Advertisement
This blog is no longer updated and is closed for comments. We welcome your comments about Catholicism in our Catholic forums.
Amy Welborn is the author of 17 books on prayer, saints, apologetics and church history. Her articles and columns have appeared in Our Sunday Visitor, Commonweal, First Things, Catholic Digest, Liguori, and been syndicated by Catholic News Service.
Amy has an MA in Church History from Vanderbilt University and spent several years working in Catholic schools and parishes before taking up writing full time. She was married to Catholic author Michael Dubruiel until his unexpected death in February of 2009. She has five children ranging in ages from 4 to 26.
This is a fascinating notion: art as a kind of moral dry run. "If we cower in the movie, we'll probably cower in life." I'm not sure it's quite the same thing as catharsis.
What I find amazing is that people sit through much gorier movies, but cannot stomach The Passion or this movie because they know that it's real.
There are people who will watch this movie in its entirety, not because they have courage, but because they are able to compartmentalize things. Such people call themselves realists and know there is very, very little they can do to change the forces and cultures that allow travesties like this to occur. So they will watch, be moved, and walk away mourning that such things happen, hoping that someday, things will change, while simultaneously believing it is someone else's job to change things.
There are others, less able to compartmentalize, who will feel every moment of the characters' pain and might be unable to finish watching the movie. If they walk out or abstain from watching because they are so affected, it does not mean they lack courage. Many such people are the very ones who contribute to movements that are helping women's rights in foreign countries, they are the ones who join anti-hate movements in their own country, or advocate through their political processes to demand greater transparency in foreign relations, or dedicate their prayers to the poor and suffering around the world.
Who, then, has truly imbibed the spirit and purpose of the movie? He who watched it, or he who feels it?
Re: compartmentalizing
Very true. But it's also true that art and imagination can be a moral dry run. That was a lot of the idea behind studying the martyrs and thinking about death when you're still young and healthy -- to practice a frame of mind now, and to figure out what you need to do now to be ready then. And of course painful true stories in art can elicit prayer, which reaches across time and space, as well as more concrete forms of help for our faraway neighbors in trouble.
I think St. Therese talks about how imagination of martyrdom was very helpful to her spiritual growth, somewhere.
Saw the screening for the film in Los Angeles. It was absolutely beautiful and gives a whole new perspective on our own freedoms and struggles, and fueled my personal awe of the Islamic women who live with such threats; especially in light of the struggles in Iran following the elections.
My thoughts after seeing the film are here.
We cannot turn away when such injustices against innocent women occur. True, Iranian women suffer as do their Saudi sisters. The difference is that now Iranian women have been able to let their voice scream to the world. The deafening silence from Saudi Arabia's women is because many are abused, tormented, and denied basic human rights every day.
I wait for the day when a gutsy journalist or a gutsy politician or even human rights group will give these women their voice. So far, the ignorance against Saudi women's plight is total silence or indifference, or ignorance.
I've been corresponding with an Algerian woman who was involved in the war against France, which is going to take me far deeper into their struggle than I may be comfortable with - having read the biographies of Djamila Boupacha in the early 70's followed by Rosa Luxembourg of Poland both of which still sends chills up my spine.
Many other revelations of extreme hardship, toil & endurance often leading to torture and horrendous death have emerged - continue to become unfolded ... hopefully making us become more enlightened to the evil,that is being wrought upon the women of the world ... our mothers, sisters, daughters, wives can never be overlooked, forgotten ... let-alone be forgiven ...
Should we fail in our quest for honour, justice and ultimate worth and praise for our womenfolk - we do not deserve to call ourselves men ... and should hang our pithy heads in shame ...
Post a Comment
By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.