Helen Thomas’s stomach-turning comments about the Jews returning to Germany and Poland, where six million were gassed and cremated into piles of ash, are striking for their racism and insensitivity. Whether she said them out of senility or anti-Semitism is beside the point. Either way she has no business working for any respectable media organization or sitting as the senior White House correspondent directly in front of the President of the United States. When Don Imus made racially charged statements against a woman’s basketball team, candidate Obama demanded he be fired. It will be interesting to see how President Obama, who could not offer a single word of support for Israel since the flotilla affair, will react.
One can only imagine the uproar against Thomas
had she said that all blacks should go home to Africa, or illegal immigrants to
Tijuana. It seems that Jews are the only group that you can attack with
impunity because they are the only ones unwise enough to tolerate it. Better
yet, we’re the only group often so filled with so much self-loathing that we
actually initiate many of the attacks.
Few of us are surprised that it is a coterie of
Jewish advisors to President Obama who have joined him in condemnations of
Israel over Jews building in Jerusalem. This week the New York Times published
an article by Michael Chabon arguing that many Jews are ‘blockheads’ and
notions of Jewish intelligence are highly overrated. He may be correct.
But as I read this strange screed from one of America’s most celebrated Jewish
novelists I wondered if, say, Maya Angelou would ever pen an article about how
many black dumbbells there are. Attacks on one’s own seems to be an art form
perfected specifically by Jews.
Helene Cooper wrote a column in the New York
Times (funny that so many derogatory articles on Israel and Jews always appears
in a Jewish-owned newspaper) asking whether Israel has become a strategic
liability to the United State. She quoted many senior Jewish political advisers
to the democratic party who advised that if Israel continues to embarrass the
United States it might be time for the superpower to distance itself from the
little Jewish irritant. The criticism made for interesting reading,
implying as it did that while Israel is an embarrassment to the United States,
its relationship with such great human rights exemplars as Saudi Arabia, Egypt,
and Turkey ought to be sources of downright pride.
Turkey merits special mention because not only
does its media accuse the American military of harvesting organs from helpless
Iraqis, which it cites as one of the reasons for the American invasion, but
because Prime Minister Erdogan sees fit to call Israel barbarous, lecture
Jews about not murdering, and refers to Hamas as freedom fighters. Curiously,
at the same time he was spewing his venom toward the Jewish state this past
week, the Pope was in Cyprus where he was being publicly begged by Archbishop
Chrysostomos II, the leader of the Orthodox Church of Cyprus, to stop the
illegal Turkish occupation of Cyprus, now in its thirty-forth year, and protect
Christians from growing attacks by Turks. Just prior to the Pope’s visit a
Christian bishop had been stabbed to death outside his home in the
Mediterranean port of Iskenderun. The archbishop said that Turkey had “barbarously
invaded” Cyprus and “continues to carry out its obscure plan, which includes
the annexation of the lands now under military occupation and then conquest of
the whole of Cyprus. They wish to make everything Greek and Christian disappear
from occupied Cyprus.” Of course, Turkey won’t even acknowledge its genocide of
the Armenians, a position that President Obama has shamefully supported in
order not to offend Turkey’s belligerent leader.
Of course, Cooper’s article quotes the ubiquitous
J Street head Jeremy Ben-Ami whom journalists have come to appreciate because
of his consistency and reliability in always saying something disparaging about
Israel. In this case Ben-Ami is quoted as saying ‘he represents Jews who… are
raising the issue of Israeli government actions as a strategic liability for
the United States.’
I lived in England for 11 years and was sickened
by the regular abandonment of Israel by some of the most high-profile
Anglo-Jews whenever Israel’s actions became controversial. For those wondering
why a floodgate of anti-Semitism has opened in Britain over the last few years,
look no further than the fact that Israel’s greatest haters can often point to Jewish
critics as being much more strident than them. And still it continues, with
even high profile Jewish leaders like Chief Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks remaining
mum on Israel even while it was assailed by countless countries for enforcing a
blockade against a terror organization that has fired 10,000 rockets against
it.
Still, I never believed that American Jewry would
emulate this cowardice. But President Obama’s public abandonment of Israel is
directly traceable to the small price he pays among American Jews. On my radio
show on WABC in New York many callers contend that President Obama is an
anti-Semite. I condemn such character-assassination in the strongest possible
terms. Obama has elevated Jews to some of the highest positions in the land,
including his most recent nominee for the Supreme Court, Elena Kagan. Rather,
the President inability to condemn Hamas and support Israel, which is a stain
on his presidency, results from his considerable moral confusion and a
misguided sense of right and wrong. Under Obama America has retreated
substantially from President Bush’s policies of promoting democracy and human
rights and has reverted to Kissingerian realpolitik, ready to make deals with
tyrants so long as it promotes an artificial sense of peace.
But Obama can get away with it because American
Jewry has become so silent and so weak. Whenever Israel undertakes
controversial action, American Jews begin writing op-eds in The Atlantic
and The New Yorker about how the once-moral nation has lost its way.
Funny how those same writers do not condemn President Obama’s policy of
Predator drone strikes against Taliban leaders that inevitably involve
considerable civilian collateral casualties
Sorry guys. Israel is going to remain
controversial, as one might expect from any country under a constant
existential assault from nearly all its neighbors. When threatened by Hitler
Britain leveled whole German cities. The United States did the same to the Japanese.
Israel has never even pondered such actions, even as thousands of its citizens
have been blown to smithereens.
The Jews who were murdered in Germany and Poland
cannot speak out in support of a Jewish state. The rest of us, however, have
absolutely no excuse.
Rabbi Shmuley Boteach is founder of This World:
The Values Network. His new book, ‘Renewal: A Guide to the Values-Filled Life,’
has just been published by Basic books. Follow him on Twitter @RabbiShmuley.








posted June 7, 2010 at 11:33 am
Think it is time (at 90) for Helen to retire! Open mouth, insert foot!
posted June 7, 2010 at 11:52 am
Perhaps it’s simply the unanticipated consequences of Jewish values – to question, critique, challenge – that we find so many Jews leading the anti-Jewish (and anti-Israel) charge. I find it curious that, for example, Stepen Colbert is proud of his Catholic religion, while Jon Stewart makes fun of his own Jewish heritage. jews are apologetic, self-critical, disparaging. And non-Jews, seeing this, can only conclude that Judaism and Jews earned it. If Jews are viewed poorly it is not because they should be, but because of the self-destructive posture assumed by so many members of the tribe.
posted June 7, 2010 at 12:39 pm
What helen said was over the top, but, it is true imho that Israel should never have been made a nation in another nations borders without the consent of that nation. Now that Israel is a country it too late to undo that mistake. It is also very hard for an american(usa) to see such biased coverage from the media.
All people need to stop seeing the world in a tribal way. nationalism and religion are things that enslave people. All human life should be treated equally.
How can anyone not see that keeping concrete, chocolate, and other basic goods from a state is not right?
Even if you disagree with the protesters, killing them for delivering humanitarian goods ,while in international waters, while under the flag of another state was a war crime.
A great man once said, Man will never be free until the last king is strangled by the entrails of the last priest.
posted June 7, 2010 at 1:03 pm
Once again, “America’s huckster” – not “America’s rabbi” -lies.
The NYTIMES is NOT – i.e., no longer – Jewishly-owned. The Sulzbergers became Episcopalians a long while ago.
If Israel is so important for Boteach, why hasn’t he – like so many Orthodox Jews- made aliyah? HYPOCRITE!
posted June 7, 2010 at 1:18 pm
Thank you for speaking your opinions loudly and eloquently. I absolutely agree with your article and hope that more Jewish people, particularly the young generation, would realize that standing up for their opinions is not shameful and that apologizing for the existence of the Jewish state must stop.
posted June 7, 2010 at 1:42 pm
Dan, the whole ‘maybe Jews are hated because of the way they act’ meme is so tired. Please give it a rest. I wonder how quick you would be to blame other minorities’ oppresion on their own behaviors, or is it only the Jews that you single out for this kind of hateful ideology?
posted June 7, 2010 at 2:33 pm
um, schmuley is a media loving scumbag. and helen thomas is an old coot. i agree with dan. you know what meme is tired kauko? the “poor pitiful victimized israel” bit. you aren’t the victim anymore, you are the oppressor. i hope that the US detaches itself completely, i’m sick of being involved with israel and palestine. Two countries hellbent on killing themselves, so let them march to their own mutual demise.
posted June 7, 2010 at 4:04 pm
First of all the United Nations sanctioned Israel and it’s land. I don’t pity the palestinians, the muslims who for the last thousand years can’t raise themselves to a sustainable civilization, whereas the Israelis have a great economy and culture. The muslims have been in the black and white slave business since the third century and are massacring the black and white christians in Africa and wherever they can. furthermore the arab muslims not only hate non-muslims but they believe the black muslim is inferior. Why can’t the arabs raise themselves up with all the wealth of oil at their disposal. As a christian I will align myself with a democratic nation like Israel rather than the totalitarian governments of Syria, Jordan,formerly Iraq, Iran, etc, whom I believe are jealous and have no tolerance, only hatred for non-muslims. I am shocked by the head-in-the-sand attitude of Jewish organizations and individuals who do not stand with Israel. I pity them because history will repeat itself for those who turn their backs on Israel’s fight for survival. I disagree only with Rabbi Shmuley’s remark about Obama choosing Jewish cabinet members. Obama picked them because their propensity as a socialist, communist (take your pick, it’s the same old trick)is to destroy religion, individualism, the middle-class, sovereign states like Israel, etc. God Bless America-before Obama, and Israel! Philip Tropea, ‘The Singing Author’, http://www.tenorphiliptropea.com
posted June 8, 2010 at 6:26 am
“…For those wondering why a floodgate of anti-Semitism has opened in Britain over the last few years…”
You say you lived in Britain for 11 years, and you think the anti-Israeli sentiment is anti-semitic??
Now I agree that the British left is rabidly, and unfairly IMo, biased against Israel. But to call them anti-semitic is either a sign of gross ignorance (considering you were a long-term resident), or a deliberate attempt to smear those you disagree with.
This is the left we are talking about here. Call them unrealistic, call them unfair, call them downright stupid… any of those accusations could be made. But they are not anti-semites. Pretending that they are is intellectually dishonest. Disagree with them as much as you like, as I do myself. But don’t try to pretend that these people are racists, because they are not.
posted June 14, 2010 at 8:25 am
If I had a dime for each time I came here.. Great read!