President-elect Obama hasn't been to church in weeks, saying he doesn't want to disrupt the service for others. I find that rationale a little tough to swallow, but wish that he would share his real thoughts on the matter. As with so many other large cultural issues, he could move forward an important conversation about faith in our nation.
Of course, if President-elect Obama chooses not to attend church, that's his business. And he owes no explanation for making that choice. The idea that our president must attend church, flies in the face the very religious liberty upon which our nation is founded. But telling us that he has made that choice because he "doesn't want to disrupt the service for others" stretches even this supporter's ability to trust his answer on this issue.
For starters, my guess is that while his attendance at a church of his choosing would cause some logistical challenges, on balance, most worshippers would be delighted share a pew with the president-elect. Far from disrupting the service, I imagine it would affirm the faith of those who worship alongside him.
And even if one accepts his rationale for not attending church with others, it does not explain why the president-elect has not made alternative arrangements for formal prayer in a more private setting. He would be far from the first public figure to do so. So that cannot be it either.
It would be quite interesting to here from him why he chooses not to engage in any kind of public worship at this time, especially after so many years of regular church attendance. But whatever the real answer is, the inability to share it has as much to do with the American public as it does with President-elect Obama.
Are we really ready to hear our president say that public prayer is simply not that important to him?
How safe is it to make such an admission to the American public, which is overwhelmingly churched? It is precisely those among us who would most like to see a president engages in some form of regular prayer that must make it okay to say that he chooses not to.
If all we do is harangue those whose religious views differ from our own, then we make it impossible to have an honest conversation about the value of prayer in our lives. If we want President-elect Obama to really tell us what's going on, then we must be ready to hear what he might have to say. Failing that, we will get the kind of avoidant answers which help nobody, but at least avoid the nasty fights over religious faith which we seem compelled to have over and over again.
President-elect Obama owes the American people a better explanation for why he is not attending church. And the American people owe him the respect he deserves for making a perfectly reasonable choice about the place of prayer in his life. If he could give that answer and we could really hear it, the nation would be the better for both.
Add to Del.icio.us
Add to Technorati
Add to Digg
Add to Newsvine
Add to Facebook
Add to StumbleUpon
Subscribe
Author, radio and TV talk show host, and President of CLAL-The National Jewish Center for Learning and Leadership, Brad Hirschfield is the author of 
One of the reasons I did NOT vote for Obama was his association with Rev. Wright. I would rather he had been in no church at all than know that he sat idly and listened to those diatribes and did nothing until it was obviously a political liability for him.
Logistics aren't really the issue. All of the presidents in recent memory have fund their way into a Washington area church. (And look how much it helped keep Nixon and Clinton on the straight and narrow...) I hope he finds a place to pray that suits his needs.
Saul,
You got that right, and read my mind.
What if Obama picked a church with which "others" had issues, like the one he was in with Jeremiah Wright?
Honestly - there are better things to get worked up about than Obama's not announcing which church he now attends. I need him to run the country.
why is this any of our business? why does he need to explain?
one's faith-lack of same-searching, etc. should NOT be public property.I am tired of the constant insistence that politicians proclaim their faith and that everone embrace the "Judeo Christian" denomination whatever that is. Maybe it meansChristiansshould go to church on Purim & we should goto shul Sunday morning
I heard on O'Reilly, that paragon of no spin, that someone posted an atheist sign next to an Xmas display in some government building in Washington State saying that religion was not good. Of course, Bill-O and the Xians are up in arms. "How dare anyone else have any idea that does not honor Xianity."
The Xians put their religious ideas on public property, but no one else has the right to express contrary ideas. And Yes, Rabbi Brad is here promoting the idea that The President-elect should bring more RELIGIOUS FOOLISHNESS into the public realm.
The First Family could actually WALK to St. John's Church on Lafayette Square across from the White House, less than half a mile. The Church has welcomed many Presidents in the past.
Post a Comment
By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.