The New Christians

Who Will Call Out John Piper?

Friday August 21, 2009

Categories: Theology
So yesterday, John Piper once again entered crazy-television-evangelist territory and blamed a small tornado that jumped over Minneapolis and toppled a steeple on Central Lutheran Church on the fact that the ELCA delegate were down the street discussing whether to welcome practicing homosexuals into the clergy. He even implies in his post that the lack of warning by the National Weather Service shows that God cooked up this twister with her his pinky at the last minute.

Of course, this is not new territory for Pastor Piper. He made similar claims to know the Divine Mind after the Minneapolis bridge collapse, the Asian tsunami, and other times. And, as might be expected, Piper has been gently questioned by Scot, excoriated by Adam, Drew, and others, and brilliantly satirized by Jenell.



All of this is to be expected. Piper's twisted logic that interprets some natural phenomenon as authored by God to scare sinners while completely ignoring others shocks us, I think, because he otherwise seems like a pretty reasonable fellow.  For words like that to come from bombasts like Falwell and Robertson is to be expected, but Piper somehow seems above that.

But he keeps doing it, so we should no longer be surprised. It's part of his schtick.

My question is this: Where is Christianity Today? Where is Tim Keller? Where are the presidents of Dallas Seminary or Wheaton College? Where is J.I. Packer, Collin Hansen, or Darrell Bock?

These people and institutions will gladly editorialize against liberals and emergents, happily write editorials against open theists or pro-choice Christians. But will they call out John Piper?

Christianity Today mentioned Piper's post in an online news piece about the the ELCA convention. And I can guess, knowing some of them, that they find Piper's interpretation of the whirlwind something between laughable and odious.  But will they, or anyone in the Evangelical intelligentsia, finally say that John Piper is outside of mainstream evangelicalism?

I doubt it.

(Want to hear another side of Christianity? Register today for Christianity21!)
Advertisement
Comments
Jessica
November 19, 2009 5:56 PM

The Jesus of the New Testament does indeed preach about love in the sense referred to MikeC, but he also talks about the Judgment of a righteous God upon things that he hates. Jesus died for sinners, that is clear, not just to die for them, but so that they WILL trust him and put aside all sin and follow him.

With this point of reference in mind, the conservative church or whatever you might want to call it has a strong biblical standing upon homosexuality. In response to homosexuality, it is clear from the Bible that if the word of God is true, which I believe it is, we can observe it in the every day world as well. Human physiology clearly shows that Males are Made for Females in the way that the Penis enters the Vagina perfectly, so when two become one, life can possibly result as an action. In the same way, we become one with Jesus through the cross NOT on our own terms, but on the terms provided by God through Christ. This is perhaps why Gay people in such relationships have such a higher chance and likelihood of dying from STD's. God wants people to turn away from their sin. So the ordination of a gay priest/bishop/pastor, wants the love part, but refuses to accept that to follow Christ is to leave all sin behind. The Genesis account of man and woman is the clearest example from Scripture of what is God's standard for relationships, and this can be backed up by verifiable evidence. It is made too big of a deal because it is a "hot issue," in politics, to God, all sin is a BIG issue, so under the qualifications of a pastor/deacon found in 1 Timothy, "A bishop then must be blameless, the husband of one wife, vigilant, sober, of good behaviour, given to hospitality, apt to teach;" and 11Even so must their wives be grave, not slanderers, sober, faithful in all things. 12Let the deacons be the husbands of one wife, ruling their children and their own houses well. How does a church that allows the ordination of homosexuals get past this verse? But only by conforming to the standard of our country and world. God has a much higher standard, how about we let the standard of his word conform us, rather than try to let the world conform us.

As for the Tornados, I am not God, I do know he talks about in his word about incoming disasters, but I've also seen "Good" Christians who love Jesus get cancer randomly out of the blue. The ones that love the Lord go to the grave loving Jesus or they gain strength from him, but they truly seek him out through the whole ordeal. So trying to explain a tornado and dissect God's motivations for causing it to happen is by large here say. Piper is right when he says it is quite possible that God meant it as a call to repentance. Look at the storms and disaster in the Old Testament, they aren't random acts with no purpose, God is always behind it and it is always an act to bring people back to repentance for their unfaithfulness. Whether or not the tornado "changed" directions is to call condemnation, it might be, but it also might be for other reasons. Again it is a "Hot topic." people like to make things out of hot topics because it is something to talk about.

The point is, our GOd is ABSOLUTELY A LOVING GOD, but he is absolutely also a righteous God that sees beyond what we see, we see the Hot topic of the day, GOd sees people turning back to him and maybe a warning to come with it. People will go there own way even in churches, they will choose their values and pick and choose what parts of the Bible they like and ignore the rest, is this biblical Christianity? This is called American Christianity largely, turn back to the Bible, not interpretations from a 21st century American - do whatever is right to you point of view as you can find in the book of Judges, but the long-lasting history of the true church that has been faithful to God. It can't be because Jesus did not come out of nowhere, he came from the prophecies of the Old Testament, and he used his Apostles to establish his church on the basis of the Old Testament being the Word of God. Also, some extra tidbit.

Zach
December 22, 2009 2:45 PM

"But will they, or anyone in the Evangelical intelligentsia, finally say that John Piper is outside of mainstream evangelicalism?"

This is a strong statement.

My answer? I hope not because I don't think that would be true. I've read Piper's article carefully multiple times and don't find anything in it that would place him "outside of mainstream evangelicalism" as I understand it. Evangelicals may disagree with Piper's view of "Providence," as he calls it. That is, they may disagree with his understanding of God's intervention in the world and in world affairs. And that simply brings us back to an age-old debate.

My question is: What, specifically, about Piper's post places him "outside of mainstream evangelicalism?"

elg347@gmail.com
December 24, 2009 11:36 AM

I m only a training pastor in brooklyn. God called me,as i was a restaurant owner and manager for the past 25 years. I had a terrible near fatal accident one night coming home from work.then soon after God began to totally direct my life. he sent me to a pastors reveilalin boston i saw a tunnel come over the stageof fire going up to heaven. the pastor began to prophecy that God told him the next 25 years on this planet would be the worst time in history. the power of God went through me i thought i was letteally on fire. it was awsome. after that God began to show me many Futre events through the scripture and other prophets.i could write for hours of the things God has reveal to me to teach me. but here is m point. i only go or see what God is trying to show me. I beleive him i have seen so many miracles and real visions while i was completely awake not deaming. when they happen they are more real then realty. God burns them into your spirit he writes them onto your heart. that's why know one can tell me God is not real and that he is not write now judging us in this country. we are living in the beginning of sorrows math 24
if you beleive in the holy spirit slow down and spen time in God's presence he will reveal many things that he is not pleased with and many things that are to come.God Loves all of us but he hates sinners he word cannot change. we try now to change his lwas and staues to fit
our life stlye. if we reject God he says he will give us over to a lie. this has happen to many in the church and outside of the church.
so now i know from what you said about John Piper that God is using Him and guiding him. you see it is had to realyy beleive with all of our heart and all of our mind and all of our soul. we think we are so smart because we are so educated. this has nothing to do with hearing form God or beleiving him. shut yourself into your room, secret closet, shut off your phone, do not eat anything for as long as you can. lay on the floor on your face. then ask God anything you what about anything or anybody and God will reveal it to you.
then you will know what God is saying because you will hear him yourself

Nick Matyas
January 11, 2010 5:08 PM
http://webroyalty.com

Its really nice post....
I was searching this kind of posting .....
I just liked it....
Thanks....

webroyalty

David
January 26, 2010 9:39 AM
http://www.desiringgod.org/Blog/1968_clarifying_the_tornado/

This article seems to ignore the full scope of what Piper really said:

"Conclusion: The tornado in Minneapolis was a gentle but firm warning to the ELCA and all of us: Turn from the approval of sin. Turn from the promotion of behaviors that lead to destruction. Reaffirm the great Lutheran heritage of allegiance to the truth and authority of Scripture. Turn back from distorting the grace of God into sensuality. Rejoice in the pardon of the cross of Christ and its power to transform left and right wing sinners."

Two days later he wrote the following: Three years ago God sent the tornado of cancer into my life. It split the steeple of my health and shredded the tents of my sexual life. I wrote an article to myself: Don’t Waste Your Cancer. It could have been titled: Don’t waste your tornado. God’s message to me in my tornado was essentially the same as to the ELCA in theirs."

Biblically speaking Piper nailed it. He is in perfect alignment with Jesus' statement in Luke 13. ANd he is not even close to echoing statements by Falwell and Robertson. If that puts him outside of mainstream evangelicalism, then so be it. I will gladly join him outside of that camp if being evangelical means watering down biblical truth.

Read All Comments

Post a Comment

By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.



Please type the text you see in the box below to verify your post and help us prevent spam. You have a limited time to type - you may wish to compose your comment in a separate document and paste it here upon completion.

Type the characters you see in the picture above.

Advertisement

Search This Blog

About The New Christians

Tony Jones is the author of many books, including The New Christians: Dispatches from the Emergent Frontier and The Sacred Way: Spiritual Practices for Everyday Life. He is a leader in the emergent church movement and a renowned expert on postmodern theology and the American church landscape.


Find out more about Tony, his books, and his speaking schedule at his website.

feed icon Subscribe

RSS Feed

Receive updates from The New Christians
Tony on Twitter:
My Amazon Favorites:


Social Networks:
Facebook
LinkedIn
Flickr
YouTube
Vimeo
Pandora

Calendar

Advertisement

Advertisement


About Beliefnet

Our mission is to help people like you find, and walk, a spiritual path that will bring comfort, hope, clarity, strength, and happiness. More about Beliefnet.

Legal

Copyright © Beliefnet, Inc. and/or its licensors. All rights reserved. Use of this site is subject to Terms of Service and to our Privacy Policy. Constructed by Beliefnet.

Advertisement

Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.