Red Letters

Red Letters

Are We Guilty of Slumdog Tourism?

posted by Tom Davis

I’ve just returned from Kenya and this post in the New York Times has particular significance to me. As a non-profit leader, I’m constantly asking myself if what we are doing as an organization is truly helping the people we seek to serve. Or, are some of our methods more about an experience we receive (missions tourism), instead of initiative that help release people from poverty. Thanks to my buddy, Chris Marshall, for the heads up on the article. The author, Kennedy Odede, lived in Kibera slum in Nairobi for 23 years. Take a look at things from his perspective: 

Slumdog Tourism

SLUM tourism has a long history — during the late 1800s, lines of wealthy New Yorkers snaked along the Bowery and through the Lower East Side to see “how the other half lives.”

But with urban populations in the developing world expanding rapidly, the opportunity and demand to observe poverty firsthand have never been greater. The hot spots are Rio de Janeiro, Mumbai — thanks to “Slumdog Millionaire,” the film that started a thousand tours — and my home, Kibera, a Nairobi slum that is perhaps the largest in Africa.

Slum tourism has its advocates, who say it promotes social awareness. And it’s good money, which helps the local economy.

But it’s not worth it. Slum tourism turns poverty into entertainment, something that can be momentarily experienced and then escaped from. People think they’ve really “seen” something — and then go back to their lives and leave me, my family and my community right where we were before.

I was 16 when I first saw a slum tour. I was outside my 100-square-foot house washing dishes, looking at the utensils with longing because I hadn’t eaten in two days. Suddenly a white woman was taking my picture. I felt like a tiger in a cage. Before I could say anything, she had moved on.

When I was 18, I founded an organization that provides education, health and economic services for Kibera residents. A documentary filmmaker from Greece was interviewing me about my work. As we made our way through the streets, we passed an old man defecating in public. The woman took out her video camera and said to her assistant, “Oh, look at that.”

For a moment I saw my home through her eyes: feces, rats, starvation, houses so close together that no one can breathe. I realized I didn’t want her to see it, didn’t want to give her the opportunity to judge my community for its poverty — a condition that few tourists, no matter how well intentioned, could ever understand.

Other Kibera residents have taken a different path. A former schoolmate of mine started a tourism business. I once saw him take a group into the home of a young woman giving birth. They stood and watched as she screamed. Eventually the group continued on its tour, cameras loaded with images of a woman in pain. What did they learn? And did the woman gain anything from the experience?

To be fair, many foreigners come to the slums wanting to understand poverty, and they leave with what they believe is a better grasp of our desperately poor conditions. The expectation, among the visitors and the tour organizers, is that the experience may lead the tourists to action once they get home.

But it’s just as likely that a tour will come to nothing. After all, looking at conditions like those in Kibera is overwhelming, and I imagine many visitors think that merely bearing witness to such poverty is enough.

Nor do the visitors really interact with us. Aside from the occasional comment, there is no dialogue established, no conversation begun. Slum tourism is a one-way street: They get photos; we lose a piece of our dignity.

Slums will not go away because a few dozen Americans or Europeans spent a morning walking around them. There are solutions to our problems — but they won’t come about through tours.

Comments

Powered by Facebook Comments



Previous Posts

The Real Russia: The Journey Starts
It's a day 15 years in the making. Woodmen Valley Chapel pioneered orphan care ministry with Children's HopeChest. They've sent hundreds of members to work in the Mstyora orphanage. They've funded dozens of projects, piloted new programs, and expanded their work year over year. But, there'

posted 9:13:24am May. 24, 2012 | read full post »

Help a boy in Uganda with cancer
Eleku Peter, a young boy who is served by the Oditel CarePoint in Uganda, was recently diagnosed with large cell lymphoma. As you can see in the picture, Peter's neck became swollen and painful. CarePoint leaders took Peter for initial testing which was later confirmed by the National Cancer Inst

posted 8:38:27am May. 21, 2012 | read full post »

Does sponsorship work? One child's story... [VIDEO]
Russia was the place where my heart was broken for orphans. In 1997, I took my wife and eight-month-old son to run a camp for 150 orphans in the Vladimir region. I was never the same after that experience. We met a little orphan girl named Anya who was ten. She became our daughter one year lat

posted 8:27:39am May. 18, 2012 | read full post »

Download a Free Chapter Today
For nearly 15 years, Woodmen Valley Chapel has supported the children of the Mstyora orphanage in Russia. One of the very first pioneering churches to get involved in orphan care ministry, they truly understand how to walk alongside local leadership and empower children to overcome poverty, abandonm

posted 8:49:48am May. 16, 2012 | read full post »

"The course of my life was about to change..."
Today's post comes from Caleb David, founder and executive director of One Child Campaign. One Child Campaign is a partner ministry of Children's HopeChest. Thank you Caleb! At the end of this post, you'll have an opportunity to join Caleb on a trip to Moldova and Russia. It's in partnership with Ma

posted 9:40:12am May. 08, 2012 | read full post »

Advertisement
Comments read comments(7)
post a comment
doreen

posted September 15, 2011 at 9:34 pm


Thank you for your perspective–i know I have been to a few mission trips-most memorable was Russian orphanages. I know that we spent all day playing with the kids-helping the care givers and leaving them with as much as we could travel with. when I returned home the impact has stayed with me and I share the misfortunes often and in doing so help those who THINK they suffer–God bless you.



report abuse
 

Sherie

posted September 16, 2011 at 12:36 am


Tom, I would love to hear more about the conclusions you come up with in regards to the positive/negative impacts of your trips. I have been on several mission trips, and I too wrestle with the money I spend to travel, wondering if others would be better served by receiving the money. I want to be an active part of true solutions and help, but sometimes it feels like the only way to do that is through donating money. I don’t need to see poverty to know it is real and heartbreaking, but is my presence of any real help either. They are tough questions.



report abuse
 

Matt Hall

posted September 16, 2011 at 2:01 am


So true. Good story.



report abuse
 

Martha Lewis

posted September 16, 2011 at 12:31 pm


Tom, thank you for sharing this story. I’d never thought about this before, but it’s so true. I call people who just want to see poverty “thrill seekers”. Unfortuneatly it happens all too often. Years ago I spent time in Zambia, Africa on a mission trip. It was life changing to see the poverty, to see how the children lived, so different from the United States. But what struck me most was the hunger to hear God’s word, the people were so open to hearing the gospel. AIDS was and is such a huge issue there and many that I met during my time there have died from AIDS. I’ve always believed if a person goes on a mission trip to another country that they should be moved by God to do so. I have not been the same since spending time with the people in Zambia. Thanks again for sharing the article. Childrens Hope Chest is not a “thrill seeking” organization, it truely cares about the people in other countries. I have talked to people who have come back from mission trips associated with CHC and their lives are changed. God Bless.



report abuse
 

jan ling

posted September 16, 2011 at 12:42 pm


This is something I have always wondered about. How do the people who live day in and day out feel about the observer. What can I do? seriously I want to do what helps. My heart breaks when I hear of exploitation of people who are already struggling for survival. My prayers are offered for you and your family.



report abuse
 

K. Duane Carter

posted September 17, 2011 at 9:31 pm


I like this article because it shows us what those real, live human beings are feeling who live in these poor conditions every day. Poverty MUST end. It is NOT normal. Yes, the need is overwhelming, but we can all step up and help one at a time, and I also believe we can ask God to multiply our every deed, our every smile, and our every prayer. He’s pretty good at that :) . Thanks Tom for sharing this.



report abuse
 

Clinton White

posted September 20, 2011 at 11:34 pm


Great article that stopped WAY short. I hear his concerns. I know I’ve been that “tourist” on many occasions. At the same time I’ve actually lived in some of those places at least for a few weeks or months…longer than a mid-morning walk-through.

So this article ended with, “There are solutions to our problems — but they won’t come about through tours.” That’s not a very satisfying ending! I’d like to hear the writers’ ideas for solutions that do work!



report abuse
 

Post a Comment

By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.

Share this story


About Beliefnet

Our mission is to help people like you find, and walk, a spiritual path that will bring comfort, hope, clarity, strength, and happiness. More about Beliefnet.

Help

Media Kit

Subscribe

Legal

Copyright © Beliefnet, Inc. and/or its licensors. All rights reserved. Use of this site is subject to Terms of Service and to our Privacy Policy. Constructed by Beliefnet.

Advertisement

Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.