Fascinating piece at GetReligion.org about whether offering Yoga in public schools violate the separation of church and state. There's a strong case that it does.
Advertisement
Fascinating piece at GetReligion.org about whether offering Yoga in public schools violate the separation of church and state. There's a strong case that it does.
Hot Topics:
Righteous Posts:
Best Posts That No One Read:
Little Known Facts:
Still Cracks Me Up:
Posts That Annoy Conservatives:
Posts That Annoy Liberals:
Posts That Annoy Everyone:
Yoga is not Hinduism. Both Yoga and Sanskrta predate Hinduism. Yoga and Hinduism are near neighbors, and like many long-term neighbors, their lives have been intertwined. However many Hindus do not practice Yoga, more still only practice one form of Yoga, and many practictioners of some forms of Yoga are ignorant of Hinduism.
By the way, other scholars say that "Union" is a better translation of Yoga than "yoke", despite the alliteration.
Yoga belongs to Hinduism of more abstract nature. To talk of Hindu gods and the pantheon in relation to the yogic postures is not at all relevant or correct. The spiritual ultimate state of a practitioner of Yoga unites the atman-individual soul with the Brahman- the ultimate soul.In that sense it is a union that leads to salvation which is a stage beyond attaining heaven.It is liberation in the true sense.I salute Patanjali who revealed that a human body and spirit are unto themselves One has to seek salvation within You are the godhead, the devotee and the ultimate supreme spirit.You can achieve the blissful state of salvation .You seek within you and an external messiah is not needed.In that sense it does not encourage the separation of the church and the state.It does not necessitate faith in an external agency.
Swami Param hit the nail on the head. The word "yoga" means to yoke with God. And the God of yoga is typically Shiva or some other Hindu incarnation. If you know consciously that you are yoking with Christ consciousness, then you may be doing a form of Christian yoga. To understand what yoga is one might try the self-enquiry practices of philosophy called in Samskrit vichara. One tries to reconcile the phenomenon with the noumenon and realize that there is only one God, there is nothing but God, and it is our job to see the presence of God in everything. Does this sound like Christianity to you? Furthermore, the difference between jiva (the self, the atman), the jagan (that which moves, or the world) and Ishwara (God) and how they are separate, the same, and the way in these interact with each other. And if you are practicing yoga to gain strength and power, you are concerned with Iccha (will) Jnana (wisdom) and Shakti (power of manifestation. Furthermore, the understanding that Shiva (consciousness) and Shakti (manifestation of phenomena) are one thing and never separate, and in this, no one person is separate from any other person or physical manifestation of the earth. Does this sound like Christianity? Is christianity something that breaks the separation between church and state? Yes. If you are practicing yoga and your body is your temple because you are realizing God and your Self, are you violating the separation of church and state? Well, since it is completely inward and philosophical in nature, then no. But if you are Christian and you don't like this and call it religion, then you will say that it violates that separation because it completely negates all separation!!! Western minds don't like such thoughts. They get bent out of shape. So if you practice yoga, please realize that the purpose of every thought and breath and deed is to TOUCH and SEE GOD. So. Is it religion? I practice it and I am very serious with my faith. Faith and spirituality are typically linked with religion, which is the political manifestation of sects and worldly nomenclature that seeks to divide and conquer. If you would like to do Yoga Booty Ballet, so be it. But the purpose of yoga is to realize GOD, not to get abs from Navasana and Virasana and flexibility from Hanumanasana and Paschimottanasana. These words are Sanskrit and they belong to an ancient faith called Sanatana Dharma which has erroneously become known as "Hinduism." Do know what you do and why you do it. And check out Ramana Maharshi's method of self-enquiry. You can skip the political manuscripts masquerading as the word of God and touch living faith that does not rely on martyrdom and hierarchies.
Practicing the asanas- the physical postures of yoga does not make you a hindu any more than swimming in the pool at the YMCA makes you a christian.
The Dharmic/Indian "religions" don't require you to believe in God or anything specific so technically everyone is a Hindu/Buddhist/Jain and anybody can practice yoga. It's only a problem for true Christians and Muslims who believe the Dharmic faiths are "pagan" practices here
@Kevin: Technically you're a "Hindu" no matter what you do. "Hinduism" and the other Dharmic faiths are inclusive. And comparing yoga to a swimming pool lol?
Post a Comment
By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.