Text Messages

Patton Dodd: November 2008 Archives

Tuesday November 25, 2008

Categories: Christianity, Church

Do Ed Young's sex sermons speak to singles?

The most emailed article at the New York Times right now is about Ed Young of Fellowship Church in Texas and his much-discussed sermon series on sex. As part of the series, he challenged all the married couples in his church to have sex each day for seven days. 

I have lots of questions here, but I'll restrict myself to just one: How do singles figure into Young's sex sermon series? In every interview clip I've seen, Young emphasizes that the challenge is just for married people, and the Times says Young's advice to singles has amounted to: "I don't know, try eating chocolate cake."

When I was a young, unmarried Christian, "try eating chocolate cake" is not far from the vision of sexuality I was given. When I married, I discovered a host of Christian teaching on sexuality, some of it quite beautiful, profound, and pragmatic. But in the years after I became a Christian and before I married, my experiences of Christian teaching on sex were much like what I worry singles at Fellowship Church are experiencing now: Sex is for married people, and if you're not yet old enough or fortunate enough to be married...wow, that sucks. 

Lauren Winner's Real Sex is the only Christian book I know of that explicitly and comprehensively addresses non-marital sexuality. There, she says that Christian teaching on sexuality ought to be part of a larger vision of embodiment--whether single or married, sexually active or chaste, we ought to be learning how to be in our bodies in ways that glorify God and fully express our createdness. That's a nice start, but I wonder what else single Christians are hearing from their ministers? Does anyone know? Is Ed Young speaking to this during his series? Is anyone speaking to it? What is the Christian vision of sexuality for singles? 

Update: I wanted to highlight this comment posted below by Al Hsu. He helpfully mentions his book on Christian singlehood as an additional resource. 

This is a symptom of a larger (evangelical) problem of overemphasizing marriage to the exclusion of singles. In the early church, it was actually considered more spiritual to be single than to be married, because marriage was seen as "worldly" and a concession to the flesh. The Protestant Reformation flipped this and said that marriage and family was normative and elevated marriage over singleness. A more biblical balance is that marriage and singleness are equal gifts and equally valid ways of living. If Christians really understood this and believed this, it would help us have more constructive things to say than "eat chocolate cake."

(My book Singles at the Crossroads has a chapter on singleness and sexuality. Not nearly as comprehensive as Lauren Winner's Real Sex, but I hope it's at least somewhat helpful!)


Monday November 24, 2008

Categories: music

Who is your favorite under-appreciated musician?

Mine is Bill Mallonee, whose painful story Nate Anderson tells beautifully in the latest issue of Christianity Today. When Paste Magazine came out with their list of the Top 100 singer-songwriters, I tore through the issue to see if Mallonee made it, and was gratified to see him (even if ranked at 65). But such recognition has been tragically lacking. If the world were put to rights in terms of lyrical artistry, Bill Mallonee would be fronting a band that played to packed arenas, and Chris Martin would be playing dusty bars. 

Mallonee's former band, Vigilantes of Love, made a record called "Audible Sigh" in 1999 that my wife and I have been not just playing, but talking about for nearly a decade. It's that layered--poignant, heartbreaking, beautiful in every measure. A "Blood on the Tracks" filled with dark witness to good news. 

We saw Mallonee play a drab Cambridge bar in 2002. He was the opening act for an overrated band (that shall remain nameless). Five or six of us stood at the edge of the stage during Mallonee's entire set and let him lead us in a chorus of joyful heartache. Everyone else in the house congregated around the bar, waiting for him to finish. Mallonee sang his heart out right to us, we sang along, and he thanked us after each song. At the end of the night, he came back out with the overrated band and joined them in a gorgeous, lingering rendition of--what else?--"I Shall Be Released." I've seen a lot of great shows, but that one touched me like few others have. 

More Mallonee below, from a show in Somerville, Mass. 

But tell us--what artist do you love that you wish others loved, too? 



Friday November 21, 2008

Categories: Patton Dodd

The Power of Negative Thinking

Here's the article I mentioned before. I wrote it right in the middle of an ill-fated week, partly because I was way past a deadline, and partly because I wanted to capture mourning in progress, rather than reflect on it after the fact. Here's an excerpt, and I'll post the whole thing after the jump:

For many years, I believed it was foolish and faithless to acknowledge all that is wrong with my life. I believed I was a new creation, and admitting anything less was not acceptable. I missed seeing a lot that was wrong with my community, my family, and myself because I thought the Christian thing to do was to emphasize the positive, glory be to God.

But Jesus came for the sick, not the healthy--by which he surely meant that he came for those who know they are sick, and not those who, being sick, nonetheless claim they are healthy.

Friday November 21, 2008

Categories: Family

Thanksgiving starts tonight

Here in the Dodd household, Thanksgiving starts tonight. My mom flies into Denver from Mississippi early this evening. My beloved sister, her brilliant husband, and their three kids come tomorrow, on my birthday. We'll cook up a mess of fried chicken tomorrow night, the first of several indulgent meals between now and next weekend. 

I'm particularly excited for this year's holiday because it stands in such stark contrast to last year's. For that, I'd like to go ahead and give thanks. 

This time last year, my sister, Kaysie, and I were in the midst of one of the longest years of our lives. We spent much of 2007 making hard decisions about the care of our father, whose myriad addictions had caught up to him. We were beset by one emergency after another, involving no small amount of hastily planned of cross-country travel. Long story, a novel-in-waiting. (Or a movie--"The Savages" has uncanny parallels.) Thanksgiving, which we spent at my sister's home in Tulsa, was particularly difficult for a host of reasons. A few days later, my father died. During that same week, we lost two more family members. 

That's a whiff of the story of 2007. I wrote about it in brief for YouthWorker Journal earlier this year, and I'll try to dig that article up in another post. 

Life has times of intense blessing, and times of intense hardship. I'm not sure I've yet learned the art of living through either, but I'm working on it. For now, in advance of an extended Thanksgiving that I'll begin to observe in a few hours, I want to express gratitude for the intense blessing of this moment. We're healthy. We're together. We've mourned a lot, and it's time to celebrate a lot. Over the next week, we're going to eat fried chicken and a pot of green chili, plus traditional Thanksgiving delights (with splashes of new dishes from Bon Appetit); we're going to watch It's a Wonderful Life and Elf, and, while Mom babysits, take in the new Baz Luhrmann film. Weather allowing, we'll hike a trail or two, and, a different kind of weather allowing, go sledding. 

It stands to be a blessed week, more blessed than I deserve. I'm already thankful. 

Thursday November 20, 2008

Thank Heaven for Todoist

If Todoist--the staggeringly simple personal productivity tool--isn't my #1 app of the year, it's only because Scrivener took my dissertation off life support. (That it's back on life support now is not Scrivener's fault; it's a user error). But Todoist is a godsend. Simple. Elegant. Practical. Motivational. And, incredibly, the work of one programmer. 

Here's ReadWriteWeb's original review. (Todoist has been updated quite a bit since.)

You can thank me later. 

Thursday November 20, 2008

Categories: blogging, politics

Straight Talk on Gay Marriage

Pun intended. Starting today, two of our bloggers--Tony Jones and Rod Dreher--will begin a debate discussion Beliefnet Blogalogue on same sex marriage. They'll post on their respective blogs and link back to one another. Here's what's unique about this discussion, and why...

Thursday November 20, 2008

Categories: movies

Roger Ebert, speechless and chatty

My undergraduate literary theory professor warped my brain, for better and worse. One item in the Worse category: He ruined my love of Roger Ebert. One dumb morning, Professor Grumpy (not his real name) worked up a full head of...

Wednesday November 19, 2008

Categories: Culture

7 Delightful Things

For a variety of reasons, it's been a distressing week. And it's only Wednesday. And I didn't sleep last night. Times like these, nothing to do but think about delightful things. Here are 7:1. The new Life photo archive.2. The...

Tuesday November 18, 2008

Categories: Christianity

Colorado Springs, 2-paper town

A tale of two ledes: Focus on the Family just announced a layoff of 20% of its workforce--big news here in Colorado Springs, where the ministry is one of the ten largest employers. Here's how our daily paper, the Gazette, reported...

Monday November 17, 2008

Categories: politics

This Just In: Obama Not Orthodox

Based on remarks President-elect Obama made to Cathleen Falsani four years ago (and recently reprinted on Beliefnet), there's been a dustup over whether he can legitimately be said to be a Christian: Joe Carter at Culture11 says no.Rod Dreher echoes him.Tony...

Monday November 17, 2008

Categories: Culture

The Filmmaker of Light

Vanity Fair reports on an internal memo from Painter of Light Thomas Kinkade in which he outlines 16 principles for making a film modeled on his paintings. (The film is called "Christmas Cottage"--which could also be the name of virtually...

Monday November 17, 2008

Categories: Bible

Which Bible translation is best?

Scot McKnight says to find the answer, you have to ask another question: What's your purpose in reading it?  ...

Friday November 14, 2008

Categories: Culture

Three things from Steve Martin

Steve Martin's Born Standing Up is the most fun weekend reading I've done in a long time. Pensive yet page-turning. Three moments I'll remember:1. While studying Wittgenstein in college--which Martin was paying for by doing standup comedy--Martin was wrestling with whether...

Friday November 14, 2008

Categories: Bible

Evangelism or Entertainment? (Or, Evangelism IS Entertainment)

A curiosity I noted over my cereal flakes this morning: Michael Spencer (the Internet Monk) linked this week to a year-old article by the New Yorker's George Packer about the Creation Museum. In his summary of the article, Spencer says...

Thursday November 13, 2008

Categories: Bible

De-versifying the Bible essay

Without further ado, here is the promised essay by Glenn Paauw on International Bible Society's additives-free Bible.I must say, I'm rather fond of the deck:Bible literacy is lower than ever. Who's to blame? Try Bible publishers.Read it all....

Wednesday November 12, 2008

Categories: Bible, movies

Celebrity Bible characters

Paul Asay put together a cast of characters for an imaginary "Genesis: The Movie," with suggested celebrities to fill the roles. My favorite moment:She has no lines. She has no name. Lot's wife is famous for one thing: turning into...

Wednesday November 12, 2008

Pixar's "Up" is totally cheating

This looks to be another in a series of Pixar directors moving further away from pure pop and closer to pop art (though Brad Bird kinda skipped over the pure pop stage entirely). But does it bother anyone else that...

Wednesday November 12, 2008

Categories: Culture

Culture War and context

On election night, a Facebook (and real life!) friend, Brandon, posted a status update to the effect that Americans were naive for voting for Obama. I took issue with Brandon's remark, which he had first delivered to me over iChat,...

Monday November 10, 2008

The changing of the evangelical guard

Sociologist Michael Lindsay (author of Faith in the Halls of Power, one of last year's best religion books) weighs in on the shifting ground of evangelical influence in the Beltway. ...

Friday November 7, 2008

Categories: Christianity, books

Cultivators and Creators: An Interview with Andy Crouch

Andy Crouch's Culture Making: Rediscovering Our Creative Calling is the Christian book of the year--its Publisher's Weekly nod for best religion book won't be its last. The concept of "culture" has been something of a snare for American Christians--we've critiqued culture...

Thursday November 6, 2008

Categories: beliefnet, blogging

Welcoming Scot McKnight and Tony Jones to Beliefnet

Join me in welcoming two new blogs to Beliefnet: Jesus Creed, crafted by the careful hands of Scot McKnight, and The New Christians, the brainchild of Tony Jones. Jesus Creed, long one of the web's most popular religion blogs, is that...

Wednesday November 5, 2008

Categories: politics

Christian reactions to Obama's victory

From status updates on my Facebook profile, a bird's eye view of Christian responses last night. All names have been replaced with "Sally." Sally is no longer proud to be an American.Sally loves America.Sally is sad that America is incredibly naive.Sally loves saying...

Tuesday November 4, 2008

Categories: beliefnet

Tell us how you voted, and why

Take Beliefnet's Election 2008 survey. ...

Tuesday November 4, 2008

Categories: beliefnet

Support Kids, see Africa. If you can take it.

This month, Beliefnet has teamed up with Tom Davis and Daniel Clark at Children's HopeChest to raise support for orphans in Africa. You'll see my charity badge on the right, and you can donate directly to CHC from that...

Advertisement

About Text Messages

This blog is no longer updated and is closed for comments. We welcome your comments about Christianity in our Christianity forums.

Patton Dodd is a senior editor for Beliefnet and the author of My Faith So Far: A Story of Conversion and Confusion (Jossey-Bass).

Search This Blog

Calendar

Advertisement

Advertisement


About Beliefnet

Our mission is to help people like you find, and walk, a spiritual path that will bring comfort, hope, clarity, strength, and happiness. More about Beliefnet.

Legal

Copyright © Beliefnet, Inc. and/or its licensors. All rights reserved. Use of this site is subject to Terms of Service and to our Privacy Policy. Constructed by Beliefnet.

Advertisement

Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.