other Jew and we have to stand up for one another.

scott, have you found the windows and doors blog yet? Look under faiths&practices/judaism.

Someday, when every person in this world treats everyother person in this world like family, we will finally understand the importance of not killing eachother.

Until then, I'm taking cover.


Someday, when every person in this world treats everyother person in this world like family, we will finally understand the importance of not killing each other.

C, be careful what you wish for. The first murder we know was of one brother killing the other (Cain and Abel).

Too bad people won't get the larger sense of the word "family", which we all certainly are, on a global scale. While I truly hate to be a pessimist, I don't believe we'll ever get there.


Did you all hear what Obama said in Germany? He is first of all a citizen of The United States of America, and then a citizen of the world. He cares about all people, and justice is important to him. The people in other countries see this and believe him. Americans should stop being so sure that the only reason he is saying what he has is to become President. Of course he wants to be our President, many things need to be changed before more seams open.

nnmns you are so correct we cannot run this country correctly and police the middle east at the same time. In the end like most politicians Obama will end up making so many promises he will be ineffective in office.

Post a Comment

Are you aware of our Rules of Conduct?




Advertisement

Related Features

News
More Religion News
Click here to go back to the News & Society page.

Faith in the Funnies
Wall Street: The End
Wall Street: The End
by Patrick Chappatte
View »
Unholy Communion
Unholy Communion
by John Cole
View »
God and Politics
God and Politics
by Pat Bagley
View »
Rush Hour Event
Rush Hour Event
by Larry Wright
View »
More Cartoons »