One City: A Buddhist Blog for Everyone

Enlightenment without retreat?

Friday October 16, 2009

Categories: Buddhism, Talking Dharma

by Davee Evans

How about a year off? NY designer Stefan Sagmeister does this every seven years. He shuts his design firm, and heads off to work on personal projects for creative renewal. Watch his views on taking time off at the TED conference. Stefan's suggestion is outrageous for the working world, but not news in the spiritual. Retreat of some form seems to be a necessary component of contemplative practice. But how many of us as Western Buddhists can afford more than two weeks off for retreat, much less fifty two?

As Buddhism comes to the West, a major question on my mind is if the emphasis on retreat needs to change or if it is still a crucial component. In a certain sense, the retreat principle is in all forms of meditation. Even a few minutes a day is a kind of mini-retreat; of separating from both our daily, hectic schedule. But can we achieve anything from just an hour a day? For me personally, having day long and weekend long intensive practice sessions are significant experiences. I have no idea how to weigh their value vis-a-vis daily practice, but a day long takes me to a more subtle level.

What do you think? Can Western Buddhists be as successful a contemplative tradition, in the midst of busy lives? Or do you think it's just always been this tough to retreat?

Advertisement
Comments
shamanu
October 19, 2009 11:59 PM


In fact retreat, may lead away from enlightenment...if indeed such a direction exists

shamanu
October 20, 2009 12:07 AM


Sit. Focus on a point in the middle of the room. Focus on the "air" at this spot. It seems sort of to be composed of subtle microscopic 'speckles'...now see the 'clearness' the speckles are floating in. (or the 'space between the speckles') This is the Clear Light. It's not something 'spiritual', it's the light that illuminates your room, your corn flakes. See the clear light that the air is floating on. When you do, this is enlightenment. It is really extremely simple, and very close. It's effortless, yet incredibly difficult. It's sort of like maintaining complete and deep relaxation throughout an orgasm.

Stillman
October 20, 2009 12:38 PM
http://www.stillmanbrownphoto.com/blog/

Thanks for the link Davee! I've been pondering this very question lately. I took last summer "off" to go on retreat, teach myself digital photography, and be outdoors. It wasn't really time off, it was time "on," and I found it deeply renewing.

Murthy
October 21, 2009 8:46 AM

Retreat is very much required to asses where we are on the journey to I.
One may follow whatever methodology he/she likes. It surely gives clarity on future approach.

Your Name
October 23, 2009 2:00 PM

i know a guy who teaches buddhist meditation. he lives in a group house with other buddhists and they all go away to england and italy for a week at a time on retreats. then, they organize these fund raisers at indian restaurants to get others to contribute money so they can get their group house fixed up (electrical wiring, new windows, etc). see, they have to save up their own money to afford the air fare for the retreats and of course none of them has real jobs, dealing with real assholes. they make a part-time living teaching meditation but it won't pay for the house repairs. that's where we lay-buddhists come in. we contribute our hard-earned money in return for good karma so they can live a comfortable existence and still go away to charming temples overseas. as jung said, organized religion is a safe haven for the frightened, lonely, world-wary but eventually you still have to individuate and mature into a whole human being who takes on real responsibilities i.e. goes to work and deals with real assholes in the real world. i meditate and work on myself to avoid the shenpa that my co-assholes assault me with everyday in the workplace. and i've never been on a retreat in my life.

Read All Comments

Post a Comment

By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.



Please type the text you see in the box below to verify your post and help us prevent spam. You have a limited time to type - you may wish to compose your comment in a separate document and paste it here upon completion.

Type the characters you see in the picture above.

Advertisement

Search This Blog

feed icon Subscribe

RSS Feed

Receive updates from One City: A Buddhist Blog for Everyone

About One City: A Buddhist Blog for Everyone

Welcome to One City. You've lived here your whole life, whether you know it or not. One City blog is an outgrowth of The Interdependence Project, a Buddhist-inspired nonprofit organization led by Ethan Nichtern, dedicated to teaching the insights of Buddhism, meditation, mindfulness, and interconnectedness in the 21st century world.

If you're interested in how your mind works, are interested in meditation (but don't want to pretend you live in ancient Asia), care about the world, are into media, love contemporary culture, and above all, really dig the truth of interdependence-that nothing happens in a vacuum--then this blog is for you.

More on Buddhism

Buddhist Dharmachakra
Beliefnet's Buddhist section offers quotes, articles, videos, and guided meditation.

About the Authors

Davee Evans
A Shambhala practitioner in San Francisco
» Posts by Davee Evans
Evelyn Cash
Evelyn is a Soto Zen practitioner and engineer living in Wichita, Kansas.
» Posts by Evelyn Cash
Ethan Nichtern
Author, founding director of the Interdependence Project, and the host of the I.D. Project’s popular weekly podcast
» Posts by Ethan Nichtern
Ellen Scordato
A business owner, editor, teacher, and board member of the Interdependence Project
» Posts by Ellen Scordato
Greg Zwahlen
Practices meditation and studies Buddhism
» Posts by Greg Zwahlen
Jerry Kolber
Jerry lives and meditates in New York state.
» Posts by Jerry Kolber
Jon Rubinstein
Jon writes about art and the media from a Buddhist perspective.
» Posts by Jon Rubinstein
Kirsten Firminger
A Doctoral Candidate in Social Psychology
» Posts by Kirsten Firminger
Lodro Rinzler
Lodro Rinzler is a second-generation Shambhala Buddhist practitioner and teacher.
» Posts by Lodro Rinzler
Paul Griffin
A writer, scholar, and tutor in New York City
» Posts by Paul Griffin
Patrick Groneman
Assistant Director of the Interdependence Project
» Posts by Patrick Groneman
Stillman Brown
A photographer, writer, and meditation practitioner living in Brooklyn, NY
» Posts by Stillman Brown
More »

Advertisement

Advertisement


About Beliefnet

Our mission is to help people like you find, and walk, a spiritual path that will bring comfort, hope, clarity, strength, and happiness. More about Beliefnet.

Legal

Copyright © Beliefnet, Inc. and/or its licensors. All rights reserved. Use of this site is subject to Terms of Service and to our Privacy Policy. Constructed by Beliefnet.

Advertisement

Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.